8 ms·
Back when Edgeium was new and just Chrome but with a lot of Google cruft removed, I actually used Edge instead of Chrome when I was on Windows. It was the same
by jeroenhd 5y ago
Back when Edgeium was new and just Chrome but with a lot of Google cruft removed, I actually used Edge instead of Chrome when I was on Windows. It was the same browser with some additional tweaks that I quite liked.
Then Microsoft started this aggressive, disruptive push to bring it to iOS Safari's level as the only browser people should use.
I don't know any good operating systems for normal people anymore. Windows 10 and 11 are hostile, macOS only runs on very expensive hardware and doesn't run most programs people need (because the business world is still Windows oriented) and Linux has been making progress but still isn't a good alternative for the common user unless they have an expert to rely upon when something breaks down. ChromeOS doesn't run on most devices (it can, but the images aren't available) and I wouldn't recommend a Google-oriented OS to most people anyway, if they can avoid it; Android is bad enough already.
I miss the Windows 7 days. The Win10/11 kernel may have seen loads of improvements, the UI and basic behaviour has only been regressing for many years now. The Windows 11 window snapping is nice but it doesn't excuse the aggressive spyware that comes with the OS, and neither does it excuse this antitrust lawsuit in waiting.
- r00fus 5y ago> macOS only runs on very expensive hardware and doesn't run most programs people need (because the business world is still Windows oriented) This is an outdated take - it's functionally untrue in most business settings. Gaming on the other hand, is very much still mostly Windows only.
- mackal 5y ago> Gaming on the other hand, is very much still mostly Windows only. I game a lot, I haven't rebooted into Windows in well over a year. Luckily I don't really play games that require stupid DRM/anticheat (although, that is being worked on) I would probably start playing Apex Legends again if they allowed EAC Linux support. Epic added support, the devs just need to support it -.-
- FinalBriefing 5y agoI've had a great experience with Lutris for Linux. https://lutris.net/ https://lutris.net/
- godshatter 5y agoSteam with proton, proton glorious eggroll, vulkan, lutris, and recent changes to wine have been a godsend for gaming on linux. It's night and day now. Aside from some really old games and newer competitive games (which I don't play regardless of OS), there are very few games that I can't play well in my 200+ steam games library. I often play native games in Windows emulation mode because a lot of linux ports are terrible but proton makes them play much better even though it's running the Windows binaries.
- jonny_eh 5y ago> proton glorious eggroll what?
- 1_player 5y agohttps://github.com/GloriousEggroll/proton-ge-custom https://github.com/GloriousEggroll/proton-ge-custom An experimental patchset for Wine/Proton. Might help with some newer titles, and Steam gives you the choice per-game to target a specific Proton version.
- godshatter 5y agoIt's a version of proton with some of the enhancements that the main proton team either won't or haven't added yet. I haven't looked into whether it's an individual dev doing this on their own or if they are affiliated with the proton team. I run the GE versions of proton because they solve some problems I have in certain games without breaking anything. It's my understanding that the proton devs are from the same team as the wine devs and that they have strict rules about introducing new code that doesn't meet certain standards for wine (i.e. affecting more than just games). The GE builds include some of this code that hasn't been integrated yet "in the right way". This is all just my understanding from reading various discussions, so may be incorrect in whole or in part.
- smoldesu 5y agoI'd agree if they still had 32-bit support. Nowadays though, even most creatives are getting frustrated by the vicious upgrade cycle and outright refusal to continue support for fairly modern tooling. If by "business" you mean word processing and web browsing, then... yeah. Chromebooks are also a competitor if we're bringing the bar that low.
- nyuszika7h 5y agoHonestly, Apple (and Microsoft) should have dropped 32-bit support sooner. The only reason it's such a big issue now is because lazy developers kept building apps that are 32-bit only because "it works fine on 64-bit systems". The same thing happened with the Python 2 -> 3 transition.
- smoldesu 5y agoThat doesn't really fix the paradigm today though. A lot of people (myself included) consider 32-bit support to be essential if they want their device to run everything they want, and I don't really see that going away until there are convenient, performant ways to execute 32-bit code on modern CPUs.
- selfhoster11 5y agoA big reason why some people stayed on 32-bit was that 64 bit consumes more memory while providing not much useful in return when your address space doesn't exceed 4GB. In an era when you rarely had machines with this much RAM, 32 bit computing is a perfectly rational choice to maximise the amount of memory available.
- Tagbert 5y agoWhen I installed Catalina, only 6 32-bit apps were flagged. I had already known about one of them and had moved on to a replacement app. I had forgotten about the others and this was just some junk cleanup for me.
- nitrogen 5y agofunctionally untrue in most business settings Most business settings have some absolutely critical custom software written in Winforms or something that can't be ported, plus an entire machine of IT personnel and software tools that would be just as costly to convert.
- dogma1138 5y agoMicrosoft somewhat already did the work needed to migrate of windows by making Active Directory and Group Policy irrelevant. With office 365 and intune you can essentially have the same control as traditional AD joined machines actually Intune probably has better management than GPO these days. The only thing that is still missing for corpo is Intune for Linux and even that isn’t 100% required as long as there will be Intune for Edge on Linux, once you can manage the browser the majority of the controls the organization needs are handled.
- fragmede 5y agoSo run it through Parallels. If IT doesn't want to do it that's a different problem, but the Windows on Intel Macs hasn't been a problem for business programs for a while.
- Tagbert 5y ago“custom software written in Winforms or something that can't be ported” I haven’t seen any of these in almost a decade. there are specialized use cases that require some specialized software, but for most business operations the software works cross platform or runs from web apps. I used to keep a parallels instance to run MS SQL server for some tasks but we have even transitioned that to a less propriety setup.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mnholt 5y ago> macOS only runs on very expensive hardware and doesn't run most programs people need (because the business world is still Windows oriented) What programs won't run on macOS that "normal people" are going to need? In my experience most "normal people" use a web browser, the Office suite, and maybe some Adobe programs.
- nicoburns 5y agoAccounting software perhaps?
- minimaul 5y agoAt least in the UK, this is getting ever more cloud oriented. A lot of especially small-business accounting software is online.
- dvngnt_ 5y agogames and all gaming related software
- ehutch79 5y agoNo one at my company needs games or gaming related software to do work. I imagine that's true for most companies.
- 5y ago
- Angostura 5y ago> iOS Safari's level as the only browser people should use. FWIW, iOS doesn't chide you when you download Chrome or Firefox. Of course Apple requires them to use the iOS rendering engine - but that's perhaps a slightly different point.
- jeegsy 5y ago> Of course Apple requires them to use the iOS rendering engine How is apple allowed to do this? Would MSoft have escaped the legal trouble back then if they had simply insisted that Netscape had to run like IE?
- freediver 5y agoForcing the rendering engine upon a browser manufacturer is just "cost of doing business" on iOS. It does not have as negative consequences as forcing an entire browser upon a user (like Microsoft is doing). Chrome on iOS can still do pretty much everything it wants, including telemetry, sync etc. The users are ensured to get a browser with a rendering engine that is carefully optimized for performance and battery life by the phone manufacturer, so I'd argue the user is actually better off.
- bko 5y agoIs it still impossible to set your default browser on iOS? That to me is even more hostile than just having me click an extra button once to download it.
- selfhoster69 5y agoI don't think so. Didn't a recent software update change this?
- somehnguy 5y agoStarted with iOS 14, so a little over a year ago.
- dustinmoris 5y ago> macOs.... doesn't run most programs people need (because the business world is still Windows oriented) This is not only not true for many years anymore, it's even got so far that it's almost the opposite now. Most successful businesses nowadays are increasingly led by tech-savvy leaders, because otherwise they wouldn't be successful anymore, and those people make their own software now increasingly better on macOS than Windows for their own selfish reasons because they all run on MacBooks, iPhones and Apple Watches today. Even Microsoft's own software ironically works MUCH better on macOS than Windows. Try Office on macOS and you'll be surprised how good it is compared to Windows :)
- avalys 5y agoYou seem to have ignored the entire class of businesses that don’t “make their own software” at all.
- dustinmoris 5y agoUh yes? If you don’t make software then obviously you won’t make software for macOS either lol? Those folks also us macOS, but that was not the poiI tried to make.
- mthoms 5y ago>Even Microsoft's own software ironically works MUCH better on macOS than Windows. Try Office on macOS and you'll be surprised how good it is compared to Windows That has not been my experience (though I wish it were). Excel on MacOS still feels clunky and has significant performance problems with big files - including crashes.
- ehutch79 5y agoIn my experience excel has gotten significantly better in the last 2-3 years. Though yes, that accounting sheet that has 2 million blank rows, and some macro trying to access a file in c:\windows\system32 is likely still causing problems... (not kidding)
- 5y ago
- coolso 5y ago> Then Microsoft started this aggressive, disruptive push to bring it to iOS Safari's level as the only browser people should use. Counter-point: my dislike of Edge aside (especially since it uses Chromium instead of their own engine, which is lame), Google has made an aggressive, disruptive push to switch people to Chrome for many years now, which itself has made some aggressive, disruptive effects on the web. Is a little friendly "popup" from a competitor in a style all other browsers incorporate really such a bad thing to help keep Google's market dominance in check a bit? I don't think Microsoft or Firefox should just roll over and do nothing while Google pushes Chrome in everyone's face every chance it gets - it seems to have cooled off a bit recently (or maybe that's just due to me switching to DuckDuckGo permanently) but in the very recent past it was still doing so. > I don't know any good operating systems for normal people anymore. Windows 10 and 11 are hostile May I ask what makes you think this? Occasional oddities aside, I've found Win10/11 to make for an incredibly pain-free desktop experience. While the upgrade to Windows 11 was a bit of a pain due to all of the weird system requirements - I have the hardware required, but apparently not everything was enabled or set up properly and it took some effort to do so - and the start button location is still taking some getting used to, it mostly Just Works and gets out of my way. I've found it to be the opposite of hostile.
- alexiaya 5y agoI don't necessarily think either is a good thing, but Microsoft is being far more aggressive than Google is. - In Windows 10, they already made it harder to change your default browser. You have to explicitly open the Settings app and go to the relevant page (maybe if you're lucky the app you're using can link you there at least), and then when you try to change your default browser it will try to push you to try Edge. - In Windows 11, they went even further: you now have to change the default apps separately for every single protocol and file extension, rather than having an option to set an app as default for everything it supports. The concept of a "default web browser" that's easy to understand for the average user no longer exists. - When Firefox decided to implement a hack to let users directly change their default browser with a single click, Microsoft decided to patch it because "it can be used by malware to hijack your default browser". Which would be a completely reasonable explanation if we ignored the context this is happening in, but they're making their ulterior motive painfully obvious. - And now, they're going even further by injecting unwanted and unprofessional self-promotion into third-party websites without the user's consent. It's quite different from what Google is doing, because they only suggest you to switch to Chrome when you visit Google Search, they don't try to stop you when you try to download Edge or Firefox from Chrome. I seriously hope Microsoft gets hit with an antitrust lawsuit again, they completely deserve it. Looks like they haven't learned from last time. If MS really cared about security as they claim rather than competition, they could very easily implement a popup dialog that shows up when an app tries to change your default browser. Heck, maybe even make it part of UAC for extra security. That way, it would only take two clicks and be also far more secure than whatever they're doing right now. Also, I'm not entirely sure about this, but I remember reading somewhere that MS is also doing the same on Firefox downloads. While Google may somewhat deserve it (though that doesn't make MS's behavior any less user-hostile), Mozilla definitely doesn't deserve it as Firefox already has a quite low market share.
- donmcronald 5y ago> Back when Edgeium was new and just Chrome but with a lot of Google cruft removed, I actually used Edge instead of Chrome when I was on Windows. I fell for it too. There was a brief period where you could do a clean Win10 install, log in to the OS with your MS account, and everything just worked and synced in a "this is nice" sort of way. The cynic in me kept thinking "don't fall for it," but it was too convenient. Now I regret it and the only reason I haven't switched back to local accounts is because I'm not happy with any of the competition either.
- taeric 5y agoFwiw, my family has been perfectly happy with various Linux machines. Most things work with just a browser. Such that my kid's school just gives Chromebooks. They prefer the Ubuntu and Pop os machines, but are fine with any. The windows machine was ok when we had it, but it did crash more. I only regret some content creation tools. Used to regret gaming, but steam has come a long way.
- marcodiego 5y ago> window snapping is nice A long time ago, I helped the development of some useful compiz plugins: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-X9bcrJ3TjY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-X9bcrJ3TjY . I abandoned the development when compiz was rewritten in c++, but the next step we planned was to add the choice of some fixed window layouts. Seems very close to what window snapping turned out.
- mise_en_place 5y agoAnecdotal but I’ve never had any issue with Linux. Aside from installing Nvidia proprietary drivers when secureboot is enabled. In which case DKMS is broken so I had to enroll a new signing key in MOK and use that to sign the nvidia kernel driver. If I need to run Windows, I will either use WINE or single GPU pass through to a Windows VM on KVM. Never needed to dual boot. Edge on Linux is great actually, I just don’t like that I can’t disable the listening on avahi ports even though I have disabled avahi. Apparently Edge uses it to mask IP when using WebRTC.
- pierrebai 5y agoThat was a crash course on how to self-disprove one's argument, all in the first sentence. "It works well, except for this extremely common use case that requires arcane knowledge to fix."
- mise_en_place 5y agoOr you could just disable SecureBoot. I needed it for a specific use case on my laptop that had sensitive work related information (full disk encryption plus SecureBoot enabled).
- raxxorrax 5y agoIt is secure boot specific which I believe is a in theory working but in reality a broken mechanism because of certificate logistics. We could also call it Microsoft Boot at this point. Sure, it will work better in Windows, but it comes at a hidden price. Also, this won't give you too many benefits aside from convenience to skip one password entry, while any Saas will at some point leverage it against you if it every gets popular. That is basically the gist of secure boot or trusted platform in general right now. Smartphones are trusted platforms and their software landscape is atrocious and predatory. Trusted platforming would move it in exactly the same direction. Meanwhile boot viruses have become quite rare, because phishing and extortion is much more profitable.
- badsectoracula 5y ago> Linux has been making progress but still isn't a good alternative for the common user unless they have an expert to rely upon when something breaks down IME "common users" already rely on an expert when their Windows OS breaks down. Not long ago I had to walk my aunt through opening the command prompt in Windows 10 and entering the command to do a full reboot (as opposed to that hybrid shutdown+hibernation) because for some reason i couldn't really figure out from the phone the WiFi stopped working even after shutdown/reboots (she shuts her computer down whenever she isn't using it and she called me after not having connection for days). I remembered reading at some point that normally in Win10 the kernel doesn't shutdown fully but instead hibernates and my guess was that the WiFi driver somehow got in a state that didn't let it work and instead of restarting at reboot it was getting hibernated so i tried to do a full reboot. Which worked, though it could have also been something else that happened to get unstuck after the full reboot - at some other time she also had the entire taskbar get frozen and that would persist normal reboots (via alt+f4 and selecting to reboot) which was also "fixed" by that full reboot (she has the steps and commands to type written in a piece of paper by now :-P). Not to mention the myriad of issues encountered due to forced updates. I think that the whole "Windows is good for common users" idea is very outdated nowadays, it might have been the case a decade or so ago, but it certainly isn't anymore.
- Dylan16807 5y agoIf Windows says "restart" that should always mean a full reboot as far as I know. I usually disable fast startup, and it sounds like she should disable it too. Whoever set it up so that you have to reboot to shut down should have realized that the way they were implementing this was a bad idea.
- badsectoracula 5y ago> If Windows says "restart" that should always mean a full reboot as far as I know. That is what i expected but it doesn't seem to work that way and i had issues myself with it with other things, like e.g. some older games use the system timer (which is reset at full shutdown) for their animations but if the timer is a large number the animations and movement might break. This wasn't much of an issue back when most PCs were shut down every day as it would reset the timer, but nowadays the timer state persists after reboots - it was what actually prompted me to figure out how to reboot the PC from the command line as that does a full reboot. It might be a bug that persisted for a long time or some intentional feature, but either way it is something i've experienced on my PCs and for that reason i have a small shortcut that calls 'shutdown' with the parameters for a full reboot.
- ddtaylor 5y agoIf you're a user with low experience and all you want is to browse the web Linux actually works quite nicely.
- arendtio 5y agoSo what are the typical attributes of a normal user? AFAIK, everybody who doesn't need an expert to care for his system, would be capable of installing and running one of the more popular and user friendly Linux distributions. If you need an expert anyway, it doesn't matter much which OS you use. The only exception I can think of are disabled people, who might rely on very specific software.
- overshadow 5y ago> Linux has been making progress but still isn't a good alternative for the common user For non tech savvy people, Linux can cause problems, but only if they do something weird to their system. Linux, specifically Ubuntu or Mint, untouched, and unaltered is a great out-of-the-box experience. The key (if turning someone on to Linux for the first time) is to stress that the command line is for power users who want full control of every bit on the system. It's best to gradually introduce the command line once they're familiar with using the system and are comfortable doing their first (command line) update/upgrade ritual.
- jeroenhd 5y agoI agree, but when you Google "Ubuntu 21 sound not working" you end up here https://help.ubuntu.com/community/SoundTroubleshootingProcedure https://help.ubuntu.com/community/SoundTroubleshootingProced... and the first thing you see is tons of shell commands and very outdated GUI controls. This is the vendor documentation, not even a StackExchange forum. When you Google for "Windows 11 sound not working" the first result I get is https://www.makeuseof.com/fix-no-audio-windows-11/ https://www.makeuseof.com/fix-no-audio-windows-11/ which is much more user friendly. The system itself is one part of the problem, and that's the part that has been improving for years. The community providing technical help is another; Linux help forums are often full of technical users advising technical users whereas Windows help threads are usually novice users asking help and getting it in simple terms.
- AshamedCaptain 5y agoThis is actually a good observation. Yes, the Windows results are full of what I would call useless crap (e.g. "make sure you did not mute the speaker!"), but for real newbies that is likely to be useful advice, and much more likely to solve their problem than say digging into alsa.cfg internals (which is highly unlikely to be the source of the problem).
- FalconSensei 5y ago> Linux has been making progress but still isn't a good alternative for the common user unless they have an expert to rely upon when something breaks down I'd say there are 2 main problems with Linux (for non-techies, etc, etc): 1 - They are not using 'linux', they are using one of the main distros, that can have some big differences between them. That also happens with Android, BUT, people that use a Galaxy S20 will google `S20 how to xyz` without even knowing how Android differs 2 - As mentioned in other comments, setting up can be a pain. Windows have enough drivers that installing it is just a matter of putting the cd/flashdrive and clicking next-next-finish. Some big distros might have sorted that out, but then you go back to problem #1 if they are the ones having to decide on a distro 3 (bonus) - Most people don't actually benefit from having too many choices, specially from things they don't care about. Usually they will choose a smartphone by 'it looks nice, camera is good, the interface is beautiful'. For me, sounds like this could be improved if instead of recommending Linux, we (tech folks) collectively decided on just one distro to recommend to non-technical people. But I doubt that would be possible
- boznz 5y agoThere is only one main problem for linux and it is the catch 22 that most software is still mostly written for windows. I'm not talking about the generic off-the-shelf software like office/paint/browsers which have pretty good alternatives, but the 25+ years of legacy win32 stuff which still runs most businesses and factories. Lets face it nobody wants to re-write that program that Bill wrote in 2001 in Delphi or VB that interfaces to the stamping machine. I'm a Delphi Developer who moved to NZ in 2005 and several programs are still live and running in UK factories. A tribute to the Win32 sub-system rather than my programming I assure you :-)
- FalconSensei 5y agooh yeah, sure. My comment was meant for personal/home use. Work is a complete other thing since it adds more restrictions.
- BenjiWiebe 5y agoPoint number two is more the other way around. You plug a device into Linux and it works. You plug it into windows, and it only works once it's downloaded and installed the driver. But in both cases, actual user interaction required is very little and decreasing with time. I will admit though, that if something doesn't work immediately with Linux, there's a good chance you won't be able to get it working with Linux.
- Fogest 5y agoI actually only recently switched to Edge and have been enjoying it. Google is not totally innocent in this battle either. At least once a week if not more often when I am in my Gmail, on my Google Calendar, or on the Google search pages I get a little banner in the top right just like the Edge one seen in this article telling me I'd get a better experience if I switched to Chrome and have a similar download style button. And with how prevalent Google's webpages are the majority of the web users will see these adverts if they aren't using Chrome. So I'd argue that Google is not really much better than Microsoft in this regard. I guess the difference is that Microsoft has an additional avenue to advertise since they control more of the software stack. The things I have more of a problem with are the dark behaviours for things like changing my default browser. I noticed when I originally would install Google Chrome and it asks if I want to make it my default, the process to do so is more complicated. Chrome can only pop up Windows default application chooser settings dialogue and then you have to manually switch the default browser in there. Microsoft will give multiple messages you have to go through before it sets it as default. Whereas when I recently switched back to Edge they had the same banner asking if I wanted to make Edge default, except when I clicked "yes", that was all. Microsoft was able to directly make that change without having me go through the weird process of switching defaults. When one company gives themselves artificial advantages over their competitors like this that is when things start to get weird for me. For now I am going to stick with Edge for a bit, but if they continue to do things like implementing "buy now pay later" schemes I'll probably go back to Chrome.