14 ms·
My worst tech interview experience
- dom96 5y agoA recent interview experience that stuck with me was being told at the end of it that I obviously know my stuff but I just need more interview experience...
- selcuka 5y agoThat must be the epitome of stupidity. "You know your stuff but we won't hire you because you can't easily leave us".
- willio58 5y agoWow.. imagine if jobs were interviews, everyone would know how to mergesort in 15 languages from memory but not a single person would know what a div was.
- musicale 5y agoMy worst tech interview experience: all of them. > Also, writing code on a whiteboard is fucking stupid — so there’s that. Many places have switched to google docs now. Still just as stupid though.
- MarcelOlsz 5y agoI love having informal meetings with recruiters, and half an hour later it turns out they are looking for java developers, not javascript. >My worst tech interview experience: all of them. Agreed. I thought it gets better. It doesn't. It gets way worse. Best jobs I interviewed for were around 2010 for jQuery and wordpress jobs.
- Kye 5y agoI wonder if this works as a heuristic. It seems like companies working with mature software would have less pretense, and so feel less need to gatekeep. Working with stuff like PHP or classic libraries and frameworks might signal they recognize they're just tools to get a job done, and it doesn't matter how you go about it as long as it's on time, on budget, meets the spec, and won't get them sued.
- pcthrowaway 5y agoto be fair, jQuery is pretty 'mature' at this point
- Kye 5y agoThat's the classic library I had in mind. I could have been clearer. It's not perfect, but it's as good as any library would be after 15 years of changes to meet new needs.
- actually_a_dog 5y agoSeriously? Google docs are even worse than whiteboards.
- ant6n 5y agoAt least Google Docs hast Syntax Highlighting ... Oh wait.
- skeeter2020 5y agoThat would be funny if you solved their stupid question, then spent the rest of the time formating the doc to add syntax highlighting. Interviewer: You can ask clarifying questions if you need to You: What theme do you want me to use when I format this code? Monokai? Atom?
- trhway 5y ago>Many places have switched to google docs now. back then (~2004) for Google phone screen you had to "write", ie. to voice it, correct code over the phone - good luck if you didn't know that beforehand like me and was at the place without whiteboard nor pen&paper nor took laptop with you (i was just walking that Bay trail around Sun (nowdays FB) MPK campus), and i got the impression that they really expected you do to it from the mind ie. using say pen&paper would be cheating (i should have tried stick on the sand though :).
- pc86 5y agoEven more stupid. "We'll 'let' you use a computer to do our totally contrived, useless code exercises, but you can't just share your screen and use an IDE so we can see how you actually. No, just use 2020's WordPad."
- microtherion 5y agoI don't love giving coding interviews, but we use CoderPad nowadays, which is pretty reasonable for this task, IMHO. Acceptable editor, you can run your code, etc. And as the interviewer, I can replay the session afterward if I want to retrace the path the candidate took.
- boppo1 5y agoWere your experiences at the jobs positive?
- Guest42 5y agoI think a fun/useful question would be along the lines of tell me one of the biggest mistakes you’ve made in X language that shows up quite a bit on the resume.
- oneepic 5y agoI'm not so sure. I just simulated that question in my head with C# and I can't think of a single interesting answer despite 3 years of using it.
- nathanaldensr 5y agoI dislike these questions. Not everyone compartmentalizes their experiences using technology into "best," "worst," "biggest," etc. I have 26 years of software development experience. At this point, it's all feel, intuition, and instinct.
- milofeynman 5y agoA big Fintech company asked me to go to wikipedia and look up k-means squared algorithm. Implement it with tests, from scratch. No sample data etc. In about 45 minutes. I was applying for an Android position. Still sticks with me to this day how cold the interviewer was. It's a great learning experience and has made me a better interviewer This should be an entertaining thread.
- Gunax 5y agoI think this shows how difficult interpretations can be. The interviewer was probably just kidding around, but given the stakes and the unfamiliar environment, it was probaboy a rough comment. It's a good lesson in behavior. Even professional adults screw up and have foot-in-mouth moments.
- zdragnar 5y agoKidding around is kinda risky- it can easily come off as not taking you or your time seriously. Treat people with respect seems to be uncommon common sense.
- ska 5y ago>I think this shows how difficult interpretations can be It's not interpretation, really, I think. It speaks to the asymmetry of the situation and how, if you are the interviewer, you need to be thoughtful about what you say at all. I learned this early on, much to my chagrin. An interviewee was obviously stuck and getting themselves in a muddle so I stopped them and redirected to a different question; I thought it was in a lighthearted manner and communicated that I wanted them to relax and regroup - found out later they felt I was making fun of them and had a terrible interview experience. Ever since then I've been much more careful and explicit. What I thought was being considerate was read as being condescending, I suspect, even though my intent was pure the situation is fraught with potential for miscommunication.
- microtherion 5y agoIt's difficult to know how best to react to interviewees being stuck. If you leave them stuck, they may take it badly; if you redirect them, they may take it as a sign that they "failed" this part of the interview. I try to say something along the lines of "OK, I think it's time to move on to something else; in an interview situation, you sometimes go down a blind alley, but that does not really reflect on the real world, and I think I've seen enough to move on to the next subject."
- ska 5y ago
- zerr 5y agoSomewhat tangential (for the possible future): out of blue my paypal account was suspended recently, permanently, and they refuse to give any reason. Now I'm thinking to apply for some positions there only to raise this topic with the hiring manager :)
- skeeter2020 5y agoSimilar boat here. If you get an interview let me know so you can check mine too :)
- davesque 5y agoHad an interviewer literally laugh in my face at an answer I gave once and exclaim "Oh my god!". Never forgot that.
- x3n0ph3n3 5y agoThat sounds like a wildly inappropriate response, but mind telling us more?
- davesque 5y agoSure. I guess I won't name names, but it happened something like ten years ago. It was for a pretty large online stock trading platform. It was a previous era of my career when I was a full stack web dev. The interview question involved some kind of CSS gotcha. I couldn't figure it out and asked if I could Google it. The interviewers agreed. I pulled up some search results and started looking past the first few because they looked kinda click baity. One of the interviewers said something like, "Whoa, back up and look at the first link. That guy knows what he's talking about; he's the man." So I clicked on it and took a look. But by that time I was pretty nervous and my brain just wasn't working. I looked over the article and couldn't make sense of it quickly enough to figure out the answer. I think I told the interviewers something to that effect. That's when one of them laughed out loud and said, "Oh my god! It's right there in front of you!" I didn't get the job of course. That situation has replayed a lot of times in my head since then. It was one of those things where I wish I could have done something glorious and snarky to put the guy in his place. Probably best that I didn't do that though. I think reacting defensively like that just incurs an emotional cost.
- selcuka 5y ago> I didn't get the job of course Congratulations.
- mixmastamyk 5y agoThose are exactly the kind of assholes that should be named.
- chris_wot 5y agoI would love it if, at some point, the interviewers go for a job, and they get told to implement a merge sort in C on a whiteboard.
- cmckn 5y agoI think merge sort is actually pretty intuitive, why not go for the gold with quicksort?
- krasin 5y agoQuicksort is actually possible; it's really simple. What really would tick the box is Timsort: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timsort https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timsort
- thaumasiotes 5y agoMergesort and quicksort both work on the principle of sorting both halves of a list separately and then combining them. But mergesort is much simpler than quicksort. Mergesort makes dividing the list in half easy: you just cleave the list at the halfway point. Then it's your job to assemble two small sorted lists into one big sorted list, which is also easy. Quicksort makes assembling the large list easy: everything in the left list is smaller than everything in the right list, so all you need to do is concatenate the two sublists. But we've made something that was already easy even easier at the cost of making dividing the list much more difficult. Now instead of cutting the list in half, we have to rearrange it into a small part on the left and a large part on the right. (Actually, you can just assemble new lists by filtering the input for small numbers (and passing them to the left) and then refiltering for large numbers (and passing them to the right). You're already doing O(n) work on the input, so doing O(n) work two more times won't change the asymptotic complexity. But anyone who's looking for an elegant solution will hate you.)
- strikelaserclaw 5y agoyes, if u don't remember it, it takes a big of thought to how to use two pointers to sort left and right for quicksort
- ulkesh 5y agoI ask tech questions in interviews as a litmus test (for any given concept) and it always relates directly to the work being done so they can get a feel of the kind of code they would be writing and maintaining. As an example -- in my line of work, one task we perform is processing files, some small, some medium, some very large; and I wanted to make sure a candidate understood the concept of Maps in order to perform O(n) to create a map and O(1) to look up items (generally speaking, I'm sure it's not exactly that in practice), which aide in efficient processing (the age old processor vs memory tradeoff). This particular candidate got everything I asked immediately, and the interview was very short. The person was made an offer soon after and has gone on to learn what we've done, adapt, and also teach us some things that have made the software better. And the moment candidates grok the concepts I'm after, I confirm that's what I was after, and move on, trying not to waste too much time on any given item. And if they don't get the concepts after a short while, I try to lead them there and see how they react (is it a lightbulb moment or a confusion moment, etc). These are all signs for me to determine if someone is right for the position. Interviewing is a 2-way street of respect. The interviewer often has all the perceived power, but in my experience, a good interviewer eschews that perception right from the get-go and lets the interviewee know that this is more of a discussion than any kind of trickery or exam, even when it contains coding questions. This is why I will never interview for Google or any other company that has multi-stage interviews and also employs time-wasteful, and sometimes esoteric, methods such as "How many jelly beans fit in a school bus?"
- SCUSKU 5y agoI wholeheartedly agree with your idea of having a 2-way street of respect, and treating interviews less like interrogations and more like discussions. It certainly feels more natural that way, and puts less pressure on the interviewee. Regarding Google specifically, I just interviewed there about 2 weeks ago, and although I didn't get the job, I will say I felt very respected, and with the exception of maybe one interview, thought everything felt like a discussion. There were no trick questions, everything was fairly straightforward. Basically a leetcode medium/hard for the 4 technicals and just discussing my experiences in various situations for the "Googleyness" interview. I have heard similar stories about Google using these trick questions, but from what I understand these were mistakes made in the earlier days of the company and have been effectively phased out, although that is purely speculative.
- hereforphone 5y agoI've had bad interview experiences. I think most of us who've been working for awhile have. I have advice for those who are newish: Walk away if you're uncomfortable. If you're not feeling right in the interview I bet you won't feel right on the job, either. If you're being mistreated just walk away. Bonus points for getting up while the interviewer is in mid-sentence and telling them it's not a fit.
- nickff 5y agoI was with you until the last sentence. The best way to respond to rudeness is clearly and politely, unless they're screaming, berating, or threatening you. If you make a habit of responding to rudeness by acting politely, you will impress everyone other than the perpetrator(s).
- hereforphone 5y agoIt is possible to stand up and tell the interviewer (while he's in mid-sentence) that it's not a fit, politely.
- nickff 5y agoMaybe we have different ideas of what qualifies as polite, but standing up and interrupting someone mid-sentence seems rude to me.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- monkeybutton 5y agoWhat's interesting to me is that CS adjacent fields are going through the same teething pains as CS for how to conduct interviews. My background is in engineering and I'm familiar with the terrible experiences the article's author has had. At least now there is some awareness and acceptance that there are bad ways to conduct interviews and that stopping that just might be a good idea. Since then I've moved into the data science/ML world and its like starting at square zero. The field is broader and deeper than CS. Interviews are like being a ping pong ball being smashed on one side by someone with a PhD in physics and aggressively returned in kind by an economist.
- lfowles 5y agoHands down my worst interview experience was one where I was grilled on exact versions of operating systems, compilers, and software I used. Then over the phone I was asked to implement some simple functions in C++ but the interviewer kept getting annoyed I'd use shorthand like "array of doubles" and wanted me to say it like I was dictating into a compiler! The interview was cut short after I made a few off by one mixups in the code, probably for the best...
- bluedevil2k 5y agoWhat?? You had to do a coding interview over the phone?? That’s probably the craziest story on this page!
- lfowles 5y agoI'm really not sure what the purpose of the call was! It was my first scheduled contact with the company after sending in my resume, but it was directly with the hiring manager and he got right into writing code over the phone. I've checked their Glassdoor page again this year and my experience seems common.
- city41 5y agoI did a coding interview over the phone with Google. This was around 2006 maybe 2007. I did it in my car with a notebook in my lap. I don't remember the question but it was "leetcodish"
- xur17 5y agoI actually did one of these as well. We couldn't get the video call to work, so the interviewer ended up having me write the code down, and then read it to him over the phone. At the time if felt pretty dumb (and still kinda does), but he was fairly reasonable about it, and most of the back and forth was me describing the algorithm to him.
- avl999 5y agoI generally don't mind whiteboard programming interviews but even so asking someone to implement merge sort is a bad question. My sanity check for any question I ask is- Is the question I'm asking something that someone in the past published a paper about? If so then that's probably not a good fit for a 45 minute whiteboarding interview. This question falls in that category. Generally those algorithms are complex enough that it is unrealistic to expect someone to get them right from first principles so at that point you are just selecting for people who just happened to have dealt with them, memorized them or implemented them recently. I have a co-worker who used to ask people to past to parse and evaluate infix notation expressions in interviews (and there are companies that ask that question). Always stuck me as weird as multiple papers have been written about that problem, are you really expecting someone to implement a solution to a problem that people spend weeks (months?) thinking about before publishing? Could even Djikstra have come up with the Shunting Yard Algorithm in a 45 minute interview (with implementation on whiteboard) if that was his first exposure to the problem of expression parsing?
- lhorie 5y agoYep. I think it goes further than whether there's a published paper about. It boils down to "does the question have exactly one correct answer?" One important thing you learn in interviewer workshops is to avoid asking questions with "aha" components, i.e. things that can only be solved if a very specific insight is known. This type of question is problematic because it falls victim to the fallacious assumption that a candidate that excels in one specific problem must necessarily excel at others that are in actuality, at best, only marginally related. Instead, it is better to ask questions for which the solution can be arrived at with small increments in effort (e.g. maybe there's an obvious brute force solution and you start from there to discuss more optimal solutions, or maybe the candidate got stuck on some specific peculiarity and you can give a hint to unblock them and move on to another part of the problem to get more signal)
- azhenley 5y agoThe "aha moment" is also known as the eureka effect. Psychologists call this "insight problem solving", which is terrible for interviewing since like you said since it isn't a problem that you can build up towards solving. As a teacher, I try to make sure my assignments/quizzes don't fall victim of this. For anyone interested, there are a lot of interesting studies on the topic if you search on Google Scholar. You've probably already seen matchstick arithmetic problems before (i.e., move a single matchstick to make the equation valid).
- baskethead 5y agoIf Google re-interviewed all their current programmers, what percentage of them would pass the phone screen and onsites and get another job offer?
- Johnny555 5y agoWhat percentage would pass the interviews but knowing what they know now about working at Google, would take an offer at another company?
- semitones 5y agoI think almost all would pass the phone screen and maybe less than 90% would pass the interview again.
- danielvaughn 5y agoI thought about this a lot at my former job. When I first applied, we were 30 people strong, but 4 years later we were 150 people and had hired veterans from the NSA/FBI/NASA/FB/Google etc. I often thought, I definitely would not be hired if I re-applied right now.
- kamaitachi 5y agoThis is a very good question. I work in a Wall Street trading company. Up til about 6 years ago, I was actively involved in recruiting tech staff and defining our tech recruitment process. I’ve since changed roles, but was recently asked to sit in on an interview. Wow, how things have changed. I seriously doubt I would be successful going through the current recruitment process. Any why? Focus on whiteboard programming with questions that far exceed the requirements for the day-to-day job. Somewhere along the line, egos took over and we have a bunch of devs on an ego trip to prove how smart they are.
- taurath 5y agoIt would be actually great if they did exactly that, as an anonymized experiment somehow. My guess would be 40-60%.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- AnotherGoodName 5y agoAt one of the FAANGs the number one thing they drummed in during training for the interviewer is that "interviews are not an opportunity to make you, the interviewer, appear smart!". It's obvious but geek culture sometimes need things like this explicitly stated.
- strikelaserclaw 5y agoanyone can appear smart if they know the question beforehand.
- Flankk 5y agoI don't see the problem. Writing code by hand has its roots in the early days of computing with punch cards and C is ubiquitous. I suppose the comment was somewhat snide but if your skin is that thin are you able to work on a team without becoming the problem?
- ziddoap 5y agoI don't understand why "roots in the early days of computing" is inherently good. We've learned a lot since those days. As a fun example, imagine defending storing plaintext passwords "because it has it's roots in the early days of computing". Other than "because we've always done it that way", what do you learn about a candidate in a 30-60 minute whiteboard interview where you ask them to implement something they'll never have to implement on the job, while restricting them from all of the resources they have been trained to rely on (internet access, man pages, etc.)?
- Flankk 5y agoSorting algorithms are taught as part of every CS degree and C is still used today. The only real change is there are a lot more low-quality programmers than there used to be. If you have to cheat to pass a test I think that would tell the interviewers a lot. Any code monkey can search StackOverflow.
- ziddoap 5y ago>Sorting algorithms are taught as part of every CS degree and C is still used today. I still don't understand what you're learning from the 30-60 minute interview. If you want to know if someone has a CS degree, look at their resume. >The only real change is there are a lot more low-quality programmers than there used to be. You'll need some data to back that one up. >If you have to cheat to pass a test I think that would tell the interviewers a lot. I would consider someone smart if they use every resource available to them to solve the problem presented to them. You consider it cheating. What a weird way of thinking -- just rote memorization for everything in life? Everything must be from first principles? Sounds tedious and inefficient to me. Smart people realize that other smart people exist, and might even have valuable ideas or solutions applicable to their own problems.
- 734129837261 5y agoNowadays, with 20+ years of experience as a software developer behind me, having worked for Apple, First American, Bloomberg, AT&T, Booking, Amazon, many startups, etc. my job interviews have never been easier. Before I am presented with a dumbass interviewer who throws a ridiculous question my way about algorithmic stuff, I prepare them: "Since we are both seeing if the other party is competent, I want you to know that I want you to also solve my questions. They will be slightly more difficult than the questions you pose to me." When I applied for a job at Toptal this made the algorithm-test disappear like snow before an up-close nuclear blast. I've interviewed hundreds of candidates over the years and I would never ask a question I can't also answer from the top of my head, in detail, and then some. Turns out, most technical interviewers who ask you "write a bubble sort" couldn't do it themselves. And if they could, it'd be full of bugs. I mean, I'd rather have developers on my team who Google "bubble sort python" and go for a tried and tested open-source solution. I don't need developers who can reinvent complicated wheels from scratch; I want developers who are efficient. Likewise, I don't want to work for a company where developers pride themselves on over-engineering their things. Having worked at Apple, it doesn't surprise me one bit how slow they are developing simple features and fixing simple bugs. It's a red-tape hell full of not-very pragmatic engineers that are way too smart for the good of the company.
- carabiner 5y agoWoah, we got a badass over here. Seriously they have 1,000 other qualified candidates lined up right behind you. I'm sure they appreciate your time and then end the interview.
- owenmarshall 5y agoI also think this comes across as someone being pretentious and arrogant, and could be a no-hire, but there’s a nugget of truth in this: interviews are two-way streets, and getting a feel for your coworkers and your environment can be as important as landing the job. Also > Seriously they have 1,000 other qualified candidates lined up right behind you. I’d kill to have ten qualified candidates to interview. It’s a seller’s market.
- Johnny555 5y agoMy company does white board interviews and I always make a point of telling the interviewee that I'm not looking for syntax and just want to see the overall algorithm and program flow. If he wants to make a library call and can't remember the args, I tell him to make it up - I don't care if he can remember a trivial fact that his IDE will tell him or that he'll find in a quick manual page lookup. (while I meant "he" as a gender-neutral pronoun, sadly, nearly all of our senior tech candidates are male, but one bright spot is that we've got near gender parity with college interns which I hope means the job market is becoming more balanced)
- ramphastidae 5y agoThey/them is what you’re looking for: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Singular_they https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Singular_they
- NikolaNovak 5y agoI mean I don't know. A joke which may have been intended to give a hint, while putting applicant at ease, has clearly backfired ; but if that's the worst interview they have had, they're pretty lucky. I also notice the paragraph near the end with couple of general lines on good interview and the "that's how I hold interviews". Here's the thing. Nobody sets off to intentionally be a bad interviewer or coder or manager or whatever. It helps to have humility and significant open introspection to be good at something (not the only path but for most of us it's the best path). We ascribe wilful incompetence to others while we have excuses and lessons learned for ourselves. Maybe - likely - the other interviewer too thought they were giving opportunities and signals and letting people at ease?
- akdas 5y agoThis is a great example of intent vs. impact. Regardless of the intent, the impact was negative. Recognizing how their actions impact the candidate is a huge part of interviewing, and the interviewer should have seen the candidate get nervous and adjusted. That said, given that candidates are generally nervous to some extent anyway, and semi-colons shouldn't matter in a whiteboard interview, that joke seemed like in poor taste to me. That underscores why we need better training and mentorship for interviewers.
- jihadjihad 5y agoI interviewed with a company a couple of months ago and it was the first time in my career that I'd had one of those technical interviews that folks here on HN seem to run into a lot. Was shown a handful of problems in a Google doc and told the code doesn't need to compile, it just needs to be conceptually sound. Got asked how to check if a word's a palindrome, how to check if delimiters are balanced, some basic data shaping with JSON, and a pretty basic SQL question with a left join. I left the interview feeling totally confident I'd rocked it, since there were no "inverse binary tree" curveballs or anything like that, and figured that the company just wanted to make sure I knew what a stack was and what some properties of arrays are. Got rejected, asked for feedback and was told none would be given, so I rinsed the bad taste out of my mouth and went with another company instead.
- bitwize 5y agoNever expect feedback for why you were rejected. It is in the company's best interest not to explain to you why; any feedback could potentially expose them to legal liability.
- eropple 5y agoIt may be in the company's best interest to leave you in the dark, though frankly I question that wisdom and have never had it effectively defended by a knowledgeable party. And even if it is in their best interest? That doesn't mean you shouldn't expect professional courtesy out of an organization that disrupted your day and decided not to hire you after it. Being decent to people is important and you are important enough that you can expect to be treated with decency.
- Jemaclus 5y agoThis may be true, but in practice, it doesn't seem to happen. Aline Lerner (@leeny) wrote this blog post about this a while back: https://blog.interviewing.io/no-engineer-has-ever-sued-a-company-because-of-constructive-post-interview-feedback-so-why-dont-employers-do-it/ https://blog.interviewing.io/no-engineer-has-ever-sued-a-com...
- strikelaserclaw 5y ago
- lmilcin 5y agoSo... how is that "worst" interview experience? You probably haven't seen really bad interviews. My favourite was switching conference rooms until we ran out of time and the interviewer thanked me and invited for a next session. There was also one when the guy was late 30 minutes to a 30 minute interview. And the one when they spent 1h with me and at the end told me the position has already been taken. I had one where interviewer smelled really, really bad -- I left when I learned he would be my boss. I also had one where the guy said he is "best programmer in the world". I thought he is joking. Unfortunately, he wasn't. He became my boss. I left a month later when his code failed in prod (he parsed XML by specifying a line and character number to extract piece of data) but he blamed it first on the vendor (they apparently changed the format when they turned off pretty printing) and then on me (I haven't even touched the code). Apparently he never makes mistakes -- he always blames somebody else. To be fair, I have also a lot of "bad candidate" stories. Like a guy with a lot of knowledge who says at the end of interview he doesn't want to get hired, he just came to exercise before going to another company. From my PoV as interviewer I think the only real egregious error here asking the candidate to write in unfamiliar language. It doesn't matter what the language the project uses, the whiteboard needs to use language that is comfortable for the candidate. We can discuss knowledge of the language as a separate issue. Now, asking the candidate to write a particular algorithm on a whiteboard from memory is just a waste of time. The purpose of programming exercise is to see if the person knows how to program, not if they have memorised particular algorithm. Writing an algorithm like merge sort could still be productive if the interviewer has first explained the algorithm and then asked to implement it. But I still feel merge sort is a bad choice -- I prefer simple task but one that I created myself so no candidate is familiar with it. I am interested how the candidate works on the task and how he can communicate with me to solve it. You would be surprised how many candidates dismiss hints they are being offered.
- coredog64 5y agoNetflix should green light a series on bad tech interviews. With Zoom and screen recording there’s an easy way to gain raw materials. And then once we name, shame, and normalize that this is nuts, we can move on.
- RandyRanderson 5y agoAuthor states that the following threw him off: Interviewer: "you must be writing a lot of Swift" after a few minor syntax errors. Maybe being put off by an ambiguous comment was why you didn't get the job? Did you consider maybe in his notes he might've said: "Smart guy but was put off by a single comment (a failed attempt at humour on my part). Probably not someone who would thrive in a lively atmosphere". I had an interviewer ask a question and, not satisfied with the answer, get up and walk out. The other guy apologized and we had a good discussion after the other guy left.
- minimaxir 5y agoThen that's a massive failure on the interviewer's side that they cannot respect that the candidate may be under anxiety.
- taurath 5y agoThere is absolutely 0 signal there as to whether someone would "thrive in a lively atmosphere" when you're jumping through hoops for an interview that will determine your financial well being and a good portion of your live for the next n years, and its a fun example of how "engineer social hacks" continuously fail in the real world.
- olivierlacan 5y agoAh, so you're saying you're financially and emotionally secure enough not to be completely discombobulated by this incredible display of disrespect? Good for you I guess, but maybe don't apply your own mental blueprint to the rest of the world. Recommending candidates have thicker skin isn't really great a way to improve hiring in general.
- Hnrobert42 5y agoAn incredible display of disrespect? It might be rude, but that’s about it. Depending on the tone of voice, it could have been intended as a way to relieve the author’s tension. It does sound a bit annoying, but if that is the author’s worst interviewing experience, it’s not that bad.
- catsarebetter 5y agoApply Hanlon's Razor to that comment
- zffr 5y agoFWIW I don’t think Apple has a standardized interview process. Unlike companies like google or FB, each individual team decides its own interview questions. That means it’s possible to have a horrible interview experience with one team, and a great experience with another team. Not saying this system is good or bad, just trying to describe the system.
- jldugger 5y agoThis is correct, and the hiring process is broken at Apple in myriad ways, some of which you would not imagine would be allowed, let alone encouraged.
- lettergram 5y agoI’ve had so many poor interview experiences and all of them at the big tech companies. I once went to google and only 2/5 interviewers bothered to show up. Hell, in an interview I had this week I was given multiple incorrect answers to my clarification questions. Even when I said “I believe I answered it” the interviewer said “I don’t think so” until he finally looked up and was like “oh you got it” I’m on zoom watching the interviewer text / look at other screens as I ask clarifying questions and they give dismissive answers “yea yea that sounds right, do that” while never looking up from their phone. Was a pretty “wtf” moment. I completed the interview, but I got the feeling the review will be subpar.
- newsbinator 5y agoYou can comment on it. "Sorry, it looks like I must have caught you at a bad time. If you have a fire to put out, I totally get it."
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- drdeadringer 5y agoI had an in-person interview where I should have said that, multiple times.
- lettergram 5y agoIn retrospect I probably will, definitely better to do that than waste a whole day due to one distracted interviewer
- fernandotakai 5y agomy worst tech interview: i was asked to solve a leetcode problem on a google doc. i asked if i could at least do on my editor of choice while screensharing -- "nope, too complicated". i asked if i could do in pseudocode, nope "it must at least run". i tried for 10min, said "thank you, but i don't think this is working for us -- we can probably stop here. thank you for your time [yadda yadda]".
- skeeter2020 5y agoGood for you. The days when we where expected to right code without a computer ended quite some time ago. It takes a lot of strength, intellignence and maturity for the candidate to terminate the process and I respect that from both sides of the table.
- fernandotakai 5y agoyou know, i quite liked the position, but i was always told that "interviews are two way streets". if that's how they interview their candidates... well, let's say i don't want to work with people that were hired with that process. the good thing is that i interviewed and was hired about three weeks later -- and it was an even better position!
- trwhite 5y agoI've conducted several engineer interviews and sometimes I find it just as nerve-racking as if I was interviewing myself, mostly because asking questions that give me "a lot of signal about the candidate’s skills while ensuring the candidate always feels comfortable and confident" can be pretty hard. Can anyone share examples of the kinds of questions I should be asking? Are there any good articles about this?
- lhorie 5y agoThe way I structure my coding interviews is to have a simple first question that anyone should be able to solve, and then a follow-up "ok, let's now add this feature" question. I tell them upfront that googling is ok and give hints whenever I notice they are stuck. At the end of the first half, I ask if there's anything about their code that they'd like to change - basically a chance to code review. It tells me a lot about not just technical chops, but also awareness of what good practices are, as well as whether they are proactive and have an eye for quality. The second half is the brownie points session: it's where the candidate gets a chance to demonstrate that they're better than average, be it by demonstrating strong algorithmic thinking, or good refactoring and/or testing practices or what have you. Good candidates ace questions on multiple dimensions and it's pretty easy to spot a gold nugget. When the candidate doesn't meet the bar at this point, it becomes geared towards looking for growth potential (as far as me collecting signals go) and being an opportunity for learning for the candidate. It can be me giving feedback about types of things they could take into further consideration or, for less qualified candidates, a discussion of how to formulate an algorithmic idea, either in terms of thinking from first principles, or in terms of erasing dissonance between abstract ideas vs how to express them in code. I try to always pace feedback in such a way that by the end of the hour, the candidate has completed the exercise. Sometimes, that does mean that I'm literally walking them through the process of coming up with the solution. Some think this is a waste of time, but IMHO, it's important for the candidate to leave with a good impression of the interview process. If a session is a complete bust and a waste of my time, then at the very least the candidate should be getting something out of it.
- Pokepokalypse 5y agoMy worst interview experience: Company had their own custom hackerrank test set up. Timed. It failed to execute on my laptop. (Maybe browser plugins? I tried a different browser; still no joy) - I tried a few things, including using the browser debugger, and in the 30 minutes allotted, I couldn't succeed. So I asked the recruiter to talk to the hiring manager to give me another shot with a different computer, and never got a response. Mind you: they also had a horrible recruit process of filling out paperwork on their web site; including a form-entry version of your resume that you already uploaded. Plus various other forms to fill out and disclaimers to sign. Honestly, the worst I had ever encountered. Since then, this company has had 3 different recruiters (one internal, two external) try to contact me for different positions, but the first one asked for the same process of going through their careers website and filling out all the forms again - even though my previous record was still there: because it was a different position, it had to be done again. That's when I bailed.
- wyclif 5y agoI've seen a lot of companies that ask for a copy of your CV and also ask you to fill out a form with fields for all the information on a typical resume. That's a red flag that a company has some bad process going on behind the scenes.
- aaronchall 5y agoI presume they're looking for inconsistency that could indicate a lack of conscientiousness. At times when I have been anxious to get hired, I have had no problem demonstrating that I can fill out a bunch of redundant forms when required. Sometimes you need to be able to do that sort of thing, even in the best organizations. On the other hand, I don't think I'd intentionally add that to my hiring process. There are better ways to check for conscientiousness than saying, "please do this redundant activity perfectly."
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pezzana 5y ago> Trick questions and esoteric puzzles give the interviewer no useful information about the interviewee — her skills, her strengths, her weaknesses, her potential for growth. Those are the things a great interviewer should be seeking out. That means you give hints when the candidate gets stuck and you don’t interrupt them with asinine comments. Whatever problem you give a candidate to solve, your goal as an interviewer should be to get them through as much of that problem as possible, to get as much signal as possible. The added benefit is that the further you get, the better and more confident the candidate feels, which also helps prepare them to do their best for the next session. Less experienced interviewees often need more help, and that’s ok. This article lays out the problem very well, but then again so to very many others which have appeared on HN over the years. Why does this keep happening? I mean this at the most fundamental level. Why waste time with programming puzzlers to begin with? Does the candidate's degree (assuming no job experience) not obviate the need for this kind of thing? Do past programming gigs not absolve them of the need to perform in a way they'll never be asked to perform on the job? Are CS departments so full of bullshitters that unless you sic your 10x devs on them to sniff out whether they can program their way out of a paper bag, your organization runs the risk of filling up with "C Players?" I mean, what's really going on here?
- monocasa 5y agoI don't think that programming puzzles are the best way to divine better information in this area. But yes, there's a ton of people looking for a programming job that both have a lot of experience on paper and can't code their way out of a wet paper bag. It seems you can have very long stretches in a large company where you do negative work. Best way I've found is to talk to them about their experience, sort of post mortem style. Pretty much everyone can talk about their experience in some respects, even those working on classified projects; you just need to respect their boundaries.
- okareaman 5y agoI used to feel like you and ask the same questions until recently when I read someone on HN saying these interviews are meant to see how a person handles stress. Then it clicked for me. I've done pretty well at interviews despite being terrible at white board exercises because my personality is such that I treat these interviews casually. It's not that important in the larger scheme of things that I get this particular job, I'm looking at the interviewers as much as they are looking at me to see if I could work with them and I'll often joke around and keep it light hearted, even when failing a white board exercise. The interviewers know the work culture and are looking for someone that can fit. In the case presented in this blog post, the writer could not handle a small joke about the Swift language. The interviewer probably knew the team like to joke around and tease, so this person was not a good fit. I think it's really that simple. I really doubt the interviewer thought the person was not technically qualified. In one case, I was in a particularly light hearted mood and I joked throughout the entire interview. I believe to this day I was hired to lighten up the mood of the team, which turned out to be a very serious and gloomy bunch.
- mamidon 5y agoAs someone who is in their final week at Facebook, I'd be keen to read why he felt joining was a big mistake. I have a similar feeling myself -- on paper it was a great job but I was miserable.
- chespinoza 5y agoI haven't read any positive opinion of people that was working for big companies so far to be honest.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- willhslade 5y agoMy worst interview was some middling Canadian software shop that wouldn't let me use a Python IDE to implement a pagination function; like others, they wanted to do it in Notepad / Google Docs. I complained repeatedly and their defense was that "Amazon was using a similar process to find engineers". I asked if they were paying in Amazon stock. I did not get a call back, and, in retrospect, it was for the best.
- dmoy 5y agoA lot of people are really not good at conducting interviews. It's a hard skill, it has absolutely nothing to do with the rest of your job, nobody teaches you how to do it well, nobody checks to see if you're doing it well, and there's no good resources for learning. You get like a couple hours of "interview training" (50% of which is "here's how to not get us sued 101"), maybe some shadow interviews if you're lucky, and then they just throw you in the deep end and never check back. Whiteboard interviews do suck, but they exist because nobody's figured out a better alternative that works at scale. If you're a small company, you can get away with a less sucky interviewing method. If you're a massively large company, a lot of those fall apart because of various reasons (you can't ask for take-home tests because a significant percentage of your applicant pool will refuse to do it because they already have a job and stuff to do at home, you can't ask to "talk about interesting code/projects you've worked on", because either (a) they already have a job but can't show you any code because it's owned by another company, or (b) they just outright lie about everything and you don't figure it out for 6 months, etc etc). So whiteboard interviews suck, but we're stuck with them. There's some really weird things about conducting a good whiteboard interview which are not obvious 1. The candidate should not know if they're failing. The candidate should basically always get the sense that they're doing okay enough, even if they aren't. If the candidate fails your interview, but aces all the others, that's fine. Probably they should still get hired. But if the candidate fails your interview and feels really badly about having bombed it, then they just go on tilt and fail the rest anyways. That's not good signal, it wastes the candidate's time, it wastes the rest of the interviewers' time, all because you the earlier interviewer couldn't figure out how to not tilt the candidate. This is less important if you're the last interviewer on a loop. - so generally you want to start out easy, be really encouraging, and ramp up difficulty as they go on. Tilt is real, and it is not helpful in an interview situation. (Caveat to #1 - this is assuming you're working at a big enough company where your policy is to give zero actionable feedback to the candidate due to lawsuits, which is probably any large company. If you're not at a large enough company where this is true, why are you even doing whiteboard interviewing? Stop lol, whiteboard interviewing sucks) 2. You can't ask anything crazy domain specific. Sure maybe the specific super detailed queuing problem you're working on right now is fun, but it probably doesn't scale well to arbitrary-engineer who hasn't thought about queuing for a decade. Unfortunately this means you have to spend a lot of time figuring out what to ask, because the things you're currently working on are almost certainly terrible interview questions. Corollary to #2 - if you pick questions from online, or even from within your company, candidates will absolutely have seen them before, memorized them, and go from there. Your question needs to be able to be modified, expanded, and you need to know what it 3. Benefit of doubt should always go to the candidate. Forgot a library? You tell them the library, and don't count it against them. You are the candidate's StackOverflow for the interview, be reasonable. #1 up there is the hardest. Even simple things become very difficult to broach. If the candidate is digging themselves in a hole and you are having a hard time figuring out how to hint them out without psyching them out, feign ignorance about your own interview question and try to "collaboratively" work your way out of it. Sometimes it's impossible. Sometimes you'll get a candidate who literally does not know even the most basic of programming stuff for their own chosen programming language (obviously has not ever written code at all). I don't actually know how to handle that. Sometimes the recruiters will make mistakes and just send you candidates for the wrong job. So this isn't all-encompassing advice, because there's always edge cases.
- aaomidi 5y agoBackblaze asked me to implement a HashMap for a senior dev position, lol. The company is actively selecting for new-grads for senior positions.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- khazhoux 5y agoHe took great offense at the semicolon comment, but I'm not convinced it was meant to be snide. Kinda sounds like the interviewer with just pointing out the semicolons in a roundabout way. But I supposed another lesson for interviewers is to be aware of how stressful interviews are for the candidate, and to mind their language and jokes.
- eropple 5y agoThat may be true, but in situations with significant power imbalance it's important for the person in the position of power to recognize it and to not wield it inappropriately. A joke like that when somebody is under interview stress has the possibility (not the guarantee, but the possibility) of harming the interviewee's chances by nudging them in the wrong way at the wrong time in a tough situation, and that's pretty lousy to do to somebody.
- andrewingram 5y agoA few of my interview experiences from last year: 1. Being steered away from my answer for an algorithm problem, towards the interviewers preferred answer. When I reflected back on it later, I realised that my answer would have been more efficient for the specific problem asked, whilst the interviewers solution was for a more general version of the problem (which wasn't ever asked). 2. Being given feedback that I was weak on data structures, when there hadn't been any questions about data structures. I am weak on data structures though, so perhaps they just peered into my brain somehow. 3. Being told I wasn't suitable for remote positions because I was too verbose answering questions which were essentially trivia -- when I was intentionally trying to capture nuance because I didn't want to fall prey to trick questions. 1 and 2 were for the same company, but different stages.
- mrkentutbabi 5y agoHN readers seem to be filled with extraordinary people with great background that a DSA interview is an insult and waste of time. Please don’t forget that there are people without good credentials (prestigious universities). DSA interview is the only fair chance people like us have to work at high paying jobs in FAANG. How else we gonna compete? There are many candidates out there, way more experienced than us and way more credentials than us. There aren’t enough >= $200k SWE jobs out there for all of us, so we gotta do it. I’ll take DSA interview anyday if that means I’ll get to outcompete the senior engineers/people with prestigious universities and get that $200k -$300k job.
- justicezyx 5y ago> I had to deal with an asshole making jokes My read is that the primary cause of the bad experience is because of a perception that the interviewer made a joke about missing semicolon in the white board code. The attribution of that being “asshole” seems typical for a young guy who was stressed in a technical interview. Especially there could be additional signaling in the interview process that is problematic to the interviewee. But the whole post does not sound too bad to me. My personal worst example is one guy who is asking what I did previously, and after each time I gave an overview of one project, that guy just said: that sounds very easy (that was in Chinese, we were doing the interview in Chinese over phone). And that guy is a msft researcher turned engineer. I was internally amused at his employer being clueless about the skill gaps between an engineer and a researcher. To me the saddest part was that he basically is not able to present an interesting description of the prospect projects in his own team (apparently that's expected based on his reactions to my previous projects), nor appreciate my side of the story. That makes the time spent close to being meaningless for both of us.
- mgraczyk 5y agoThere is exactly one position for which asking or commenting on semicolon use in an interview is a good use of time. If the position being interviewed for is to write the semicolon insertion pass in a JavaScript parser.
- totony 5y agoMy best interview experiences were light on the technical questions are mostly back-and-forth discussion around my experience/tech.
- sillyquiet 5y agoas a senior IC, I've been asked to give technical peer interviews for candidates quite a few times. A LOT of the places I have worked there's no budget for sensible interview tools even for remote interviews (shared IDEs, etc), so you are stuck with what you can cobble together (an ad hoc shared REPL, a shared virtual whiteboard, etc). They suck a lot, and I try to keep that in account when working through problems. The best experiences are always in an actual simple dev environment where you can collaborate on code, have a live preview of UI stuff, allow access to stack overflow and other references, etc. it allows you to present a problem very similar to day-to-day work but smaller scale. And I gotta say, even that is just somewhat useful for gauging how working with that person for real would be. Interviews suck - nerves are frayed, it's not always representative of that persons skill, ability or non-assholishness, AND it doesn't allow for assessing general skill, ability to learn or ramp up, because everyone necessarily in the interview has to have some skill in the language and platform you are working in during the interview.
- tasty_freeze 5y agoMy worst tech interview was with me as the interviewer. An applicant was a friend of a coworker and forwarded the candidate's resume to HR. HR set up a round of interviews. He went through the five interviews. After, we met for 20 minutes to express our thoughts. Pretty uniformly we agreed: the candidate was middling and we'd be better off waiting for someone better. We rejected him. A day later the rejected candidate called my phone (how did he get it?) and said something like: "Hey, this is <candidate>. Why the hell wasn't I given an offer? The recruiter said that you (that is me, personally) had rejected me. Explain why." He insisted he had done great and we should reconsider. The candidate hadn't reacted well to the rejection, and rather than being the firewall that shields the interviewers, the HR guy passed the buck and blamed me. We didn't reconsider, and I gave the HR guy hell about it.
- antisthenes 5y agoOut of curiosity, what made him middling and not good? Surely someone at your org could have determined that it's better to stop wasting each other's time before going through 5 interviews? Sounds like there's more to the story than you're having us believe and the candidate had very good reasons to be upset (the exact wording and tone he used was not appropriate). If he insisted he had done great, I venture to say that he was led on during interviews and not given honest feedback.
- tasty_freeze 5y agoWhat made him middling? It was 15 years ago so I don't recall the details. The usual reasons are things like: didn't answer some questions well, or maybe their resume oversold their accomplishments (eg, "Proficient in verilog, C, C++, pascal, fortran, javascript, java" "OK, describe one of the programs you have written in java." "Well, uh, this one time there was this program that was already written, and I had to add some better error messages when it received bad input.") Why did he go through the full round of interviews? Because (1) he was referred by an existing employee so interviewer were inclined to give him the benefit of the doubt, and (2) he wasn't terrible, just nothing special; it sometimes happens that one person gets a low impression and the others think they are great and we hire them anyway. You surmise I must be telling part of the story because his reaction doesn't fit my description of the process. Yes, that is exactly the point of telling the story -- his response wasn't appropriate. Had I felt he had a reason to react that way, I wouldn't be retelling the story.
- seattle_spring 5y agoI've had a ton of bad interview experiences, but my worst was still Google. This was circa 2012 or so, was my 2nd session of an on-site day. I guess I didn't grow up around a lot of people with thick accents because I could literally not understand a single word this guy was saying, and he didn't seem to understand me. He wanted me to explain the solution before writing any code, but since we were having communication issues I asked if I could write pseudocode. He slammed (SLAMMED) his fist onto the table and yelled, "NO CODE!" ----- Other bad experiences included Palantir telling me my onsite went really well, and that they'd like me to come in again to meet the hiring manager. Expecting to talk business, I instead was presented with 2 more algorithm questions. Those apparently went OK, so the next discussion with the recruiter yielded another "informal" (his words) meeting with 2 engineers via VC. Both ended up being 2 more DS/Algo questions. ----- Another bad one I remember is a request to do a take-home coding test from Docusign (also circa 2012). They wanted me to program a "fully tested" elevator simulation using Stylus, Coffeescript, and Jade. I had never used any of these technologies, so I asked if I could write it in what I was familiar with (jQuery, Backbone, SCSS, ES5), which was denied. It would have taken me a full week to get up to speed on all of those technologies enough to submit a solution worthy of review. Absolutely ridiculous to ask a candidate to learn new frameworks just to complete the interview.
- willio58 5y agoHad an interview yesterday where the guy was seemingly more nervous than I was, and he seemed to mask that nervousness with anger/being rude. I would answer his questions, and he would act like I wasn't understanding the question. In reality, it turns out I wasn't answering his questions using the _exact_ buzzwords he was looking for. I realized this when I happened to mention a buzzword after minutes of tense back-and-forth and he immediately perked up and we could suddenly move on. Went into the next interview feeling like shit because of this. This whole process is so broken. Great devs get passed up on for terrible devs who know how to grind Leetcode and the like. I hate having to grind leetcode for weeks just to end up getting asked obscure algorithm puzzle questions that I could never prepare for. And all for a 100% React job? Jesus.
- klipklop 5y agoSame problem with a poor English speaker at Google back in ~2019. It took several minutes just to start understanding the words he was saying. I have many years of working/growing up with ESL folks and have a good ear for it and still struggled with this guy.
- lnanek2 5y agoI was expecting a horror story about some leet code problem. It's been 5 years since I last interviewed, but I always memorized how to write the common sort algorithms ahead of time first. Having to write merge sort in C doesn't really feel like a big ask. I don't know, maybe I'm old fashioned. Even if we pretend people don't spend months training on leetcode before interviews nowadays, surely sorting algorithms are still taught in basic data structures classes, right?
- askonomm 5y agoNot everyone became a developer through CS classes. I'm self-learned, mostly learned what I needed at the job to do that job. I don't think in 10 years I've ever needed to write a sorting algorithm since, well, that's built into the language, so why would I? I've had many jobs, learned many programming languages, and haven't seen one without a sort functionality built-in, or for trickier things where a more advanced library would not be available. Now maybe this is the whole point, to filter out those who never went to university, but I'd say it's still pretty dumb to test people on things that most likely have nothing to do with the job or just aren't realistic.
- caddemon 5y agoThat seems like a really inefficient way to filter out people who don't have a CS degree, given that you enter your degree info on the app (and they background check all hires). I agree with you though, I don't understand why the leetcode style interviews are so damn pervasive.
- mixmastamyk 5y agoThey almost never ask a question you are familiar with, and recently implemented, that's the problem. "Oh, I know that one!" is not a solution for the rest of us. Including you at the next interview where the different question is to implement the Ceph distributed filesystem on a whiteboard, clock-ticking, and an asshole looking over your shoulder.
- akdas 5y agoWhat's so interesting about this experience it hits so many of the points I've been complaining about in my writing about hiring in the tech industry[0]: - Giving trick questions that have an "insight" moment, instead of one that has multiple answers, even partial answers to build off of. - Not letting the candidate pick the language they're comfortable with. The candidate may even know the language they're asked to code in, but if they haven't been working with it recently, an interview is not the right time to pick it up again. - Making the candidate nervous, both by not being helpful and by watching over them with unnecessary scrutiny. - Looking for flaws instead of strengths. People, myself included, are always talking about these problems, but companies have so much inertia, they are not evolving fast enough to solve these problems. No wonder tech companies are filled with people who, while capable, often fit a particular mold, and why we end up in situations where products don't reflect the needs of the market (because the people working on those products aren't representative of the market). [0] https://hiringfor.tech/archive.html https://hiringfor.tech/archive.html
- strikelaserclaw 5y agoi was slightly sleep deprived for an algo interview and the interviewer just pasted problems into coderpad and just said nothing, i might have solved it if the guy was friendly but the absolute silence made me hear time ticking in my sleep deprived state and i psyched myself out. I went home and answered both the questions pretty handily, but man the interviewer demeanor plays such a big role in interviews.
- hardwaregeek 5y agoIt seems like companies do not understand that they are competing for programmers as much as programmers are competing for companies. If you're a programmer with at least one big N job under your belt, you don't have to take bad treatment. You don't have to deal with terrible interviews or really long processes. The power is on your side. It's only because most programmers don't understand the balance of power that companies keep getting away with this nonsense. I marvel at how companies are throwing away their chances at top talent due to these horrible processes. I recently applied and got an offer from a big N company. It took forever, easily three times the length of my other processes. I was not given any insight into my team beyond an overarching organization. The pay was not fantastic and they didn't honor my first location request. Why would I accept this? The pay I could have negotiated. But I'd still be put into a random, likely boring team in a city I didn't pick as my first choice. All to be able to work at a "Big N" company, when I've already had that experience. Maybe that works on some people but after the first Big N it's really not important.
- hazza_n_dazza 5y agoread the rest of the website too, its really funny. what a character Jesse is!
- anonred 5y ago> I was interviewing at various places, and I got an interview with the Apple Watch team Funnily enough, I also interviewed with the Apple Watch team around the same time and had a similar negative experience. I was struggling with a problem on the whiteboard and paused to ask a question. Instead, one of the interviewers (it was a pair) turned to the other and said “I wish the Calendar complication on my watch would show when this meeting ends” All the other interviewers that day were great, but it just takes a few bad apples… Even though it’s been years and I’ve had a nice tenure at FAANG, I’ll never consider joining Apple after that experience.
- technofiend 5y agoOuch! I once interviewed at a local company that used the same hardware and OS as my then employer. When I told the guy where I worked he started laughing. He apologized but he was sympathetic in a you poor bastard kind of way.
- kilbuz 5y agoAny (surely) dude who calls a feature on his glorified step counter a "complication" has already let you know everything you need to know about them.
- marcins 5y agoA complication is a watch related term for any feature that doesn't tell the time, and predates electronic watches.
- austinl 5y agoI had the same experience with Apple about a year ago. Not merge sort, but an algorithm question that also involved a fair bit of math. The type where if you know the number theory trick, the implementation becomes straightforward, but if you don't, the solution is obviously suboptimal. The recruiter also pushed me to interview with other teams, but I quickly said "no, thanks". I can't necessarily say I was frustrated though — this experience is more or less exactly what I expected from Apple or any FAANG.
- mateo411 5y agoInteresting. What was the number theory trick? I like these sorts of problems. If the role required some math along with software engineering, then it could have been a question that provided a good signal.
- WalterBright 5y ago> I didn’t write any of those sorting algorithms from memory. I referenced the infinite number of resources on the Internet to write them and ensure they were correct. I don't think the idea is to have a merge sort committed to memory. More like one can go from specification to implementation in a reasonable amount of time. Me, I kinda like to write my own first, then compare it with others. Getting flustered when on the stage is a real problem, but it fades away as one gets experienced at being on stage. Then you can respond to snarky comments with a bit of snark of your own.
- asow92 5y agoNever in my life have a coded on a whiteboard, so why on earth would I need to write compilable code on one to prove that I can write in an IDE or solve problems? It just doesn't make any sense; it's like asking a writer prove that they can set type in a Gutenberg press—why!? Sure, I can understand writing high level pseudocode on a whiteboard, but getting hung up on something like semicolons is literally pedantic and a power trip on the interviewer's side.
- asow92 5y agoAlso, when I was younger I was diagnosed with a condition called dysgraphia where my handwriting is terrible, which is why I got into typing when I was young and eventually programming. So writing legibly on a whiteboard is just an awful prospect for me as I need to think about how to write something just as much as what I'm writing.
- fataliss 5y agoI'd love if OP had more details on how they ask "great questions that give her a lot of signal about the candidate’s skills while ensuring the candidate always feels comfortable and confident". I hate passing interviews and as a result try my best to be a chill interviewer, but I yet have to find good conversational questions that get me confidence in ones' coding abilities.
- alexeiz 5y agoWe all know that companies use Leetcode problems for programming questions. But Facebook (and perhaps other big tech companies) also like to ask "system design and architecture" questions, which in my personal opinion don't have anything to do with the real world system design and architecture. Those questions are geared at recent college graduates who have no experience in system design. But if you've designed and created actual successful systems, you're likely to fail such questions. Because when you have real experience, you tend to know what works and what doesn't work in the real world, and you are likely to be conservative in the choice of your design techniques. However the interviewer expects you to use all kinds of design techniques which look good on the whiteboard but usually fail. I didn't realize how bad this situation was until I came across some books explaining how to "pass" these system design questions: you're basically supposed to say a load of bullshit, the more bullshit the better. I think the disconnect between the interview questions and the actual professional experience is simply stunning.
- nathanaldensr 5y agoI once interviewed for a company in Austin. I was kept in a small room with no ventilation for five hours. No breaks, no water offered. They got upset at me because I said I didn't like JavaScript. Funny times.
- nathanaldensr 5y agoNot from an interview, but I once took a small contract for some kind of data processing work. The guy who hired me was insisting that HTTP was an asynchronous protocol. I corrected him, thinking "oh, it's no big deal, he might've just misspoke," but the guy became absolutely irate. Hey buddy, not my fault you've never read the RFC.
- gmarcus 5y agoBack in 1994, was interviewing with Some Big Finance (SBF) wall street firm in NYC. They wanted to pair me with one of their traders to write code in real-time for intraday trades. Interviewer asked me to whiteboard a String implementation in C++. Grabbed the marker and wrote on the whiteboard: typedef RWCString SBFString; Would you have offered me the job?
- invalidname 5y agoThey should have probably applied these tips: https://talktotheduck.dev/debugging-the-technical-interview-methods-and-cheating https://talktotheduck.dev/debugging-the-technical-interview-...
- MattPalmer1086 5y agoMy worst interview was for chief technical architect for a small software house. I was asked to write a parser which could transform a simple data format into another. I asked whether they were looking for a fast solution, or a better one? I was told it had to be fast and better. Thinking I hadn't explained myself very well, I asked again, are you measuring how fast I can give you a solution, or are you looking for quality. I could do either. Again, I was told it had to be high quality and fast to produce. I took the middle ground, and wrote something in a couple of hours that did everything they wanted, and was extensible to new formats, using a variety of OO techniques. I failed the test because I hadn't used a standard library component that could be coaxed into doing that they wanted. I clearly didn't grasp the awesome power and reusability of object orientation!
- AndyPatterson 5y agoYears ago when I first graduated went to an interview for a Java dev role. Spent the full day there getting pulled apart by whiteboard interviews, exam papers, and daft questions that would have no real day-to-day use in a dev role. Even worse was I asked at the end of the day what kind of work I could be expected to do and found out there was very little actual dev work; maybe some maintenance tasks but mostly support. I became pretty bitter about tech interviews after that. Sadly interviews like that became a regular fixture and some were even worse. In a few I even had take-home assignments where I was to implement a full-project from scratch then present it at the interview (as well as all that other crummy interview stuff). I even got heavily criticised/insulted in one for prioritising my current job over the assignment and was told if I really wanted the position I "should've moved heaven and earth" - pretty deranged to ask someone to risk their income for an unpaid assignment if you ask me but anyways. With that being said, I do think interviews are becoming better. They're less about blowing smoke up the interviewers arse and more about judging how good a fit they are for the company. Interviews tend to feel more collaborative and white-boarding sessions aren't a test but a discussion, with the best language agnostic. Hopefully they keep going this way.
- aryehof 5y agoSadly, hundreds of comments that would appear to prove that "experience" is of absolutely no value in candidates. Rather companies just apparently look for quick-thinking, smart people that can answer recently memorized text-book questions.
- johncessna 5y agoI don't think writing a merge sort is either a trick question or an esoteric puzzle. Neither is using a whiteboard during a tech interview. It's very common. I'm sorry this author had a bad experience with it. For me, it's all about mindset. Interviews are a two way street. Talk to the interviewer, they're people too. If there are assholes, then whatever, you've still learned more and gotten to an better outcome for you. If you don't know the language you're asked to write something in, ask to change it to something you do know. If the interviewer says language X is required for the job just be upfront about it. Stop the interview right there and address that issue. 'Look, I don't know/haven't used x in a while. Can I use y with the understanding that I need to come up to speed quickly? Otherwise, we can get our days back.' The shame here is that the author is still clearly bitter about something that happened 6 years ago and the interviewer probably chalked it up to another hack who can't even implement a merge sort.