12 ms·
And so what are you suggesting? Everyone wear N95 masks all the time forever?
by nradov 5y ago
And so what are you suggesting? Everyone wear N95 masks all the time forever?
- spookthesunset 5y agoThere is no end game to masking. It will be in perpetuity in some places.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- NikolaNovak 5y agoIt's tricky. - fwiw, I personally plan to wear n95 mask outside of home in enclosed public spaces for the foreseeable future, and for things like shopping etc (where I'm exposed to strangers) basically indefinitely / as long as social norms and laws will allow. - I would like for strangers around me to wear masks. There's too much uncertainty and I don't know how to quantify and otherwise address risk from stranger e.g. In waiting / cashier line, or worse yet elevator (enforced enclosed proximity). I really see no good reason to be in an elevator with unmasked stranger. - how long and where do we legally mandate masks? Whooeee, I'm glad I don't have to make that awful formal call! :-) But yeah. If risk is forever, than at least some of us will use ways to mitigate the risk forever in turn. It's not binary, it's a sliding scale that's very individual. so... Yeah. Welcome to the new world! Cyberpunk dystopia future is here! :-)
- timr 5y ago> There's too much uncertainty and I don't know how to quantify and otherwise address risk from stranger You know what would help with this? A randomized controlled trial. This isn't tricky at all, except that we can't do the science because it has become political, because people insist that they know the answer already! And if the study shows what they don't want to see, then they censor it, bury it, downvote it into oblivion, or...write missives about how they're going to ignore it. Also, are you vaccinated? Yes? Then the answer is almost certainly no risk at all. This much we know from ~all of the data regarding vaccines and serious illness, worldwide.
- vishho 5y agoWe cannot do the science, because such a randomized test would be deeply unethical. Compare to having pregnant women smoke cigarettes to study effect on the fetus. You do this only afterwards with observational data. Next to politization there is also public health, which is more of a management science than an emperical science. And economic concerns. From all the data worldwide, you only reduce risk of hospitalization and death, not for spreading to your grandmother or catching it from a bypasser sneezing in your face. To act like there is no risk for the leaky vaccinated, is to actually increase your risk. Data shows that asymptomatic breakthrough infections are able to cause long-COVID. Now you did not even feel sick and gave your body and immune system rest to clear the virus. Very risky!
- timr 5y ago> We cannot do the science, because such a randomized test would be deeply unethical. Thank you for perfectly illustrating the problem. I was actually sort of worried that people wouldn't take me seriously when I said that science has become so political that we actually can't do any. It sounds conspiratorial, doesn't it? But, alas: 1) I post results of RCTs showing that masks do little, if anything. 2) Someone replies that the evidence is insufficient for reasons X, Y, Z. 3) I say "great, let's gather more evidence to resolve those uncertainties". 4) Someone replies "we can't, it's unethical". Quite a fine castle you've built on that cloud, good sir. Very safe indeed.
- cedilla 5y agoIt is unethical. All your accusations of narrow-mindedness, but you can't see the obvious, glaring ethical problems with such a trial. Not the least because it would be completely infeasible. You may pretend that we can "simply" do a "controlled experiment" but you ignore how impossible it is to tell any sizeable group of people to behave in a certain way and report honestly about it. "Randomised control trials" are the platonic ideal but in the real world, you can't endanger people for your curiosity, and you will have greatest problems to actually enforce your test protocol. It's more than "tricky". Unless you have access to some spherical people in a vacuum.
- collaborative 5y agoYou actually want to be exposed to the virus (after vaccination) during the summer and if possible as often as possible after a successful exposure. It's the only way forward. You can't lock it out forever, and you need to play catch up with it as it evolves or by the time you get it your immune system won't know what to do with it
- gladinovax 5y agoAs long as it makes you comfortable you should wear a mask. However it makes me uncomfortable to wear one. I've never worn one. The fact you are scared doesn't mean I should have to change how I live. You should change how you live in order to better cope with your fear. Expecting the world to change for you is setting yourself up for disappointment at best.
- feanaro 5y agoForever? Why would we need to do it forever when we don't do it for any other virus?
- codezero 5y agoProbably because we should have been, and now some of us have learned. It’s been a pleasure going two years without any upper respiratory illnesses for me. I look forward to being steadfast in that since it’s really not that hard to wear a mask, and it’s not hurting anyone else when I do so.
- ktkoffroth 5y agoWhat happens when you eventually do catch an upper respiratory disease, and your immune system is no longer used to the challenges it presents?
- codezero 5y agoI take advantage of every medical technology available to me. Duh.
- codezero 5y agoAre you suggesting that one’s immune system becomes stronger after year over year infection? If so, to what end? Every year? Even when I’m 80? When does my system break down. Isolation seems to solve all of these issues and I hate people so isolation is easy.
- feanaro 5y ago> Isolation seems to solve all of these issues and I hate people so isolation is easy. Ah, so this is the real reason. That's fine, but it's also not really applicable to the wider population and hence isn't about what I originally asked -- which is why we would universally continuing wearing masks forever. The answer is we wouldn't, because that makes no sense.