12 ms·
WhatsApp has removed answer to “how do I choose not to share data with FB”
- vram22 5y ago404
- mawise 5y agoWhen the new ToS event occurred, I tried contacting WhatsApp to delete my account and my data. Their answer was that I could submit that request through the App. But accessing the app required accepting the new ToS. I couldn't get through to the support person that this would violate the whole reason I wanted to delete my account.
- 1cvmask 5y agoOld habits and mindsets never seem to change despite corporate pronouncements and PR puff pieces written by stenographers. The regulators (and legislators) are either the biggest dupes, or much more likely in on it. Let’s not forget the FTC hookup for Netflix by Obama and the eventual payout when he left office. Or Ajit Pai who came from Verizon to run the FTC and undid the Obama era changes favorable to Netflix and inimical to Verizon. ——- I hardly see any of these events as triggers for the mass migration to apps like Signal. The network effects seem impregnable for now.
- kingcharles 5y agoAjit also undid the new tariffs that were about to be implemented for jails and prisons to avoid some inmates paying $50 for a 15 minute call to their family. Fuck Ajit.
- snakeboy 5y agoI'm all for hating on Ajit, but from a cursory look at the prison case, the FCC just never really had the jurisdiction to regulate intrastate calls and repeatedly lost in court on that question. There was already a 50 cent cap on interstate calls under Pai, and this year under Rosenworcel it's been lowered to 14-21 cents[1]. Am I missing something? [0] https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2020/07/ajit-pai-urges-states-to-cap-prison-phone-rates-after-he-helped-kill-fcc-caps/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2020/07/ajit-pai-urges-s... [1] https://www.prisonlegalnews.org/news/2021/sep/1/fcc-takes-further-action-prison-and-jail-phone-rates/ https://www.prisonlegalnews.org/news/2021/sep/1/fcc-takes-fu...
- themitigating 5y agoThat he still probably did it to benefit one or more companies.
- 14 5y agoLast I checked signal still needs a phone number so that is an issue. Lots of people use smartphones with no sim hooked up and wifi only. I was using wire for a bit but my 2 contacts were forced signed out and the password and password reset does not work only option is to start a new account and now they too were asking for a phone number. So onto something else I guess.
- GekkePrutser 5y agoYou can have it seems a text to any number to verify so even a dumb mobile phone would work. Though I totally agree linking an IM account with a mobile number is bad. There's benefits too like discoverability and ease of use but I prefer something where I could be anonymous and have multiple accounts.
- humpydumpy 5y agoyes, signal requiring a phone number is the problem, and the only reason why I am not using it. In the last 10 years I have lived in 4 different countries, each time switching phone numbers. It is stupid to use such an unstable number as identity. My e-mail address has remained constant during the whole time. And I do like to have different addresses for different groups of people.
- fnord123 5y ago> The regulators (and legislators) are either the biggest dupes, or much more likely in on it. https://www.reuters.com/technology/irish-data-privacy-watchdog-fines-whatsapp-225-mln-euros-2021-09-02/ https://www.reuters.com/technology/irish-data-privacy-watchd...
- no_wizard 5y agoDo you have any links about the Netflix assertion here?
- littlestymaar 5y agoEarlier this year, when the change was announced and the media talked about it, I saw a ton of people starting to use signal (non-tech neighbours, my plumber, headhunters I still have in my contact list, etc). At this point I asked my mother to install it and to my surprise a lot of her friends where actually on Signal. It's still not the majority but at this point there is a significant user base for signal, much more than one year earlier.
- invalidname 5y agoYes. But the whatsapp groups are impossible to move. I created the same group on signal. Nothing, two people move. Even in my office, a technocratic environment for sure... People won't move. We need a stronger motivator to move them or we need to make moving "seamless".
- PennRobotics 5y agoI chuckled when our daycare had a lengthy discussion about data privacy and, twenty minutes later, asked every parent to join the WA group.
- rakoo 5y agoI joined a few orgs fighting for a systemic change, understanding the decisions process and be a part of it, more collective life in support of all the discriminated people and a more ecological way of life. Left-leaning stuff. All the public communication happens on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram. Private comms are on whatever those platforms have, or Telegram and Discord. Only a minority have Signal and most don't want to hear about it. When I tell them there's an internal issue because you can't change the world and give more power to the people by using anti-users tools like those, they look at me like I'm from another planet. There's a long road ahead.
- denton-scratch 5y agoIndymedia had a collection of global mailing lists, run using private mailservers with no logs, and a private (encrypted) IRC server (with a web interface, and also with no logs). Nearly everyone in Indymedia operated under a pseudonym. But over the course of the noughties, most activists moved over to Faceache. I never understood why activists would adopt pseudonyms, but refuse to use the (relatively) secure communication channels we provided, in favour of Twat and Faceache. Being involved with Indymedia was risky - it was infiltrated by undercover cops, and some of the people posting to the newswire were probably involved in criminal acts (e.g. criminal damage).
- chiefalchemist 5y agoI'm not familiar with thos two FTC snafus. A couple of links would be helpful and appreciated.
- zaptheimpaler 5y agoI sometimes wonder whether there is any purpose to it in the long term. If/when Signal becomes big enough to be used by a lot of people, they will want to monetize too and the governments will become interested in monitoring messages there too. It just feels futile. As long as companies need to turn a profit and governments can surreptitiously surveil their citizens there's no long-term solution. We can move to the next platform until that becomes popular (and hence worth monetizing and surveilling), then the next, repeat. Its a technical solution to a political problem.
- mukundesh 5y agoSignal is developed by a non-profit and is open source, they have a higher chance of staying independent. With the cost of cloud services dropping hopefully there is less of the back-pressure to monetise
- javajosh 5y agoBTW I just learned that you can setup Amazon Smile to pay Signal - .5% of your purchases goes to them as a donation. https://smile.amazon.com/ch/82-4506840 https://smile.amazon.com/ch/82-4506840
- SequoiaHope 5y agoI’ve always assumed signal was a honeypot. They publish some source code but obviously we can’t verify the actual code running on iOS or (I assume) Android devices am I right? It seems like publishing open source could be a smoke screen. When they push code to devices they could link in alternate libraries that do whatever they want. They may even be able to push special code to targeted phones, avoiding detection by security researchers.
- indigo945 5y agoIf this is your threat model, you can sideload the app instead of installing from the app store. This way, you can verify that you have the same app as everyone else and have not fallen victim to a supply chain attack. Ensuring you received an unmodified phone without a nefarious operating system or baseband is probably harder.
- xwdv 5y agoThis was a canary, it’s over now all your data will be shared with the FBI for sure.
- Titan2189 5y agoFunny - I also read the headline as "FBI" not FB as in Facebook
- labster 5y agoYou’re still right, in a Meta sense.
- Titan2189 5y agoI see what you did there :)
- xdavidliu 5y agoso does Meta.
- labster 5y agoEvery post you make Every pic you fake Every mouse you shake Every proof of stake I’ll be watching you
- 2Gkashmiri 5y agothe government has a secret system that spies on you ever hour of every day
- xwdv 5y agoIt was FBI.
- outside1234 5y agoGood news - you should be using Signal anyway
- unobatbayar 5y agoSignal seems too good to be true. If anything is perfectly private/secure it won't be allowed to exist due to regulations or government agenda(which creates these regulations). Just like any crypto with anonymous protocols never get listed on exchanges.
- neckardt 5y ago> If anything is perfectly private/secure it won't be allowed to exist due to regulations. Why? I was under the impression that these days the NSA and other government agencies prefer perfect security since if they can crack the security then other governments could too. By forcing imperfect security the US would give up a large part of its advantage.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Schroedingersat 5y agoCentralized services will all suffer the same fate. XMPP was the correct answer 20 years ago, and (with an encryption layer) it's the correct answer now. Matrix and activitypub are also valid answers.
- barbazoo 5y agoI'm not sure what makes you the authority of valid answers in this topic but as someone who has tried movie their extended family to Matrix, I'd take that option with a grain of salt. It's a lot more complicated than choosing the objectively best product.
- Djejdbdbsjs123 5y ago
- Sporktacular 5y agoWhat was the answer before it was removed?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- max_ 5y agoHere it is https://web.archive.org/web/20180420190834/https://faq.whatsapp.com/general/26000016 https://web.archive.org/web/20180420190834/https://faq.whats...
- toast0 5y agoI worked at WhatsApp between 2011 and 2019. This FAQ had very specific instructions for how to opt out of sharing that were only available for a limited amount of time. The FAQ serves as documentation of the product and there's no need to keep online specific instructions that can no longer be followed. In order to opt out, you needed to have an existing account and take specific actions around the time you agreed to the 2016 new terms of service. Based on the internet archive, this article was removed after April 20, 2018, and before May 5, 2018. When it was most likely obsolete (I don't recall the specific deadlines for accepting the 2016 TOS) On the plus side, the various terms of services are all available without digging in the internet archive https://www.whatsapp.com/legal/terms-of-service/revisions https://www.whatsapp.com/legal/terms-of-service/revisions
- nextaccountic 5y agoThe news here is that you can't choose to not share data with Facebook anymore.
- warkdarrior 5y ago... as of 2018.
- Someone 5y agoIt’s not practical for most, but I think you can, by moving to the European Region. Comparing https://www.whatsapp.com/legal/updates/terms-of-service/?lang=en https://www.whatsapp.com/legal/updates/terms-of-service/?lan... to https://www.whatsapp.com/legal/terms-of-service-eea/?lang=en https://www.whatsapp.com/legal/terms-of-service-eea/?lang=en, the EU version removes - “Ways To Improve Our Services. We analyze how you make use of WhatsApp, in order to improve our Services, including helping businesses who use WhatsApp measure the effectiveness and distribution of their services and messages. WhatsApp uses the information it has and also works with partners, service providers, and affiliated companies to do this” - “We offer specific features and services to businesses and other organisations such as providing them with statistics regarding their use of our Services.” - “Affiliated Companies. We are part of the Facebook Companies. As part of the Facebook Companies, WhatsApp receives information from, and shares information with, the Facebook Companies as described in WhatsApp's Privacy Policy, including to provide integrations which enable you to connect your WhatsApp experience with other Facebook Company Products; to ensure security, safety, and integrity across the Facebook Company Products; and to improve your ads and products experience across the Facebook Company Products. Learn more about the Facebook Companies and their terms and policies here.”
- Bran_son 5y agoAccording to archive.org, it was removed sometime between Apr 20th and May 5th, 2018. Last snapshot: https://web.archive.org/web/20180420190834/https://faq.whatsapp.com/general/26000016 https://web.archive.org/web/20180420190834/https://faq.whats... Even when the option was there, it was hidden behind the 'read terms and conditions' link. If you missed that, there was an opt-out in Settings > Account > Share my account info. But the site implies that option is only available for the first 30 days. And even if you, despite their best efforts, opt-out, it's a very limited opt-out: The Facebook family of companies will still receive and use this information for other purposes such as improving infrastructure and delivery systems, understanding how our services or theirs are used, securing systems, and fighting spam, abuse, or infringement activities.
- 0xy 5y agoEven then, they're likely lying. Facebook collected phone numbers ostensibly for 2FA security purposes only, then immediately used them for ad purposes. Those terms are written by engineers with good intentions, but you have to remember your data is subject to the whims of unscrupulous PMs with targets to hit ;)
- polyomino 5y agoI think they would have legal write those terms not engineers. Or perhaps some copywriter and then reviewed by legal.
- dukeofdoom 5y agoLots of people dropped WhatsApp soon after FB changed their user agreement. I migrated to telegram. But not sure if its any more secure.
- barbazoo 5y agoAt least it's not Facebook.
- baby 5y agowhatsapp is more secure
- philliphaydon 5y agoWhat's App is not secure.
- indigo945 5y agoThis is not true, unlike Telegram, WhatsApp has a reasonable model for E2EE and it's enabled by default. The UI is lackluster and it really should scream more when contacts' public keys change (to prevent MITM attacks), and it doesn't protect metadata such as your contact list at all, but all of that is still better than Telegram, which offers no encryption for group chats at all.
- philliphaydon 5y ago> This is not true The fact that I recieve advertising in FB for things discussed in a 1:1 chat in whats app, minutes after discussing them, means it's not secure. E2E is end to end, not end to FB to end.
- mercacona 5y agoMay be the other E has been googling about the thing you discuss. Metadata is an important flaw, they don't need to compromise the E2E communication to track/profile you.
- sofard 5y agoIt's a shame that the most nefarious companies succeed over and over again.
- malka 5y agoit's not a shame. It's capitalism working as intended.
- entropicgravity 5y agoI dumped WhatsApp within a few days of when FB said they would be changing how whatsapp deals with user privacy. A lot of other people did too. I'm happily now on Telegram.
- GekkePrutser 5y agoTelegram is now going to force ads and block apps that don't show them.. And their chats are not even E2E encrypted except their 'secret chats' but they work only on one device and don't work in groups.
- nyuszika7h 5y agoI don't like ads either, but they're only going to be in channels, not in groups and private conversations. And if someone really wants to block ads, there are alternatives: * Build and install a custom client with your own API key, and don't share it with anyone * Use an Xposed module (already exists) or Cydia tweak if you're willing to root/jailbreak your phone As for the encryption, it depends on your threat model. Yes, full E2E by default would be ideal, but even with their default cloud encryption they're probably a lot more trustable than Facebook & co. According to their FAQ, the data is scattered across servers in multiple jurdistictions, so a lot of governments would have to team up to get any data out of them. But also, how do you handle convenient cloud backup/sync with full E2E? WhatsApp and Viber both constantly manage to lose messages for me when restoring after a device reset or switch.
- esarbe 5y agoWhy not just use Signal instead?
- theshrike79 5y agoBad tools for moderating large channels, no bot support.
- 5y ago
- AnonHP 5y agoThis is old news. When this change happened, there was a lot of outrage and anecdotally many people started using Telegram and Signal. But my guess is that at least some of the people who switched went right back because of network effects and because FB and WhatsApp started putting up advertisements about how this is only about the “WhatsApp business” platform and that it doesn’t impact users’ personal chats. It seemed like a lot of people weren’t aware that this had already been happening, before the announcement to make the opt out unavailable.
- 101_101 5y ago[dead]
- dang_wumao 5y agoIt's silly to think that WhatsApp wasn't sharing data with FB.
- saos 5y agoWhatever. Hoping to dump WhatsApp this month for Telegram
- France_is_bacon 5y ago[dead]
- maltalex 5y agoThis thread is full of people suggesting to just switch everyone, including grandma, to Signal/Matrix/Telegram/XMPP. This is naive. First of all, I'm a big fan of Signal and Matrix, but it is hard to overstate how much more polished WhatsApp is in comparison. There's just a lot more friction for grandma. There are also considerably fewer resources behind the alternatives, so things like this [0] happen (tl;dr - it took Signal over seven months to fix a bug in the Android client that would sometimes send messages to the wrong person!!) Second, the problem doesn't end with grandma. It's the network. There are literally billions of people on WhatsApp and there are places where WhatsApp is the default method of communication for everything. Schools and kindergartens use it for announcements and to communicate with parents. Service providers give out a WhatsApp number to contact support. Friends and family are all on WhatsApp in established groups with a long history that everyone wants to keep. Trying to switch everyone over is futile. Not being on WhatsApp isn't an option. It is that big. [0]:https://github.com/signalapp/Signal-Android/issues/10247 https://github.com/signalapp/Signal-Android/issues/10247
- denton-scratch 5y ago> Not being on WhatsApp isn't an option. It's an option for me! When they were launching, and for most of their first couple of years, Whatsapp spammed the bejaysus out of me. My mummy told me never to play with spammers.
- ciex 5y agoReading this as an argument that more resources means bugs are fixed quicker I have to disagree, [there's][0] [many][1] [examples][2] of big bucks software productions with notable long-lived bugs in production. [0]: https://www.socmedsean.com/solved-how-do-i-clear-the-facebook-messenger-notification-when-i-dont-have-a-new-message/ https://www.socmedsean.com/solved-how-do-i-clear-the-faceboo... [1]: https://www.techradar.com/news/ios-15-beta-still-hasnt-fixed-decade-old-bug https://www.techradar.com/news/ios-15-beta-still-hasnt-fixed... [2]: https://www.reddit.com/r/beta/search?q=video+player&restrict_sr=on&sort=relevance&t=all https://www.reddit.com/r/beta/search?q=video+player&restrict...
- 5y ago
- DeathArrow 5y agoInstead of arguing how bad WhatsApp is in terms of privacy, people would be better off by switching to more privacy respecting alternatives such as Telegram or Signal. I know it's hard to switch if most of your friends are on WhatsApp, but you can talk to them and switch together.
- moring 5y agoBack when ICQ was a thing, alternatives like Pidgin encouraged switching by connecting to the existing ICQ network. I understand that in the case of WhatsApp, connecting to the existing network means that FB still gets hold of your data so there is no improvement in terms of privacy (at first), but it is still a step forward if convincing your friends to all switch at once is not an option (which is impossible -- your friends have friends that are not your friends, so the whole world would have to switch at once).
- sneak 5y agoTelegram is not end to end encrypted, and thus does not preserve privacy at all. The best way to get your friends to switch messengers is to not be reachable on the bad ones: ie delete your accounts and uninstall the apps. Retaining your account on bad platforms makes those platforms more attractive to other users and makes the world worse.
- theshrike79 5y agoYes, it's not E2EE by default and can't encrypt group chats. But it has a native bot API and can handle multiple clients on multiple different devices without any issue.
- johannes1234321 5y agoThis works for some. However if the sports club of your kid uses WhatsApp to announce training times etc. your kid might miss information etc. Even niftier: In some countries Facebook created this "FreeBasics/internet.org" scheme where access to Facebook services is free. When travelling Indonesia WhatsApp was the only way to reach the landlords of guest apartments, taxi drivers, ... not even regular SMS/text. The strength of the network effect can be hard to break.
- piokoch 5y agoNo surprise at all, having user data is FB core business, they need to do this to earn money. Google core business is displaying adds, so don't be surprise that one day you'll wake up with a Chrome browser update in which adblock will no longer work.