15 ms·
Wolves make roadways safer
- ineedasername 5y agoAs a random aside, that reminds me of a joke: Two hunters are out in the woods when one of them collapses. He’s not breathing and his eyes are glazed, so his friend calls 911. “My friend is dead! What should I do?” The operator replies, “Calm down, sir. I can help. First make sure he’s dead.” There’s a silence, then a loud bang. Back on the phone, the guy says, “OK, now what?"
- IG_Semmelweiss 5y agoI would speculate that road, which due to cars have elevated noise levels, render them intrinsically a good cloaking mechanism to wolves stalking prey. Or at least, deer feel unable to register sounds there and thus avoid it
- goodcanadian 5y agoDeer don't generally hang out on busy roads at the best of times. I suspect it has more to do with the roadway being an open area which makes the deer more visible and thus more vulnerable to wolves.
- topspin 5y ago> Deer don't generally hang out on busy roads at the best of times. Deer hang out wherever they find food and cover. If there happen to be busy roads in the vicinity then you find them on busy roads. Busy roads also have lights; deer make use of available illumination. The frequency of deer collisions increases with the full moon because of this[1]. I have a light pole on my property and deer hang out near this. Almost every night I step outside I startle a few; there were two does under it last night. [1] https://www.popsci.com/animals/hit-deer-time-of-day-year/ https://www.popsci.com/animals/hit-deer-time-of-day-year/
- goodcanadian 5y agoDeer absolutely hang out on roads. They do not generally hang out on busy roads. Near busy roads, perhaps, but not on them.
- LorenPechtel 5y agoThe presence of predators causes prey to avoid areas that favor the predator. In this situation the issue is open space. Roads are open, wolves are a bigger threat to the deer with long sight lines. (Simple example in our own backyard. Some plants in pots, some plants in the ground with vegetation around them. The birds completely stripped the ones in the pots but didn't touch the ones in the ground. There was no cover near the pots, a cat would have no cover. With the ones in the ground a cat would have lots of cover. While we do not have a cat multiple cats sometimes come around.)
- goda90 5y agoI was reading the other day about how wolves can help reduce Lyme's carrying tick populations as well, which could be considered another positive economic impact. They of course keep deer in check, but they also keep coyotes in check while not preying on the smaller animals that eat ticks and mice like coyotes do.
- mrfusion 5y agoBut then we’d have to live around wolves. I like the idea that I don’t live near large apex predators. (I know they mostly leave humans alone but it’s still unsettling.)
- patall 5y agoAnd I like the idea of having a lower chance of dying in a road accident. Or isn't that the idea of what we are discussing here, putting actual numbers to (ir)rational fears?
- anthomtb 5y agoYou currently live somewhere that doesn’t have any large apex predators?
- alisonkisk 5y agoWhat are you talking about?
- cameronh90 5y agoI live in England, and the scariest thing you'll find in the countryside is a badger. Our badgers aren't even scary. Well - besides other humans and their dogs.
- syberiyxx 5y agoIf only financial compensation could repair the stress of cattle being hunted.
- totalZero 5y agoI wonder if they considered publishing under the title, "Wolves eat deer before they can get run over by cars."
- fastaguy88 5y agoThis could not be the title, because it is not what they found. They found that in addition to predation, the threat of wolves changes the deers’ behavior, which has a much larger role in reducing accidents.
- mrfusion 5y agoMy writing effectiveness shot up when I realized going simple is almost always the right thing to do. I was around 24 and kept wondering why most people didn’t read my emails.
- tgv 5y agoThe thing they estimate is reduction of deer collisions, according to the abstract. So that’s a rather limited scope in comparison to the title. What surprises me more (I guess I’m a bit jaded), is that the title suggests that nature is there to be economically exploited. Does a species run up a loss? Extinction is its fate.
- fastaguy88 5y agoThe use of economics is less about exploiting the wolves, or deer, and more about countering the widely held, and very personal belief (if you are a rancher), that wolves introduction has high costs from livestock predation. A rancher losing a steer has experienced a substantial economic loss.
- pfdietz 5y agoPut another way: if wolves are reintroduced and ranchers are compensated generously for lost animals, the rest of society still comes out ahead. I sometimes think many environmental issues could be resolved with sufficient bribery. And if the benefit of the policy is really that large, the bribes are affordable.
- scatters 5y agoThe economic term for this is Coasean bargaining. The Coase theorem is that this can in principle be solved privately; in practice, transaction costs and imperfect information usually make government involvement necessary.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pfdietz 5y agoIndeed! https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29222420 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29222420
- 5y ago
- elliekelly 5y agoIt makes me sad that laying out the economic benefits of wildlife conservation is even necessary. This is interesting. But why can’t we conserve wolves just because? Why do we need to point to the economics of it? Are they not worth conserving unless they help the bottom line?
- gruez 5y ago>But why can’t we conserve wolves just because? evidently not, otherwise there wouldn't be endangered species. >Why do we need to point to the economics of it? Are they not worth conserving unless they help the bottom line? to get all the non-conservationists on board.
- Grakel 5y agoWe do put money and effort into protecting them just because. But committees sit around and think, "here's a way we can further justify and generate some press." How much human effort is wasted by group politics and general shrugging?
- eggsmediumrare 5y agoConsidering your comment is greyed out (or at least was), I supposed the answer to your last question, for some people, must be yes. I suspect it legitimately doesn't occur to some people that conservation need not be an economic activity.
- wpietri 5y agoWe can. And personally, I think we should. But these economic arguments are very useful for convincing people who don't share that value.
- eropple 5y agoI dunno. More and more it strikes me that people "moved by economic arguments" are in truth having already decided their position and work backwards to justify it.
- 5y ago
- wpietri 5y agoAs somebody who grew up one state over, I can totally believe this. Deer collision featured importantly driver's ed and my thoughts for highway driving, especially in twilight and dark. Anybody who has ever had a squirrel run out in front of you knows the feeling, except here the squirrel can do 30 mph and weighs as much as a person.
- earthscienceman 5y agoAs much as a person!? A big deer can get to 300 lbs. And in some parts of the country Elk and Moose are a large concern. I'll never forget seeing my 16 year old friends truck after he hit an elk.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- spockz 5y agoWhat was 16 years old? Your friend, the truck, or both? Over here it most likely is a total loss for the car.
- onionisafruit 5y agoAccording to English’s ordering of adjectives[1], the friend is sixteen years old. If the truck were 16 years old the phrase would have been “my friend’s 16 year old truck”. [1] https://www.grammarly.com/blog/adjective-order/ https://www.grammarly.com/blog/adjective-order/
- robocat 5y agoI presumed the friendship was 16 years old. English is the worst language, just like all the other languages.
- fortran77 5y ago> As much as a person!? A big deer can get to 300 lbs Visit a Walmart. Or go to Walt Disney World. Or a Las Vegas casino. You'll see what he means.
- dr_dshiv 5y agoReally cool article. They show that Wolves create a “landscape of fear” which reduces deer engagement with roads. So wolves do what hunters can’t; not just reducing populations but also changing behavior. Kind of creepy, if you are a deer!
- jjtheblunt 5y agoHow long till deer hunters decide they need to hunt wolf to remotivate deer hunting? (I thought of this immediately as some hunters I know have absurd justifications for it being useful for ecosystems)
- felipemnoa 5y ago>>Kind of creepy, if you are a deer! This made me laugh! I think this applies to any animal that is prey.
- rewq4321 5y agoDeer suffering makes you laugh?
- DeBraid 5y agoRelated, an excellent podcast episode by that name "Landscape of Fear" from Meateater: https://www.themeateater.com/listen/meateater/ep-162-landscape-of-fear https://www.themeateater.com/listen/meateater/ep-162-landsca... Steven Rinella talks with Dr. Kevin Monteith, Dr. Matt Kaufmann, Jared Oakleaf, and Janis Putelis. Subjects discussed: genetics that rewrite our understanding of animals; big game guts; learning how to migrate; who pays for wildlife research?; brain scrambling, extreme sports, and wildlife capture; advancing modern wildlife management; etc.
- scottndecker 5y agoLove seeing some MeatEater pop up on my HN feed :)
- DyslexicAtheist 5y ago
- kiba 5y agoI would like to suggest we cede more of our land to nature, and increasing the amount of uninterrupted wilderness. But that's going to not be popular with a lot of people because it means deciding what area we get to live in or don't. Some towns are going to be removed for lack of sustainability. For this to work, we would need to also improve our land use policies in the towns and cities we currently live in.
- mrfusion 5y agoIf we opened up zoning for denser housing this might just happen on its own.
- Gigachad 5y agoIt would be incredible if we could give up endless sprawling suburbs for smaller high density areas right next to nature.
- Aperocky 5y ago> amount of uninterrupted wilderness. Towns are not the problem, highways are. Specifically interstates and other roads built to that standards.
- kiba 5y agoRoads lead to towns. You might need to remove these towns before you could disconnect the roads. Highways and interstates are problematic, yes, but they often take away lands in suburban areas as opposed to the wilderness.
- daniel-cussen 5y agoYou could just have dirt roads. The problem isn't the road per se it's the crazy fast cars on the road. If cars rode at 12mph like they do on dirt roads, at about the speed a deer can gallop, that's like 25x less kinetic energy and if you hit a deer it'll bump and keep going.
- dukeofdoom 5y agoI read something before how they change the flow of rivers. Basically predation by wolves changes the feeding behaviour of deer and other animals, which changes the type of vegetations that grows along river banks and creeks, and that can change the shape of a river.
- ketan0 5y agoHave you heard of Psychedelic water?? What is it all about?? https://sites.google.com/view/psychedelic-water-review/home https://sites.google.com/view/psychedelic-water-review/home
- nfc 5y agoSo we should allow wolves population to increase until the proportion of flying to normal cars is?
- zzzeek 5y agoEffects on housepets / livestock residing in or around homes / farms near the highway, not so much.
- 8bitsrule 5y agoHitting the deer is just the beginning. We were driving on a semi-wilderness highway when a medium-sized deer staggered up from a deep drainage ditch on the same side of the road, about 50 yards ahead. Managed to slow from 65-70 to 50 mph before hitting the animal, which slid along the highway and into the deep ditch on the other side. The slowdown helped limit the van's damage to $10,000, but it was undriveable. Even if we somehow removed the hood (bent in two over the unbroken windshield), all the fluid had ran out of the crushed radiator and into the semi-wilderness ditch. Luckily it was a hot July afternoon, and a truck going the opposite way came along in 15 minutes. The driver put the deer out of its misery. Had it been in the winter, after sundown, it might have taken hours just to be found. Happened in the 1990s (no mobiles), so we waited for a vehicle heading toward the nearest little town to find a tow -truck. With the van towed to that town (no repair shop), it was another hour before relatives arrived from the bigger town (that tow-truck had a repair shop). The insurance company paid for the repair, then dropped the policy. I never drove that route after noon again.
- Waterluvian 5y agoRandom curiosity: did the truck driver produce a firearm and shoot the deer or something? Why did the insurer cancel the policy?
- thefifthsetpin 5y agoYour question reminded me of a first responder that I knew. He was in a rural Wisconsin area where collisions with deer were common. He kept a spear in his truck to put deer out of their misery. He preferred using the spear to using his firearm since the use of a firearm came with extra paperwork.
- cbnva 5y agoThis is a somewhat car centered view: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_wolf_attacks https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_wolf_attacks I'm not very comfortably hiking in wolf territories.
- shkkmo 5y agoWolves just aren't that dangerous in North America. You should be far more concerned about bears, but dogs, mountains lions, even moose are more likely to attack and kill a human.
- PhineasRex 5y agoYou might want to look at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fatal_bear_attacks_in_North_America https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fatal_bear_attacks_in_... then. Note that the bear article is limited by region and only to fatal attacks because a list of broad in scope as the wolf attacks article would be never-ending. Lots of predators are far more dangerous to people than wolves but wolves provoke a visceral reaction because they've been demonized in a way bears, etc haven't.
- pvaldes 5y agoMany of those attacks would be entirely preventable vaccinating the cubs or adults once against rabies. Is a management problem that is fixable and relatively cheap.
- xipho 5y agoThe "bio-economy" and "bio-services" are coming. You'll start to hear these buzz-words more and more in following years, watch for the emphasis in federal science funding initiatives etc. When arguments based on economic impact are translated into laws and rules for how we do things, and we start to tie things like the paper mentions into the picture, then the logical outcome is more "reverence" for the natural world, wrapped in the veneer of capitalism. There is ample precedent, see protection of fishing grounds, biological control saving billions of $ and millions of lives [1], etc. etc. [1](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phenacoccus_manihoti https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phenacoccus_manihoti)
- greedo 5y agoWhenever I read about people concerned with wolves threatening humans, it reminds me of how sharks are treated. Both have been vilified in book and film, yet are rarely a threat to humans.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- casassas_6 5y agofafs
- DoreenMichele 5y agoI am reminded of an organization I read about years ago with the tag line "Seeing like a mountain." It was founded by someone who noticed that excess deer were stripping the mountain of vegetation and they concluded that reintroducing wolves was important for creating a sustainable environment. In the US, deer-vehicle collisions make deer the deadliest animal for people that we have in this country. https://www.worldatlas.com/articles/10-deadliest-animals-in-the-us.html https://www.worldatlas.com/articles/10-deadliest-animals-in-... In the US: Deer–vehicle collisions lead to about 200 human deaths and $1.1 billion in property damage every year. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deer%E2%80%93vehicle_collisions https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deer%E2%80%93vehicle_collisi... Part of my incomplete BS in Environmental Studies was a class in quantifying the economic value of natural resources. I did a case study on wetlands in the San Francisco Bay Area that are currently quietly being threatened by the county rail plan. The US used to pay people to fill in swamps and create "productive" land and then learned that swamps do useful and valuable things of various sorts. We updated the name from swamp to wetlands, overhauled their public image and reversed policy. We now protect and restore such areas. Quantifying the economic value to humans of a natural resource is a good means to convince people it needs protecting and it is in your best interest to protect it. This is not "charity" and shouldn't be viewed as a sacrifice. We are cutting our own throats when we ruin the world because of fixation on some overly simplified idea that it needs to put money directly into our pockets for humans to care about it. One of the best ways to fight such entrenched ideas is to quantify just how much it costs us to think that way.
- swayvil 5y agoThe intellect is always going to offer only a vastly over-simplified perspective. But it's our #1 tool. So popular that we literally cannot imagine not using it 24-7. And furthermore we invariably call that model of reality, "reality". I mean that's just how it is. Possible antidotes for this ubiquitous plague of profound blindness : drugs, art, disaster, meditation... What else?
- yoaviram 5y agoThe name of the organization is probably based on an essay called "Thinking like a mountain" by Aldo Leopold. Writing in 1949, Leopold is considered to be one of the first ecologists. It's a beautifully poetic and prophetic text. I happen to be living on a mountain in southern Tuscany. A place where wolf where hunted to the brink of extinction and the deer population is exploding. This essay resonates with me in profound ways. The essay (PDF): https://www.ecotoneinc.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/aldo-leopold-tlam.pdf https://www.ecotoneinc.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/aldo-l... PS. the whole book is worth reading.
- arminiusreturns 5y agoLots of people talking who never had to deal with wolves here. Bottom line to remember about any wolf studies is this: they don't transfer to other wolf locations. This paper is relevant for Wisconsin only. Secondarily, since this topic inevitably comes up as people say stuff like "it's silly to be afraid of wolves", all the claims that wolves don't attack people are lies, using almost exclusively US based data where the wolves were killed until under control for that very reason. For a less ideological understanding of the real danger of wolves look at the statistics in Siberia, etc. My saying for those who harp on this is "It's easy to claim refuge in statistics until you are in the middle of nothing and hear a pack a ridge or two over. Or hear them circle and yip your camp at night. Then statistics don't offer nearly the same comfort." ... Things I have experienced first hand. Slightly off topic but one of the most visually exhilarating things ever for me was to stumble across a wild pack feasting on a fresh kill... I grew up in a wolf re-intro zone and have had to deal with all the changes to the forest that came with it, many, if not most, of them bad. It wasn't until I was older I went back and re-read the justification papers and they were absolutely horrid science. There is quite a history of wolf related papers being used to justify political actions far outside what the papers support. Please don't fall into that same trap here. This is an interesting paper about the Wisconsin wolf population from a particular angle of study (not a holistic study), that's it.
- CRConrad 5y ago> Bottom line to remember about any wolf studies is this: they don't transfer to other wolf locations. This paper is relevant for Wisconsin only. How and why? Are Wisconsin wolves somehow fundamentally different than other wolves; a different species or something? I find your thesis hard to swallow. Occam's razor suggests that since they're wolves, they behave like other wolves.
- arminiusreturns 5y agoDifferent wolf breeds and different environments (for example, elk heavy animal pops are different to hunt than deer, variations in forest type, elevation, water sources, human pop within radius, etc) combined make for too many variables.
- cableshaft 5y agoAfter reading the headline it took me a second, then I went "Of course, less deer!" I hate driving country roads because I've had way too many close calls with deer that seem hell-bent on appearing suddenly from off to the side directly in front of you. I once had three separate deer crossing in front of my car incidents in just 48 hours before. 2 extremely close, one I'm surprised I didn't hit and I swerved in a dumb and potentially dangerous way to miss it (probably shouldn't have, but that's what happened in the moment, thankfully I was the only person on the road then). So yeah, bring on the wolves. I don't want deer to go extinct or anything, but I wouldn't mind being able to loosen my vice grip on the steering wheel and having total vigilance whenever I drive down country roads (especially at night).
- tapirl 5y agoRust is the new C++.
- chkaloon 5y agoI own 100 acres of woodland in south-central Wisconsin. The deer are extremely abundant and cause extensive damage to the ecosystem. We have bow hunters on the property each fall who take maybe a dozen or so deer (no guns, too many houses in the vicinity). Even with that the herd seems to get larger each year (and the deer are getting smaller in size). We're in a heavily farmed area, so a wolf pack might be unpopular, but looks like it would help on my side of the equation!
- peter303 5y agoThey also restored beavers (GO MIT!) to Yellowstone because beavers and ungulates competed for the same pkant food and the latter won.