7 ms·
They don't have to value the company at $0 to fuck you over once you're gone. The current board can depreciate all of the shares by 50% and then issue themselve
by hinkley 5y ago
They don't have to value the company at $0 to fuck you over once you're gone. The current board can depreciate all of the shares by 50% and then issue themselves twice their original shares so they break even. Then do the same thing a couple of rounds later.
I haven't seen $0 but I knew a few people who got diluted to a joke. It doesn't take but a factor of 2-4 dilution of your outlook to drastically change your opinion of how you spent that time.
- jasode 5y ago>They don't have to value the company at $0 to fuck you over once you're gone. The current board can depreciate all of the shares by 50% and then issue themselves twice their original shares so they break even. Mark Zuckerberg tried a variation of that game to cut out Eduardo Saverin's shares when they changed the company from a Florida LLC to a Delaware Inc. Well, Saverin sued and Facebook lost that lawsuit; they settled. Saverin got ~4% ownership worth $5+ billion at the time. https://www.businessinsider.com/exclusive-heres-the-email-zuckerberg-sent-to-cut-his-cofounder-out-of-facebook-2012-5 https://www.businessinsider.com/exclusive-heres-the-email-zu...
- Kranar 5y agoFacebook did not lose any lawsuit. A settlement is a far cry from a loss and judging from the outcome, it looks like Saverin got screwed over. So basically, the board will try to screw you over; if you're not in a strong enough position to do something about it then you're out of luck, if you are strong enough to do something about it, then you might be able to recoup some of what you're entitled to.
- distribot 5y agoAnyone know how Zuckerberg avoided the same thing happening to him? Bezos was a 30 year old with a decade of experience in finance, I assume he was quite savvy. But Zuckerberg was a teen.
- djyaz1200 5y agoShawn Fanning
- andrewseanryan 5y agoPretty sure it was Sean Parker but I could be wrong
- dbuder 5y agoThey did it to others? They knew ownership and control was paramount and acted accordingly.
- tdfx 5y agoAs far as I can tell, Zuckerberg's true talent is being thrown into situations he has no life experience to handle and appropriately picking the right people to surround himself with and listen to.
- antoniuschan99 5y agoHow does one go about learning about these things. HN crowd definitely leans towards the technical side myself including. Btw. The blog is very informative and have subscribed.
- hinkley 5y ago> How does one go about learning about these things. A very good question that I don't have a good answer to. Management likes that there's a steady stream of new people who don't know that there's a bunch of tricks that get used and so everyone learns them the hard way.
- low_common 5y agoHow does share dilution work? Does that mean issuing more shares? How does depreciating shares happen?
- hinkley 5y agoIt's not a publicly traded company so the paper is worth exactly as much as the people who hold most of the paper decide it's worth. They need some sort of majority to vote to change the rules, and since the employees with unexercised shares control exactly 0.0 repeating percent of the company, you're going to lose that vote. It's a democracy where the wolves vote that the sheep will be dinner.
- gnopgnip 5y agoThe board and officers still have a fiduciary duty to minority share holders. Even if they can vote the company is worth zero and issue 100x as many shares, a court can say the company wasn't worth zero and they need to compensate the former owner.
- ganeumann 5y agoWhile this is theoretically true, I think you would be hard-pressed to find an example of someone suing and winning.
- jacquesm 5y agoI know of several such cases, but it's costly, and usually a good idea to decide whether or not you want to pursue something like this involves the cost (and stress) of a lawsuit over an extended period of time, and to ensure that that is outweighed by the upside of winning the case.
- MagnumOpus 5y agoHard pressed? Ed Saverin is a very well known case. He sued Facebook after his co-founder Zuckerberg diluted him out and settled for multiple billions. But then, it was a unusually straightforward case because Zucks put his malicious intentions in writing.
- Cymen 5y agoI experienced dilution as a former employee of a startup. Teespring did a 13:1 down round a year or so after I left (2015?). If you weren't an accredited investor that could afford to invest in the round, you had 1/13 of your original shares after the round finished. I experienced both being pushed into AMT when exercising the options (they didn't offer early exercise) along with having 1/13 of my shares later on. No idea if I'll ever see any money out of the deal so I've chalked it up being a lesson learned -- many say to value stock options as $0 but they can have negative value.
- jiveturkey 5y agowell to be fair, you should never exercise if it isn't early exercise. the odds are very much against you. I mean, by the odds you shouldn't early exercise either but at least you don't get hit by the AMT bullet.
- redshirtrob 5y agoThat's certainly not true. You should evaluate the investment just like any other investment and decide if you can afford to lose the money and stomach the risk. Part of your evaluation should be consulting a tax professional to determine if there are any immediate, negative tax consequences. You're not guaranteed to get hit by AMT just because you exercise some stock options.
- hinkley 5y ago> You should evaluate the investment just like any other investment Except it's not like any other investment. It's an investment that you are too close to. You can't think 100% objectively about an investment that you're too close to. For many people the solution is unambiguous: If I can't be objective about a decision then the answer is automatically 'no'.
- redshirtrob 5y agoThere are lots of things I'm close to that I need to think objectively about. Maybe I don't hit your ideal of 100%, but I do my best. Investments is one area. The health and well being of my children is another. You can never have perfect objectivity. You do the best you can. GP's advice is too rigid and therefor not very good. FWIW, I'm speaking from experience. Had I taken GP's advice and "never exercise unless it's early exercise" then I would have missed out on a lot of money. The other thing to keep in mind is you don't have to exercise 100% of your vested options. If you're too nervous or don't trust your own judgement, maybe go for 10%, or whatever makes you comfortable. There's a lot of room between 0 and 100 here. Go ahead and explore it.
- anandrew 5y agoCould you explain more? Because this sounds like it should be very illegal. My understand is that shares represent partial ownership of the company. So what gives one set of shareholders the right to reduce others' ownership share? In fact, why don't the boards of all companies do this? Devalue everyone else's shares so they become the sole owners?