11 ms·
OK. The reason all this happening is that Bitcoin really did go to the moon. That's what powers all this speculation. If the price of Bitcoin had been stable fo
by Animats 5y ago
OK. The reason all this happening is that Bitcoin really did go to the moon. That's what powers all this speculation. If the price of Bitcoin had been stable for a decade, and it worked reliably, it would be a useful medium of exchange, but nobody would care. This is all about MAKE MONEY FAST.
Bitcoin found some early use cases. Drugs first. Then getting money out of China. Money laundering. Tax evasion. Scams. Bitcoin is the scammers dream - remote, anonymous, irreversible transactions. Much less risk of the mark coming for the scammer with a baseball bat.
Then China cracked down on cryptocurrency, shut down all the miners, and arrested a few hundred of them. Financial regulators in the more legit countries started regulating Bitcoin exchanges, so the operators couldn't just steal the money. Know Your Customer became a thing. In the US, the IRS, FinCen, the FBI, and the SEC all started paying attention to what was happening on blockchains. Cryptocurrency crime was no longer risk-free for the crooks.
But by now, sheer momentum kept Bitcoin going up. That's a powerful force. It's not forever, though. Check out meme stocks a few years later. Remember, all this stuff is zero-sum. For every winner, there has to be a loser.
That's what provides the engine behind "Web3", NFTs, DAOs, and whatnot. It's not the technology.
- gfodor 5y agoNo, that is a necessary but insufficient condition to come up with Web3. Web3 also requires the concept put forward by Ethereum of having an instruction set one can pay to run on chain. That would have probably been thought up and deployed independently from Bitcoin's price action. But both probably were necessary to provide sufficient foundational momentum to building things like DeFi.
- worik 5y agoIt turns out to be a floored concept
- cblconfederate 5y agothat's how i felt about social networking. People posting their breakfast, ridiculous. Baby pictures, silly. Cat pictures, kids these days. Yet somehow the vanity/reality show is making billions 10 years later
- clpm4j 5y agoAdvertising won't quit.
- cblconfederate 5y agoadvertising avoided social networks until it didn't.
- netheril96 5y agoI remember how Hacker News laughed at Facebook during its IPO. Hacker News are also against Google, TikTok, Snap, Instagram all the time. Investing against the popular opinions of Hacker News is an easy way to get rich.
- paulgb 5y agoI found the FB thread because I’m always curious how predictions on here pan out. I haven’t read every comment but I’d disagree with the perception that they were laughed at; the consensus seemed to be mildly positive. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3540158 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3540158
- netheril96 5y agoFacebook stock dropped a lot after IPO. That is when Hacker News laughed at it. People rejoiced that the evil company was abandoned by the market. Sorry I cannot find out the exact post.
- Ygg2 5y agoI hope Facebook does not guzzle same amount of energy as Bitcoin. We don't need another nation level energy guzzler for a spy/disinformation network.
- shagie 5y agoAn article from a bit ago to put approximate scale of the services - https://www.theguardian.com/environment/ethicallivingblog/2009/jan/12/carbon-emissions-google https://www.theguardian.com/environment/ethicallivingblog/20... > Climate researchers say two Google searches emit 7g of CO2 – the same as boiling an electric kettle. > ... > If Wissner-Gross is correct then 3,500 tonnes of CO2 (500m x 0.000007 tonnes) are emitted every day through all of us performing Google searches. Or put another way, 1.28m tonnes a year. That's about the same as Laos emits each year, the 151st biggest emitting country in the world. Compare: https://fortune.com/2021/11/06/offsetting-bitcoins-carbon-footprint-would-require-planting-300-million-new-trees/ https://fortune.com/2021/11/06/offsetting-bitcoins-carbon-fo... > All told, Bitcoin emits—by Forex Suggest’s estimate—some 57 million tons of CO2 annually, more than double Ethereum’s footprint. It’s noteworthy that for Bitcoin, all that energy generates a relatively low number of transactions. Because its distributed network is so slow, its users post only around 12,000 purchases, sales, and transfers on the blockchain each hour. That’s approximately 115 million transactions a year. By contrast, Ethereum handles over four times those volumes—devouring, once again, far less than half the juice. The result: Bitcoin deploys an incredible 707 kWh of electricity per transaction, 11 times as much as Ethereum, and emits 1,061 pounds, or half a ton, of CO2 every time you tap the app to buy a latte or zap a fraction to a buddy who beat you on a golf bet. Ethereum sends less than one-tenth of that carbon skyward for each purchase or transfer it processes. ---- So, roughly, bitcoin has a footprint that is ~45x larger than Google search. Facebook is probably lighter than that, though that's only a "its probably lighter than that" guess.
- wyager 5y ago> If the price of Bitcoin had been stable for a decade, and it worked reliably, it would be a useful medium of exchange, but nobody would care. This is all about MAKE MONEY FAST. Your counterfactual is nonsense. There is no world where Bitcoin remains stable for a decade. It's precisely the nature of Bitcoin that it either eats a large fraction of global monetary value or ends up close to zero. Bitcoin's existence provides the purest possible application of Gresham's law. The price of Bitcoin reflects the imputed probability of bitcoin eating monetary value, as well as the fraction it ends up eating. > all this stuff is zero-sum Bitcoin is positive-sum if you believe in the benefits of sound money, but yes, people who are net dollar bagholders (e.g. US govt and people with US govt debt) will lose wealth if Bitcoin successfully demonetizes the dollar. It would probably be wise to hedge against this scenario by balancing long dollar positions with long Bitcoin positions.
- narrator 5y agoThe thing I think driving Bitcoin is that all the other assets that can absorb billions of dollars in liquidity are throughly manipulated. A trillion dollars goes into Sovereign Debt. The government can issue endless sovereign debt to dilute that. A trillion dollars goes into the stock market. The companies on the stock market can issue tons and tons of new shares to dilute that. A trillion dollars goes into paper gold. The commodities markets can naked short paper gold for however long they want to since there's cash settlement allowed of futures contracts. A trillion dollars goes into bitcoin, the price just goes up and there's no dilution. This is what makes it a symbol of resistance against those assets and the way corporations, sovereigns and commodity market makers use their particular rules to extract wealth from their investors. Also, Bitcoin is open source. So you can download the Bitcoin code and fork it and call it THE SUPER NEW IMPROVED BITCOIN, and set the "super new improved bitcoin" generation to a trillion bitcoin an hour, but the original bitcoin nodes are still around and doing their thing. However, there's nothing stopping people who want to do it your way from using your chain.
- tick_tock_tick 5y agoOther assets classes can absorb billions of dollars because that's not a lot of money to them while it's a ton for Bitcoin.
- gitfan86 5y agoActually the opposite thing happens in the stock market. The shareholders vote on the board of directors and the board of directors pay the CEO mostly based on the stock price going up. One way they do that is buying back shares. Another way is buy making money via positive cashflow and giving dividends to the share holders. Bitcoin has negative cashflow, the only way it goes up is by more people putting money into it. I'm not saying that is a bad thing. Picasso paintings also have negative cashflow when you account for storage and security of the art. The only way a Picasso goes up in value is if more people with more money want to buy one. It is unfair to call Bitcoin a Ponzi scheme because no one calls a Picasso a Ponzi scheme.
- manwe150 5y ago
- digitailor 5y agoBarring value judgements about the subject, there are some large chronology and fact checking problems with this post. The federal scrutiny of Bitcoin happened a long time ago now. The China crackdown was this year. The US agencies mentioned all started examining bitcoin in 2012 at the very latest, and had a decent grip by the next year. Left off the list is the agency with the most impactful jurisdiction- the DHS- who essentially "signed off" on the "legality" of Bitcoin in 2013, specifically citing the ease of tracing bitcoin transactions. The IRS gave its guidance on bitcoin (and classed it as property for taxation purposes) in 2014. FinCen was not particularly concerned at this time, according to someone at FinCen at the time. Cooperation between compliance specialists (like Promontory) and major investors and the federal government (for KYC and AML) hit full steam by end 2013, by necessity. The FBI seizes assets suspected of being used in the commission of federal crimes, and bitcoin is simply another asset for them to seize, which the Justice Department has done successfully for a decade now. One could argue that bitcoin was able to go to the moon because of these decisions, actions, and verdicts. Sources: people who worked in these agencies or organizations at the time and the publicly available information at the time that it was disseminated.
- Animats 5y ago2018 was the year the US SEC really cracked down on ICOs. First a few of the totally fraudulent ones.[1] Then, anything that looked like a security offering.[2] The IRS has been gradually upping the pressure. Form 1040 for 2020 included, for the first time on the main form, the question "At any time during 2020, did you sell, receive, send, exchange or otherwise acquire any financial interest in any virtual currency?" The IRS has access to Know Your Customer data from many crypto exchanges, so, anyone who checks "No" and has a crypto exchange account will get attention. Here's a history of the IRS slowly tightening its grip on cryptocurrencies.[3] [1] https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2018-53 https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2018-53 [2] https://finance.yahoo.com/news/sec-brings-ico-crackdown-open-132238303.html https://finance.yahoo.com/news/sec-brings-ico-crackdown-open... [3] https://hub.accointing.com/our-crypto-platform/report-taxes/part-3-a-guide-to-irs-history-with-cryptocurrencies https://hub.accointing.com/our-crypto-platform/report-taxes/...
- 5y ago
- Lordarminius 5y ago> This is all about MAKE MONEY FAST. Which area of modern tech is not about "make money fast" ? Lol You're ngmi amigo
- koonsolo 5y agoExactly. The whole dotcom was also about making money fast. But that doesn't invalidate real uses-cases.
- rasengan 5y agoPrior to COVID-19, there were protests going on in 16 different countries. Fast forward to today, there are still protests going on globally [1]. The US has printed more money in the past 2 years than ever before [2]. At least half the country believes an election was "stolen" [3]. Ghislaine Maxwell is on trial while being linked to some of the most powerful people in the world [4]. Whether or not you agree with the different thoughts people have about any of these things, I think it's possible that there's in fact a movement into Bitcoin borne out of more than just "greed," but instead, fear and hedging. I agree that there are a lot of horrible shit coin projects out there, but there are also several blockchain projects utilizing the new technology for its intrinsic value of decentralization and what that affords. Hillary Clinton seems to believe that cryptocurrencies are about nation state vs the next social mechanism [5]. It's likely true, and that change is being brought forth by blockchain. Books changed the world. Churches changed the world. Radio and TVs changed the world. The Internet began to decentralize it... and blockchain is finishing the job. [1] https://i.redd.it/8csx4xepjm381.png https://i.redd.it/8csx4xepjm381.png [2] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M1SL https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M1SL [3] https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2021/may/24/republicans-2020-election-poll-trump-biden https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2021/may/24/republicans-... [4] https://www.nytimes.com/live/2021/12/06/nyregion/ghislaine-maxwell-trial https://www.nytimes.com/live/2021/12/06/nyregion/ghislaine-m... [5] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-11-19/cryptocurrencies-can-destabilize-nations-hillary-clinton-warns https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-11-19/cryptocur...
- sanderjd 5y agoExcept none of those things has anything to do with bitcoin... I mean, I'm not sure you're wrong here, it just seems like a step was missed. Your comment is about bitcoin, but your conclusion is about a bunch of stuff that does not run on the bitcoin blockchain. What's the missing piece here?
- siwatanejo 5y ago> For every winner, there has to be a loser. Completely agree with this sentence. Now, have you happened to frame this sentence in your head when talking about fiat money? Just wondering.
- aaronbrethorst 5y agoI’d rather get paid in dollars than in JSON metadata and JPGs of apes.
- maccolgan 5y agoThat's actually what dollars is, JSON metadata.
- grey-area 5y agoBacked by a large government with huge resources and control over > 300 million people.
- keymone 5y agowhat about getting paid in BTC?
- bongoman37 5y agoAround 2017, someone asked me if they could pay ~$22 in BTC. I've not touched it since. Percentage wise, it is my best investment ever by a wide margin.
- __float 5y agoInstead of "just wondering" with a not-so-subtle disagreement, it would be more constructive to expand on how you think this applies to fiat money.
- alexjray 5y agoThis is the same argument as fiat. The fact that it's paper is not what makes it valuable...
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> Remember, all this stuff is zero-sum. For every winner, there has to be a loser. That's not how it works. Suppose Bitcoin comes into existence and people mine a billion dollars worth of it. They now have a billion dollars worth of Bitcoin. Nobody else has lost anything. If they sell the Bitcoin and someone else buys it, the buyer hasn't lost anything. They had $100 worth of cash and now they have $100 worth of Bitcoin. Provided the price is stable, their net worth doesn't change. If the price goes up, they make money. If the price goes down, they lose money. That part is zero sum, but the initial mining still created the value that it created. It would only be zero-sum if Bitcoin goes to zero. Not just 5% of where it is now, actually zero. Because otherwise it would still have created whatever non-zero asset value people still ascribe to it.
- librish 5y agoThe point is that for every dollar someone takes out of the crypto eco-system someone else has to put one in. With miners taking their own cut that means the game is actually negative sum for normal people trading in crypto currencies.
- space_rock 5y agoSpeculation is zero sum ignoring adding liquidity to the market in a positive sum game Everything else is positive sum. Trading, moving money, storing wealth...
- lmm 5y agoBut it's not stable enough to be terribly useful for storing wealth or moving money, at least by the standards of normal legal assets. So most of the value must come from crime and speculation.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoFor miners it's positive sum. For people who buy cryptocurrency with government-issued currency it's zero sum. They don't show up with cash and go home with nothing. They get that amount of cryptocurrency. They only lose something if the value goes down. Which it might, or it might not.
- ojr 5y agoIf ajax was the beginning of Web 2.0, Bitcoin was the beginning of web 3.0 and immutable public databases
- divs1210 5y agoNot only this, Satoshi had even predicted that the price would be very unstable and grow exponentially before it became stable. Early Bitcoiners have known this and predicted it several times. See this post from a decade ago for reference: https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/1c5j46/you_people_are_seriously_not_thinking_clearly/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/1c5j46/you_people_...
- lottin 5y agoSatoshi also predicted hyperinflation in 2008 after central banks intervened to mitigate the financial crisis. He was most likely a computer scientist, definitely not an economist.
- hihihihi1234 5y agoHe was most likely this computer scientist: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hal_Finney_(computer_scientist) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hal_Finney_(computer_scienti...
- was_a_dev 5y agoDesktop link: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hal_Finney_(computer_scientist) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hal_Finney_(computer_scientist...
- garmaine 5y agoHal Finney was not Satoshi, and there's not a single shred of evidence in that wiki article pointing towards him. Instead it's just his grieving family being traumatized by scammers.
- hihihihi1234 5y agoThe evidence is circumstantial but not conclusive. Did Finney ever explain how he came to be the recipient of the first ever Bitcoin transaction if he wasn't Satoshi? Who do you think is Satoshi, if not Finney?
- ThomPete 5y agoYou can say the same about FIAT currencies too, but compared to Crypto i am forced to use them and they can be changed from within, Bitcoin cant. I find the hesitance towards bitcoin and crypto extremely puritan in ways that nothing else can live up to. Bitcoin have had several booms and busts. Each time it crashed it found a new higher floor. This has been going on for more than 12 years now.
- keymone 5y ago> Bitcoin is the scammers dream - remote, anonymous, irreversible transactions. s/scammers// also, not anonymous without huge effort and deep expertise. exactly what money of the future is supposed to be. want reversibility - build a company that offers it by taking on risk. want any other service that modern financial system provides - build it. doesn't have to be baked into the currency especially with all the destabilizing levers that come with those features.
- netcan 5y agoI disagree. Not with any particular detail, but with the "all told..." I think it's incorrect to the of crypto-currencies/etc as heading towards some sort of equilibrium. >>"Check out meme stocks a few years later. Remember, all this stuff is zero-sum. For every winner, there has to be a loser." I think this is similar to the mistake of the last 4 decades' monetary/macroeconomic theory and practice. Expecting that inflation/default would ultimately balance/equilibrate rising public debt. Well... debt rose for decades while inflation remained much lower than it had in earlier periods. Same here. Sure, the equilibrium price for bitcoin may be zero. In that case, for every winner there is a loser.
- matheusmoreira 5y agoYou're actually right, you know. Bitcoin failed at everything it set out to be. It failed to be a currency. It failed to be anonymous and untraceable. It failed to be decentralized. It failed at basically everything except making people rich. The fact it's still the number one cryptocurrency is proof that this market is irrational and couldn't care less about fundamentals. Monero is the better coin in every way yet nobody seems to know about it. And so what if criminals are using it? It's just like cryptography: you can't choose who it protects. If anything, the fact criminals are using it strengthens its value proposition because it means it works. KYC/AML are just the financial version of global warrantless surveillance and should be opposed on principle just as strongly as we fight for our privacy on every other front. If that makes life a little harder for authorities then so be it.
- pclmulqdq 5y agoPeople are actually scared of monero, since it actually does what bitcoin set out to do. It's a little funny. It doesn't have the same insane volatility, so it's not exciting, just "criminal". I wonder if that suggests that the volatility is coming from exchanges that don't list monero, though.
- jbverschoor 5y agoSame can be said for any startup, market or business. Technology is not what makes Uber, Airbnb, Booking.
- twox2 5y agoIt's not really zero-sum though, because hedge funds are pouring billions of dollars that they don't care about losing in order to jump start the crypto economy. Who is the loser? Their investors who won't even notice? It's fake it till you make it. I think they're going to make it.
- SergeAx 5y agoNo, it's not zero sum. For every winner there is a bunch of loosers plus a lots of electricity burned.