7 ms·
> Three former Google employees have sued the company, alleging that Google's motto "Don't be evil" amounts to a contractual obligation that the tech giant has
by thaumasiotes 5y ago
> Three former Google employees have sued the company, alleging that Google's motto "Don't be evil" amounts to a contractual obligation that the tech giant has violated.
How could anything possibly happen other than getting tossed out of court immediately? They want US courts to adjudicate which acts are and are not "evil"?
- jonas21 5y agoI'd also imagine you'd have a pretty hard time convincing a US court that working with a US government agency is "evil."
- dragonwriter 5y ago> I'd also imagine you'd have a pretty hard time convincing a US court that working with a US government agency is "evil." The case isn't asking a US Court to find that. It is asking a California State Court to find that challenging corporate involvement in a particular federal action on the same moral grounds that the State of California was challenging the underlying federal action at the same time was reasonably either or a combination of (a) within the ambit of an obligation undertaken to raise potential “evil” actions, or (b) legally protected political activity, or (c) legally protected discussion of working conditions. (And there's a couple other things in it that could succeed even if those all fail, notably the slander charge about knowingly false information spread about involvement in public leaks.)
- jldugger 5y agoI'm curious how a judge tosses this out. Do they just say "Look, the law has nothing to do with stopping evil, so stop asking us to try"?
- thaumasiotes 5y agoThe law isn't unrelated to stopping evil, but it isn't able to determine what evil is. Whether an act is "evil" is a theological question, so to the extent plaintiffs are actually relying on the word "evil", separation of church and state will prevent the court from even considering their claims.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Whether an act is "evil" is a theological question Whether challenging an act is within the reasonable scope of a contractual obligation to report suspected evil is, however, not a theological question, and does not involve deciding the question of whether the act is, in fact, evil, whether or not that is a theological question (it is not, necessarily, it is a moral question.)
- carlivar 5y agoIt's not theological. It is moral. Atheists have a moral code. So does a society.
- Eelongate 5y ago> Atheists have a moral code. [Most?] atheists have moral codes. Yours is not necessarily mine. Sorry to be pedantic, but implications of atheist unity really bug me.
- jeremyjh 5y agoYou don't need theology to define evil, dictionary.com defines it as "morally wrong or bad".
- willcipriano 5y agoEvil is a personal concept, nobody thinks they themselves are evil outside of a few extremely rare exceptions that mostly involve severe mental illness. Good and evil would appear meaningless and arbitrary to a alien, a strange custom invented by a primitive people.
- adventured 5y agoWhy would one ever default to believing aliens are likely to be highly enlightened? It's as likely that they're just lucky with resources, location, timing. They might be savages that primarily jump forward in technology by constantly fighting wars amongst themselves. The aliens observing our supposed primitiveness are just the ones that came out on top in their latest civil war and went out exploring using the technology that the 14,000 years of war cultivated. Maybe they're the most obnoxious, spoiled, entitled assholes you could ever imagine. Luck rolled their way ten thousand times in a row and they act like it. There's absolutely no good reason to default to believing aliens are likely to be far more enlightened than we are.
- azekai 5y agoMost law exists to punish lawbreaking, and courts enforce those laws; they do not directly legislate what is or is not evil. The laws reflect the mores of society, and courts are typically not called upon to make sweeping definitions of what those mores are.
- sjtindell 5y agoI would assume it would be about “don’t be evil” being such a broad, noncommittal statement.
- akomtu 5y agoThe judge should quote Eliphas Levi on what evil is. IIRC, Levi argues that evil is about abandoning reason, for reason is what makes us different from animals.
- SeanLuke 5y agoWait, what does reason mean precisely then? This sounds half-baked. Let's say I have the preverbial lever which kills someone but gives me a million dollars. Is it reasonable for me to increase my own utility by pressing the lever? Thus would Levi say it's not evil to do so?
- addingnumbers 5y agoMy beliefs aside for the sake of argument, one could claim the evil all falls to the person devising that contraption and issuing the reward for that decision.
- SeanLuke 5y agoThat seems to let one off the hook. Suppose that if person X dies you inherit his million-dollar wealth. We're out camping and you have the opportunity to do him in. So YOU'RE not evil in taking that opportunity: but rather, what, the campground is evil for making the opportunity happen, or the legal system is evil for permitting inheritance and not universal surveillance?
- akomtu 5y agoExactly. What you've described isn't evil. What would be evil is creating a society for those people where all truth is suppressed, all irrationality is praised, good deeds are punished and amoral behavior is rewarded. Basically, making that society as backwards as possible. And if in a few generations people there will embrace that order, because they don't know any better, and start descending into animalism, that would be an example of evil. In other words, evil operates at the soul level, so if you reject the idea of soul, you won't be able to come up with evil or good plans: all acts will be superficial.
- 5y ago
- Minor49er 5y agoThe judge would say "what laws were specifically broken?" Then toss it out when the plaintiffs come up empty handed. If the case somehow did get through, they would have to justify how their own repeated violations of Google's data security policies, which led to their terminations, would put them in the right. They would have a hard time of showing that they themselves are clean of evil.
- carlivar 5y agoLaws don't have to be broken in a civil case.
- dragonwriter 5y agoYes, they do. Criminal laws don't have to be broken, but criminal laws aren't the only kind of laws.
- jcranmer 5y agoThis is a civil case, where the causes of action arise either from contractual violations or from private rights of action authorized by law. The counts alleged are "breach of contract", "promissory estoppel", "breach of implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing" (all three of which are essentially saying "Google legally promised they wouldn't do something they did, and it hurt me"), defamation, and, uh, "termination in violation of public policy" (which is basically saying it violates employment discrimination laws, and is at best poorly drafted in the complaint). In this case, the tossing out would be along the lines of "the facts alleged in the complaint are, even if true, insufficient to let you bring this lawsuit" (or, more succinctly, "failure to state a claim [upon which relief can be granted]").
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoI'd be nice of the judge to censure the lawyers for wasting the court's time too.
- authed 5y agoAt least they have a better chance then if they went against the current motto "Do the right thing" (ie: the right thing for who? the advertisers?).
- carlivar 5y agoIf Google was able to fire workers for being evil, I think these employees have a case for the reverse as well. Many contract disputes boil down to the definition of the term "reasonable" so why would "evil" be different? Ultimately it's on Google for including the word in legal documents.
- Animats 5y agoThat's a good point. You see phrases such as "consent shall not be unreasonably withheld" in contracts. It's common in leases, where you can sublet with the consent of the landlord. Court decisions in this area are not consistent.
- bpodgursky 5y ago> If Google was able to fire workers for being evil, I think these employees have a case for the reverse as well. The reverse here is that the employees are allowed to quit. Google isn't trying to sue any employees for "being evil".
- stuaxo 5y agoThat isn't the reverse at all.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoWhy not?
- AlbertCory 5y ago> "If Google was able to fire workers for being evil" Are you treating that as fact? Obviously I haven't looked at the paperwork for every fired employee (and probably no one will ever get to), but I think they have some other pretext. "<employee> was fired for being evil" is not a phrase you'll ever find.
- TheCoelacanth 5y agoIt's right there in their code of conduct[1] that employees can be fired not just for being evil, but for "seeing something that [they] think isn't right" and not speaking up. > Failure of a member of our extended workforce or other covered service provider to follow the Code can result in termination of their relationship with Google. > don’t be evil, and if you see something that you think isn’t right – speak up! [1] https://abc.xyz/investor/other/google-code-of-conduct/ https://abc.xyz/investor/other/google-code-of-conduct/
- NaturalPhallacy 5y agoFTA: >"There are all sorts of contract terms that a jury is required to interpret: 'don't be evil' is not so 'out there' as to be unenforceable," she said. "Since Google's contract tells employees that they can be fired for failing to abide by the motto, 'don't be evil,' it must have meaning."
- thaumasiotes 5y agoThat doesn't mean that the meaning can be determined by a court. It can't.
- realce 5y agoAt the very least, certain definitions have been ratified by Google if they've fired anyone for "being evil" - have they?
- AlbertCory 5y agoI can't say for sure, but I would doubt it. They tend to have some other official "cause."
- webkike 5y agoI’d argue that’s the entire point of courts…
- criddell 5y agoSure it can.
- sophacles 5y agoYou keep asserting this, but I remain unconvinced. Can you expand your "argument" from "It can't" to something a little less vague?
- thaumasiotes 5y agoThe US government is prohibited from taking a position on religious questions. The nature of evil is such a question. The government frequently declares that something is "bad", but it is not able to declare that something is "evil".
- daenz 5y agoThis is what happens when people are radicalized by their feelings. I'm confident that their hearts are in the right place, but give me a break. If you work at Google, you should have the sense that this kind of flimsy case is going nowhere at all. >But the plaintiffs' lawyer, Laurie Burgess, said it is not beyond what courts regularly must decide. Sounds like the lawyer is taking them for a ride on their dime, imo.
- crawfordcomeaux 5y agoThere's literally no other way typ find out if this can be handled in the courts.
- InvertedRhodium 5y agoI'm inclined to agree, however if you remove the feelings from the situation - it doesn't seem much different to any other contractual obligations - like the amount and frequency of their wage payments. If your contract stipulates that you (and your employer) should "do no evil" without supplying a definition for "evil" then it really isn't that much different to any other contractual breach. Also, you'd have to be stupid to put that in an actual contract.
- gnicholas 5y agoI'd be surprised if this weren't a case taken on contingency (that is, where the lawyer only gets paid if the plaintiff wins or gets a settlement). The lawyer could still benefit from fame/notoriety even if they lose, but their incentives are generally aligned with the plaintiff's.
- xxpor 5y agoIANAL either, but this isn't nearly as crazy as I thought it'd be based on the headline. They basically say don't be evil was part of the employment contract (via the code of conduct), the employees fulfilled their obligation to advise Google not to be evil, and then Google fired them. From wikipedia: The elements of promissory estoppel are: * an express or implied promise; * detrimental reliance by the promisee foreseeable to a reasonable person in the promissor's position; * actual detrimental reliance by the promisee (worsening of their position); and for specific performance (as opposed to reliance damages), injustice can only be avoided by enforcing the promise. Point by point: * Google promised to not be evil because every employee (including the CEO and members of the board) agrees to the code of conduct. * The promisee (employees) relied on that when they made their decition to work at google and enter the contract. That was reasonably foreseeable by the promissor (Google). * The employees actually did rely on the promise when they took the job, and circulated the petition to not be evil, since they were promised all employees agreed to it. No comment on the specific performance remedy since I didn't read that far to see if that's what they're demanding. Obviously there's points in there that could be reasonably debated, but it seems not-crazy enough to make it past a motion to dismiss.
- ycombigator 5y agoWe're here talking about it though.
- defen 5y agoI've heard of many big companies not wanting to use JSON-license licensed software for this reason (too much legal risk) - https://www.json.org/license.html https://www.json.org/license.html
- toast0 5y agoDouglas Crockford has been very willing to give special license to use things for evil; you just have to ask. (May not be good enough for Debian, I guess)
- lovemenot 5y agoTo save others the trouble, here's the relevant section: The Software shall be used for Good, not Evil.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Ekaros 5y agoI wonder which side is required to define "evil" in this case? Probably Google's lawyers... Might be interesting what they come up with... If it ever gets to that point.
- puzzledobserver 5y agoIANAL, but isn't / shouldn't the process be the following: Google's lawyers drafted the employment contract and used the word evil. Now it is up to the employees lawyers to argue for an interpretation of the word, and if that interpretation is reasonable, then it stands? There is a Wikipedia article about something similar: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contra_proferentem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contra_proferentem
- jcranmer 5y agoIgnore the media reporting around the lawsuit and turn to the complaint itself (it's linked in the first sentence of the article [1]). The complaint centers on a Code of Conduct that the employees signed, and then that the employees were terminated for speaking out internally about what they felt was a violation of the "don't be evil" motto. I'm not sufficiently familiar with California employment and contract law to know how much of a leg this case has, but on a quick scan, one of the counts (discrimination due to sexual identity) is dead in motion-to-dismiss phase, one (slander) might survive if amended, and the other three will turn on whether or not the Code of Conduct's statements that employees should speak up about perceived violations of "don't be evil" is enough like a contract to make retaliation in firing because of it a violation of contract. Notably, it never asks the court to decide if its acts were or were not evil. It's not insane enough to be thrown out immediately, but there's several facts about the Code of Conduct I'd want to learn about that aren't in the complaint. [1] This should be standard practice for anyone reporting on legal cases, and it frustrates me to no end that it is not.
- cormacrelf 5y agoEveryone in this thread should calm down and just read this comment.
- comfysocks 5y agoThanks for posting this. All of the knee-jerk comments are hurting my mind.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> I'm not sufficiently familiar with California employment and contract law to know how much of a leg this case has, but on a quick scan, one of the counts (discrimination due to sexual identity) is dead in motion-to-dismiss phase, No such count exists in the complaint! There is a component of Count V of that type but Count V can stand without it. That said, the other bits in Count V are also fairly weak, though the sex/orientation/identity one is the weakest. > one (slander) might survive if amended, Not sure why you say that; while obviously the facts require trial the slander/false light charge seems to make all the necessary claims to establish the tort.
- perl4ever 5y agoI would for the sake of argument stipulate that "evil" means something, that a court might be able to adjudicate it, and that CBP does many specific things which might be deemed evil. However, even given all of that, I do not believe it is possible for Google to exist without being complicit with the overall purpose of CBP. I don't see any particularly salient dividing line between generically working with them and not. There might be something evil about the details of the particular project, but if CBP as a whole is evil, I don't comprehend how working with them automatically makes a difference when you are based in the US anyway. I can swallow "a US court adjudicating which acts are evil" much easier than "a US court adjudicating which major parts of the US government are generally evil". The latter seems like some sort of propaganda fantasy, a snake eating its tail.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gruez 5y agoWhy not? There's this case that went all the way to the supreme court: >The issue is that, before the 2008 global financial crisis, Goldman had gone around saying things like “our clients’ interests always come first” and “integrity and honesty are at the heart of our business.” Then the global financial crisis occurred, and: > 1. It came out that maybe Goldman’s clients’ interests sometimes came second, and maybe integrity and honesty were sometimes not quite at the heart of its business[1]; and > 2. Goldman’s stock price went down. >[...] >Perhaps in 2007, investors read in Goldman’s disclosures that “our clients’ interests always come first” and “integrity and honesty are at the heart of our business,” and they thought: “Yes, it is good that Goldman has integrity and puts its clients’ interests first, that is valuable for its business, we will buy the stock.” In 2009, after Abacus and so forth, investors thought “alas, no, Goldman does not have integrity and does not put its clients’ interests first, we are disappointed, we will sell the stock.” In other words, perhaps investors ascribed value to Goldman’s statements about integrity and honesty, and then when they found out that those statements were not true that value went away and the stock went down. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/newsletters/2021-06-22/money-stuff-everything-still-might-be-securities-fraud https://www.bloomberg.com/news/newsletters/2021-06-22/money-...