7 ms·
English Teenager Finds Bronze Age Ax Using a Metal Detector
- afandian 5y agoIt's not a 'government guidelines' it's law! For those interested https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treasure_Act_1996 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treasure_Act_1996
- pmyteh 5y agoYes! And the definition of Treasure given in the article is not only incomplete, but isn't the clause that would apply to these objects. (Bronze isn't gold or silver, but these are probably covered as multiple associated prehistoric base metal objects).
- OJFord 5y agoIn fairness, the actual (slightly odd perhaps) phrasing is: > When treasure is found, the finder does not own it, and it is illegal to try to sell it, according to government guidelines. There could well be guidelines that say that, about the law ('it is illegal', as it says). HMRC has plenty of guidelines on what tax you owe and how to pay it etc. for example, but it also comes down to law at the end of it.
- juanani 5y agoHuh, I wonder if they wrote that in after they looted dry their former colonies..
- OJFord 5y agoWhy, what difference would it make? The law is that the crown (potentially) owns it, so assuming you're meaning that it's hypocritical... no not really? (Unless 'they' is 'the British people' who democratically/collectively looted and then later (or whenever it was) wrote laws?)
- tata71 5y agoI thought this thread was already goofy, and then you started talking about the UK as if it was a democracy.
- OJFord 5y agoWell, it is, but I didn't assert that anyway, that was a hypothetical interpretation of the other commenter's 'they' after I'd initially assumed they (the commenter) meant HM's Government.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- fnordian_slip 5y agoAnd it's law for a reason. While interested hobbyists are often appreciated by archaeologists, there are quite a few people who are small-scale Schliemanns (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heinrich_Schliemann#Criticism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heinrich_Schliemann#Criticism). And with metal detectors being rather cheap, the damages these people cause do add up.
- shmde 5y agoQuite funny they have this act considering they stole a lot of very rare and precious artefacts from India. Maybe they should return those too.
- unfunco 5y agoSo what?! Finders keepers! Shut up. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x73PkUvArJY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x73PkUvArJY
- ralfd 5y agoThe NYT article is behind a paywall, but does the landowner gets something too?
- pmyteh 5y agoPayments are ex gratia at the discretion of the Secretary of State, so in principle it's entirely up to them. There is a legally-guiding Code of Practice[0], though, which gives a starting point of 50% to the finder and 50% to the landowner. That proportion can change if there's an agreement about how to divide any spoils between the landowner and the finder in advance of the find, if there's misconduct on behalf of any party (e.g. trespass, failure to report in the legal time limits), etc. The occupier (e.g. tenant) is eligible too, sometimes. [0]: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/treasure-act-1996-code-of-practice-2nd-revision-england-and-wales https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/treasure-act-1996...
- ponow 5y agoMilly should be able to keep or sell what she found, if it was her land. If a museum or government wants these things, then they can go find them themselves on their own land. This socialization of individual efforts is maddening.
- andylynch 5y agoThat's not really how archeology works... the idea is to preserve a shared history and ensure discoveries are properly recorded. Also worth pointing out if something is deemed treasure, an independent valuation is made. If the museums concerned choose to make an acquisition they pay the landowner and finder the value of the find. If they don't, it's returned to the finder or landowner.
- francisofascii 5y agoI think landowner should get some compensation for a find, but I think it would be maddening if the landowner was entitled to anything found on their land. It is not like the Ax belonged to the landowner or was created by the landowner.
- gamerDude 5y agoWhy not? If a company buys land because they think oil is below it, are they not entitled to the oil? It definitely wasn't created by or previously belonged to the oil company.
- dredmorbius 5y agoThat turns out to be a rather interesting rabbithole. Land rights, mineral rights, and rule of capture are suggested terms for exploration. Much of the law has firmer foundations in tradition than any consideration of science, empiricism, justice, or merits.
- panzagl 5y agoIn the western US it is common for mineral, oil, and water rights to be separated from occupation rights to land.
- 271828182846 5y agohave been thinking of taking up that hobby from time to time. somebody here with some insights into it? how would get started?
- the-dude 5y agoDo you have a metal detector?
- debacle 5y agoIf you are in the US, detectoring will be much more boring than in the UK. Best way to get started would be to watch The Detectorists on Amazon.
- newman8r 5y agounless you're into prospecting or meteorite hunting - in which case there's a lot of opportunities in the Southwest US on BLM and other federal land. https://www.detectorprospector.com/ https://www.detectorprospector.com/ is a decent resource The Mojave nugget was found in California with a radio shack metal detector https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mojave_Nugget https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mojave_Nugget
- missedthecue 5y agoI've been doing it for about 8 years. The best part for me is the research. Going through old maps and topographies and aerial photographs is good fun for me. The hardest part is getting permissions from land owners, many of whom have no idea what you're trying to do and are therefore rightly suspicious. But I'm fairly outgoing and friendly in nature so that hasn't been too difficult. As others have mentioned, if you're in the US, you're unlikely to find very old things like European and Asian hobbyists are able to, but finding 150 year old coins and war relics is satisfying enough for me.
- kingcharles 5y agohttps://archive.md/gMdLn https://archive.md/gMdLn
- JoeAltmaier 5y agoI was a little taken aback when they just, kept digging. It was clearly a significant find. To continue disturbing it without taking proper records was a little careless? Maybe when she becomes an archaeologist she will learn a better way.
- milliams 5y agoFor a light-hearted insight into the English metal-detecting scene,. I'd recommend the TV series "Detectorists" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Detectorists https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Detectorists
- seanhandley 5y agoIt is totally sublime.
- scrumper 5y agoI agree. It was lovely to watch, a good-hearted, entertaining, relaxed show with very likable characters and gorgeous photography. And I will forevermore know to call people operating metal detectors "detectorists."
- brnt 5y agoI'll pile on because I haven't seen such an interesting and lovely series in a long, long time. Wish the series would never end!
- dredmorbius 5y agoNot to be confused with a Swiss discovery of a bronze dagger, posted a few days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29405696 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29405696 (I'd thought this might be a dupe, it's not.)
- jacksonkmarley 5y agoTIL there is such a word as 'ax'.
- unbanned 5y agoYou must be using an archaic pronunciation, like when you say ask instead of aks.
- e40 5y agoWait, the only picture is the one at the top of the article? That's absolutely a terrible picture of it.
- unbanned 5y agoAxe
- frosted-flakes 5y agoAx is the American spelling of axe, and the New York Times is an American publication. Hence, "ax" is correct.
- 0xdeadb00f 5y agoAmericans spell it "Ax"?? I had no idea. This is new to me.