22 ms·
What a progressive utopia does to outdoor dining
- nostromo 5y agoCould commenters read the article before commenting about how San Francisco isn't a progressive utopia? The author knows this. The author's argument is that San Francisco's progressive ideals often look past reality and end up undermining its own goals.
- mensetmanusman 5y ago“ A given curbside-dining setup might make gaining access to a nearby building a bit harder for the fire department than it would be if a car or SUV were parked in the same spot. “ Imagine thinking this with a straight face. How could it be harder to move civilians and a wooden plank compared to a locked SUV? Aha
- starkd 5y agoFrankly, I'm more alarmed about the "alfresco dining". Who really wants to eat in the nude ???
- dang 5y agoPlease don't do this here.
- BostonEnginerd 5y agoTo be fair, many of the outdoor eating spaces are 8-10ft wide, 20+ feet long and have substantial structure like roofs. An SUV is probably be easier to tow out of the way.
- wolverine876 5y ago> How could it be harder to move civilians and a wooden plank compared to a locked SUV? A lot of outdoor dining is much larger and more obstructive than a wooden plank. I see entire structures, planters, electrical power, heat lamps and fire 'pits', etc. > Imagine thinking this with a straight face. If we approach unfamiliar ideas curiously, we can imagine part of factual reality that is outside our conceptions: people know things we don't and have legitimate motives we haven't considered. I know almost nothing about outdoor dining; it would be interesting to hear from a restauranteur and city planner.
- JamesBarney 5y agoQuestion. We've now had outdoor dining for the past year. What do you think the chances are that this regulation significantly moved the amount of fire damage or number of fire related deaths that occurred?
- wolverine876 5y agoI strongly disagree that we can guess without expertise. I'm not even sure the sample size is big enough: We could eliminate fire regulations in skyscrapers, and probably, over a year, it would cause no damage. Fire regulations are catastrophe insurance.
- JamesBarney 5y agoHow much do you think it changes the risk of death? Last year ~800 ppl died of fire in commercial buildings. What would that number have been if outdoor dining was allowed everything?
- ineedasername 5y agoThere are more issues caused by fires thann just deaths. Non lethal injuries come to mind, along with lost livelihoods and other economic damage. And there's more than just fires to think about. You're choosing one narrow slice of potential consequences and presenting your opinion on that basis. I'm not even sure I disagree with you, but it's hard to tell because you're coming at the issue in this way.
- wolverine876 5y agoSo using the fire code, ~800 people died last year (where? what data?). What is your argument for not using it?
- ineedasername 5y agoNo data from this year can be considered representantive of what the actual trend would look like under normal circumstances. Not least of why is that none of these new structure have had much time to age and wear out to the point of causing structural issues. You might be right and there's little or no safety issues to worry about, but the data needed to assess that opinion doesn't exist yet.
- egh 5y agoHave you seen a car? Have you seen a parklet? If you had, you would understand perfectly well.
- jjulius 5y ago>How could it be harder to move civilians and a wooden plank compared to a locked SUV? Aha One is a locked SUV whose windows are designed to be broken easily and safely in case of emergencies, pop into neutral and push out of the way sort of quickly (depending on whether or not there's even enough time to do that, but I digress). This SUV has wheels whose direction you can adjust in order to to help maneuver the vehicle easily. The other is a structure often built considerably longer than even a few SUV lengths, weighed down so that guests and weather don't move it, and made out of material that is considerably less easy to break through in an emergency situation than the aforementioned tempered/laminated safety glass. Said structures may even contain even more hazards - eg, gas-powered heat lamps - than you would find in a traditional parking space. This structure is bulky and doesn't have wheels to help change the direction you want to move it in. >Imagine thinking this with a straight face. The irony...
- kevin_thibedeau 5y ago> pop into neutral Not doable in most modern cars without the key.
- handrous 5y agoReally? That's a development I wasn't aware of. I'd also assumed that was the easy answer to "it's an actual emergency and we need to move this SUV". They really lock the car from shifting into neutral without a key? [EDIT] The more I think about this the more it bothers me. Being able to shift even if the car is partially disabled—including, quite possibly, whatever's responsible for reading a modern electronic key—is really important for safety, and also for generally dealing with a disabled car after it's come to a stop, which can also be safety-related if you're trying to, say, get it off a busy highway. Especially being able to get into neutral. That there's any possible way that failures in not-strictly-necessary-for-shifting systems could block that seems crazy to me.
- jjulius 5y agoThey're not wrong, but they're also not entirely correct. Many vehicles have a panel beneath the wheel that has a release inside it for such a situation. It's just not easy/convenient. But playing devil's advocate, assuming that no modern car can be popped into neutral without a key, a car is still much more favorable than many parklets. You can easily break the glass to run firehouses through, or you can more easily run the hose over/under/around it because it's a smaller object than an outdoor dining space. Emergency crews can run between parked cars, but there often aren't any such opportunities in a 16-foot parklet.
- tqi 5y agoSee for yourself: https://sf.eater.com/2021/7/27/22595233/best-parklets-san-francisco https://sf.eater.com/2021/7/27/22595233/best-parklets-san-fr...
- logosmonkey 5y agoHuh, I wasn't aware these were even a thing. While many of them seem quite reasonable a few seem rather intrusive on the public space. The Palette one specifically makes me feel uncomfortable just looking at it, I feel like if I were walking down that sidewalk I would feel as though I were entering a private space.
- somewhereoutth 5y agoOf course this would be less of a problem if a) buildings weren't made of wood, and b) people didn't keep setting fire to them. (Source: SF resident for a few years - someone even burnt down my hardware store! As I was going there for a screwdriver!)
- kamray23 5y agoReally a big problem in Finland. Imagine having 6 centuries worth of churches slowly disappearing beacuse "church burning" seems to have become a common holiday activity.
- dang 5y agoCan you please review the site guidelines and stick to the rules when posting here? We'd appreciate it. Note these ones: "Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith." "Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work." "Eschew flamebait." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- mensetmanusman 5y agoSorry about that! Should have used more clear language :)
- 908B64B197 5y ago> Imagine thinking this with a straight face. I'm actually curious what the fire department itself has to say about it. Typically, they are the ones carrying fire code inspections.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoI wonder if they differ in opinion with the fire departments in the other cities where this isn’t an issue?
- 908B64B197 5y agoWhat I suspect is that the bureaucrats use fire safety as an excuse to justify their work; if a structure really is dangerous for fire safety the owner will get a visit from the fire department rather quickly as soon as they notice it.
- standardUser 5y agoThe incredible density of patios in Manhattan leads me to agree that this argument is nonsense.
- wolverine876 5y agoIf you want to take down a fence, first learn why it was built. I can guess at reasons but it would be interesting to hear from a city planner on the reasons and history. My guesses: * The sidewalk is public space. Does the public give away free real estate to the restaurant, to be used to generate revenue by the square foot? If the restaurant wants outdoor dining, they can build it on their own property. Perhaps the city should at least charge rent (in non-pandemic times). * Cities don't want loud drunk people on sidewalks, i.e., a bar scene on the sidewalk. Public alcohol consumption is generally banned in most places in the US, afaik. * It obstructs sidewalks, which have an important purpose and were built to a certain capacity. Analogously, should we allow dining in the street, blocking a lane of traffic (structures could be built that would shield patrons from the street). Possibly, there was less foot traffic during the pandemic so the problem wasn't as noticeable. * Laws that apply to one person apply to every restaurant in the city. Maybe the temporary pandemic situation limited how many and how did it, and we don't want every restaurant building outdoor dining on the sidewalk. The title is inflammatory: Assuming 'progressives' are bad, caused the issue, the issue is somehow bad. I expect more from the Atlantic than joining the lynch-the-progressives mob.
- lettergram 5y ago> Assuming 'progressives' are bad, caused the issue I do t think there’s an assumption, politically active progressives in office are pushing the policy? If I’m incorrect, who’s policies should we be evaluating to fix the issue?
- wolverine876 5y agoWhy do you think that these policies are a product of these people?
- CaptainZapp 5y ago> Does the public give away free real estate to the restaurant, to be used to generate revenue by the square foot? I can only speak for Zurich, where there is a lot of outdoor dining during the season. The space used by restaurants for outdoor dining on public space is "leased" to the restaurant. They pay a fee for the use of public space to the city.
- Afforess 5y ago>City staff said they don’t see any way around putting restaurateurs through a more intensive process to make their outdoor structures permanent What? Make the current rule changes permanent? How come this is not considered as "a way" and dismissed out of hand? I'm genuinely amazed at the lack of imagination here. 5th graders could solve this problem.
- notJim 5y agoTo be fair, there are legitimate things to consider like accessibility and fire safety that were waived temporarily. The whole thing that makes fixing this hard is that there are good reasons some of these rules exist.
- SamoyedFurFluff 5y ago> For decades, it turns out, needlessly onerous regulations had deprived Californians of both the pleasure of eating outdoors and the convivial streetscapes that curbside dining creates Yes, like the regulation that sidewalks have to be clear enough for someone in a wheelchair to pass through?
- julienb_sea 5y agoWhile disappointing, this is not exactly a surprise. California's approach to regulation, in general, is onerous and creates substantial headwind to development or change. This is not a statement about the legitimacy of the underlying concerns for why such regulation exists. The problem is the patchwork of regulation, multi-stage enforcement, and ability for competitors and activists to introduce painful delays and reviews at each stage. Streamlining is desperately needed, and public review should be more limited in scope and timeline.
- eweise 5y agoI was told once by a long San Diego resident, that the city starting limiting outdoor seating decades ago to discourage Italians moving in at the time, from opening restaurants.
- zwaps 5y agoCompared to European cities (except parts of London or Frankfurt etc.), US cities have always felt dead to me. Even Chicago and New York. There's previous few places in these cities where one can sit outside somewhere interesting. Specifically, they exist in such a low concentration that no real public "life" happens, rather, life happens beyond closed doors of establishments. Contrast this with cities in Europe where people just hang out, like for free, all around the town at rivers, parks, bridges and have a good time. It always feels like European cities place a premium on such public places, on the idea that a good time could be had without going to a commercial venue. I guess this is why US cities feel weird to me... somehow compartmentalized and commercialized, even oppressive. I realize you are not supposed to walk "around town" in the US. Rather, you pick a target (Bar, Restaurant) and then go drive there. And that's fine. I also know public consumption is frowned upon. But look at people sitting at the Seine or Canal St. Martin in Paris on a summer evening... sharing spaces between open-air restaurants, sidewalks and just public spots. It's a far cry from "rowdy drunkenness" that US Americans frequently imagine, and (to me), something is just missing without this public life. And even more extreme version of the US model can be seen in newer parts of rapidly growing cities like Dubai and many new developments in Istanbul and the like: Here, the city amounts to a system of isolated complexes, separated by highways or roads and with little walkability. Residential areas are also often physically shut off from the public. The closest you get to a normal space is a Mall. I find just being there makes me depressed. Other's don't mind at all. Weird. Edit: More of what I mean in this video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tbxQHjcctZk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tbxQHjcctZk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tbxQHjcctZk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tbxQHjcctZk
- davidgay 5y ago> Contrast this with cities in Europe where people just hang out, like for free, all around the town at rivers, parks, bridges and have a good time. It always feels like European cities place a premium on such public places, on the idea that a good time could be had without going to a commercial venue. Except that one of the nice things in European parks is that they have outdoor cafes, bars, food sellers, etc, i.e., commercial venues. I sometimes get the impression that the US doesn't think public parks should have any commercial elements, thus contributing to their lack of life...
- dougmwne 5y agoCandyland meets Kafka indeed. This a great article for all, not as a political piece, but as a teachable moment about process, stakeholders, requirements , over-optimization and compromise. We many not be able to fix California, but we can at least try to fix our own projects.
- oblib 5y ago"For decades, it turns out, needlessly onerous regulations had deprived Californians of both the pleasure of eating outdoors and the convivial streetscapes that curbside dining creates." I have to think that any restrictions on that are local, not statewide. Personally, I can't think of many places in LA where I'd want to sit right next to the street, and even less a parking spot on one. The city just wasn't built to accommodate that and it's silly to think public parking should be converted for that purpose. Honestly, this sounds more than just a bit snobbish to me.
- peregren 5y agoThe chances are, if it's inhospitable to dining outside, it's a road[1] or a stroad[2], not a street[3]. And its not snobbish to want places that are a little more friendly to people. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Road https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Road [2]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stroad https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stroad [3]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Street https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Street
- dabbledash 5y ago“ city residents and urban planners draw a crucial modern distinction: a road's main function is transportation, while streets facilitate public interaction.[1] Examples of streets include pedestrian streets, alleys, and city-centre streets too crowded for road vehicles to pass. Conversely, highways and motorways are types of roads, but few would refer to them as streets.[2][3]” I lived in NYC for a decade and know plenty of city residents, none of whom make this distinction. I really hope this doesn’t turn into a case of niche experts redefining a common word and then insisting that people using the normal definition are somehow wrong or less precise.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoI know lots of people who would never make that distinction either, but that's mostly because they've never actually thought much about urban planning, pedestrian/vehicle interaction, mixed-used neighborhoods and so forth. That doesn't mean they are bad or stupid people, it's just not their thing. What are the normal definitions of "road" and "street"? What words would you use to describe the differences that Strong Towns is referring to?
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 5y agoI wish there were more of a science to implementing regulations. We might all agree that X is desirable, but there are tons of ways of trying to achieve X, and finding a good one doesn't seem to happen that often. Debate about it turns into accusations that because you don't like how the X regulation was implemented, you must be against X, therefore you must be evil scum. Systems get written in stone and duct taped together in a forever additive way. Nothing gets AB tested. Nothing gets refactored.
- floatrock 5y agoWith a unit test, you hit Run and it's either Red or Green. With a constituency, there is no such universal agreement on what is desirable. Politics is the messy, ambiguous, and incomplete process of deciding which X is most desirable.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 5y agoThere’s not agreement on what’s desirable, but there’s agreement of what the goals of a piece of legislation are. Often, those goals area measurable. The scale of experimentation that would be required to scientifically test whether legislation does what it’s supposed to do would be massive, but I’d bet it would be worthwhile.
- bluGill 5y agoSure, but the problem is there are unintended consequences that you don't even think of until after passing the law. Sure you can measure metrics, but only the metrics you know to measure, not ones that you didn't think of.
- stormbrew 5y agoI love San Francisco more than most places I don't live, but I really have a hard time even beginning to agree on any description of it or really any part of California as a "progressive utopia". Certainly it has a lot of open minded people in it, but it has awful housing policy, mediocre transit for a city its size, historically some of the most brutal police behaviour and crackdowns, and an incredibly stark wealth divide. Many of these things get reflected in policies about land use too, to which the things this article is talking about are likely second order effects. I mean, realistically table stakes for progressive utopia have to include universal health care, which I guess makes Hawaii the only state that's even at the table.
- mjfl 5y ago> I really have a hard time even beginning to agree on any description of it or really any part of California as a "progressive utopia". I think the label is tongue in cheek. You would agree that San Francisco has the most "progressive" policies of any American city, and therefore if there was a "progressive utopia", SF would be the closest to it?
- stormbrew 5y agoI can't honestly say that I know enough about enough American cities to know if I agree with that, but I would honestly be pretty surprised if there aren't any American cities that rate better on the things I listed, in part or on whole. As another person in this thread mentioned I think the one exceptional standout is LGBT issues, and even that's largely because of a motivated local queer community and even then it's also the city where Harvey Milk was shot.
- eganist 5y agoEh, Alaska has the oil dividends.
- salt-thrower 5y agoAnd on top of that, the politics and policies of these so-called progressive utopia cities in California are frequently the subject of scorn and derision by actual progressives I know of. I don't know anyone who would genuinely call it a "progressive utopia." It's a laughable idea unless you're trying to sell headline clicks.
- noduerme 5y agoI don't know how this can be laid at the feet of progressives. It's mainly NIMBYs who oppose outdoor dining. Here in Portland, progressivism and anti-car, pro-biking/walking dogma has been hitched to the expansion if outdoor dining that in some cases shuts down whole streets, as another way of intentionally making it hard on us evil people who insist on owning cars. As a neighbor of one of the proposed streets to be shut down, who already deals with a lack of parking and a lot of drunk kids staggering around at 2am on Saturdays, I opposed the total street shutdown because while I'd love to live in Paris, I don't particularly want to live in Amsterdam. But the "parklets" in Portland have taken their place beside the many (wonderful) food cart pods, and definitely seem here to stay. Which is great. It absolutely saved a lot of struggling restaurants during the pandemic, and it adds another layer of life to the streets.
- greggman3 5y ago> In San Clemente, a successful effort to remove some parklets originated with downtown merchants who wanted parking for their customers. The youtube channel, Not Just Bikes, showed that in the 1970s, much of the Netherlands was car centric and claimed there were death threats by store owners who thought that getting rid of the parking spaces would deprive them of their customers. According to the channel the opposite was true. Removing the cars increased the number of people on the streets significantly and business for those stores increased. I have no idea if that would work for San Clemente. It's not some $800k person city like Amsterdam. It's a 64k person city slightly isolated beach community with a 5-6 block long shopping street lined with parking. https://goo.gl/maps/H6wyLdguSjcGKMACA https://goo.gl/maps/H6wyLdguSjcGKMACA Assuming it could get the foot traffic it would be 10x nicer with no cars and more outdoor seating but they'd still need some place to put the visitors (off the main street parking structures/lots)
- jsemrau 5y agoPlaces like these always make me wonder about why would I drive there to sit outside and look at someone else's car.
- jimmux 5y agoI have seen this in my city recently. There's a fairly popular tourist street where they removed all car access, converting it to a pedestrian strip with a tram line. The businesses fought it aggressively because they thought customers would disappear along with the few parking spaces. As expected by most sensible people, the opposite happened. More space for customers means they can access shops without cramming through busy footpaths, and enjoy the street itself more, spending more time there. Now it has more capacity and the businesses that opposed it seem to be doing very well.
- breakyerself 5y agoHow is a mecca for wealthy tech workers supposed to be a progressive utopia. Theres really not any such thing in the USA. Not that I'm aware of.
- salt-thrower 5y agoYeah, I wish someone would explain how a city with perhaps the biggest concentration of wealth inequality in the world, fueled by nearly-unfettered speculative venture capital gambling on unethical tech companies, is a "progressive utopia." These headlines are clickbait. I wish The Atlantic was better than this, but I know it's not.
- google234123 5y agoOnly 12% of voters vote for the right wing party in SF. How much more one-sided to the left could a place get?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- salt-thrower 5y agoYou're claiming that because most people vote Democrat, it must be a progressive utopia? The Democrat party is barely a left-leaning party. You have famous national examples like AOC and Bernie who are very progressive, but by and large, most Democrats are happy to accede to corporate power and regressive policies when it actually matters. What is considered "radical left" here in America is basically centrist by the standards of the rest of the world.
- breakyerself 5y agoProgressive and not right wing are not the same thing.
- gadders 5y agoThere has never been one in all of human history.
- beervirus 5y agoAhh, I thought this was going to be about the “people experiencing homelessness” making it miserable to dine outdoors. Turns out there’s a whole other problem too!
- jayd16 5y agoYou have to appreciate logical leap it takes to argue that because a policy was implemented during a pandemic, the policy obviously scales to routine traffic and zoning. I'm all for taking back the street but this argument isn't going to convince anyone who wasn't convinced already. Also this has to do with progressive policies exactly how?
- mitchbob 5y agoArchived: https://archive.ph/boYg6 https://archive.ph/boYg6
- Jensson 5y agoSan Francisco is very much not a progressive utopia, they just have bad government. I live in Scandinavia and outdoor dining does just fine here. Not in the winters of course, but in the summer you see it everywhere. Companies just apply for a permit, the government reviews it and quickly comes back with an answer, our cities typically have an SLO of 4-10 weeks after applying to get an answer and that includes dealing with people complaining. San Francisco not being able to do that is just evidence that San Francisco has inefficient government, but that has nothing to do with them trying to be progressive.
- bruce511 5y agoTo be fair the article is comparing SF to other American cities, not to actual working progressive cities. And yes, American govt is vastly inefficient at all levels, mostly because the individual is prioritised over the community. When the goal is to prevent individual harm, at any cost, then naturally there is little change because someone is always around to object.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- PedroBatista 5y agoThat’s like saying “Communism works, we just had a few bad apples”. San Francisco has been electing progressives from top to bottom since forever. They identify themselves, run and get elected as progressives, they implement policies and get re-elected, so they are progressives. Not taking responsibility is something progressives also are known for :)
- edmcnulty101 5y ago> Not taking responsibility is something progressives also are known for Yeah it's strange how it hasnt had a conservative mayor in power since the 50's and city council has been solidly blue for God knows how long. And people are claiming it's not progressive?
- skrebbel 5y ago
- chrismcb 5y agoI didn't get too far into the article, but it seems the main answer is America's fear of alcohol. One of the coolest spots in Prague is a little snack bar stand near the giant metronome. Serving mostly beer. With only a few outdoor seats most people would take their beer upstairs and watch kids skate... This couldn't happen in America, and that is sad.
- qbasic_forever 5y agoIt's entirely up to cities and states to set their alcohol laws, and that's kind of the beauty of America. In Las Vegas, open containers and such are totally legal--you can walk around the strip from casino to casino sipping drinks. But in another town like Salt Lake City the alcohol laws are much more strict because the population there decided they wanted to take a harsher stance on it. People have the freedom to decide through America's democratic structure what laws are in an area.
- aaronbrethorst 5y agoGo skim the San Francisco Parklet Manual: http://groundplaysf.org/wp-content/uploads/San-Francisco-Parklet-Manual.pdf http://groundplaysf.org/wp-content/uploads/San-Francisco-Par... I see a well-designed, clear, and not-very-dense set of guidelines for building and maintaining an outdoor dining space. You could probably squeeze everything in this document into 10 pages of terse prose, but that would be far less intelligible. Friedersdorf is just being his typical contrarian self in order to get contrarian clickthroughs. There's some really great content in this document: pages 29-30 explain in very clear terms how to attach your parklet to an existing street, and include clear, helpful diagrams. Pages 37-39 explain in great detail how to make your parklet accessible to people using wheelchairs, and even include helpful architectural diagrams and photographs. If the original PDF had been submitted instead of Conor's contrarian clickbait, I imagine that most of the comments would've been about the terrific guidance around best practices.
- danans 5y ago> San Francisco–style progressives aren’t the only Californians endangering outdoor dining. In San Clemente, a successful effort to remove some parklets originated with downtown merchants who wanted parking for their customers. San Clemente is nothing at all like a "progressive utopia" - it's voted solidly Republican for decades including in 2020 [1]. The author then goes on to tip his hat to a progressive politician from San Francisco for authoring a bill to extend outdoor dining: "State Senator Wiener is correct when he observes, “If a city had come forward before the pandemic and said, ‘Let’s dramatically expand outdoor dining,’ there would have been a lot of pushback. Like, ‘Whoa, what’s going to happen to the neighborhood? We need parking.’ This is not a mysterious unknown now. Not everybody likes it, but most people do. They love it.”" "Wiener’s bill authorizes the extension of temporary permits for outdoor dining, which are ultimately under the control of a state alcoholic-beverage commission..." ... all of which flat out contradicts the click-baity headline that the issue has something to do with progressivism. It's not about progressivism in the slightest. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/San_Clemente,_California#Government_and_politics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/San_Clemente,_California#Gover...
- ajuc 5y ago> hurdles to converting parking spaces into outdoor seating areas Stuff like this makes me realize how alien USA is.
- stuaxo 5y agoA "progressive utopia", I think not - even from the other side of the planet the inequality and huge amount of homeless is obvious. It's barely progressive, the fact it's labeled as that is an indictment on the author or on America if that's what passes for one.
- gambiting 5y agoI think either the author is clickbaiting or they literally have no idea what they are talking about. American "progressive" ideas would be at best centre or slightly right leaning anywhere else in the world.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoWhat is this segment about? > Aaron Peskin, a member of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors, compared parklets to beaches, “arguing that anyone should be free to sit down in a parklet and enjoy a cup of coffee,” Eater’s Becky Duffett reported. “But, in practice,” she continued, “countless restaurant and bar owners have called into these hearings and shared complaints with their supervisors, saying they are hundreds of thousands of dollars in debt, they have spent tens of thousands of dollars on parklets, and are having to clean out urine, feces, and needles every morning.” A theoretical comparison to public beaches is one way to see the issue. But isn’t buying a coffee as a condition of occupying a section of asphalt a lower barrier to entry than having to own a car and feed a meter? It seems totally disconnected from the rest? Are they having to give up these due to pointless red tape or are they just fighting to exclude non-paying customers from using this part of the street? Is "you can't just act like you own part of the street when you don't" the red tape they want to get rid of?
- serverlessmom 5y agoAn important note about this as well is that when people become intoxicated they tend to become more flagrant about wearing masks and maintaining social distancing. This is generally true whether the person means to be that way or simply starts losing their ability to pay attention. Yes, you are not supposed to serve a person who is visibly intoxicated- but even a single alcoholic drink effects the way that we as humans relate to our environment However I would also argue that even under those circumstances outdoor seating will still remain safer as we continue to live in the pandemic. I think that rushing to remove many of the changes we have made to our society to help mitigate the effects of the corona virus is a mistake. We are not through the woods yet.