10 ms·
If you want to take down a fence, first learn why it was built. I can guess at reasons but it would be interesting to hear from a city planner on the reasons an
by wolverine876 5y ago
If you want to take down a fence, first learn why it was built. I can guess at reasons but it would be interesting to hear from a city planner on the reasons and history. My guesses:
* The sidewalk is public space. Does the public give away free real estate to the restaurant, to be used to generate revenue by the square foot? If the restaurant wants outdoor dining, they can build it on their own property. Perhaps the city should at least charge rent (in non-pandemic times).
* Cities don't want loud drunk people on sidewalks, i.e., a bar scene on the sidewalk. Public alcohol consumption is generally banned in most places in the US, afaik.
* It obstructs sidewalks, which have an important purpose and were built to a certain capacity. Analogously, should we allow dining in the street, blocking a lane of traffic (structures could be built that would shield patrons from the street). Possibly, there was less foot traffic during the pandemic so the problem wasn't as noticeable.
* Laws that apply to one person apply to every restaurant in the city. Maybe the temporary pandemic situation limited how many and how did it, and we don't want every restaurant building outdoor dining on the sidewalk.
The title is inflammatory: Assuming 'progressives' are bad, caused the issue, the issue is somehow bad. I expect more from the Atlantic than joining the lynch-the-progressives mob.
- lettergram 5y ago> Assuming 'progressives' are bad, caused the issue I do t think there’s an assumption, politically active progressives in office are pushing the policy? If I’m incorrect, who’s policies should we be evaluating to fix the issue?
- wolverine876 5y agoWhy do you think that these policies are a product of these people?
- CaptainZapp 5y ago> Does the public give away free real estate to the restaurant, to be used to generate revenue by the square foot? I can only speak for Zurich, where there is a lot of outdoor dining during the season. The space used by restaurants for outdoor dining on public space is "leased" to the restaurant. They pay a fee for the use of public space to the city.
- bobcostas55 5y agoSomehow none of those issues are a problem in Europe.
- jjulius 5y agoPerhaps cities were initially planned with them in mind as opposed to in the US?
- bowmessage 5y agoAh, yes, all of those carefully-planned-out European cities that have been fully thought through before the first brick was laid...
- wolverine876 5y agoMany cities are planned. Paris was planned in the 19th century, after it had been around for millenia, and they tore stuff down and rebuilt it.
- HarryHirsch 5y agoIt's telling that there are people who have never experienced the result of proper town planning and conclude that town planning is an impossibility.
- bowmessage 5y agoHow so? My argument is the "initial planning" of many European cities never really happened. Plenty of planning has happened since, I'm sure!
- jjulius 5y agoRemove "initial" from my original post and my point still stands; Europe planned for them at some point, the US didn't, and what the US did - to this article's point - doesn't lend itself to adapt to these parklets so readily.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoAnother important question you could ask about the fence is: how come those people over there manage to do just fine without the fence? (and going deeper, do they, in fact do just fine?) The obvious point of comparison are most southern (and some northern) european countries that have lots of outdoor (often on-street) dining, apparently without much deleterious effect. What would be so different in the USA as to create a different outcome? Sometimes, that asshole Chesterton put up a fence without a good reason at all.
- wolverine876 5y agoAgreed. It would be interesting to see how those European cities do it. I don't recall feeling obstructed by it, the way I do in US cities recently (I don't mind it, but I notice it). IME, in Europe, the outdoor dining is usually directly adjascent the restaurant (in the US, it's often on the curb side of the sidewalk), though that is really speculation based on limited experience. Perhaps that is actually on restaurant property, and they set back the indoor structure. Or perhaps European sidewalks were built with that capacity in mind. Also, perhaps the US, usually more restrictive with alchohol, has been less accepting of drinking in public. It doesn't seem like a problem to me, but then I hardly ever see anyone drinking in public. A city block with lots of restaurants and drinkers? > Sometimes, that asshole Chesterton put up a fence without a good reason at all. I find that is very rarely the case, especially for rules widespread across the country. Usually 'no good reason' means 'no reason I know' or 'not a reason I care about'.
- xyzzyz 5y agoResidents of San Francisco have not been in my experience shy about drinking in public, or, for that matter, shooting fentanyl or defecating. These are rather everyday occurrences in the city, so I imagine people can handle some outdoor dining in restaurants too.
- wolverine876 5y agoA good point, though many on HN aren't so happy about those outdoor activities.
- Afforess 5y agoI realize you are not defending these ideas, just stating them. However, they are absurd.... objections In order: 1. Charging rent would cost more administratively than giving the space for free, in 99.9% of cases. Yes, the city should allow the restaurants to "borrow" public space for free. People want this! It's in the public interest! 2. This is false. Public "outdoor" alcohol consumption is generally acceptable and if put on the ballot would win in most places. It's legal where I live, in Austin TX. 3. Sidewalks were built to encourage pedestrian foot traffic in cities. Outdoor dining also increases foot traffic. The two concepts aren't opposed, they are mutually beneficial. 4. ...Okay? Laws shouldn't discriminate between businesses of the same class, this is a good thing. Sure, there might be reasons a fence was built. But there might not be! We shouldn't become a veto-ocracy.
- JamesBarney 5y ago2. It's legal in Houston,Tx too. And It's never been a problem. The only I remember anyone even taking advantage of this is the occasional neighbor walking their dog in the evening with a beer or a glass of wine.
- handrous 5y ago> 2. This is false. Public "outdoor" alcohol consumption is generally acceptable and if put on the ballot would win in most places. It's legal where I live, in Austin TX. https://www.wideopeneats.com/states-can-drink-public/ https://www.wideopeneats.com/states-can-drink-public/ Scroll to the map. Looks pretty mixed. California and Texas in the "mostly OK" bucket, but then you've got Illinois, New York, and Florida as high-pop states in the "mostly not OK" bucket. State-wide bans in Maryland, Virginia, and Washington, too. I'd guess, based on that, that more people live places with significant restrictions on open containers in public than not, but it may be fairly close to an even split.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- fallingknife 5y ago> We appreciate your interest in our content. Unfortunately at this time, we are unable to allow international traffic or online transactions. wow
- tschwimmer 5y agoYou're on to something with Chesterton's fence, but don't mention a few key reasons for these rules. Safety is a major driver in the changes I see being reported. Some parklets go to the corner, which can make it be hard to see oncoming cars when you're trying to cross the street. The wall height thing is about accessibility for emergency responders, as is the roof height thing. The max parking spot coverage thing is probably about parking capacity. Ultimately, it's a bad situation. It's not being handled well, but I don't really think there's a good outcome that doesn't compromise on either safety, parking or screwing over the restaurant operators.
- wolverine876 5y ago> The wall height thing is about accessibility for emergency responders, as is the roof height thing. Good points. Imagine that we allowed other businesses to build extra structures on the public sidewalk. Does the hardware store just build more retail space? It's a bit absurd from that perspective. > The max parking spot coverage thing is probably about parking capacity. Many see reducing parking capacity as a benefit: Parking capcity consumes limited real estate (imagine a dense downtown), driving up all other real estate prices. It's a public subsidy for greenhouse gas producing cars. However, the solution is probably not random takeover of parking spots.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago> Imagine that we allowed other businesses to build extra structures on the public sidewalk. Does the hardware store just build more retail space? It's a bit absurd from that perspective. If we, the public, decide that dining facilities on public sidewalks are something we want, then so shall it be. We, the public, are not likely to decide that Home Depot should expand their shelving onto the sidewalk.
- wolverine876 5y agoI agree we can (afaik), but I mean to address the main question, should we? I'm not saying Home Depot has a case for equal protection, but using the analogy to point out the absurd aspects of giving free public real estate to a private business (while there are other aspects that are not absurd). I thought we, Hacker News commenters, decided? ;)
- JamesBarney 5y agoWe were told the same thing about cabs, and hotels. And even though AirBnB and Uber exist, the world is fine. Personally I even prefer a world where I can Uber from my AirBnB to a sidewalk cafe and have a glass of wine.
- wolverine876 5y agoSo no regulations are valid, because you found a few to be invalid? > We were told the same thing about cabs ... and Uber exist, the world is fine. Lots of traffic problems in major cities due to giving Uber unlimited public resource capacity, rather than using the free market to bid it out (which is what medallions are, if I understand correctly). Did the world blow up? Is that our standard for success? The world of many medallion owners blew up because Uber bought off government and propagandized the public to give them for free what others have to pay for. > Airbnb Regulated in many/most cities.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago> using the free market to bid it out that's pushing the use of "the free market" quite a bit. Cities control the supply of medallions. The fact that people can bid whatever they want for them doesn't make it a "free market".
- johannes1234321 5y agowe don't have any true free market. All our markets have limits due to some form of restriction. Even without medallions there would be resgrictions due to road space etc. but withinnthe framework society decided on thr medallions give a market.
- tekromancr 5y agoThe alternative is letting a few monied lords gobble up the commons and rent it back out.
- HPsquared 5y ago
- njudah 5y agoYou mistake legitimate questions about the policy with questions about its implementation. The policy, and the issues you raised, were discussed, decided and voted on -- what the article highlights is the needlessly bureaucratic implementation.
- wolverine876 5y ago> what the article highlights is the needlessly bureaucratic implementation If you agree with the article ...
- imgabe 5y ago> The sidewalk is public space. Does the public give away free real estate to the restaurant, to be used to generate revenue by the square foot? If the restaurant wants outdoor dining, they can build it on their own property. Perhaps the city should at least charge rent (in non-pandemic times). Sometimes. It depends on the city. Sometimes the landowner owns the sidewalk, or at least has responsibility for it. If you are responsible for cleaning the sidewalk and assume liability if someone slips and falls on it, why not also have the ability to use it? I'm not sure where SF lands on this. > Cities don't want loud drunk people on sidewalks, i.e., a bar scene on the sidewalk. Public alcohol consumption is generally banned in most places in the US, afaik. Sidewalk cafes are not nightclubs. There's a difference between people sitting at a table and having a bottle of wine with a meal vs. a frat party. I don't think anyone is proposing a nightclub or bar scene on the sidewalk. These are people sitting at tables eating dinner. > It obstructs sidewalks, which have an important purpose and were built to a certain capacity. Analogously, should we allow dining in the street, blocking a lane of traffic (structures could be built that would shield patrons from the street). Possibly, there was less foot traffic during the pandemic so the problem wasn't as noticeable. It sounds like they're built in parking spaces, which are obviously not on the sidewalk or in the street. It's a space that would otherwise be obstructed with a parked car. > Laws that apply to one person apply to every restaurant in the city. Maybe the temporary pandemic situation limited how many and how did it, and we don't want every restaurant building outdoor dining on the sidewalk. Why not? It seems unlikely that every single restaurant would, but it also seems like people like eating outdoors. So, why not?
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago> I don't think anyone is proposing a nightclub or bar scene on the sidewalk. These are people sitting at tables eating dinner. I'm generally in favor of all this stuff. Neverthless, I did see an article in either The Guardian about complaints from residents in London (I think) regarding the expansion of sidewalk dining because it tends to up being not "just people sitting at tables eating dinner". Then there's this NYT recently about similar questions in NYC: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/11/16/nyregion/outdoor-dining-near-me-nyc.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/11/16/nyregion/outdoor-dining-n...
- jollybean 5y agoMost of those issues are a bit overstated. Get rid of the cars and make the road the sidewalk. It works fine all around the world.
- rcpt 5y agoThis might be the most hated idea on Nextdoor. You could probably convince those city council meeting enthusiasts to double property taxes before they'll agree to road closures in favor of pedestrians and cyclists
- jollybean 5y agoI think it depends. Arbitrary road closures and bike lanes may not be popular, but on high streets where it's mostly shops it's a different story.
- HPsquared 5y agoIts popularity would depend on if you poll the people who use the road but don't live there, and those who live there but don't use the road.
- JohnWhigham 5y agoThis exact impasse is why America will never be more like Europe.
- raxxorrax 5y agoWhat about the people that live there and use the road? A car is something luxurious and yet also something a lot of people are dependent on by now. I technically wouldn't need one since my workplace is very near, but that isn't the reality for most people. There also is no Uber outpatient care and many people have responsibilities outside their nearest starbucks. You won't "solve" the need for individual traffic with a sidewalk, that is just the reality of the situation. I live in a city with a car free city core. Of course we have more cars today than before the change around 20 years ago.
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 5y ago> Cities don't want loud drunk people on sidewalks, i.e., a bar scene on the sidewalk. Public alcohol consumption is generally banned in most places in the US, afaik. Which is ironic, because if you sit down anywhere outside in SF for an hour, there's a rather high and predictable chance that a person suffering from severe mental illness and/or narcotics abuse will park themselves next to you, begin to scream unintelligible sentences, to hurl insults at the patrons and act in a generally threatening fashion. Everybody will try not to make eye contact or acknowledge their presence in any way, hoping they leave of their own accord in a few minutes. You do the usual dance of pretending that the screams aren't at all distracting to the conversation you're having, while also being barely able to pay attention to anything else, in the off chance you need to dodge something thrown in your general direction. Usually nobody gets hurt, but sometimes you get unlucky and lose the stab lottery. Life goes on.
- 908B64B197 5y agoWhat's the solution? 5'000$ per month tents for homeless residents. [0] Care to venture a guess how much of that is salaries for government employees in charge of the program? Keep in mind government can only grow in size; never shrink. [0] https://nypost.com/2021/06/26/san-francisco-run-homeless-encampment-costs-60k-per-tentsan-francisco-run-homeless-encampment-costs-60k-per-tent/ https://nypost.com/2021/06/26/san-francisco-run-homeless-enc...
- bobsmooth 5y agoReopen the asylums Reagan closed.
- haberman 5y agoI was shocked to come across this figure today: > "If the United States still hospitalized its mentally ill at the same rate it did in 1955, its mental health institutions would house almost 1.1 million people any given day. Instead, they house fewer than 50,000 patients," - Michael Shellenberger. https://twitter.com/sullydish/status/1470504513874403333 https://twitter.com/sullydish/status/1470504513874403333
- thereisnospork 5y ago>The sidewalk is public space. Does the public give away free real estate to the restaurant, to be used to generate revenue by the square foot? If the restaurant wants outdoor dining, they can build it on their own property. Perhaps the city should at least charge rent (in non-pandemic times). The public collects a 10%ish[0] tithe on all that additional revenue, acting as if there is no financial benefit for the state (and public at large) is silly. [0]Sales tax + income tax
- floatrock 5y ago> Does the public give away free real estate to the restaurant, to be used to generate revenue by the square foot? I mean, basically yes. We just call them parking spaces. We decided most of the street should be a carve-out to vehicles and the people who can afford to drive and park them. Whenever a Rapid Transit bus lane is being proposed, shopkeepers oppose it because it "removes parking spaces", aka "the free real estate that the shop uses to generate revenue". So that public subsidy exists, we're just debating whether we want to allocate it towards drivers or pedestrians. Ok ok but what about parking meter revenue... > If the restaurant wants outdoor dining, they can build it on their own property. This I this we're on the same page, we're just haggling over price. Lets say a parking meter charges $2/hour (peak event meters in SF can go as high as $4, others can be less than $1, tweak your own napkin math). Let's assume full occupancy (x 8hr) for the full year (x 356) and we get $6,000 with these optimistic utilization-equivalency numbers. I'm not an expert on commercial real estate, but $6,000/yr or $500/mo doesn't feel unreasonable as an upper bound for an annual lease on a parking spot. The road upkeep and maintenance almost certainly costs more, but we already agree this is a public subsidy, we're just trying to figure out who gets it.
- google234123 5y ago> The road upkeep and maintenance almost certainly costs more, but we already agree this is a public subsidy, we're just trying to figure out who gets it. B/c of the large amount of corruption that progressive cities tend to support.
- wolverine876 5y agoCan you back that up? Define "progressive city"? Compare it with other cities?
- isoskeles 5y agoWe’re talking about SF, so you can probably extrapolate from there.
- ehnto 5y ago
- epistasis 5y ago> If you want to take down a fence, first learn why it was built I used to do this, but 99% of the time it was to enforce economic or racial segregation, so I don't find the maxim very useful anymore.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- DnDGrognard 5y agoThe mention of alcohol licences is very telling in the article and your comment - maybe some of the legacy of the founding religious cults needs looking at here. Also look at the pic in article - its parking spaces that have been converted. From experience in the UK its not patrons of restaurants with outdoor dining or drinkers outside of pubs in the evening that are the real problem.
- TrueGeek 5y agoThe article isn't about sidewalks though. It's about re-using parking spaces. The word 'sidewalk' appears only once in the article, and only in reference to the type of thing you'd see in Europe. The "parklets" are build in the street, just at the edge (and off) of the sidewalk so the 100% of the sidewalk is still usable.