18 ms·
What if you invert your thesis. Sooner doesn’t necessarily imply “higher standard”: 1 - American school teach the alphabet before grade 1, and push kids to re
by gumby 5y ago
What if you invert your thesis. Sooner doesn’t necessarily imply “higher standard”:
1 - American school teach the alphabet before grade 1, and push kids to read early. German schools don’t even teach the alphabet until grade 1' yet by the end of that year the reading level of the kids is the same as US kids at the end of grade 1, or better. German Pädagogin justify this by saying there is some neural development issue — I think that is likely bull. But what I do recognize is that instead of being pushed to read before the kids are ready, the kids instead learn other valuable life skills. I happened to learn to read at age 5 (not in Germany nor USA) but that didn’t make me “better” than other kids; they did other things.
2 - kids who have parents who can afford tutors and such can push the kids through the prescribed steps sooner. Kids whose parents each have two jobs to get food on the table, well, they simply can’t. So the former define “higher standards” because they chose their parents well?
3 - To combine the two: if we can open up opportunities for all the kids aren’t we likely to end up with a larger pool of well educated people who will end up being the inventors, leaders, poets etc of the future? How many ramanujans are we leaving behind?
I’m not saying “throw out all the standards” but rather quite the opposite. I think your unidimensional absolutism is narrow and inadequate.
- watwut 5y ago> German Pädagogin justify this by saying there is some neural development issue — I think that is likely bull. Why would that be bull? Kids brains develops over time.
- gumby 5y agoGood question: I should not have phrased it that way at all. I mean there isn’t a sharp delineation that magically happens; there are n factors (some large, unknown number) each of which develop at a slightly different rate in each child; there’s nothing magic about reaching 6. My opinion might reflect an accidentally rigid expression of this when my own kid was 6. Thanks for your comment!
- Hitton 5y agoad 1) that's caused simply by phonemic orthography of German. English orthography is hell compared to that, it's not surprising that they need to start to learn it earlier.
- dathinab 5y agoUhm, are you sure. I multiple times heard from exchange students that the standard of the English curses they had in the US hand been below the standard of the English cursed they had Germany...
- leereeves 5y agoWealthy parents will still define higher standards, because they will send their kids to private schools where more advanced math is taught (e.g. Phillips Exeter Academy teaches calculus to all students and offers linear algebra, statistics, and discrete math to advanced students.[1]). Instead of opening up opportunities for all the kids, this will ensure that no poor student can compete because the courses won't even be available. 1: https://www.exeter.edu/mathematics-beyond-core-courses https://www.exeter.edu/mathematics-beyond-core-courses
- RhodesianHunter 5y agoMy crappy public highschool had calculus, it was just called AP.
- tylerhou 5y agoAs someone who went to Exeter and did higher-level math there, you didn't have to even start calculus in order to graduate. Also, the calculus taught there is roughly the same level as a decent public school. And you can probably get the same level of education at a local college. After retaking calculus at Berkeley (which I admit is not exactly a local college), IMO they teach it here more rigorously (e.g. they introduce epsilon-delta fairly early, and they are precise about details like domains of functions, etc.) The real place where Exeter shines is for competition math and for second/third year college math courses. But most of the people who seriously study competition math there have a strong math background to begin with, so I find it unlikely that someone who is inexperienced in math would actually pick up competition math as the culture is intimidating. Also, very few students take second/third year college math. When I was there, they offered one term of topology and one term of real analysis. Each of these classes had one section of ~10 people. But in all honestly, only a few students in the class actually were mature enough to understand most of that material. Even though I was on the stronger side of students, I don't think I internalized the material at all. I'm honestly really skeptical of pushing students to learn more and more "advanced" material because getting good at math isn't about being able to memorize mechanical rules for derivatives or integrals. Learning math should be about learning the process of discovery -- playing around with problems until you are able to tease out some insight or a solution. The skill of "distilling" a problem to its essence is one that has served me much more usefully than being able to find an integral.
- polaris_mars 5y agoIt is so ironic that you mention Germany,where kids are split (at age 10, 12?) into hauptschule (lower ability), realschule (medium ability), and gymnasium (higher ability). To think ramanujans of this world would benefit from lower standards is also having no idea or never knowing one in real life.
- dathinab 5y agoThe system you refer to is and in many regions had been phased out as it turns out that the splitting around 6th grade isn't really working well. Also even before you had schools which covered multiple of this schools and allow students to "move" between them, sometimes in a per-course level. There also always had been ways to get the same degree as from a gymnasium even if you initially ended up on a hauptshule, through it was a often shitty path and potentially took you a bit longer. While a few people which state out in a realschole doing it was the norm, for people on a hauptschule it was very very very unlikely. Don't get me wrong the German school system is a mess, especially if composed to some of the Nordic states but it still beats the US.
- zozbot234 5y agoThe problem with that sort of tracking is that no one wants to be stuck teaching kids with "medium" and "low" skills. So these kids are going to get matched to the worst, lowest skilled teachers, and no chance of realistically getting back on the "high" track! You can of course fix that by rewarding the best teachers and training them better in effective instruction methods (i.e. nope, the kids aren't going to just "learn stuff on their own"!) but guess what, both of these are political anathema in the public schooling system. Especially in the U.S.
- fxtentacle 5y agoNo. You can take a course to upgrade from middle to high tier after the fact. A friend of mine did the middle track first and after working a bit he then went on to university. He's now doing AI programming. The system is quite fluid if you put in some effort.
- djsbs 5y agoI learned how to read in Spanish, and very shortly thereafter I moved to an English country. Totally different. You just cant compare a phonetic language to one like English. My daughter is now learning how to read in the best school in my city and its taking her over year compared to me. We started at roughly the same age, but she and her classmates are struggling through hours of practice. “Thats a sharp e honey” “That letter is silent, baby” “You’ll never sound that out, that words just messed up” EDIT - punctuation and mistypes
- gumby 5y agoMy kid’s school had them start English in grade 1, learning both languages in parallel, with English being complete immersion (not a word of German spoken and even in a couple of cases hiring teachers who spoke no German). The kids learned both languages at the same rate. My story is just anecdote, not science, of course, as is yours. I noticed that a number of the German parents had the same concerns as you, because they expected the spelling to be more phonetic. German orthography, like Spanish’s has changed over time to match pronunciation shifts. English does not. As a result English words often hold their roots. The trade off is that you may not knownthe pronunciation of an unfamiliar word but may be able to figure out its meaning. As with all languages, in the end none is “harder” than the other despite folklore: sharp corners are always being knocked off because the tool is so important and in continuous use. In the most recent German spelling reform, the authors were concerned about this trade off. Another way to describe it: you can’t approach writing c++ as if it were Java, and vice versa. Quite similar, yet quite different.
- djsbs 5y agoIm not at all surprised that they learned at the same rate. Their English reading was bootstrapped by the German. Likewise, I could mostly read English when I arrived in the new country despite not being able to say or understand a single word. This is because English is, maybe, 75% phonetic and I had already figured reading out. Reading is not just memorizing characters and phonemes, but being able to join everything into a fluid mental motion. In english, practice of their fluidity is constantly being interrupted by an adult having to tell the kid which sound variation a vowel has
- xyzzy21 5y agoExactly. The thing is that you have to adjust curriculum to the developmental stage of the INDIVIDUAL child. Teaching someone too early only wastes the time, resources and money of that teaching. Too late and you lose future options. I didn't learn to read until 1st grade but many of my peers learned in kindergarten. Individuals do NOT all reach the same learning readiness phase at the same time or same age (two different things). BTW this "teacher's credential 101". Systems like Montessori focus on this dynamic and thus have fairly open-ended schedules for things. Falling behind is defined by not meeting ANY learning goals but being on schedule is meeting enough learning goals. Naturally customization of education like this does not fit well into a "School as a Factory; Child as a manufactured Part" model or the efficiency metrics that factories typically have that are similarly applied to public schools in the US (standardized testing is akin to process control; you do want some type of testing but it has to be structured with more nuance because children are not factory parts with narrow distributions of variance). At this point, home schooling probably can't be worse. But more focus on customization of education is pretty essential. US Schools are 80%-90% focused on the bottom 10%-20% of IQ based on actual school budgets and funding. And for those not in that bottom group, it's all 100% uniformity and low budgets. One size can never fit all.
- Retric 5y agoPart of this is simply a function of specialization. Teaching high school let alone first grade to an extremely high academic standard doesn’t actually achieve anything significant for society. It’s arguably much better to give kids reasonable minimum standards and plenty of free time and the capacity to explore their interests. This avoids burnout and generally keeps people interested in their passions rather than simply getting through the slog. On the other hand getting as many people as possible especially those with developmental issues to a minimum standard allows them to function in society. That pays real long term dividends and is worth significant investment.
- pclmulqdq 5y agoWhat if the students are interested in learning a subject to a high academic standard and will be bored otherwise? I was getting lower grades at my easy "teach to the bottom 10%" public school than the very difficult private school I moved to. By just dismissing academic rigor, you are alienating the high-performers who WANT to care. That's a bad group of people for a society to ignore.
- syshum 5y agoThe German System is also groups children based on their performance, not their age That is the largest problem with American schooling, is we try to keep all kids in a chronological age based system, instead of a skills based system.
- cs702 5y agoYour comment changed my mind about the debate in California: > Sooner doesn’t necessarily imply “higher standard” To be clear: I don't know enough detail about the proposal in California to judge it, but the idea that most children might be better off learning certain subjects at a later age, when they are more mature, cannot be dismissed a priori, without facts, based on ideological arguments. Your comment reminds me of this passage from an old article about Finland's educational system, widely considered to be one of the best in the world: > Children [in Finland] spend far more time playing outside, even in the depths of winter. Homework is minimal. Compulsory schooling does not begin until age 7. “We have no hurry,” said Louhivuori [a Finnish teacher]. “Children learn better when they are ready. Why stress them out?” Text in brackets is mine. I highly recommend reading the whole article: https://www.smithsonianmag.com/innovation/why-are-finlands-schools-successful-49859555/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/innovation/why-are-finlands-s...
- secondaryacct 5y agoHave you met a Finnish person? They are introspect to the point of being unable to take part in a conflict, care more about their individual peace than any collective construct. Best in the world ? If you want muted isolated adult, probably.
- sitkack 5y agoIf what you say is true, you haven't shown a link between Finnish schooling and their adult behavior. Your comment does not follow.
- naasking 5y agoNone of those claims necessarily imply they are not more educated and better off.
- scotty79 5y agoHonestly this sounds like absolutely wonderful qualities I wished more people in the world had. Nothing screwed us more than willingness of people to take part in conflicts. Imagine how much harm and waste could be avoided if when generals daid, let's go liberate Afghanistan soldiers responded, nah, I'm good rather then collectively following ideas of imaginary Uncle Sam.
- hdjjhhvvhga 5y ago> I happened to learn to read at age 5 (not in Germany nor USA) but that didn’t make me “better” than other kids; they did other things. My experience is the opposite. Because I learned to read early, I was able to absorb a huge amount of information previously inaccessible to me. There was simply no comparison - I was far better in every subject that required either knowing some information or processing it. The only exceptions were the subjects where body skill was important (art, PE, etc.) - in these areas I had some competition, I others there was nobody. I believe our chances balanced more or less in the second year of high school.
- officeplant 5y ago>2 - kids who have parents who can afford tutors and such can push the kids through the prescribed steps sooner. Personally I was lucky my dad was running a computer repair business from the 80's onward. Growing up with a computer and a mountain of pirated educational software prepped me more than anything else my parents could have done. They lucked out that I particularly enjoyed learning.
- CWuestefeld 5y agoTo combine the two: if we can open up opportunities for all the kids aren’t we likely to end up with... Well, maybe, but you're hiding a lot in that "if we can". You're assuming that this possibility is brought to fruition, and using the shiny abstract potential of that optimization to argue against real-world actual practices, and this is apples versus oranges. In fact, I have approximately zero confidence that your "if we can" could ever come to pass. Consider the crazy levels of funding that's already pumped into education with no discernible benefit, and the extremely powerful lobbies that work night and day to maintain the status quo (modulo the increases in funding). In a perfect world without competition for scarce resources we might be able to do what you envision. But starting the project from the current political realities, it's not in the realm of possibility. So let's not let the pipe dream interfere with some way to prevent the status quo from sliding down into even worse territory.
- KorematsuFredt 5y ago> kids who have parents who can afford tutors and such can push the kids through the prescribed steps sooner. Kids whose parents each have two jobs to get food on the table, well, they simply can’t. So the former define “higher standards” because they chose their parents well? Yes. Kids born in rich families will do better, kids born to better parents will do better and that is a good thing. A lot of scientific research in early years did not come from government funded labs but rich people working on their passions. Note that privileged people will define "higher standards" always no matter what laws you pass and how you twist the public education system. But these sort of social justice solutions damage the very poor people who cant afford kumon.
- godelski 5y agoIf you're going to compare America vs Germany I'm willing to bet you're going to run into Simpsons paradox.
- kolbe 5y ago1. userbinator was discussing the impact of exceptional people on society, and you're citing average behaviors of a people in one narrow educational sphere. Nikola Tesla has zero relationship with the middle of any curve. 2. Children are quite literally extensions of their parents. Their intelligence, beliefs, genetics, et cetera are a product of their nature (100% parental) and nurture (varies, but usually significantly attributed to their parents). Giving your child tutoring is no more cheating than when you pick up a book for yourself. Your children are you. 3. userbinator was in no way criticizing the opening up of opportunities to achieve equality by elevating all people to genius status. He, and most people here, are critical of handicapping the gifted/lucky/affluent/whatever in order to achieve parity at a lower level. The fact is it doesn't matter if you learn AI programming because you're so gifted the knowledge just flows into you easily, or if your parents spent $1mm a year teaching it to you. We need AI programmers, and having none because you thought it was unfair for people to get that education when others can't is nuts.
- complexmango 5y agoWe began algebra in 5th grade in India. In much humbler circumstances. Luckily, our teachers made it clear that math was about effort, not skills, talents, or parents. We were all expected to practice a lot of math, including algebra, until we figured it out. And it worked - the ‘gifted’ students needed less practice, everyone else needed more practice. But by 6th grade, everybody passed algebra and figured out the basics. By 9th grade, when we were doing pre-Calc, it was unthinkable that someone in our class couldn’t do algebra. Applying ‘Social Justice’ to math is simply the continued dumbing down of California. To what end, I can’t figure out.
- civilized 5y agoThis comment would make sense if the debate was over whether or not students should be forced to take algebra in 8th grade. But it's actually about whether students should be allowed to take algebra in 8th grade.