11 ms·
I became the internet’s most notorious bike thief
- lr1970 5y agoMy anti-theft device is my Brompton foldable bike. It folds down to a small package in 10 seconds and I take it with me anywhere I go including buses, trains, etc. It came with a nice black zipper cover. One cannot see that there is a bike inside. This helps with some pesky ticket masters on trains.
- walrus01 5y agosee also: bike thief 2012 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UGttmR2DTY8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UGttmR2DTY8
- kQq9oHeAz6wLLS 5y agoI was hoping your link was Freezepop https://youtu.be/W3eLl3pQGoY https://youtu.be/W3eLl3pQGoY
- claviska 5y ago> And the irony, of course, is this: the pictured bike itself was never stolen, but the rushed magazine photo has been – by hundreds of people, perpetuating a fake crime over and over. At what point (if ever) would using a photo like this fall under fair use? The author doesn’t seem to care, but I’m curious if copyright is ever forfeited due to widespread use or inaction of the copyright holder.
- ThunderSizzle 5y agoMy understanding is that copyright is only honored by the legal system if it's been enforced by the copyright holder. If the copyright holder knows its being used, and doesn't attempt to enforce copyright rights, but after a decade or similar, changes mind and starts enforcing, the court might rule that copyright is no longer enforceable.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Nursie 5y agoI don't believe one is required to defend copyright. Trademarks, certainly, but not copyright.
- nash 5y agoNever is the simple answer. Otherwise all copyright would have pretty much been eliminated by the pirate bay. Enforcement and collection of the damages is a totally different issue.
- jeroenhd 5y agoIn the US, the picture would become public domain 70 years after the death of the author. As for fair use: if you were to criticise something related to the image (say, you make a whole youtube video criticising the blog posts on this website and this image scrolls by when you do a quick lookaround on the website) or make some kind of transformative art out of it and the author would sue under DMCA or similar and the lawsuit would be based on US law, fair use would probably apply. Fair use is a defence to use in a lawsuit, after all, not a right, but you can definitely do things with this picture that would be defensible under fair use. Companies specialising in copyright would probably try to convince you to avoid a lawsuit and come to a mutually beneficial agreement before the thing is settled, though, because big media companies do not like it when copyright law and things like fair use get defined (and thus consumer rights may be gained, and the excessive wealth of the media industry might get dented). What the pirate bay did could never really be construed as fair use. At best, they can claim to simply host links, no content, and should not be held accountable for the illegal behaviour of the users and searching clicking said links, just like normal service providers. That's not an exemption in copyright law, though.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Fair use is a defence to use in a lawsuit, after all, not a right The statutory fair use defense codifies a Constitutional (First Amendment) limit on the copyright power found by the courts prior to the existence of the statutory defense, so it is both a defense and a right, specifically, the Constitutional right of free speech. Lawsuit defenses, more generally, are assertions of rights, whether statutory, common law, or Constitutional.
- toast0 5y agoUsing a photo like this in an article about how photos are used without permission is probably fair use. Using a photo like this as part of your article on bike theft without permission is probably not fair use.
- boomboomsubban 5y agoThe now defunct magazine presumably held the copyright, and it's entirely possible the licensed the rights to a third party.
- usrusr 5y agoGiven bankruptcy law, how much choice would they even have?
- lozenge 5y agoNo, copyright isn't forfeited like that, only trademarks are. It fails this part of fair use: 'The purpose and character of the use, including whether such use is of commercial nature or is for nonprofit educational purposes. Courts typically focus on whether the use is “transformative.” That is, whether it adds new expression or meaning to the original, or whether it merely copies from the original.'
- mindslight 5y ago> No, copyright isn't forfeited like that Taking a step back, why not? Even (especially) real estate gets forfeited like that. It seems like the mp3s I've had for 20 years should fall under adverse possession. Or if you'd like a higher bar for openly possessed, then torrents have that have been publicly seeded for multiple decades.
- franciscop 5y agoNote that the article author represented in the images seems not to be the author of the images themselves. AND since it was done for a company in all likehood neither the person represented in the image nor the person taking the picture hold the copyright of the picture (since it's a different person and not the author with a tripod as implied in the article).
- wpasc 5y agoI think it makes more sense than the author expects. Bike thefts probably are not frequently caught with a high wuality camera, still pose, proper lighting, photogenically bland clothing choice, etc. such that it seems like a stock photo for bike theft. Only another purposeful photo of bike theft that is similarly or moreso staged should outdo it, but for general purpose image use (like a powerpoint or something) the photo kind of makes sense as a popular choice.
- charlieyu1 5y agoBuying a stock photo for commercial use costs like $0.3 each if you are buying in bulk, which I assume that’s how it should work for a media company.
- severak_cz 5y agoAuthor of this article simply made very good photo of bicycle theft.
- javajosh 5y agoAs a father, I would be mildly concerned about this notoriety, especially as a traveler. Airport authorities are not known for the subtlety of their understanding, and it is entirely plausible that this man might be arrested and jailed on the basis of not only being photographed committing a crime, but now admitting to it, calling himself a thief. Yes, this would be preposterous, wrong, and I might go so far as to call it evil. Certainly stupid. But can you really say it can't happen? Would it surprise you if it happened in the US, or that rather than apologize and reverse the injustice that it would be ignored or worse, jumped on by conspiracy theorists and an even harsher penalty applied? To live in a post-evidence world is to live in a world of chaos and terror where light-hearted online banter can and will be used against you. You laugh now, and say it couldn't possibly happen? Well, wait.
- sergers 5y agoHe was not photographed committing a crime. They framed a shot, akin to acting, and no bike was stolen. The author clearly outlines this point that nothing was stolen. If the author showed his face, showing a clear resemblance, I could see notoriety possibly raise some eyebrows being the same guy as the bike thief stock photo... But that's a very far fetched possibility. Unless the guy was convicted of a crime, with a criminal record, then maybe have some issues... But this instance maybe take off the tinfoil
- javajosh 5y agoThis is an expression of contempt for authority, and is not a criticism of the OP. The fear I recommend is not tinfoil hat stuff, it's just an unfortunate byproduct of broken minds running a broken justice system. You should also know that posting on a forum with "hacker" in the title is dangerous.
- dpifke 5y agoAre you also arguing it's "dangerous" for Michael Hall (aka notorious serial killer Dexter Morgan) to walk through an airport?
- jackvalentine 5y agoTo me this story is about how garbage most illustrative imagery on the internet is.
- dustintrex 5y agoWhy? Virtually all stock photography involving people is staged, and that's OK, because they're meant to be just that, illustrations.
- jackvalentine 5y agoThey are all so light in relevance that the content would be better if there were no imagery at all. None of these articles are improved by having a stolen staged image of a bike thief in them. Might as well draw a picture of a bike in MS paint. Same effect.
- GuB-42 5y agoI think that a picture is easier to get at first glance than the words. Let's pick an article at random: "End of UK lockdown may mean a rise in bike thefts". You most likely need a few seconds to read and understand that the main topic of the article is bike theft and start to visualize it. I mean, chances that you start reading the title and think "it is about covid" and as you read the end, you think "no, it is about bike theft". Put a really obvious and staged picture of someone stealing a bike and you instantly get it. Kind of the same reason why we put icons next to text in software UI, even though it is redundant.
- jackvalentine 5y agoI understand what you’re saying but perhaps the reader should be required to put the effort in to read 11 words rather than seeing a shorthand and jumping to conclusion!
- GuB-42 5y ago
- squarefoot 5y agoJust one more reminder that when one puts something online, it stays there forever. The innocent photo of someone in his 20s dancing naked while drunk at a party that today could award him bonus social points among peers, would destroy his political career 30 years later.
- _-david-_ 5y ago>The innocent photo of someone in his 20s dancing naked while drunk at a party that today could award him bonus social points among peers, would destroy his political career 30 years later We have a politician in either blackface or KKK outfit. I don't think dancing naked at a party is enough.
- varjag 5y agoOK make it a 'her'.
- hellbannedguy 5y agoThat's why we should post nothing. Yes--absolutely nothing, and tell everyone who has your picture in an album, or digital, about your aversion to pictures, and posting. Idea for a tee shirt. Front: Don't take a pic of my mug. (You can't say "picture of me" because they will think you are a narcissist, or egotistical. Back: And never post my mug to the internet, and that you includes grandma. Although I love you!
- ThePhysicist 5y agoSlightly off topic, but I think bike thieves are becoming more and more professional recently. Here in Berlin many now use small cordless screwdrivers with a custom gearing mechanism that operates a bolt-cutter. With that they can even cut through thick steel-bar type bike locks in a few seconds, without making any noise. I saw that in a police report lately but I can't find a link with a photo of the device now, unfortunately. It's really quite ingenious from a technical point of view. It seems the only way to protect against theft is to ride an old bicycle.
- executesorder66 5y ago> cordless screwdrivers Do screwdrivers typically have cords? And if so, what for?
- xenonite 5y agoI guess a cord protects a screwdriver from being stolen.
- namdnay 5y agoProbably not a native English speaker. They mean a cordless driver/drill
- nathanm412 5y agoElectric screwdrivers with not much more torque than a human hand can apply are pretty common and small. They spin much faster than I can turn a screwdriver and stop before they can strip any screw. With the right gearing and modification, I can see one easily cut through a bike lock. https://duckduckgo.com/?t=ffab&q=cordless+screwdriver&iax=shopping&ia=shopping https://duckduckgo.com/?t=ffab&q=cordless+screwdriver&iax=sh...
- aigo 5y agoWe have had this level of professionalism in London for some time now. It's not necessarily true that you must ride an older, uglier bike, though this will work. All that is needed is to be the least stealable bicycle in the rack. In my case this means two locks of different kinds. It's a big deterrent and they will move on to other, easier targets. If you can avoid being the lowest hanging fruit, you will probably be alright.
- ddmma 5y agoThe advantage of stealing bikes are that have big value and lowest return rate from police or recovery. Had a project of bottom bracket IoT so peddaling could blocked but wasn’t feasable.
- bambax 5y agoThis is reminiscent of another story about images: https://www.hanselman.com/blog/there-is-only-one-cloud-icon-in-the-entire-universe https://www.hanselman.com/blog/there-is-only-one-cloud-icon-... If an image works then people will copy it at nauseam.
- Gravityloss 5y agoI wonder why people are obsessed with image copying. It has lead to the invention of writing for example. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Egyptian_hieroglyphs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Egyptian_hieroglyphs Maybe it provided some evolutionary advantage already at a really primitive form. For example maybe people were drawing hunting plans on sand?
- shever73 5y agoA similar thing happened to one of my photos from Flickr. It was of a riverbed dried up in the Kenyan drought. Someone messaged me to ask permission to use it in a project and since then, it has appeared in news articles everywhere - mostly without attribution - and with the location varying from a selection of African countries to California and lots of places in between.
- franciscop 5y agoI find it sweetly ironic that ALL those magazines talking about stealing bikes are committing copyright infringement (which the media is used to call "stealing").
- manquer 5y agoMore likely the picture was added to stock photo library (illegally maybe) and they all use from there.
- zamadatix 5y agoAt the same time they'd probably find it a sweetly ironic show of how it's too hard to control copyrighted material on the internet or something for. After all like the article says it probably wasn't intentionally ripped or any claims avoided it more likely ended up in a stock photo site with the wrong license attached and the author never pursued it.
- markstos 5y agoOr you upload some photos to Unsplash. My bike photos there have been viewed about 2.5 million times on the site and downloaded over 1,000 times, findable on many sites around the world. Publishing the photos on Flickr doesn’t hold a torch to the exposure from Unsplash!