18 ms·
Piracy release group EVO ‘blames’ movie industry for its popularity
- dredmorbius 5y agoTitle shortened from: "The film industry effectively solved the problem of unauthorised downloads; now it is “unsolving” it…"
- lbriner 5y agoThe title is confusing. It reads like the film industry purposely decided to allow unauthorised downloads for some reason.
- apozem 5y agoI don’t work in streaming, so take this opinion with a grain of salt, but my impression is this problem will solve itself in a few years. Right now the video industry is in land-grab mode. Everyone knows there are too many subscription streaming services. In five years there will be three, maybe four winners, and everyone else will sell content to them.
- emrah 5y agoThe problem isn't that there are too many, but that they are too expensive, especially since one needs to subscribe to several of them to get enough diversity/coverage of content ala cable.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoIt is the same problem with yachts.
- michaelt 5y agoWell, the TV industry always knew there were people who were willing to spend $100/month for cable. And it had adverts. They hate the idea of those people paying less.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y ago> They hate the idea of those people paying less. They do? I think many people are just suckers who can't say no.
- stevenwliao 5y agoWhy is anyone entitled to as much content as cable for a Netflix-like price?
- redis_mlc 5y ago> In five years there will be three, maybe four winners, and everyone else will sell content to them. In a few years the content industry will own all of the subscription streaming services. Disney is well on its way to ensuring that.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- goodpoint 5y agoAKA yet another oligopoly. It's really not ending well for customers, both in terms of quality and price.
- toss1 5y agoLikely true that we'll see market consolidation. But that sounds to me like it will make it worse in the end. Fewer and larger competitors will likely wind up like ISP services, consistently and overpriced as if they were colluding, without even having to collude. Sure, each service will have a larger selection, but like the cable companies now, we'll be paying for a lot of cruft that we don't want, and still not getting some content really important to us. IOW, it seems like the A La Carte that we all want started to appear, and now it is going away before it ever really got established.
- Finnucane 5y agoI work in publishing, and it is still hard to get management to understand that convenience and a reasonable price is more effective than drm for fighting piracy. On the other hand, Spotify also solved the industry’s problem of having to pay artists.
- redis_mlc 5y agoSpotify is the problem - they're owned by the industry.
- KptMarchewa 5y agoNot really. Their income will soon overtake pre-widespread-internet peak. https://www.riaa.com/u-s-sales-database/ https://www.riaa.com/u-s-sales-database/
- slothtrop 5y agoRIAA income != artist income
- vlovich123 5y agoIs that accounting for inflation?
- john_miller 5y agoNo, the peak statement is not valid if inflation is considered. But the page has a "Adjusted for inflation" checkbox on the right, so you can see for yourself. :)
- akamaka 5y agoThat chart shows revenue, so I don’t think it takes into account the higher profit margins that come with not needing to manufacture and distribute physical media.
- ma2rten 5y agoI don't understand why buying music on iTunes was so popular in the US for a while, when in Europe everyone was already listening to Spotify.
- draw_down 5y agoI don’t think anything has fundamentally changed, piracy was a response to content owners shortsightedly trying to extract maximum dollars. There was a brief interregnum when everything switched to streaming, but it didn’t have anything to do with studio execs coming to their senses.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoA) copyright should be lowered to 10 or maybe 20 years. B) content owners have the right to ask for however much they want for content if copyright lengths were reasonable
- vlovich123 5y agoI think a hybrid model would work well where you don’t get royalties from access by non-profits/individuals but corporations with a sufficiently large market cap (eg $1bn) do have to pay royalties to distribute such content.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoI do not see any reason to add that complication.
- vlovich123 5y agoPolitics. Shrinking copyright from 90 years to 20 years for most uses might work if you can say that content creators get to still charge big corporations from charging royalties for the remaining 70 years.
- Something1234 5y agoHow so? That doesn't make sense. I think most of the royalties come from the long tail of companies, and market cap is a really terrible way of determining the worth of a company
- vlovich123 5y agoFine then strong man the argument and say companies > $100m in revenues. I also didn’t mean to imply right away. I meant “after 10-18 years”.
- tryptophan 5y agoA model I like is as such: Copyrights are possible to extend indefinitely. The owner must declare a value every year for their copyrighted material. The owner must pay X% of the material's value per year as tax. The owner can release the copyright at any time. Others may bid to own the copyright. If it is higher than the owner's declared value, the owner must raise their bid to match, or else the copyright is sold to the highest bidder.
- kf6nux 5y agoTitle is a little misleading. Article is basically saying that, through a combination of too many streaming services, fragmented content, and premium pricing, the tv/movie industry is recreating a demand for piracy.
- taftster 5y agoYes, it's a clever but unfortunately click-bait title. I was duped to reading the article (which is very short too, not very much meat). The core idea of the article is interesting, but very shallow coverage, somewhat even obvious.
- jmacd 5y agoDisney is the main culprit here. They are making a few significant missteps with their otherwise very well executed streaming offering. Initially they offered their streaming service at a very competitive price, but I think they have gotten some of the sequencing wrong after that. Initially early subscribers were hit with these up charges for new films. I think Mulan might have been the first one? It was mid pandemic and they didn't get a chance to release it in theatres, so I think it felt like it made sense at the time and I am guessing they saw it as pretty successful. They quickly started doing it with far less interesting films, and ones that I could see at release time in the theatre. At home streaming just isn't a "special occasion" like going to the theatre is, and while I was happy to make it a special occasion during the depths of stay-at-home lockdowns, there are a lot of competitive forces now. An extra $20 or $30 might seem to Disney like an amount people will happily pay for every new release, but I think the appetite for that will be pretty low going forward. Disney also offered an attractive discount for a 1-year subscription initially, so it was pretty easy to do. I've been happy with it, but I notice my kids are on Netflix much much more. That really surprised me. Now, my subscription renews in April of 2022, but Disney has already started emailing me that it is going to increase almost 50% in cost at renewal time. I don't know why they feel the need to start telling me that so far in advance, or so many times (3 emails now). All it's done is make me thing "ok, that's a lot, let's see if we really use it" and also "hmm, I've spent some $ on these new releases". They don't seem patient or that they are thinking through this messaging/experience nearly as well as Netflix. Netflix does increase their prices but they do it rarely and they always pummel you with new content around the time they are doing it. They also packaged in lower resolution options, etc so you can keep your costs down if you really want to. Disney hasn't done any of that.
- hellbannedguy 5y agoThe industry most likely shot themselfs in the money maker? Monday morning 2008, "Hay Joe-- I saw the new Hellraiser 2. It was great! I got it on Pirate Bay. The quality was just ok though, and I wish I saw it on a big screen." Two weeks later Joe is planning his friday night. I'll call Ingrid, and take her to that new vegetetarian restaurant, and maybe she will be condusive to Hellmaker 2? On the big screen? Hollywood just made money off free adverting. (Lars Ulrich is in the front row of the theater crying. His date is a snare drum with two drumb sticks jabbed through the skin. He's nervously rubbing Minoxidill into his forehead. I--should--have--a--date? I'm but a famous rocktwat? "But Governor--they be taking my money? Cry, cry,cry. I couldn't let them take me money?"
- bshepard 5y agoHere, from one of the founders of Ordoliberalism, is a consideration that is useful to keep in mind when reflecting on intellectual property: "Anbieter und Nachfrager suchen stets - wo immer es möglich ist - Konkurrenz zu vermeiden und monopolistische Stellungen zu erwerben oder zu behaupten"....."Suppliers and buyers always seek - wherever possible - to avoid competition and to acquire or maintain monopoly positions" - Walter Eucken
- dredmorbius 5y agoIt strikes me that the goal being sought here appears to be far less profit maximisation and far more market dominance. Economic theory is mistaken in presuming profit is the principle driver, power is. Profit is merely one means to power.
- pinum 5y agoI recently watched Arcane using the Netflix Win10 app. The A/V sync was off by enough to noticeably break lipsync, the episode listing was broken (only the first few were shown, but I could still watch the rest by allowing it to autoplay the next one), and the splash images shown while each steam started often served as spoilers for the episode that was about to play. I would've had a much better experience if I'd just went to thepiratebay and sought out nine MKV files instead.
- 1_player 5y ago> I would've had a much better experience if I'd just went to thepiratebay and sought out nine MKV files instead. I did. I had none of your issues. "Piracy is almost always a service problem and not a pricing problem." — Gabe Newell
- bananamerica 5y agoWhy not use the website?
- hjadal 5y agoAfaik the resolution is lower and some audio features are not supported in most browsers. It is only Microsoft Edge on Windows and Safari on Mac that supports 4k, https://help.netflix.com/en/node/13444 https://help.netflix.com/en/node/13444.
- p_l 5y agoIt's DRM requirement
- isiahl 5y agoThe website doesn't deliver 1080p video in any browser but Edge (and this may have changed with Edge being switched to Chromium)
- chrisseaton 5y ago> The website doesn't deliver 1080p video in any browser but Edge I'm pretty sure I watch HD Netflix in Safari. Surely I can't be watching 720p and be deceiving myself?
- jetrink 5y agoIn our case (two person household), it makes much more sense to pay $4 to rent movies individually. We watch about four movies per month, so this gives us access to virtually every movie ever at a cost equivalent to a Netflix subscription. In addition, it greatly cuts down on the effort that it takes to find a movie that we're both interested in seeing. TV is different, because the cost of renting a season is still insane. I think the real value in subscribing to streaming services right now is the TV shows.
- rightbyte 5y agoYe subscription streaming are no way competitive with rentals for most people. Unless you want to watch some series on Netflix, the price is just too high for what you get. It is like going on a buffet - you think there is value for the money but you don't eat enough more to justify the price.
- slothtrop 5y agoWhere do you normally rent?
- Nextgrid 5y agoNot the author but I had a good experience with iTunes. I wouldn't normally buy anything on there due to vendor lock-in (I believe the files are DRM'ed) but since this is a rental anyway I don't mind.
- Oddskar 5y agoAnd it would make even more sense to just pay for a VPN subscription, since they're cheaper than $4 per month.
- __david__ 5y ago> TV is different, because the cost of renting a season is still insane. That's because Amazon, iTunes, etc. make you buy a TV season instead of renting it. The crazy thing is—when I took stock of all the TV I watched and priced it out, buying the seasons online was cheaper than my cable subscription. That's when I finally took the plunge and cut the cord…
- pedrocr 5y agoDevice restrictions are even worse than there being too many services. Netflix is still limited to 720p even when used with Chrome on Windows. When running Linux there's no option to get even 1080p let alone 4K. These companies build their backends on these platforms, try to drum up popular support for net neutrality, and then screw everyone on device neutrality. No wonder downloading an actual file usable everywhere becomes popular again.
- progbits 5y agoThey also refuse to buffer properly. Tiny latency spike or brief packet loss? Enjoy 480p video for the next minute or so because it downgraded automatically and there is no way to force it back.
- dylan604 5y agoThat's the beauty of HLS/DASH. Rather than just flat out stopping a la RealPlayer, they allow the video to continue until your network gets its act together. How is it the provider's fault if your network takes a dump for a bit?
- progbits 5y agoThis would make sense for a live stream. But we are talking Netflix movies here. If my network can maintain more bandwidth than needed for 1080p/4k most of the time (which it can) then there is no reason it should ever fall back to lower quality due to a short blip because you can keep several seconds (or minutes) of buffer. For example I never have this problem on Youtube. Only Netflix.
- tomjen3 5y agoMY network is plenty fast. I have 1gb down. If they can't make it work with 1/10th of that, that is their problem, not mine.
- dylan604 5y agoWe know that having bandwidth does not mean you get full use of that bandwidth. Even using AWS CLI to download large content from an S3 bucket does not saturate my 1Gbps line. There are all sorts of places in a network to prevent you from using the full bandwidth, namely your ISP. To that point, I would not be shocked one bit to find that your ISP is playing with data from Netflix. Hell, mobile carriers tell you they are doing it.
- strictfp 5y agoBalkanization in the licensing models is the biggest problem for people outside of the US. There is a lot of media that I cannot buy digitally. Some of those I can buy in physical formats, and some I just straight up cannot buy. Period.
- JD557 5y agoOne aspect of region locking that makes me very confused is dubbing. I just moved to Germany and a lot of movies in streaming services are only available in the German dub, not with the original voices... Why? I mean, I assume that for some reason the platforms just buy the rights for the dubbed version, but don't the subbed original versions also have a ton of demand (maybe more than the dubbed version)?
- _nalply 5y agoBecause Germans monumentally hate subtitles. I know that because I am Deaf and I would like to have subtitles even using German services, but they hate subtitles so much that they even won't have optional subtitles. Probably because some Hinterwäldler accidentally turned on subtitles and bogged down support by being livid and not listening to the simple solution of turning subtitles off.
- datenarsch 5y ago> I mean, I assume that for some reason the platforms just buy the rights for the dubbed version, but don't the subbed original versions also have a ton of demand (maybe more than the dubbed version)? Why would it have a ton of demand? Nobody in Germany wants to watch subbed original versions for the same reason nobody in the US wants to do that. The German market is big enough so that everything gets localized and people are used to that and expect it.
- slothtrop 5y agoOver here, contracts with telecom giants like Bell are keeping some media (e.g. HBO content) away from stand-alone streaming. They have their own pet streaming services that require a cable subscription. Possibly factoring among the reasons GoT and the like had been so rabidly pirated. When not everything is available, online rental is now a more viable option than it once was. I wonder why it's only the tech giants like MS who offer this. Why isn't Netflix also allowing digital rentals? I'd rather not pay MS, Apple or Google to see a movie over 50 years old. edit: according to this https://blog.playstation.com/2021/03/02/playstation-store-to-discontinue-movie-and-tv-purchases-and-rentals/ https://blog.playstation.com/2021/03/02/playstation-store-to... even Sony stopped (or will stop) offering digital tv/movie purchases and rentals owing to the popularity of streaming. From memory, these were expensive. I guess there's a costly overhead to the service.
- greenshackle2 5y agoYou don't need cable (anymore?) to subscribe to Crave.
- slothtrop 5y agoSeems that's right, however according to this - https://www.finder.com/ca/internet-tv/cravetv https://www.finder.com/ca/internet-tv/cravetv you need to pay $19.98/mo + tax for Crave + HBO. There is no stand-alone HBO package in Canada, because of the Bell contract. Admittedly it's not much cheaper in the U.S and also owned by a large conglomerate.
- greenshackle2 5y agoYes, I'm subscribed and I don't have cable. They changed the packages recently. HBO is no longer optional. The basic package is now $20 and includes HBO. But they added a new cheaper "mobile" plan which is $10, still includes HBO, but you can only watch on one device at a time.
- raspyberr 5y agoPiracy makes me feel like I'm living 50 years in the future. One where there's no such thing as artificial digital scarcity. Yesterday, my partner and I wanted to watch something. I started downloading it because I'm not going search on which streaming service this 3 year old show is on. As I was downloading it, she found it on netflix. I stopped my download and we watched it there. From my point of view, piracy will go down by 98% when all shows and films are accessible in one place. Until that happens, 50 years from now, I'll continue to pirate.
- smcl 5y agoIs there a place that lists what films or shows are on what streaming platform in a given country?
- ClearAndPresent 5y agoJustWatch.com will do this.
- barbazoo 5y agoWill it reliably do this for markets other than the US though? Not long ago it definitely didn't. I'll give it another try but I'm not getting my hopes up.
- notatoad 5y agojustwatch.com
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pronoiac 5y agoI use trakt.tv; I think it had some coverage that justwatch lacked.
- twobitshifter 5y agoIt’s built into Roku, although I’m not sure how well they do but outside the USA at this
- errantspark 5y agoAs some guy once said, "Info wants to be free, but it also wants to be expensive" IP ownership as it exists today is fundamentally broken from the underlying reality. We need a culture where coming up with something new is compensated fairly but at the same time recognizes that the cost of sharing info is next to nil and we're all being held back from a global optimum by pretending otherwise.
- criddell 5y ago"Info wants to be free, but it also wants to be expensive" Isn't that one of the things the NFT people are working on?
- errantspark 5y agoI was mostly quoting it to reference it's context. The full quote (by Stewart Brand) is: “On the one hand information wants to be expensive, because it's so valuable. The right information in the right place just changes your life. On the other hand, information wants to be free, because the cost of getting it out is getting lower and lower all the time. So you have these two fighting against each other.” So yes, NFTs are absolutely one of the myriad of (stupid) ways we're trying to grapple with this conflict as a society.
- elzbardico 5y agoI see no reason why I should not have control upon music that I wrote or performed. I do it for free for friends because I am not that good of a musician. But what makes you get the right to decide about My content?
- danpalmer 5y agoBundling up products/services/value is a classic business technique. It's easy to sell customers on one low monthly price. Also, Unbundling products/services/value is a classic business technique. It's easy to make money on providing one specific service for a small fraction of the bundled price. These two forces happen in cycles, and streaming video is going through an unbundling phase right now.
- beardyw 5y agoNetflix seem to have got pretty needy. I got 18 emails begging for me to come back since October. So their cheery "cancel any time" was said through clenched teeth. It would be fantastic to have a Spotify type service for films. In fact I would pay proper money to just have access to all stuff over say 10 years old. I suspect it will never happen. Music has been a commodity to take home for over 100 years. Video 50 years, so just another 50 years to go.
- dasil003 5y agoThis article and a lot of comments here don't understand the business reasons why this happening. Everyone rings their hands and says why can't we just have everything in one place for a "reasonable" price like Spotify? Well first of all, Spotify is no panacea, artists and labels don't really like it but they have no choice because they need distribution in order to sell albums/concert tickets. Even the largest artists like Taylor Swift who has protested against low Spotify royalties only temporarily took some material off Spotify, and ended up putting it back because in the end she looks like the bad guy to her fans if they can't stream her on Spotify like everything else they listen to. Netflix was originally hoping to corner the market in a similar way, and they had a good first step with the Starz deal in 2008. However video is different and those rightsholders had full view of what happened in the music industry, so they were not about to make the mistake of ceding all power to a middle man. By the time Starz deal expired in 2012 it was clear that Netflix could never get all content because rightsholders would not let it happen. Similarly, the industry realized they need their own distribution. So Netflix and HBO entered a race to become each other. Since then the technology has only commodified which has allowed more rightsholders to get into the game. Is this bad for consumers? Sure, but "the industry" is not a monolithic entity, and they certainly will do everything it takes to avoid becoming dependent on a single distributor with too much power like Spotify. It doesn't matter how many angry nerds complain on the internet, these companies will continue acting in their own self-interest, and the market carrying capacity for streaming services is probably way higher than most consumers want to admit. The only thing that will turn this around is by services dying because people don't pay for them, and I don't see that happening any time soon.
- naasking 5y ago> Even the largest artists like Taylor Swift who has protested against low Spotify royalties only temporarily took some material off Spotify, and ended up putting it back because in the end she looks like the bad guy to her fans if they can't stream her on Spotify like everything else they listen to. Artists probably need to stop seeing royalties as a viable income stream and instead see it as publicity for their tours where they actually make money.
- 5y ago
- ThatMedicIsASpy 5y agoOnce they solve the terrible quality that streaming is sure. If you have invested into your audio/video setup (9.2 surround) streaming offers terrible bitrates (especially audio). Netflix is terrible for your home cinema - it means their shows will not come out on BluRay.
- newaccount74 5y agoAnother problem with streaming services is that their software is really bad. On the one hand there are obvious bugs: - Amazon Prime shows a cryptic DRM error on Windows and I have no idea how to fix it - Apple TV interface stutters and is close to unusable on a 2015 Macbook Pro - Disney+ is unusable on a touch screen in Edge on Windows because trying to scroll titles left and right triggers back/forward navigation - Disney+ has a memory leak in Safari on Catalina that causes Safari to kill the tab after two hours or so - Netflix on Windows has poor A/V sync with Bluetooth headphones and no way to adjust it And then there's the usability issues. No streaming platform has good search or a simple list where I can look at what's available. They all just try to overwhelm you with thumbnails and hope you forgot what you searched for and just watch something else instead. I see why people still pirate stuff.
- btmiller 5y agoWhile I’m in the doesn’t-mind-paying-for-multiple-subscriptions camp, I do feel like we’ve been here already and it was super clear to see that once all content was natively digital that we’d regress back literally to what we already had with channel bundles over cable. Seems most likely to me that it’s simply a newer generation of minds reencountering things the previous generation already experienced.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Mindwipe 5y agoThe notion all AV content should be in one place strikes me as rather incongruous with the widespread opinion on HN that all text content trending to Facebook and Twitter rather than a million blogs has been a disaster. FWIW, I don't think all video should be on one service. I think that would be actively bad.
- Mindwipe 5y agoThe film industry solved unauthorised downloads? Hasn't Glyn Moody been claiming that it's still a huge issue due to DRM for a decade? I can't think why nobody takes him seriously.
- iso1631 5y agoStar Trek Discovery Season 4 was released only in the US and Canada, unlike the previous 3 seasons. Thus it was impossible to watch it in the UK, so out comes the torrent client. It is now available for purchase on itunes, which I assume I can play on my TV either via the apple tv app, or via airplay, so that's fine, and I paid for it, no need to torrent. At least for those of us in the UK. In the majority of countries though it's still not available. If your company is unwilling to sell the content, you can't complain about people getting it from other sources.
- captainbland 5y agoNot forgetting though that Picard came out on Prime after Discovery and most of the rest of Star Trek being featured on Netflix. How many streaming services are we supposed to sign up for to follow one franchise? Nevermind the lack of availability in the UK, this situation is nonsense, they're practically begging us to start pirating their stuff.
- iso1631 5y agoI'm old enough to remember when people wanted to unbundle their viewing from ridiculous cable tv packages. We got that, and now people are complaining. The key problem here is the lack of availability (still) in 150+ countries that could watch it before. The cost is a separate matter
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y ago> Thus it was impossible to watch it in the UK Based on the first three seasons, I believe the UK is being done a favor.
- criddell 5y agoPerhaps it isn't a question of will but rather a question of rights. For example, perhaps the musicians who played on the Star Trek series had a contract that only covered the US and Canada and any further distribution required a separate agreement? The studio could have negotiated from the start for global rights but maybe the money wasn't there and the show wouldn't have been made otherwise?
- thrawa163794261 5y agoI have no problem paying a "reasonable" amount for content, I've had plenty of paid accounts to multiple services. I've given up keeping up. The combination of Radarr + Sonarr + Plex or Jellyfin + Sabnzbd + a Usenet account @ ~$10/month is too good. I have immediate access to all new content, automatically downloaded as well as a back catalog that is more complete than I can get from any set of streaming services. The local interface is excellent, discovery is good. No ads and I can access the content from anywhere in the world from any device. Even if I was willing to pay for every subscription I needed to access the same content, I would still consume it with this stack, the experience is too good. A subscription to each of the top 10[a] streaming services is ~$85/month (~$1020/yr!), that still includes some ads! At some point someone out of APAC is going to start selling a device with a large drive and the stack ^^^ bundled with a Usenet subscription (if there isn't one yet). That will remove the complexity and mainstream this type of piracy. I don't know how the industry is going to solve this, I know they need to before they go the way of paid adult content. [a] https://screenrant.com/ten-most-popular-streaming-services-ranked-subscriber-numbers/ https://screenrant.com/ten-most-popular-streaming-services-r.... I chose the least expensive ad-free option for each service. For Amazon Prime Video I used 1/3 of the $12.99/month cost, $4.33.
- winternett 5y agoThe way they pay creators and actors is appalling. Spotify although they charge $10 for a monthly subscription, the musician that made the music only gets .000000000001 of a penny per stream. The same is being one to film makers, actors and studios. People also normally encounter regional restrictions on content that they find on the web and don't want to register a whole month of service (on another site they have to log into) when they only want to watch one single show on a platform. That's just a few reasons why piracy is still present. Give it until next year and they'll slowly start rolling commercials and ads into paid for monthly subscriptions permanently as well. We're cows, carefully primed for "$ milking" by big industry really.
- peapicker 5y agoI get .03 to .05 of a penny per stream on Spotify for my music, depending on factors I don’t understand. So $3 to $5 per thousand streams. Still not great but not as dismal as you put it. I have one very successful friend who gets about 1.2 million streams a year on Spotify. He works usually with two collaborators so the ~$50,000 he makes per year on Spotify is split three ways before income taxes. Of course he also is on other platforms too.
- winternett 5y agoIt's better to be a Spotify shareholder than to be a musician publishing to the platform. That's where we are now... I'm also baffled that Spotify does not grant verified/accomplished contributors to the platform free accounts by default. I wouldn't be surprised if a huge percentage of their premium listeners are the very same people who publish their music to the platform. The Internet unfortunately is quickly becoming a "scam-based economy". It's flooding out all the potential it once had. I just decided to create and focus on my own personal music label web site moving forward. If I'm going to give most of my music away for pennies, I'd rather have more meaningful and useful analytics and FAR less complication in publishing my own music. :/
- kataklasm 5y agoThat math doesn't add up. If a single stream makes (0.04×0.01) dollars or 4% of $0.01 on average, thats $0.004 per stream. If your friend has 1.2M streams a year, that's $4800 in payout per year. Can you elaborate please?
- haunter 5y agoAs an EU citizen I also have to say the Digital Single Market [1] was a good idea but bad in execution. I work at a video game publisher and you can see that in prices where people in Bulgaria, Croatia, Hungary etc. have to pay the same price as people in Sweden, Finland, Denmark etc. You can't discriminate positively, so all the new AAA games ended up 60€. So of course in poorer countries the piracy is higher EVEN THOUGH people would be willing to buy it but regional pricing is basically outlawed for the European Union. iirc Valve/Steam also had some problems with this in the past, they used to have different prices for EU countries but they had to stop that. We can set prices lower for CIS countries, or say Moldova, Turkey etc. but not for EU. 1, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_Single_Market https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_Single_Market
- flipbrad 5y agoTo be absolutely clear: as I understand it, the law you're talking about currently doesn't apply to media content, including digital games. From the official FAQ to that law: "For online services related to non-audiovisual works protected by copyright (such as e-books, video games, music and software), the non-discrimination provision – i.e. the obligation to allow foreign customers to access and benefit from the same offers as local customers – does not apply under the Regulation." Also, the law prevents you from blocking or charging customers to customers accessing your service from an EU country different from the one in which you're established. So in your example, you could set the price as low as you like for Bulgarians, you just can't block Swedish people from visiting your games store online, or try to charge that Swedish person more.
- amne 5y agoVoice telecom operators have this all figured out. Companies exist to function as interconnection hubs only and are very successful at it. Billing systems (mostly built on RADIUS) keep track behind the scenes of every second of voice call routed through these companies. All it took was a regulating agency to force the telecom operators to open up and allow 3rd parties to interconnect to provide their own voice service and/or act as hubs. And all of that at regulated prices per minute. So let's say you subscribe to Voiceflix for 5$/month but want to "call" Game of Towers which has a different techprefix so you're routed outside your network at a (hopefully reasonable) cost. Initially it will be expensive (remember the prices in early '00 per minute of voice call?) but eventually it will come down to earth. So now you have two types of entities: - content storage: tries to get as much exclusive content but for overlapping content tries to "bid" the lowest price so it gets the traffic. - hubs that want to take your money and stream from content storage services and don't care which one has the content as long as it is within profit margin the user can stream it.
- bircherr 5y agoReading this triggered some good nostalgic memories of the time when pirating video content was a bit of a game to see who could amass the best (ie early release non cam) collection. Back in the late 90s I hosted a FTP dump site on an OC3…and it was a constant effort to keep up with evolving sources mIRC, CuteMX, Filetopia, Limewire, eDonkey, etc. Eventually I had something like 1000 movies but actually watched only a handful. Haha. Anyways, agree with the author that pirates are motivated by the “fun” of it - and it is a hobby for many.
- richardfey 5y agoThese streaming services will disappear. You should just buy directly from the distributor and pay as you go. Want 1.5h of WB entertainment? Here's your 0.8$ invoice.
- Damogran6 5y agoAvatar: Bought 4 tickets in 2009, Bought DVD and BluRay version (that are still in my closet) Wanted to watch it last week in the background while I worked. $3 everywhere. You got my money, I’ll watch it when it’s on TNT, or SyFy, or whatever on dish network. I’m not paying $3 to rent it again. This article is spot on. We pay for Prime (can’t peel out the movies), We get HBOMax with our cellphone package(?), can’t peel it out if we need tethering…pay for netflix and Disney+ So I’m ALREADY paying, easily $135 a month. I’m done. You want me to go back to NOT paying that much, we can do without, because it doesn’t feel like I’m getting nearly $5 a day in value out of it…
- dang 5y agoUrl changed from https://walledculture.org/the-film-industry-effectively-solved-the-problem-of-unauthorised-downloads-now-it-is-unsolving-it/ https://walledculture.org/the-film-industry-effectively-solv..., which points to this.
- nkrisc 5y agoI understand that in one sense, digital products can be infinitely reproduced, so it's not like someone is deprived of the product when it's pirated. What I can't reconcile is the entitlement that one deserves to be able to view a specific movie or TV show. I've often heard the argument that there's no harm done, because the pirate wouldn't pay to watch it anyway. Yet the only reason the show is there to pirate is because others are willing to pay for the privilege of viewing it. If everyone took the "pirate" attitude, then there simply wouldn't be any shows to pirate. Now in reality that seems unlikely to actually transpire, so there likely is no harm done. But why does the pirate deserve to watch for free? We're not talking about access to food or clean water. If I had no legal way to obtain food, I'd steal it in a heartbeat. If I can't find a legal way to watch the latest uninspired Star Wars spin-off, I'm just not going to watch it and do something else. I'm all for civil disobedience when warranted, but I have a hard time justifying it for watching a TV show.
- howinteresting 5y agoCulture is as much part of the human experience as food is. We should aspire towards the goal that all humans deserve to have access to our collective cultural output.
- prohobo 5y agoThey'd probably stop pirating if it caused film culture to collapse; whereas so far, the only agents currently destroying film culture are production/licensing companies like Disney. It's a social activity after all, and social currencies extend beyond money; ie. reputation, access and fairness. I'm not entirely well-versed in this, but from what I understand pirate money comes downstream from these social criteria. This is why certain platforms like Steam and Netflix work (or used to, in Netflix's case, while they still had a good reputation). Pirates have proven to be more than willing to pay for content when they consider it appropriate to do so (money going directly to the creator, superior access, etc.)
- nkrisc 5y ago> They'd probably stop pirating if it caused film culture to collapse; I doubt it. How many animals have been hunted to extinction even though the hunters’ livelihood depended upon those animals? The stakes are far lower here.
- ok123456 5y agoEVO: Thank you for your service.
- shadowgovt 5y agoIt's been fun watching the Trek fandom take a flying leap onto Pirate Bay in response to Paramount pulling the Trek content from Netflix internationally without offering Paramount+ in all those markets. ... And not just international viewers. US viewers with existing Paramount+ accounts started pirating Discovery in solidarity.
- wodenokoto 5y agoI actually find playpilot.com really useful for checking where to watch something. I wish they'd be more straight-to-the-point, and have fewer pop-ups, but on the plus side they have quite niche streaming services available and can filter availability by country, which is really nice. Their recommendation engine is laughably awful, and you can't do searches for things like director or studio, so it's not useful for discovery at all. But if a movie or series comes up in conversation, it's the best I've found.
- Oddskar 5y agoOne facet of this that rarely gets mentioned that I often experience since I live in the EU is subtitle and audio availability is teeerrible for most of the streaming services. Amazon Prime is unusable because the vast majority of movies that they have is all dubbed and do not provide original audio nor english subtitles. I do not pay money to watch a movie get distorted by dubbed audio. No thank you. Same goes for a lot of movies on Netflix, although they are way better than Prime.
- nabla9 5y agoI have free Apple TV+ with new iPhone and I still download torrents from their films into my Linux to watch. Streaming is new tech using old business model.
- Epiphany21 5y agoMy opinion is that streaming services are a terrible value and automatic recurring charges from subscriptions are a huge headache to manage. I'm in a sort of financial catch-22 as a young adult, where I can only now afford these frivolous services because I saved my disposable income instead of squandering it on 20 different subscriptions to begin with. So why even start?