10 ms·
Black text on white background (#000 on #fff) used to be standard on computer displays, and still is for many desktop applications. The expectation is that one'
by layer8 5y ago
Black text on white background (#000 on #fff) used to be standard on computer displays, and still is for many desktop applications. The expectation is that one's display is set to a reasonable brightness & contrast settings for that, which usually means less than 50% brightness setting. In addition, as the GP notes, black usually isn't very black on LCD displays (IPS panels in particular).
Web sites using noticably lower text contrast are bad in that one has to constantly adjust the display settings depending on the web site or app. Having less-than-optimal eyesight, I struggle with anything significantly less than pure black on white for running text, with regular contrast/brightness settings.
- Dylan16807 5y agoThere's definitely a specific reasonable brightness level for #fff, depending on room brightness, somewhere in the realm of 200 nits. But I think a reasonable setting for #000 is "as dark as it goes". It doesn't seem right to depend on screen settings to control the contrast against black.
- lhorie 5y ago> Having less-than-optimal eyesight Do you use custom setups to browse the web? I'm curious what your thoughts are on color schemes such as HN's or Google's. Those aren't #000 on #fff but also aren't egregious super low contrast either, and at least to me, moderately high contrast palettes are easier on my eyes when I'm situationally reading in a dark room than pure black on white.
- layer8 5y agoOn Firefox I use the "Font Contrast" add-on. HN is acceptable (barely) on OLED mobile for me, but I’d prefer a white background and blacker text (like e.g. reddit). On other displays I often compensate by increasing the font size, but obviously that’s not optimal.
- junon 5y agoSince you have eyesight considerations, I'm curious: what about white on black (#fff on #000)? Is there any noticeable impact, positive or negative, over black-on-white?
- jakear 5y agoFor my eyes black on white is far superior. White on black results in haloing around all text, whereas black on white results in generally pretty crisp text. This is why I use light themes and high-contrast mode for anything that supports it. (The glaring exception is Spotify) The basic idea is that for folks with blurred vision (not out of focus, literally blurred), bright colors will erode into dark surroundings. Dark text on light background means the text is uniformly slightly lighter than "ground truth", light text on dark background means a distracting halo forms around the text.
- junon 5y agoThe halo coming from your own vision, not as an artifact of the LCD screen or something like that, right? Thanks for the information, this is interesting to note!
- layer8 5y agoNot the GP, but yes, it's a perceptual effect from one's own vision.
- sleightofmind 5y agoThis. A thousand times. I'm an oldster -- and no, 40 is not old. My vision varies from dead sharp to blurry depending on eye fatigue, probably blood sugar levels, and how my rather large floaters are behaving. But by the end of a day of reading, it's almost guaranteed that my eyes will be blurry from fatigue and age-related stiffness, complicated by that modern-day miracle -- replacement lenses for cataracts. As a consequence, reading any light text on dark background when my eyes are blurry is just a mess of haloing. The haloing bleeds three or four lines above and below the line I am reading, creating a big fuzzy mess that's annoying and hard to read. To be clear when I mention floaters, I don't mean the little black squigglies that everyone experiences at any age. Rather mine are more like floating but not completely un-anchored translucent blurs that move right when my eyes move left. I suspect mine are Weiss rings. Know that all that time you spent choosing a font color that is one-level of gray removed from invisible ink will never be enjoyed by me. I've overridden the the default font and font color in my browser to be a nice large, heavy, mono-spaced black font. When my eyes are fresh, yeah, I can read your 300-weight pseudo-invisible ink just fine, but it flatly irritates me, hence the overrides. And right click inspect is my boon companion when reading any page too-trendily designed. If you're less than 40, it's hard to appreciate how age changes one's eyes. So if you're a youngster, have a bit of sympathy for us old folks when choosing color schemes. Or don't. I'm happy you can do creative, and that those of us with less-than-youthful vision can make adjustments. Best of both worlds.
- mech422 5y agoIt might have been standard on web pages... But there was a reason green screens and especially amber/yellow displays were popular long after color displays came out... I still find amber on black one of the easiest color schemes to read. edit: s/on/one/
- layer8 5y agoI used to be quite fond of the amber CRTs, and still am from an aesthetic point of view. Also, for roughly my first decade of programming I used white text on blue background almost exclusively. So I get those who like dark mode. But eventually me and my eyes got older.
- mech422 5y agoyeah - I find as I get older, I prefer a darker environment for working on the computer (turn of the room lights, etc) and a bright(blinding!) environment for working with my hands ;-) (Where did that #%$#% screw go!) I also find, I'm _waaayy_ more annoyed by smudges on my glasses then when I was younger.
- fsckboy 5y ago>there was a reason green screens and especially amber/yellow displays were popular long after color displays came out... yes, and the reason was the fuzzy-blurryness of color display technology at that time, and the fact that those in the industry were already used to monochrome displays and had workflows and settings adapted to monochrome. Once color display quality became high enough, monochrome demand completely evaporated. I'm not saying that there is nothing nice about a monochrome display, and displaying light on black (my terminal and emacs windows are still black background, with a distinct fondness for green; I too am an old-timer), but still...
- mech422 5y ago>>yes, and the reason was the fuzzy-blurryness of color display technology at that time, and the fact that those in the industry were already used to monochrome displays and had workflows and settings adapted to monochrome. Once color display quality became high enough, monochrome demand completely evaporated. Eh? no one had color back then.. You had monochrome - you just got to pick which color you wanted: white, yellow, amber or green. And I never saw monochrome demand 'evaporate' - I saw lots of new people come into computing in the 90s that wanted color for games, photo editing, whatever. edit: what I mean is, there weren't enough of us 'text only' people to make it worth while for manufacturers with the armies of new users coming in with games, gui's and all that
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Black text on white background (#000 on #fff) used to be standard on computer displays Aside from computers with built in (e.g., early Macs) or external TV-style displays that had no color support (e.g., Timex Sinclair 1000), and later Macs even though they had color support, that doesn't seem to have ever been common, even on other machines of the same time. EDIT: It was common on word processing, desktop publishing, and some other apps once WYSIWYG became a big trend, but that was pretty explicitly about print-on-white-paper skeumorphism, not an idea of what was ideal for work on a computer outside of the specific context of mirroring what print would look like.
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> Black text on white background (#000 on #fff) used to be standard on computer displays, and still is for many desktop applications. The expectation is that one's display is set to a reasonable brightness & contrast settings for that Tangentially, original Kindles render black text on a gray background, and it's great. Books use white paper and will hurt your eyes with glare if you read them outdoors. But somehow Amazon has decided that gray is only for their cheapest, crappiest model, and you should be excited about the "PaperWhite" "option". I don't get it.
- yoz-y 5y agoThat gray is a hardware limitation and the white isn’t show white either.
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> That gray is a hardware limitation The gray is markedly superior to the white. It may be a hardware feature, but it's not a "limitation".
- yoz-y 5y agoIt would be nice if the default background color was a choice rather than a price point. Personally I like reading in dimly lit rooms or subway rather than outside, so a brighter “paper” is an advantage. But I definitely understand that for reading on a beach you would like a darker one.