8 ms·
This seems like... obviously a security? I seriously hope they're registering with the SEC for this. https://www.investopedia.com/terms/h/howey-test.asp https:
by gruez 5y ago
This seems like... obviously a security? I seriously hope they're registering with the SEC for this.
https://www.investopedia.com/terms/h/howey-test.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/h/howey-test.asp
>1. An investment of money
check
>2. In a common enterprise
check
>3. With the expectation of profit
Probably? Why else would they be buying a team for?
>4. To be derived from the efforts of others3
check.
edit: I took a look at their "Flightpaper", and in it they acknowledged that some parts of it might pass the Howey Test, and they recognize the possibility of regulatory oversight
>This funding model requires extensive SEC regulation oversight.
However, they're pretty light on details on whether it would actually be approved by the SEC or not. Also by the looks of it they haven't registered with the SEC right now, but they're already raising funds?
- charcircuit 5y agoStop being a fun police. The internet allows us to be free from the government.
- CryptoPunk 5y agoYou will find the opposition to cryptocurrency is strongly correlated with believing that people should not be free from the government.
- emerged 5y agoBeing free from the government, also known as being a criminal.
- vmception 5y agoIts a prisoner's dilemma, the SEC's mission of protecting investors is impossible if their only response to compliance are enforcement actions that will hurt investors In the past, this meant that exchanges won't list the token to trade (or delist, with traders panic selling before the delisting events), as any asset notified as being a security requires a broker-dealer to trade it ONLY IF it is registered. But for the past 2 years, centralized exchanges aren't involved in the liquidity. The network has innovated a way to incentivize liquidity with a fundamentally different model of exchange called AMMs (automated market markers, the acronym tells you nothing about why it is different though, but thats the term to look up). AMMs let people pool liquidity onchain and there is practically zero consequence anymore from SEC action - with regard to globally accessible liquidity. And sure, maybe the numerous liquidity providers can be sanctioned but they don't care, it is extremely easy to mix your legitimate funds with Tornado Cash and come out the other side and make a liquidity pool anonymously with mixed funds. It is up the regulator to figure out who to sanction and in this case the mixer's use isn't criminal and the clean funds on the ensuing anonymous side are only a civil issue. Also, even if you want to argue the cat and mouse game favoring the government's omnipotence, liquidity can be burned making that liquidity permanent no matter what happens to the human. I would actually argue a significant bullish thesis is based on how many assets are intentionally burned in liquidity pool bearer shares. Its pretty much perfect right now (with room for improvement in the liquidity pool technology). Between permissionless AMMs and permissionless bridges, and 3 trillion USD already within the crypto ecosystem outside of exchanges, its just not really the same game as it was 3 years ago. The SEC regulates the intermediaries and now those intermediaries have been disintermediated.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- riffraff 5y agoYou're missing the part where this interfaces with the classical finance system. The whole organization that wants to buy an NBA team exists in the US legal system, and that is the point that will be regulated, the fact they get funded with USD via a bank or crypto through a pool is irrelevant.
- vmception 5y agoI was answering in general, these DAOs are dime a dozen and most never try to do something with the classical financial system
- gamblor956 5y agoThe SEC regulates companies that publicly issue stock and the intermediaries like stock exchanges on which that stock can be traded. The company bit of the equation has not been disintermediated. In fact, that's the whole point of this transaction: to create a publicly traded company.
- vmception 5y agoyes they regulate both I was mostly talking about the other daos that exist which dont attempt to do anything in meat space
- throwawaycities 5y ago3 really depends on the rights of the token. It’s not exactly without precedent, take the Green Bay Packers it’s the sole NFL team not owned by private billionaires, in fact it doesn’t have any owners. Nearly every 10 years they raise funds through a “public offering” of “stock” amounting to hundreds of millions of dollars. Every time they obtain a no-action letter from the SEC. Packers “stock” is not stock in the common sense of the word as it doesn’t convey ownership, again there are no owners of the team (despite people often incorrectly saying the city owns the team). But Packers stock does give holders the right to vote/elect a certain number of directors to the board. Lots of DAO tokens are structured this way, where holders are given voting rights but not ownership rights. There are numerous other examples including other sports related examples. Perhaps the best part of the Green Bay Packers is that the reason they only publicly offer “stock” every 10 years or so, is they have to obtain permission from the NFL and the NFL’s official position is that the NFL must restrict the Packers public offerings because it is a “competitive advantage” over every other team backed by billionaires.
- VWWHFSfQ 5y agoNearly everything you said here is completely false. > But Packers stock does give holders the right to vote/elect a certain number of directors to the board. The toy stock certificates they give out to the fans that buy them have no voting rights whatsoever. Or any kind of rights at all. It's basically just some packers memorabilia. > Nearly every 10 years they raise funds through a “public offering” of “stock” amounting to hundreds of millions of dollars. what on earth. they do not raise "hundreds of millions of dollars".
- PretzelPirate 5y agoFrom https://www.newsweek.com/green-bay-packers-ready-sell-stock-offering-team-first-time-almost-decade-1649561?amp=1 https://www.newsweek.com/green-bay-packers-ready-sell-stock-... > Shareholders don't receive any power in the organization aside from an invitation to an annual shareholder's meeting with voting rights to issues decided at the meeting. The stock also pays no dividends to shareholders.
- dheera 5y ago> With the expectation of profit Umm no. I have the expectation of loss but am putting a small amount money to insure myself against the emotional distress of if I missed a big mooning opportunity. The default expectation is that the money is all lost. So no, it's not a security.
- panarky 5y ago> big mooning opportunity If you invest $100 with the expectation that it will be lost with 99% probability, and that it will become $100,000 with 1% probability, you are expecting a profit of $901. That is an "expectation of profit" my friend.
- dheera 5y ago> you are expecting a profit of $901 No, it would be stupid to "expect" a profit of $901 because there is no scenario in which you would gain $901. You would either have -$100 or +$100000 and never +$901 in your stated scenario.* In your case since there is a 99% probability of -$100, my "expectation" would be -$100 and if "surprise" of $100000 happens that is "surprise", not part of the "expectation". * I realize there is a term called "expectation value" and I hate that term with a passion because in any distribution that doesn't roughly resemble a bell curve it would be stupid to "expect" the mean value. Statistics like the mean are not a good way to establish a strategy for a game that you only get to play once.
- josephcsible 5y ago"Expected value" means the mean of any distribution, not just ones shaped like bell curves. GP is correct.
- dheera 5y agoExactly, my point is it's stupid terminology. I use the word "mean", not "expectation". That brainwashes people actually "expecting" the mean to happen, which in this case, it never will. Treating the mean as an expectation of some sort is just not a good formulation to strategize about this game. GGP said "you are expecting a profit of $901" -- I'm not, personally. I'm "expecting" -$100. How about we take a bet? I'll expect -$100, you expect $901. If I win you give me $100, if you win I give you $100, and if neither of us wins we split the $100K. Deal? This is a game theory problem, NOT a statistics problem. In my case the utility of losing -$100 is zero, the utility of gaining $100K is very positive, the utility of missing out on the $100K is extremely negative.
- EMM_386 5y ago> This seems like... obviously a security? Or obviously an ETF, or obviously a mutual fund, or obviously a market maker, or obviously The Fed. There is literally a 1-1 attempt at mimicking the current financial system under the label "DeFi". The problem is that the vast majority of the participants don't care about this. They care about 720,687% APY as of this posting on things like this, which anyone should realize is nonsense: https://euphoria.money/ https://euphoria.money/ That's $100 to $3 billion in two years. Good luck with that.
- pas 5y agothose insane yields are deceptive because they are not adjusted for inflation of the currency/token/coin
- qeternity 5y agoWell, sort of. Your yield isn't in dollars, it's in number of tokens. Your dollar yield will be the token yield minus the change in token price.
- EMM_386 5y ago> Well, sort of. Your yield isn't in dollars, it's in number of tokens. Perhaps they should be more transparent about this, because I can end homelessness in the United States right now with $100 based on their reported APY. The only people who are attracted to this misinformation are amateur investors, and I fear that is the whole point.
- qeternity 5y agoAbsolutely. I’m not defending it. But this is my point, it takes an understanding of finance and an understanding of what’s actually happening with these smart contracts. Retail will get slaughtered.
- spinchange 5y agoYes, ETFs and Mutual funds are both registered securities. They are regulated instruments/investments. They could not be sold, legally, if they were not registered with the SEC (it doesn't have anything to do, specifically, with being traded on stock exchange- a security can be non traded too) The parent comment is pointing out that this looks like it meets the same definition as those other things and needs to follow the same laws, no matter how much people like it, want it, think it's better than what's it's "replacing"
- atmosx 5y ago>> 3. With the expectation of profit > Probably? Why else would they be buying a team for? Teams are money sinks. The reason to buy a team is political power. To the extend that the state will turn a blind eye or two (see ^2). A totally random example[1], less random examples: Juventus, AC Milan, Olympiacos[^2] and countless others. Just pointing the obvious, I agree that this transaction should be regulated, all I'm saying is that (3) is not _necessarily real_ in this or other cases. [^1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joan_Laporta#Political_activities https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joan_Laporta#Political_activit... [^2]: https://newrepublic.com/article/159252/noor-one-vampire-ship-heroin-turkey-greece-corruption-scandal https://newrepublic.com/article/159252/noor-one-vampire-ship...
- sofixa 5y agoAmerican sports teams are generally very profitable due to the structure - franchises, closed, no relegation or promotion, shared academy intake academy preference to the worst performing teams - basically an owner can not invest anything, the team can perform bad, and they'd just get good youngsters without getting relegated, and keep the same revenues, whereas a European team being managed badly or with little investment will fall down the pyramid, with diminishing revenues, and they'd have only their own academy to count on, without investment to buy new players. And for your Barcelona example, it isn't a good one. It's a fan owned club, the president is elected and isn't an owner and can't really invest in it bar some special cases.
- CryptoPunk 5y agoIf it's a non-profit organization, acting as the intermediary between the DAO and the legal system, that takes legal ownership over the team, then it could eliminate the expectation of profit, and be free to engage in this transaction, right?
- netcan 5y agoIt's definitely an enterprise of some sort, and hence probably qualifies for many kinds of checks and laws. For good or ill, a common pattern is (1) someone just does it. (2) it attracts regulatory oversight/action/whatnot (3) regulation becomes actually functional.(3.5) the incumbent now has advantage. PayPal, Uber, etc. What's the alternative? Ban it? Create a framework regulating something that does not exist? All that said, crypto-ish ownership of a sports team isn't a bad idea.
- loceng 5y agoIt's part of a marketing-advertising brand awareness play, even if not directly profitable.
- skizm 5y ago3 doesn’t apply. The only way to make money is to resell the token/coin/whatever. The holder can’t actually extract any value from the underlying asset.
- 3solarmasses 5y agoIf we're going to parrot outdated legislation, let's also force all automobiles to be classified as horses & carriages, so they can be taxed in accordance to the carriage act of 1794.