10 ms·
How Much Does Education Improve Intelligence? A Meta-Analysis [pdf]
- ok123456 5y agoThis is a meta-analysis. It inherently has a selection bias of other studies which failed to show a null-effect.
- olifante 5y agoTL;DR: “we found highly consistent evidence that longer educational duration is associated with increased intelligence test scores. […] the results support the hypothesis that education has a causal effect on intelligence test scores. The effect of 1 additional year of education […] was estimated at approximately 1 to 5 standardized IQ points.”
- commandlinefan 5y agoIsn't there an ongoing debate whether or not IQ actually correlates with intelligence though? A skeptic could say that education focuses on mastering test-taking, so would naturally lead to increased test scores.
- skybrian 5y ago"Intelligence" is a somewhat nebulous term and people can disagree on what counts as intelligence. IQ measures something that is important for both education and life outcomes, though.
- criticaltinker 5y agoYes I suspect Goodhart’s law is unavoidable to some degree. That said, are there really any other viable ways to measure intelligence in a standardized and reproducible manner?
- qudat 5y agoI was taught in my psychology 101 class that IQ is supposed to test innate intelligence: something that does not change over time or by learning. In that context, this study literally is non-sensical.
- nostoc 5y agoThe IQ tests are not designed by gods, and while this is not the intention, education could very well have an effect on IQ. In fact that's the conclusion of the study here.
- AQuantized 5y agoThere's no such thing as 'innate' intelligence in the sense of not changing over time. Trivially, your IQ is benchmarked against a norm of people your own age, with the absolute value of correct results changing considerably with age (typically rising steadily until ~25 before declining). There are also techniques like the dual n-back that show at least short term changes to IQ tests.
- voxl 5y agoNonsensical or a direct refutation of the idea?
- linspace 5y ago> innate intelligence: something that does not change over time or by learning Isn't it a contradictory definition? If someone is intelligent then it will learn to improve on a test, otherwise, it's not intelligent. Maybe we should take the gradient of the IQ scores.
- baja_blast 5y agoBut brains are plastic and ever changing, learning new skills strengths connections and forms real physical changes in the structure of the brain. For example someone could start out with terrible visual spatial skills, but through practice their brain adapts to improve so that it does not need to constantly keep expending do much energy on a task it regularly encounters. There is no reason to believe that regions of the brain often tested in IQ tests can't develop overtime increasing ones score. Sure it almost never happens since most people never engage in activities that would strengthen it, but it's silly to think it can't. Innate intelligence assumes the brain is static and cannot change, which has been proven to be false.
- Auracle 5y agoFrom what I’ve seen the only people that think that don’t have any idea what (most) IQ tests are like. People seem to think they’re like the ACT, with questions that you read and can be taught. Instead you’re just completing patterns of symbols. It’s yet another scientific facet of our lives that’s been politicized.
- sudosysgen 5y agoWhat? No. There are many kinds of IQ tests. Some require you to complete patterns of symbols. Most do have a verbal logic and purely verbal dimension, which is sometimes worth just as much as completing patterns.
- Auracle 5y agoYou're right, I was too absolute in how I worded that. That said, I believe most widely used tests at least have a nonverbal portion. It's kind of a shame that we lump all IQ tests together; it's probably pretty easy for researchers to confirm their biases by using an inappropriate test.
- GhettoComputers 5y agoReally? I thought they were all culture neutral raven matrices.
- avs733 5y agoIQ scores tend to correlate with IQ scores...whether you think they are representative of a holistic intelligence is somewhat up to you. These researchers looked at studies of cognition specifically, and did very little to control for the variety of measures of cognition that are out there or their disciplinary or general context from what I can tell.
- zephyr-wind 5y agoDumb question but can someone explain why we think that (1) education improves intelligence, rather than the alternative conclusion that (2) the intelligent are more inclined to stay in education institutions longer?
- olifante 5y agoRead the article, that’s one of the first possible issues they address.
- pitched 5y agoThey did point that out in the abstract. The data sources being school policy changes and school-age cutoffs does probably help a lot to prove the direction though.
- ploum 5y agoWhile the question is not dumb, the answer is in the very first sentence of the link. So aking the question here is, yes, dumb. I know nobody read the links anymore and react only to the title but, seriously, that’s worrying to not even try when you have a question. Writing the question to ask probably took 10 times more than clicking on the link and reading the first sentence.
- zephyr-wind 5y ago"Read the paper" isn't exactly the answer I'm looking for, but thanks for trying. Only upon reading the paper do you discover that a "school-age cutoff", much like the famous hockey player study cited by Gladwell in Outliers, is one of the ways for controlling the selection effect I mention.
- skybrian 5y agoThere's no reason it can't be both at the same time: IQ helps for education and education helps raise IQ. Since they are controlling for the other effects, that means this analysis doesn't measure them. (Assuming, that is, the controls worked.)
- Tangokat 5y agoIt seems to me that possibly the highest return on investment a government can do is investing in education. More intelligent people likely impacts tax revenue, crime etc. does anyone know if there are studies done on this?
- s5300 5y agoUnfortunately for the United States, the last Secretary of Education was the heir to the largest MLM scheme in the nation (possibly world?) More intelligent people are likely a detriment to MLM revenue.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoLet's be factual, she married into the MLM family riches. Her own family was super rich because of a patent which is a totally different scheme where you skim some wealth of lots of other people's work without really contributing anything to society.
- vlovich123 5y agoThat seems like an ungenerous characterization of patents. There are issues with them but I wouldn’t say that it’s primarily a mechanism to skim some wealth of lots of other people’s work.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoThat's literally the original historical purpose, and some would argue still effectively is, but yeah patents have a great PR team.
- ryan93 5y agoFortunately for the united states school is funded at the state level.
- TheOtherHobbes 5y ago
- hungryforcodes 5y agoWhen I studied psychology in university, the general thinking at the time was that IQ tests measured education and not actual intelligence.
- xyzzyz 5y agoThis is very strange, especially as stark differences in measured IQ (and, in fact, in intelligence) between small children are often rather apparent, before one gets any substantial amount of formal education, and because there are no known studies showing that education can actually increase IQ in any non trivial and lasting manner, other than literally teaching people answer to specific IQ tests. Why would psychologists believe something so clearly wrong?
- echopurity 5y ago>This is very strange, especially as stark differences in measured IQ (and, in fact, in intelligence) between small children are often rather apparent, This is pseudo-science. That's why nobody who understands science "believes" it. >There are no known studies showing that education can actually increase IQ in any non trivial and lasting manner Even if this were a scientifically meaningful statement (which it isn't), it's factually incorrect. Try checking out the abstract next time: "Intelligence test scores and educational duration are positively correlated... Education appears to be the most consistent, robust, and durable method yet to be identified for raising intelligence." more info: https://www.livescience.com/36143-iq-change-time.html https://www.livescience.com/36143-iq-change-time.html
- golemotron 5y ago> Why would psychologists believe something so clearly wrong? Because they are scared of the slippery slope in questions of nature vs. nurture. Steven Pinker's book 'The Blank Slate: The Modern Denial of Human Nature' explores this topic and the cultural antecedents of naive nurturism.
- Auracle 5y agoHint: it has to do with uncomfortable differences in IQ testing between certain groups of people.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoIQ is normalised by age (apparently, it seems hard to find simple info on this) which suggests if you score 100 you are average, for your age. In a society where nearly everyone goes to school, that seems like a confounding factor. Every year older will mean, for most people up to age 16 or so, another year of education. Feels like you could pull some interesting info out of that, but not sure how.
- spekcular 5y agoIt's worth noting there are good reasons to believe the effects here are somewhat spurious – not "true" improvements but hollow gains akin to "teaching to the test." For instance, the top display of figure one suggests a fade-out effect with age, similar to the one seen with intelligence gains from pre-school programs (which disappear within a few years) [0]. Also, there's a reverse causality issue the authors don't fully control for, in the sense that more intelligent children are also more likely to persist longer in schooling. As more and more careful studies were done on early childhood interventions, with larger sample sizes, the promising results of early investigations vanished. I expect the same will (largely) happen here. [0] http://www.johnprotzko.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/Protzko-2015.-The-Fadeout-Effect.pdf http://www.johnprotzko.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/Protzk...
- glennpratt 5y agoWhen I learned about early education a long time ago, the argument was not about boosting short term cognitive abilities, as in this study about IQ tests, but long term socioeconomic improvement (i.e. we heard about changes in graduation, employment and crime). https://equitablegrowth.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/playfair-2021-09-08T100334.936-1080x762.png https://equitablegrowth.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/playf...
- spekcular 5y agoYes, I think this is a much better frame on the research. (And one that e.g. James Heckman has switched to.)
- jrm4 5y agoRelatedly, playing a videogame will make you better at that videogame. Whenever we speak of education and intelligence, you really have to remember the limits and inclinations of the tools you're using to measure the things. IQ tests are a very good measure of how good you are at IQ tests, and success in school is a very good measure of how good you are at taking other kinds of tests. But concluding anything more than that requires something more rigorous than tends to happen in this area.
- jononomo 5y agoThere is no such thing as a test that is not an IQ test. That is why the term "g" is used -- it stands for "general". The thing people discovered was that performing well on an "IQ test" predicted that you will perform well on any general test. Whatever an IQ test measures generalizes to other domains.
- HPsquared 5y ago"Exam technique" is definitely a thing, though. For example on a timed test, not wasting excessive time on a question you don't know the answer to.
- enchiridion 5y agoIt seems like scheduling and prioritization are important elements of intelligence.
- Pyramus 5y ago> something more rigorous than tends to happen in this area. This is a great example of an ad-hominem attack, but against a whole profession, that tends to pop up fairly regularly on HN. I saw somebody else call it "hackers are better X" or something like that. So yes, there is this whole profession, that do nothing else but debate the subtleties of said profession. That's what they do, they go to great length, setting up experiments, writing papers, and trying to outshine their opponents at conferences. They have been doing this for decades. But they couldn't think if a simple counter-argument? How likely is that?
- ryan93 5y agoThe bigger studies in the meta analysis seemed to show a smaller benefit to education. Even so a few years of education adds only a few points. The gaps between like physicists and people in remedial math would require decades of school to close
- chewyshine 5y agoAs a funded research academic who's studied cognitive ability(ies) for 25+ years, there are too many wacky and mistaken statements in these comments. Intelligence (aka g or IQ) is one of the best researched constructs in social science. We know more about it than virtually any other concept in the people space. We know what it predicts, we know alot about group differences on the variable, and -- to the extent possible in any science -- we know that the group differences are real and not a result of systemic bias in the assessments. We know there's a strong genetic component and, of course, enriching experiences like education can increase it to some extent. We know it's relatively stable from 21 to 60 and, at the group level of analysis, it decreases as folks move from middle age to old age. So, this is one of those areas I know way too much about and many of the comments seem wrong-headed. Makes me wonder how much faith I should put in comments on topics where I don't know as much.
- sudosysgen 5y agoI don't think we actually know anywhere near as much as that about it. We have no idea that there is no systemic bias - even progressive matrices tests can credibly have some bias, I found them a lot easier since I've learnt about XOR for example. This is not something that has been studied sufficiently and it's very difficult to know each way, it remains that IQ tests are a cultural artifact. As far as a strong genetic component, there are very few studies that actually establish that and they all have considerable issues. The extent that we know is that IQ is relatively strongly heritable, not genetic. You will find that many funded research academics that study cognitive abilities disagree with your assessments.
- clove 5y agoThis is exactly the type of commenter he's talking about. Contributing to Gell-Mann Amnesia.
- sudosysgen 5y agoI'm repeating what people with PhDs in psychology and psychopedagogy with specialities in measuring knowledge, intelligence and ability, which are currently implicated in ongoing research in the field have told me, almost verbatim. There are currently a lot of unknowns as far as IQ. We have yet to accurately measure the cultural impact of IQ tests, in fact, we have yet to come up with a solid methodology for that, as all IQ tests are cultural artifacts. We have yet to properly measure the fetal and epigenetic components of IQ, with differing impacts found that are still not totally accounted from. We have yet to manage to completely square away at the Flynn effect, which is an incredibly large effect on IQ that may be fully cultural according to some psychologists, or based on non-cultural environment, as far as I'm aware or have been told this is still not fully explained. At the same time, changes in relative IQ scores between groups are difficult to account for if IQ is as heritable as it seems to be, There are a LOT of unknowns in IQ. It is far from "as well as understood as science can". We don't even know all that we don't know. This isn't the Gell-Mann effect in action. This is someone trying to pass off a controversial opinion in a field (perhaps not amongst people whose job is to work on the tests for obvious reasons) as the established truth, and in doing so ignoring a body of research, which is far from unusual especially in these fields. At the very least the fact that I've heard one thing from multiple subject matter experts and something else from them shows that there is significantly more doubt and uncertainty as claimed in the original message.
- dhanna 5y agoThese tests are probably measuring something. But I don’t see how anyone with a high IQ can take IQ test seriously. I’ve been studying the writings of early artificial intelligence pioneers (Minsky, Simon, Newell, Von Neumann, etc) and to think that we can assign an integer measure to the most complex information processing systems in existence seems like one step above pseudoscience.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dhanna 5y agoGranted that measure is normalized, and my anecdotal evidence does match the feeling of being several standard deviations from the average person. Maybe my gripe with IQ is that as a theory, I find it intellectually unsatisfactory. I can accept that being good at solving the puzzles they gave me in tag class correlates with positive life experiences.
- 323454 5y agoHow does this square with intelligence studies of deaf people? Despite being half as likely to complete tertiary education, the deaf exhibit the same IQ distribution as the general population. Are they doing something else that is just as effective as education at increasing IQ? > In sum, the implication of the research of the last fifty years which compared the IQ of the deaf with the hearing and of subgroups of deaf children indicates that when there are no complicating multiple handicaps, the deaf and hard-of-hearing function at approximately the same IQ level on performance intelligence tests as do the hearing. [1] [1] https://academic.oup.com/jdsde/article/10/3/225/413353 https://academic.oup.com/jdsde/article/10/3/225/413353
- disambiguation 5y agoSome interesting quotes from the discussion section: > this design should be interpreted as producing a “local average treatment effect” that might not generalize across the full educational range (Morgan & Winship, 2015, p. 305). > the key assumption — that the age trend extrapolates — is difficult to test. Moreover, although this approach produced large effect-size estimates, we did not identify any studies that tested whether these effects persisted into adulthood. > The finding of educational effects on intelligence raises a number of important questions that we could not fully address with our data. First, are the effects on intelligence additive across multiple years of education? > Second, are there individual differences in the magnitude of the educational effect? One possibility is the Matthew effect (Stanovich, 1986), whereby children at greater initial cognitive (or socioeconomic) advantage benefit more from additional education than those at lower advantage. > Third, why were the effects obtained from the control-prior-intelligence and policy-change designs ... still apparent in later life, when effects from targeted educational interventions, such as pre-school, have tended to show fade-out into early adulthood? > Fourth, which cognitive abilities were impacted? It is important to consider whether specific skills ... or general abilities—such as the general g factor of intelligence—have been improved > Fifth, how important are these effects? ... to our knowledge, no studies have explicitly tested whether the additional IQ points gained as a result of education themselves go on to improve these outcomes. > Finally, what are the underlying psychological mechanisms of the educational effect on intelligence? Ceci (1991) outlined a number of promising pathways, including the teaching of material directly relevant to the tests, the training of thinking styles such as abstract reasoning, and the instilling of concentration and self-control. The discussion section is well structured to emphasize the confidence is purely in the correlation between education and an improved score, but there are still a number of open questions about the psychological mechanism of education, the socioeconomic and long terms effects, if effects are additive, and whether or not a change in IQ is meaningful and improves real outcomes.