11 ms·
Over 200 newspapers now involved in lawsuits vs. Google, Facebook
- NikolaNovak 5y agoOn one hand, if there is a new media outlet via new distribution model that's winning the market, fair. So if an online-only news source is taking away traffic and money away from physical newspapers, there's part of me that'll feel sad, but whatcha gonna do. On the other hand though, it's a completely different model in my mind to scrape/link/copy/extract somebody else's hard work and news and editorials; and then become the majority/sole recipient of monetization (direct or via ads or other means). It's not good for society, it's not good capitalism either as it'll simply dry out the sources and then nobody can play and have fun anymore.
- nobodyandproud 5y agoCaptured my exact sentiments. How many US tech websites were involved in lambasting decisions by France and Australia to force Google to play nice?
- Swizec 5y agoFewer than 50% of Google searches result in a click these days. Largely thanks to the helpful (to the user) excerpts they provide ... and (I think) the trashy SEO-focused barely readable writing that you often find upon clicking through. https://sparktoro.com/blog/less-than-half-of-google-searches-now-result-in-a-click/ https://sparktoro.com/blog/less-than-half-of-google-searches...
- shadowgovt 5y agoNews has always enjoyed / suffered a tricky carve-out in our understanding of the interaction between the first amendment and copyright because (by its nature) its value to the public is in dissemination. So while it's generally not okay to wholesale-copy a news article, it's always been okay to quote it (and, in the concrete and particular case of Google and Facebook, it's also always been okay to point people to it). So the disruption of the revenue model (surprise; turns out people were only getting the ads as a consequence of buying the paper, they weren't why they bought the paper) is particularly tough because the core activity that is disrupting the model (making news universally accessible and useful) is by itself a public good. (It's worth noting that the newspapers in this story have to go through the anti-trust door on this topic specifically because [I assume] there isn't any meat on the bones of claiming ownership of the news Facebook / Google are aggregating.)
- 13415 5y agoPotentially stupid questions: Aren't there efficient techniques to prevent web scraping? And if Google really scrapes web content from them without their permission, wouldn't that be commercial copyright infringement which falls under criminal law? That's the thing I don't understand about the current situation.
- claudiulodro 5y ago> Aren't there efficient techniques to prevent web scraping? Not especially, since internet browsers make GET requests the same as scrapers. There are techniques around blocking user agents, rate limiting, etc. but that's an arms race against the scrapers. The tricky part about blocking Google is that if you do, your site won't show up in Google search results. :)
- shaftway 5y agoGoogle in particular always uses an identifiable agent. So you could serve one set of content to Google and a separate set to actual visitors, preventing Google from scraping the content. They clearly want the benefit of being scraped (the traffic) without the cost (the loss of traffic from people who don't click past the headline to the article).
- NikolaNovak 5y ago1. Are there techniques to prevent web scraping? Yes. Are they "Efficient", and even more importantly, effective? Debatable 2. However, more to the point, what's the end game there? If there are 10,000 outlets out there; and arbitrary number, say 100 of them block scrapes; now the other 9,900 will show up in Google/Facebook search and shares, and those who implemented scraping protection will quietly fade into non-existence. It's a damned-if-you-do:damned-if-you-don't choice of modern media consumption model. I assume that most outlets have decided that the exposure, trickle of users and monetization they DO get is superior to the influx of users drying out. It's consequence of the oft-quoted platitude that these days, for most people Google and Facebook ARE "The Internet" :-/
- cblconfederate 5y agoThe sad thing is that newspapers allow that themselves. They can block out google and FB but they don't want to. It's a similar tragic fate to that of a drug addict. However if content-makers want to overcome this they need to cut off big tech access to their content, at least temporarily. The frontpage of HN is mostly news articles and some blogs. They get a lot of exposure, a lot of readership. Yet somehow google + FB end up making the money.
- colinmhayes 5y agoFacebook and Google control demand. If a newspaper doesn't let them post their content the aggregators will just grab an article that is nominally the same from a different publisher that does provide them access.
- _aavaa_ 5y agoIf their content is so interchangeable, why should they all stay in business?
- colinmhayes 5y agoSomeone has to actually write the content before everyone else copies it.
- AniseAbyss 5y agoUltimately Google will just give some desperate Afgan kid a 100 dollar bill and a smartphone. That kid will be killed a few weeks later and replaced by a new one. The new journalists.
- PeterisP 5y agoCopyright is a thing. When many newspapers and news sites have the exact same content, they're generally licensing it from a large news agency which actually wrote the story, it's not someone just illegally ripping off their paywalled content. On the other hand, if multiple sites can each write equivalent content, then there's nothing wrong with competition eliminating whomever is weakest - the more expensive (not free), the less viral (harder to share), etc.
- freediver 5y agoNewspapers allowed Google and Facebook to drag them to their territory of online ad-monetized business models in which they have no way of competing (because of tech discrepancy). This then led to deterioration of journalism and its inevitable transformation into sensationalism and entertainment, again driven by the incentives of the ad-monetized business model, because clickbait makes more ad money. It is a sad state, but hardly it is fair to blame someone else for it. Own it up, create credible news products, and monetize it like news were monetized for hundreds of years - you pay to read it. The lawsuit admits that what we call "news" is really entertainment with the goal of producing content, not to inform the public, but to maximize CPM. Fox News already made it official [1]. Now you have to explain it to your viewers/readers too and make life less stressful for everyone. [1] https://twitter.com/vladquant/status/1454288815049240586 https://twitter.com/vladquant/status/1454288815049240586 Edit: I get a lot of value from my local newspaper. It is monetized with (local) ads but they are unobtrusive and non-invasive. The content matters because there is a limit to how much it can fit in an edition. I can simply skip the pages with ads if I do not want to read them. And sometimes the ads are the only thing I am interested in, when I am looking for something specific or want to see what is new. That is the beauty of it. Now compare that to the horror story that is the online news. Content is created by the droves. Ads are everywhere, obtrusive and invasive to user experience, not to mention all the tracking and mining of user data. I never purposefully check the online ads. It is a lose-lose-lose situation for the business, the advertiser and for the user. The only reason it exists is because it is 'free', coming with two caveats. One obvious - we get what we pay for. The other not as obvious - we are what we read. "I cannot remember the books I've read any more than the meals I have eaten; even so, they have made me." ― Ralph Waldo Emerson
- cageface 5y agoNewspapers and magazines have derived most of their revenue from ads since long before Google and Facebook. They're lucky to break even on subscription fees.
- jeffbee 5y agoSeriously newspapers spent the entire 20th century charging people as much as $100 for classified ads, job postings, real estate listings, etc. Craigslist murdered them and they deserved it. Everything after that has been sour grapes.
- mindslight 5y agoFirst, there's no mention of the legal theory under which they're claiming damages. Is this something to do with caching, aggregation, AMP, or what? The only thing the article touches on is Google being a monopoly for ads, but that would seem to be a very small part of how Google contributed to undermining the news industry. Also even if these newspapers are successful, does anyone foresee any of the damages actually going towards reporters' salaries for doing real investigation again? It would seem that the case is really just an attempt at extracting some money for whatever private equity firms are currently feeding on the carrion.
- jimbob45 5y agoI agree. Any time I see daydreamy claims like "treble damages", I feel confident that someone is getting scammed. Either newspapers are trying to extort the runaway success of Google and Facebook or lawyers are trying to loot what remains of the newspaper industry. Given the lack of legal basis here, I'm inclined to believe the latter.
- Gunax 5y agoMy guess/gut is this is a legal theory/stretch and it's unlikely to work. But my understanding of anti trust law is it's always running into new situations that need to be adapted to. Even anti trust law itself was new/controversial at one point, and the concept of forcing or breaking apart private businesses was novel.
- mindslight 5y agoIMO all this talk of "antitrust" with regards to big tech is a red herring. At best, it will just facilitate the synergy of government and corporate power, through a "do this or else" cudgel. What we need is strong privacy legislation (ala GDPR) so that we can actually opt out of being data subjects, and mandated interoperability (through open protocols and published APIs) such that companies have to compete for each user's business rather than just abusing Metcalfe's law. That legislators don't understand this feels like it's because they don't want to understand this. They see a growing power and their focus is on how they themselves can control that power, rather than how to prevent it for the benefit of all (ie preserve freedom).
- desireco42 5y agoThat is all fine and dandy, but if Google and FB decide to drop them all-together, and offer you news that isn't "protected", then they are screwed even more then today. It is dying industry, well, the model is dying, not the need for news.
- cblconfederate 5y agoIt's been dying for too long, but it isn't really, no? What gets to the frontpages of HN and reddit are copyedited articles, not tweets. And like 85% of my twitter timeline is links to those articles. So, who are we fooling, people do want to read edited articles.
- yawaworht1978 5y agoThe newspapers have missed the opportunity to monetize for themselves and now need to roll out everything anew. As they should, today's google amp links are much worse content wise than daily mail articles, and that's one hell of a low bar.
- ghaff 5y ago>The newspapers have missed the opportunity to monetize for themselves What do you think that opportunity was for most even decent-size city newspapers? A few national/international brands have done OK but that's because the NYT, say, has subscribers all over the world. Even something like the San Francisco Chronicle never had that same opportunity. Maybe if everyone had pushed back harder on making content available for free and paywalls were more the norm in the early days of the newspapers going online. But I sort of doubt that would really have worked.
- yawaworht1978 5y agoIt's hard to tell, even in hindsight. Maybe something like free access without ads to paper subscribers. I just tried to run a search query with explicit "without google" and am returned the full spectrum of google marketing tools:-)
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoThey could have formed a joint venture to build a Craigslist killer, go after MLS listings, any number of things that would enhance their traditional business with desirable services. Instead they just stood by and watched the world change.
- hash872 5y agoI'd imagine these lawsuits' chance of success will very strongly hinge on where they are impaneled. A jury in a conservative, working class or populist area will probably be pretty sympathetic to striking back at Big Tech, regardless of how weak the merits of the case are. An appeals court may later throw the verdict out. To my understanding, the US is the only developed democracy to still use juries for civil matters (and even for criminal cases it's relatively rare). I am personally anti-populism, and think that civil cases with large financial stakes should be decided by an (appointed not elected) judge- not a random group of folks who can afford to skip work for two to four weeks. The standard explanation we all learn in business school is that newspapers had geographic monopolies pre-Internet, so they were able to rake in astonishing profit margins via advertising (like 30-40% margins). Their lunch was mostly eaten by Craigslist, years before Google and Facebook- plus the fact that the effectively infinite number of websites out there drove advertising prices down a ton
- bb611 5y ago> I am personally anti-populism, and think that civil cases with large financial stakes should be decided by an (appointed not elected) judge- not a random group of folks who can afford to skip work for two to four weeks. US Federal judges are all appointed, not elected, so not much to worry about there. The judge and jury serve different purposes in the US system. The judge's job is to decide questions of law, the jury's is to decide questions of fact. Appeals courts can generally only consider failures by the initial judge on questions of law, meaning it only gets overturned if the first judge really screwed up their job. Given that, it's not clear to me how removing the jury improves the system.
- hash872 5y agoMany state judge are elected- for a very long time, the US was the only country in world history to ever elect judges. It's unheard of, not just in the developed world, but also among developing countries. (We were however joined by Bolivia in 2011). And of course many important civil cases are heard in state court. This reminds me of the famous quote by a judge in West Virginia, Richard Neely. He actually said this! “As long as I am allowed to redistribute wealth from out-of-state companies to in-state plaintiffs, I shall continue to do so. Not only is my sleep enhanced when I give someone else’s money away, but so is my job security, because the in-state plaintiffs, their families and their friends will re-elect me. ”
- deadalus 5y agoI HATE clicking on a Google link and discovering that it's paywalled. It's a massive waste of time.
- wodenokoto 5y agoWhy is this even allowed by google? It’s a bait and switch similar to serving visitors and search engines different content.
- joegahona 5y agoHow is it a bait and switch? If the content is relevant, it's relevant. If you clicked through to something that said it was about NBA basketball and it was instead about knitting, _that_ would be a bait and switch.
- zajio1am 5y agoFirst, if i get paywall page instead of the article then it is not relevant, because it is about paying and not about the original query. Second, it does not make sense - if i use a public search engine, i expect publicly available information. If i have subscription to specific newspaper i would use search dialog in that newspaper. If a public search engine returns me paywall for a specific newspaper, it is minimal chance that it is the same newspaper i am already subscribed to.
- joegahona 5y agoSo if a user subscribes to the paywall site, that article is "about paying"? The article's content is distinct from the method by which the publication chooses to earn revenue. A paywall article is "about paying" as much as an ad-ridden article is "about belly-fat ads." They're both designed to make money, only one shifts the cost to the end user. I'm all for putting a lock icon next to it in Google searches, or doing whatever's necessary to signal that it's paywalled, I guess, but don't blame the search engine for attempting to organize the world's information.
- 5y ago
- gerash 5y agoThe most important factor is that on the internet local news media lose their geographical monopoly. So everyone can subscribe to NYT or WSJ no matter where they live. This effectively creates a winner takes all situation like in many other industries which get closer to a free market. Add to that the fact that classified ads have been taken over by likes of ebay, LinkedIn, craigslist, etc. Basically the business model of the old newspapers have been disrupted and trying to blame it on popular targets like Google and FB is pointless.
- giarc 5y agoHasn't that always been the case? Even before the internet, I remember seeing copies of the NYT or WSJ on newsstands everywhere. I believe you could subscribe and it would get delivered to your door.
- athenot 5y agoI receive the NYT on my doorstep on weekends and my copies say "Printed in Georgia". The content does not vary, though.
- reaperducer 5y agoIt does vary, depending on your region. My observation is that not all regions get extra content. NYT papers in New Jersey used to have different content. I'm not sure if that's still the case. West coast editions printed in Los Angeles used to have an entire extra section. The last time I checked, that section is no longer there, but there are other subtle changes. Like the weather forecast in the upper right corner of the front page.
- athenot 5y agoAh yes the weather is specific to the South East. But I don't recall seeing ads for local businesses nor articles about local affairs.
- netcan 5y ago
- gberger 5y agoWhat makes a lawsuit "quiet"?
- kragen 5y agoThis was predicted in the EPIC 2014 video in 02004. If you haven't seen it, it's a very thought-provoking look at the future of news. The original requires Flash, of course. It got a few things wrong. It doesn't mention filter bubbles and algorithmic radicalization, for instance.
- willhinsa 5y agoI'd never heard of this before. I found a copy on YouTube, and it's fantastic. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eUHBPuHS-7s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eUHBPuHS-7s
- namdnay 5y agoOhhhh was that the one with “Googlezon”? I remember that video doing the rounds
- kragen 5y agoYup. And although that particular merger hasn't happened, it correctly predicted the trend toward consolidation.
- dredmorbius 5y agoConsolidation is what capital does.
- dredmorbius 5y agoYou've mentioned this before, here:[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5549627 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5549627 (2013) There you link to writing of your own from 1997, "Real News": http://www.canonical.org/~kragen/real-news.html http://www.canonical.org/~kragen/real-news.html A book that explores some of these concepts (in terms of the Net's impact on traditional news media) is Andrew L. Shapiro's book The Control Revolution (1999).[2] What numerous prognosticators (yourself, Epic, Shapiro, and more) got right was that the traditional print media would be profoundly disrupted. What seems to have been broadly missed was that digital, algorithmic media would allow for individual targeting and manipulation, if not by the publishers or platforms themselves then by those who exploited them, either in partnership or as hostile attackers. ________________________________ Notes: 1. Not stalking, honest! I was looking for this particular comment to come back and respond to it. 2. Not to be confused with James Beniger's similarly-titled 1986 book. Shapiro does reference it, both are well worth reading. Shapiro's is far more politically-conscious. Shapiro's: https://www.worldcat.org/title/control-revolution-how-the-internet-is-putting-individuals-in-charge-and-changing-the-world-we-know/oclc/43719224 https://www.worldcat.org/title/control-revolution-how-the-in... Beniger's: https://www.worldcat.org/title/ltltthegtgt-control-revolution-technological-and-economic-origins-of-the-information-society/oclc/1283256258 https://www.worldcat.org/title/ltltthegtgt-control-revolutio...
- jccalhoun 5y agoI have long said the problem with paying for news is that it is rarely worth paying for. When I was in grad school there was a program that gave us "free" copies of the NYTimes and USA Today (I'm sure part of our tuition paid for it but all we had to do was swipe our student id to open the newspaper box). I would get them every day and there were rarely more than one story in them that I would actually read.
- bluedays 5y agoSounds like a product designed to accommodate a wide set of interests for a diverse group of people. Are you sure you’re not just boring?
- bryanrasmussen 5y agooften things that are wide are not thought of as deep, and that there must be more misses than hits in a wide approach, those factors being taken into account I don't understand the assumption that one is boring because only hit a few times and not affected deeply with an approach designed to achieve exactly that effect.
- KarlKemp 5y agoIt's the rare product where it's good for you even when others consume it. Sort-of like a vaccine, but for democracy.
- harles 5y agoUnless it’s more of a horse dewormer for democracy, which I fear a lot of media is headed towards.
- KarlKemp 5y agoThe cynicism "the media" gets is entirely boring and mostly wrong. If you read one of WSJ/NYT/WashPo and never get near youtube, you will be well informed. But the actual problem with your statement is that it implies some alternative to "the media", and/or that it's said as if the world without the news media is somehow similar to the one we currently life in. There isn't and it wouldn't: a democracy is a regulatory system that needs the feedback loop just like your AC needs to get measurements from a thermometer to adjust its settings. Take out that part, and democracy is done for.
- coretx 5y agoHow many of those 200 newspapers have the same owner ?
- yabatopia 5y agoThere's a link at the end of the article to a list of all the newspapers and their owners.
- knorker 5y agoBut what do they want? I mean aside from "make laws to force google to license our stuff, they must be forced to publish our stuff, and forced to pay for it", which is totally insane. Personally just fucking let me pay $1 per article for me to read. I will NEVER subscribe to a recurring thing, but i bet you I'll start paying a lot, as I want to read many articles per month. Paywall sure, but get the fucking subscription the hell away from me.
- kmonsen 5y agoI think it needs to be less than $1, and really easy to do. And there needs to be trust that the card will only be used for that one article.
- thomasahle 5y agoSomething like $sqrt(n) per month for `n` articles would be interesting.
- knorker 5y agoSure. I may be showing my money privilege. I would pay, but that doesn't mean it's the best price. Just an example. Yes: fast, easy, and safe. But those are implementation details, and solvable ones. But seems to me they're not onboard with any of it. They want an account, and a bunch of BS. I was once so tempted that i was FIVE screens into one paper's registration process when I went "fuck this" and closed the tab. Apparently they don't want my money.
- kmonsen 5y agoThis has happened to me many times as well. It needs to be extremely friction free and pretty cheap.
- Enginerrrd 5y agoTotally agree, although $1 is too much. But $0.25 sounds about right. To be honest, just give me the price you charge advertisers to advertise to me and let me read it with no advertisements. I'd be immensely satisfied with that solution, but no way in hell am I paying $15-$30/month for every single separately affiliated site. It's ridiculous honestly when they're otherwise perfectly happy to serve me ads instead for a fraction of that price.
- hairytrog 5y ago“IF YOU DON’T READ THE NEWSPAPER, YOU’RE UNINFORMED. IF YOU DO, YOU’RE MISINFORMED.” - Mark Twain (1835-1910)
- kungito 5y agoIt was actually Denzel Washington who said that: https://marktwainstudies.com/the-apocryphal-twain-if-you-dont-read-the-newspaper-youre-uninformed-if-you-do-youre-misinformed/ https://marktwainstudies.com/the-apocryphal-twain-if-you-don...
- encryptluks2 5y agoI wish adblockers would just block paywalled content.
- imapeopleperson 5y agoI still can’t believe we are going to let a company with such a horrendous track record launch a platform that has the potential to be 90% of where we spend our waking time.
- wly_cdgr 5y agoI am not sure being salty that you suck at the internet qualifies as grounds for a lawsuit
- ineedasername 5y agoI think they're fighting the wrong fight, and too late. The advertising angle here seems moot, especially since news outlets had been self-sabotaging themselves out of relevance in the digital age for years before Google was even a thing. 1) Google found a way to get ads to consumers that is more attractive to advertisers. Whether or not they have a monopoly, advertisers won't suddenly go back to ineffective news media ads if Google is broken up and makes room for other competitors that also get ads to consumers better than legacy media does the job 2) Their ad revenue is much more limited by lack of readership than anything else. #2 is why I said it's not just the wrong fight, but too late: online news sold out their future to Google years ago in a race to the bottom with each other. No one wanted to stop Google scraping their content because, once a few outlets allowed it, none were willing to cede readership to others that might get more attention from Google. So pretty much everyone allowed Google to scrape news content and present chunks of it in search results, and over time is means fewer people have any reason to click through. At the same time the outlets ramped up syndication and cut budgets on original work so readers had even less reason to click through to any particular site. That's where they lost the fight. If Google has an ad monopoly, the news outlets have no special status as victims of it and there every reason to believe their decades-long foot shooting would have placed them exactly where they are anyway.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- anthk 5y agohttp://68k.news http://68k.news
- siruncledrew 5y agoThe News Media Alliance, which is doing this lawsuit, is basically another lobbying group from News Corp, Hearst, Sinclair, etc. Based on just those 3 names alone, you can infer this is not a group of benevolent angels or small-town newspapers. It's companies run by the likes of Rupert Murdoch with previous geographic monopolies and networks of O&O stations that are salty that they don't hold the same stranglehold over information they used to. Clearly, this is a feigned appeal to get rent-seeking laws in their favor to profit from.