5 ms·

Google Maps is blocked in China, I think.

tonyhb 5y ago
So, as much as people like to throw shade at Google, we can say that they haven't caved on this. That's a plus for them.
- ntSean 5y ago
  It’s not that they didn’t cave, Google products are unavailable due to sanctions. Google Search for example was heavily modified for the Chinese market.
  - judge2020 5y ago
    > Google Search for example was heavily modified for the Chinese market. Do you mean something other than Project Dragonfly, which was terminated?
    - xyzzyz 5y ago
      Google had been running search in China up till 2010, and it has been censoring its results according to Chinese government wishes. Then, Google found out that China has been hacking them, got angry and left.
      - randmeerkat 5y ago
        It’s a little bit more nuanced, China hacked Google, so Google stopped censoring search results, then China banned Google.
      - cromwellian 5y ago
        Leaky censoring, you could still find the banned stuff. Sergey Brin was very anti-authoritarian given his background, and Google's decision to leave China was far more principled than "we have no choice". They were given a choice to comply with onerous government restrictions and decided to say no. (And yes, the "old" Google of the Brin area is gone. I also don't think Steve Jobs would kowtow to the CCP and compromise Apple like Cook is doing. The post 2010-era is now run on bean-counter ethics)
        xyzzyz 5y ago
        Yes, you’re totally right. When I was growing up in 2000s, Google was the epitome of cool, and I dreamed of working there. Then, when I worked there in mid-to-late 2010s, it was not at all what it had been before.
      - thenthenthen 5y ago
        They still maintain a rather large office in the university neighbourhood in Beijing. They even moved to bigger one few years back and there was a fire [0]. In Andrew Blum’s book Google is quotes to even “have left a couple of boxes there”, referring to network equipment. They have not really ‘left’. [0] https://www.thebeijinger.com/blog/2018/12/13/large-fire-erupts-roof-googles-beijing-offices-zhongguancun https://www.thebeijinger.com/blog/2018/12/13/large-fire-erup...
  - bigmattystyles 5y ago
    Aren't they unavailable because they specifically didn't cave though?
    - borski 5y ago
      No. They’re unavailable because they refused to go back into the market after China got caught using espionage. Were it not for that, it’s very possible Google would have caved; we don’t know how that would have fallen. It’s convenient they didn’t have to answer that, but not because they didn’t cave.
      - magicalist 5y ago
        Absence of evidence doesn't seem as definitive as you're making it here, but it's worth noting that we have two counterfactuals we can use as a prior: Bing still works in China and Yahoo only pulled out last summer, in spite of public espionage and hacking incidents.
        lostlogin 5y ago
        > Bing still works in China If by ‘works’ you mean it allows searches that China finds acceptable.
      - nerbert 5y ago
        It’s not true though. They were under tremendous pressure to adapt their product and change it for the ccp (with censorship for example). They were constantly resisting by introducing workarounds. Until the espionnage thing when they said "fuck it, we’re done". I remember very well: I was living in China at the time.
  - seanmcdirmid 5y ago
    Google did actually make a stand here a decade back, and have been blocked ever since. The last straw for them at the time, however, wasn't political pressure to make some islands look bigger or censor some websites, but espionage.
- mc32 5y ago
  Google withdrew from the Chinese market for multiple reasons, but one influential one was the state sponsored penetration of Google ops in China.
  - gowld 5y ago
    That was 10 years ago, before they negotiated for access.
    - Thorrez 5y ago
      Do you have information on what that negotiation or access is? Full disclosure I work at Google.
  - jhugo 5y ago
    To be clear, Google still offers multiple products (including their primary one, Ads) in the Chinese market and has several offices there.
- emsy 5y ago
  Google also has an entirely different business model than Apple. You could say they would be in direct competition to the CCP so I don't think this is a reason to hold Google up for their "principles".
- nathanvanfleet 5y ago
  I think you're assuming they are not available because they pushed back on the one specific thing about island size and not something else all together. It's not really proven that they are not available because they have that much integrity.
- resters 5y ago
  We should not give Google a pass on this. Google does whatever the US Government wants, and lately the US Government has a far worse humanitarian track record than the Chinese government (when you consider all the civilian death and suffering in the middle east over the past few decades).
prewett 5y ago
It used to be available at ditu.google.cn (only from within China), don't know if it still is.

So, as much as people like to throw shade at Google, we can say that they haven't caved on this. That's a plus for them.

ntSean 5y ago
It’s not that they didn’t cave, Google products are unavailable due to sanctions. Google Search for example was heavily modified for the Chinese market.
- judge2020 5y ago
  > Google Search for example was heavily modified for the Chinese market. Do you mean something other than Project Dragonfly, which was terminated?
  - xyzzyz 5y ago
    Google had been running search in China up till 2010, and it has been censoring its results according to Chinese government wishes. Then, Google found out that China has been hacking them, got angry and left.
    - randmeerkat 5y ago
      It’s a little bit more nuanced, China hacked Google, so Google stopped censoring search results, then China banned Google.
    - cromwellian 5y ago
      Leaky censoring, you could still find the banned stuff. Sergey Brin was very anti-authoritarian given his background, and Google's decision to leave China was far more principled than "we have no choice". They were given a choice to comply with onerous government restrictions and decided to say no. (And yes, the "old" Google of the Brin area is gone. I also don't think Steve Jobs would kowtow to the CCP and compromise Apple like Cook is doing. The post 2010-era is now run on bean-counter ethics)
      - xyzzyz 5y ago
        Yes, you’re totally right. When I was growing up in 2000s, Google was the epitome of cool, and I dreamed of working there. Then, when I worked there in mid-to-late 2010s, it was not at all what it had been before.
    - thenthenthen 5y ago
      They still maintain a rather large office in the university neighbourhood in Beijing. They even moved to bigger one few years back and there was a fire [0]. In Andrew Blum’s book Google is quotes to even “have left a couple of boxes there”, referring to network equipment. They have not really ‘left’. [0] https://www.thebeijinger.com/blog/2018/12/13/large-fire-erupts-roof-googles-beijing-offices-zhongguancun https://www.thebeijinger.com/blog/2018/12/13/large-fire-erup...
- bigmattystyles 5y ago
  Aren't they unavailable because they specifically didn't cave though?
  - borski 5y ago
    No. They’re unavailable because they refused to go back into the market after China got caught using espionage. Were it not for that, it’s very possible Google would have caved; we don’t know how that would have fallen. It’s convenient they didn’t have to answer that, but not because they didn’t cave.
    - magicalist 5y ago
      Absence of evidence doesn't seem as definitive as you're making it here, but it's worth noting that we have two counterfactuals we can use as a prior: Bing still works in China and Yahoo only pulled out last summer, in spite of public espionage and hacking incidents.
      - lostlogin 5y ago
        > Bing still works in China If by ‘works’ you mean it allows searches that China finds acceptable.
    - nerbert 5y ago
      It’s not true though. They were under tremendous pressure to adapt their product and change it for the ccp (with censorship for example). They were constantly resisting by introducing workarounds. Until the espionnage thing when they said "fuck it, we’re done". I remember very well: I was living in China at the time.
- seanmcdirmid 5y ago
  Google did actually make a stand here a decade back, and have been blocked ever since. The last straw for them at the time, however, wasn't political pressure to make some islands look bigger or censor some websites, but espionage.
mc32 5y ago
Google withdrew from the Chinese market for multiple reasons, but one influential one was the state sponsored penetration of Google ops in China.
- gowld 5y ago
  That was 10 years ago, before they negotiated for access.
  - Thorrez 5y ago
    Do you have information on what that negotiation or access is? Full disclosure I work at Google.
- jhugo 5y ago
  To be clear, Google still offers multiple products (including their primary one, Ads) in the Chinese market and has several offices there.
emsy 5y ago
Google also has an entirely different business model than Apple. You could say they would be in direct competition to the CCP so I don't think this is a reason to hold Google up for their "principles".
nathanvanfleet 5y ago
I think you're assuming they are not available because they pushed back on the one specific thing about island size and not something else all together. It's not really proven that they are not available because they have that much integrity.
resters 5y ago
We should not give Google a pass on this. Google does whatever the US Government wants, and lately the US Government has a far worse humanitarian track record than the Chinese government (when you consider all the civilian death and suffering in the middle east over the past few decades).

prewett 5y ago

It used to be available at ditu.google.cn (only from within China), don't know if it still is.