7 ms·
Blockchains don't solve problems that are interesting to me
- jetpackjoe 5y agoStellar (XLM) I think solves all these, including clawbacks. https://developers.stellar.org/docs/glossary/clawback/ https://developers.stellar.org/docs/glossary/clawback/ https://stellar.org https://stellar.org
- woodruffw 5y agoAuthor here: I was actually pretty excited about XLM, until I flushed about $50 (at the time) of it into the void from the Keybase thing. I still don't really know what I did wrong, other than it never ending up in my (since liquidated) Coinbase wallet.
- jetpackjoe 5y agoYou may have missed the memo_id[1]. If you still have access to your Keybase account, you can try Coinbase support. Assuming you sent it to the correct address, they should have the funds and may return it to you if you can prove you own the sending address. (No idea if this will actually work). Stellar has since fixed this by enabling exchanges to require a memo.[2] [1]https://www.lumenauts.com/guides/what-are-memos https://www.lumenauts.com/guides/what-are-memos [2]https://www.stellar.org/developers-blog/fixing-memo-less-payments https://www.stellar.org/developers-blog/fixing-memo-less-pay...
- pacnobi 5y agoThis reads as though you were only interested in the Keybase airdrop to immediately cash out and not actually interested in learning about the technology. Like other commenters have said, I think Stellar either accomplishes lots of the things you're hoping for or gives you the tools to build them and if you're genuinely interested in these problems I think it's worth another look. If you send me your Keybase address or a coinbase deposit address and memo I'll send you $50 worth of XLM at current prices. In return, please try using Stellar and learning more about it.
- woodruffw 5y agoI appreciate the offer, but I'd rather not. I should also be clear: I wrote this from the perspective of a lazy consumer; I'd rather pay and use a solution than write my own. I'm not sure how Stellar will help me, unless my local bar has started taking XLM. I suppose I can ask them tonight.
- pacnobi 5y agoFair enough. I think this is a common misconception -- cryptocurrencies aren't for the "lazy consumer". They're financial plumbing and, especially at the moment, useful for very low level primitives. To continue with your bar analogy and relate to Stellar, the bar would be unlikely to have any involvement with cryptocurrency. Someone else would build on top of Stellar so that you could pay USD at a Japanese bar and the bar would receive yen. All of the features exist on Stellar to do that today for far less than a cent in transaction fees, settlement time in minutes, and less carbon impact than a single Facebook data center. The major barriers are all around regulation in the "real world", something that no cryptocurrency is equipped to solve. :)
- rvz 5y ago> The major barriers are all around regulation in the "real world", something that no cryptocurrency is equipped to solve. :) Correct. Unlike many other cryptocurrencies, the Stellar blockchain has the suitable use-case of powering CBDCs which is where more financial companies will side with if more regulations hit cryptocurrencies in the future. [0] https://resources.stellar.org/stellar-for-cbdcs https://resources.stellar.org/stellar-for-cbdcs
- rvz 5y agoThere you go. Post like this are still thinking that Bitcoin / Ethereum represents all cryptocurrencies. These two have proven that it is unsuitable to use for paying for your groceries at the local supermarket. Hence the author of this post mentioning: > I’m not one of them. But it’s hard enough to get my nonagenarian grandfather to let me pay for dinner with my own payment card; I am not going to try to get him to accept Ethereum. There are better cryptocurrencies that solves all of this and Stellar is one of them which is also being used for Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDCs) [0] [0] https://resources.stellar.org/stellar-for-cbdcs https://resources.stellar.org/stellar-for-cbdcs
- hilyen 5y agoThe decentralization of the internet should be increasingly important as we see government and corporate censorship increase. I couldn't care less about the money aspect, I look forward to decentralized apps replacing corporate controlled public spaces.
- fnord77 5y agoyou don't need a blockchain to have decentralized networks
- actually_a_dog 5y agoNo, but, considering a blockchain is literally just a distributed log, it certainly helps to have decentralized networks in order to implement blockchains.
- peoplefromibiza 5y agoInternet is already decentralized TCP/IP doesn't care who you are and where you come from blockchains solve problems like "how can we order all our transactions and write them on this global immutable, append only log, so that anybody can see them?" a problem I never had, honestly.
- agumonkey 5y agoI keep reading how the web must mean something politically but so far all I see is weakening of spirits and noisy if not dangerous distraction (and mob mentality). To me less web, and less means imply deeper human investment.
- danShumway 5y agoI'll add on top of the article's claims, crypto is also not solving any decentralization problems that are interesting to me. There are a few interesting ideas with the blockchain, and it was something that was worth looking into at least initially. It's something that could be iterated on, it's not useless. But at this point, it is becoming increasingly obvious to me that as a general strategy, federation is a better approach to decentralization than the blockchains' vision. Around the parts of decentralization that actually matter to me, and in particular in regards to anti-corporate/anarchist spaces, blockchains have almost universally ended up fairing worse than simpler federated projects. The introduction of a "ledger" in the first place seems to be a magnet for the exact corporate/government attention that people say they want to avoid. I've also seen a lot of attempts at turning the blockchain into a tool for app creation and community management, but as far as I can tell none of them have turned out to be particularly noteworthy or useful -- there's not a lot there where I'm looking at it and thinking, "this shows massive potential." So when I think about my limited time on this earth, I am much more inclined to spend it following and supporting stuff like Matrix, Mastodon, Peertube; heck, even the really "boring" stuff like just increased pressure on Apple to support web apps better on iOS is going to have a much bigger impact on decentralized, anti-corporate app creation than almost anything I can see coming out of Ethereum right now. It's not that there's zero value in the blockchain as a concept or zero potential, if people want to do engineering in that space then fine, I guess. But I look at what the blockchain spaces are putting out right now, and it's just not comparable to any of the other efforts that are going on with decentralization. It turns out that securely syncing an uncontrolled ledger is not as important of a problem or as useful as we thought it might be. The closest thing I've seen here to an actually exciting project is Handshake, and Handshake has a ton of problems, it's not a great, permanent solution to the problem of DNS ownership. It just happens to be one of the very few, narrow areas where a shared ledger really does matter.
- DantesKite 5y agoAgreed. Nobody is solving any interesting problems in crypto-space, except for a few computer scientists. The rest are degenerate gamblers who don't realize cryptocurrency is exciting because it's no different than a slot machine at the casino. There are so many problems I'd love to be solved by crypto, but it's so frustrating how caught up with winning the lottery these people seem to be. It's an ad nauseum cult. The only good thing about crypto is how it occasionally decreases inflation in the US every time this digital "gold" is lost.
- zeusk 5y ago> The only good thing about crypto is how it occasionally decreases inflation in the US every time this digital "gold" is lost. when they buy the crypto - dollars are sent to the seller. Only thing "lost" is the crypto coins themselves.
- mromanuk 5y agoThe crypto is not lost either, just the value.
- _robbywashere 5y agoAgreed. Nonsense tulip bulbs! I for one appreciate inflation and the fed printing money. Its for our own good. As with most if not all government entities they have the people’s best interest in mind and refuse to serve a small elite group of friends. I’ll be happy when this whole decentralized thingy ends and goes to zero.
- latchkey 5y ago> Nonsense tulip bulbs! https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/there-never-was-real-tulip-fever-180964915/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/there-never-was-real-...
- neither_color 5y agoCalling it degenerate gambling is uncouth and reeks of classism. I think the adequately paid tech workers who frequent HN miss something very important that crypto attempts to solve that appeals very much to common people. I say adequately paid because a FAANG salary is more analogous to a skilled factory salary a half century ago, allowing you to buy a house and car and put your children through college, something out of reach for people making the median income. These are people who aren't stupid and understand that inflation is happening and purchasing power is going down and who realize that their fearless leaders don't actually have an answer to it besides gestures and platitudes. Putting some hope in crypto gives the common man a non-zero chance of his purchasing power going up. Holding regular savings accounts does not. Crypto may or may not be the answer but I see it as a rational bet.
- rp1 5y agoRegarding being asked about blockchains: I think people might just be trying to make conversation with the author because they know crypto is a place their interests intersect tech, and clearly the author has an opinion on the subject. But how many of these “takes” can we see on HN? What am I supposed to take away from this? Personally, I don’t think farm animal sanctuaries solve a problem that’s interesting. There just isn’t much to gain by sharing my opinion on farm animal sanctuaries with others though, especially multiple times a day.
- eropple 5y agoThe reason you hear people say that this stuff sucks, while not addressing the menace of animal sanctuaries, is big and obvious and reasonable: one of these things has massive externalities on the world and the other has animals in it.
- rp1 5y agoSure, but after reading that PoW is bad for the environment for the 1000th time, what am I supposed to do? It feels like the conversation has stalled.
- peoplefromibiza 5y agorepetita iuvant
- eropple 5y agoCan you explain to me what conversation you think should be happening past that? It's not just proof of work that's bad either. Proof of stake still burns resources for no nameable gain save to the earliest movers on a particular memetic pyramid--just fewer of them.
- woodruffw 5y agoI think I've seen someone make this point before, so to recycle it poorly: a lot of the "cool" technology in the blockchain space looks almost like CS information hazards: things like Merkle trees and SNARKS are just so cool that we engineers get all hot in the pants to try and use them, practicality or performance be damned. I think we're finally starting to see some reasonable spillover from that, thankfully.
- bogota 5y agoThat is a pretty limited view of what blockchains solve these days. This reads like someone looked into Bitcoin once ten years ago and then applied that to everything that came after it. You don’t have to be interested in it but I hardly find this blog as a compelling or well thought out reason for finding them boring. It’s more like a reason for why you want to stay ignorant about the tech which no one asked you to know about in the first place.
- Jdixnxjsj3 5y agoWhat problems do blockchains solve these days vs ten years ago?
- dilyevsky 5y agoRansomware payment
- SAI_Peregrinus 5y agoYou mean "distributed involuntary bug bounties". /s
- BozeWolf 5y agoIt is not about the problems it solves now. It is about the potential it has to solve problems……
- dkersten 5y agoWhat problems does it have the potential to solve?
- danShumway 5y agoThis is kind of the article's point though, because there are other federated/decentralized efforts going on outside of blockchains that do solve problems now. Having the potential to solve problems possibly in the future isn't that special, lots of things have the potential to solve problems eventually. The questions are: - how long will it take to solve those problems? - how much effort will it be? - how likely is it to succeed? - are there other efforts that are more promising? - what are the costs/downsides associated? - etc... And when you start asking those practical questions about the real world, and not just thinking about "maybe this will be great someday", then cryptocurrencies start to look a lot less attractive.
- diveanon 5y agoDaily anti-blockchain/web3/cryptocurrency posts from people uninvolved in the space are not interesting to me. I get that this is a massive echo chamber, but it really is getting boring hearing the same inaccurate straw mans and opinions being thrown around.
- smoldesu 5y agoThis is a site about entrepreneurship and venture capital, both of which have Web3/Crypto in their crosshairs. I think reporting on the subject more than average makes perfect sense in this context, considering how much money is getting poured into crypto VCs.
- woodruffw 5y agoI can assure you that I am neither an entrepreneur nor remotely friendly with venture capitalists. But that's just me; I have no idea what other HNers motivations are.
- jclulow 5y agoIt's even more boring to find the "I am so tired of people who don't understand the majesty of the racket I've bought into" comment in every thread on an article that is critical of blockchain-related things.
- woodruffw 5y agoI'd appreciate knowing where the straw-men are. I tried my best to write a post about the things that I want to see in the financial world, and why neither cryptocurrencies nor anyone else has delivered them.
- papito 5y agoIn my old workplace, we had a running joke where at the end of a meeting about using a certain tech stack we brought up blockchain as an option. We laughed, and dispersed. Safe then, and safe now. Blockchain is ancient tech by Internet time, and it still has not been applied to anything useful or practical, despite the constant claim of sky-high promises.
- radicalbyte 5y agoThere are actually some interesting tools that are being marketed under the name "blockchain" but have very little to do with Bitcoin. For example IBM's "Kafka with digital signatures" technology. It's kind of boring, very useful, but by marketing it as "blockchain" they can convince some clueless CEOs that it's worth the extra 0's they're asking for.
- baby 5y agoOr there are cryptocurrencies innovating in a space that is much more general than blockchains. For example, zero knowledge proofs or threshold signatures, which I’m convinced will see many more applications as a result of the cryptocurrencies innovations.
- radicalbyte 5y agoWe're using ZKP in our covid credential system; crypto and "blockchain" are - rightfully - nowhere to be seen.
- baby 5y agoNice. It’s starting to spread :)
- wmf 5y agoIBM canceled all that stuff.
- renewiltord 5y agoThere is a general pattern with Internet commentary where things that are decried as useless or not as good just become the most popular thing. I wonder what it is. I recall this happening in my time here on HN and Reddit. - The iPad - AirPods - Bitcoin - Facebook It’s almost at the point where I think it provides signal that something will be valuable. My personal hypothesis is that it captures the idea “I think this should not be considered valuable but lots of people around me do think it is” which sort of happens only if that last condition exists. So any time I read something like this, it means there’s some sort of invisible popularity for some product I don’t know about. Interesting idea.
- woodruffw 5y agoIt's apparent to me that cryptocurrencies have plenty of value tied up in them at this point. But the object of the post was to solicit a better understanding of whether they've solved the problems I'm interested in.
- 1270018080 5y agoThe money is there, VC people are eager, the concept has been around for years, and like you said, there is a cult base that is absolutely indoctrinated. The world is ready for one (1) implementation of blockchain that actually does something meaningful and better than what already exists. Yet here we are. People are spending their lives trying to convince others that blockchain is a good technology, but nobody actually doing anything with it. It's not like there's a grand conspiracy blocking any companies from being successful, blockchain/crypto is just for con artists and the gullible.
- jyap 5y agoIt’s because we have established living and survival conditions based on decisions we have made through life. These then form biases. E.g. * iPad vs Android ecosystem * Bitcoin/crypto vs fiat A lot of these takes are from disruptive technology.. It’s called disruptive for a reason and that reason gives it lots of arguments to why it could fail against established thinking. So if something had a lot of haters in technology.. it could be a disruptive technology which has a good risk to reward ratio if it becomes adopted.
- aaron695 5y ago> Blockchains don't solve problems that are interesting to me Choose Boring Technology This article is the problem with IT Overseas remittance is a huge ongoing fucking issue. Many NGOs want solutions. A stack of money has been wasted on trying to fix overseas remittance (And many things in the sector) because of people like OP who want easy solutions today. It's a hard problem that takes time. Helping others isn't handing out soup kitchen food with Cher on Xmas then pissing off. Bitcoin/blockchain might take years to fix this. Sorry it's not interesting to everyone, but some people genuinely want to help others and do things in the world, and that's boring.
- agumonkey 5y agovechain had a pragmatic case
- actually_a_dog 5y agoCan you expand on this for someone like me, who's not a crypto wonk?
- agumonkey 5y agoI didn't dig deep but: - vechain lead worked in supply chain - he thought having a unified blockchain based tracking system would be great my few insight in the world made me like the idea because a lot of people are basically doing semi manual tracking, boring and slow.. so a system for this would be a good benefit
- logicalmonster 5y agoIt's fine for the author to not be interested in crypto, but his focus on financial examples indicates that he's probably not really thinking about the most interesting problems that could be solved with Crypto. Digital Money is a huge deal, but it's just the first phase of Crypto's potential. Crypto isn't just about an easy way to send cash from the US to Brazil. Think about smart contracts. Think about Oracles. Think about distributed apps and computation and API access. Crypto might enable radical new things we have barely conceived of yet.
- woodruffw 5y agoI tried to mention the kind of things I'd expect smart contracts to help me with, like creating a debit pool for me and my friends when we go to a bar. The parts that I'm missing are (1) a practical cryptocurrency thingy that actually does that without charging me more than the drinks, and (2) a reason why it shouldn't just be a service that connects to ACH or another settlement layer.
- logicalmonster 5y ago> (1) a practical cryptocurrency thingy that actually does that without charging me more than the drinks, and I don't understand why some people are so cash-averse, but the problem you mention seems best suited to cash at the moment, or perhaps one person having a tab and the rest throwing him some cash at the end of the night. Once Crypto becomes more efficient for this kind of thing (different tech like Algorand, or second layers like Matic) maybe there's a better use case for this kind of smaller problem. > (2) a reason why it shouldn't just be a service that connects to ACH or another settlement layer. Privacy seems like an important enough reason. I don't want the government to know if I choose to go to a gay bar. I don't want my bank who controls whether or not I get a mortgage to know how much I chose to drink one evening.
- woodruffw 5y agoI use cash a lot. The example was me attempting to come up with a use case that I might conceivably actually use. The privacy point is a good one, but it’s also orthogonal: your privacy isn’t particularly well preserved by a global immutable ledger.
- derac 5y agoIf someone disagrees with the article and believes any of these problems are solved, can you detail how?
- dekervin 5y agoBlockchains has been solving my "problems". The issue is he has a very limited set of "problems" in life. and that's fine too.
- jerrygoyal 5y agoand what would be your problems
- toolz 5y agoI see so many first world people writing about crypto not solving problems for them. I'm sure it's not malicious, but crypto is trying to bring equality to finance. Of course it's not going to be obvious or even the focus of crypto to solve problems for the already overly catered to rich people. There's nothing wrong with that and there's nothing wrong with writing about how it doesn't solve problems for you, but don't you think it's a little bit bad to not at least look at problems truly impoverished people have and mention those? I think it's something like 17% of the world is underbanked or unbanked - that means there is a huge issue where families can't save money and the people who work smart and/or hard can't grow out of their situation. I don't mean all crypto is aiming to solve these problems, but it's certainly a category of problem solving that's important to me as a human who wants to see equality in finance, globally.
- earnesti 5y agoCrypto solved very nicely my problems, well the money related problems. Now I am rich and life is comfortable.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- danaris 5y agoI have yet to see any clear explanation for how cryptocurrencies are supposed to solve the problem of people in third-world countries not having access to banking, in practice. For one thing, it seems to me that step 1 in that is understanding why they are underbanked or unbanked, because if it's because they don't have reliable access to the internet...well, that's going to put a bit of a crimp in any plans to get crypto to them.
- toolz 5y agoThere are many articles describing how crypto can help in this category, from people who lack the proper documentation to open bank accounts to people who live in areas that are too high risk for traditional banks to include them. Lack of stable internet is going to be an issue for many, but that's a problem that is being worked on by many organizations and I presume will be solved in time.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoThe biggest problem with all of this blockchain stuff is that all the incentives are around publicizing the scams. On the upswing, the scammer is trying to recruit marks for their pump and dump scheme, so they market their scam to as many people as they can. Then the axe falls and the anti-blockchain take the opportunity to point out how everything is wrong and call for government destruction of the entire technology. Meanwhile some open source developers are trying to decentralize finance and because they're not scammers, they have no marketing budget and nobody knows about what they're trying to do.
- tsimionescu 5y agoWho are these open source developers? What projects are they working on? Help them with some marketing, don't just claim they exist.
- baby 5y agoanybody working with threshold signatures and zero-knowledge proofs.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agohttps://github.com/ong/awesome-decentralized-finance https://github.com/ong/awesome-decentralized-finance But I'd actually be interested in hearing about ones I don't already know about. That's the thing I'm complaining about. Why is every story about some schmucks who are obviously on their way to jail or bankruptcy court and not any of this kind of stuff?
- actually_a_dog 5y ago> The biggest problem with all of this blockchain stuff is that all the incentives are around publicizing the scams. I think you want to differentiate between cryptocurrencies and other blockchain applications here, don't you? Everything[0] I've seen that could be characterized as a straight up scam has been someone pump & dumping their new cryptocoin. --- [0]: Except NFTs, at least as they've been used so far. The concept of an immutable, digital record of ownership of a thing seems good to me (think real property deeds, for instance). But, the idea of using them to claim "ownership" of a JPEG or something seems ridiculous to me on its face. Either I don't understand how it's supposed to work, or a lot of people have been very publicly taken for a lot of money via NFTs.
- neximo64 5y agoWeb3 without crypto is what will work and not be bs.
- djohnston 5y agoI also really enjoy web3 over current web UX. Without crypto you mean non-finance stuff but still a blockchain, or something else?
- finikytou 5y agowhat about transportation? ive heard its heavy paperwork and payment to make sure they ship / pay / deliver things. blockchain would allow to cut many middlemen
- SAI_Peregrinus 5y agoHow? Blockchains don't update themselves based on meatspace events, you'd still have to trust someone to keep track of shipments and add entries to the blockchain.
- noxer 5y agoHere are some answer to the question in the part "Overseas remittance without middlemen" - Where does the money exit? Cross-bolder payment+settlement trough crypto needs an bridge asset in the middle that would be crypto. So the in and out (exit) is done on either side trough a local cryptocurrency exchange or a liquidity provider potentially even a decentralize liquidity pool. But AFAIK currently its only done with normal exchanges. This means both sides could use fiat and theoretically do not need to know that the "money" went trough crypto at all. However there are ofc many people who do it manually i.e. they buy crypto send it to their families and explained to them how they can sell it. - Again, the transaction fees. Western Union is expensive; is Bitcoin or Ethereum doing any better.... Short answer, No. Both BTC and ETH are way too expensive (for typical low value transactions). PoW/PoS can not be cheap to transact because there is always a middleman taking a cut (fee). However there are other systems based on FBA (Federated Byzantine Agreement) which are specifically made to not have a middleman that collects fees. This results in transaction cost of fractions of cents regardless of transaction value and a settlement time of a few seconds. Note that the "cost" can not be zero to prevent spam but that money doesn't go to anyone so no one could have an incentive to raise the cost. Instead the cost adjust to network load so its cheap for everyone who does not spam. - Novel criminal potential. I dont think this will be a problem for commercial implementations of crypto remittance. Companies use some form of risk management with insurance and all that doesn't change much. The actual part where cryoto is involved is probably the easiest to secure (assuming the system explained above is uses and end user never "touch" crypto unless they choose to) For people dong it manually criminal do pose a risk but is it really larger than sending paper money via mail and then potentially take it to a bank to exchange it (yes people are forced to do this). Is it a particularly interesting problem? Probably not for most people but its large, like really really large. Several hundred billion per year and growing 5-10% annually. Million of people affected. Low risk for the target people, they are not encouraged to hold highly volatile assets or use them to pay for something.
- tchock23 5y agoThe best founder I personally know (5 startups, all positive exits) tried his hand at blockchain for enterprise with his recent startup and had to pivot months into it because there wasn’t a valid use case. I haven’t explored it myself, but his experience gave me enough reason to pause for B2B applications.
- jeff303 5y agoIs Nakamoto consensus not an interesting idea?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]