5 ms·
What human institution has endured? For more than say a few centuries? Of those few, how many served any of their original purposes, but instead optimized for t
by h2odragon 5y ago
What human institution has endured? For more than say a few centuries? Of those few, how many served any of their original purposes, but instead optimized for the continuation of the organization to the exclusion of the stated mission?
"Gimme that old time Religion" and "here come the New Boss"
- framecowbird 5y agoThe British monarchy managed about a thousand years, as did the Roman empire
- kragen 5y agoThe British monarchy lost most of its power in the Magna Carta in 01215, was interrupted by the establishment of the Commonwealth in 01649, was replaced by the Glorious Revolution in 01688, lost most of its remaining power to Parliament in 01689, and became British in 01707. I'll give you the Roman Empire, which lasted close to 1500 years, and also, for example, the Imamate of Oman, the Japanese Imperial Family (which has lost and regained its power over Japan two or three times), and Al-Azhar University, which celebrated its thousandth birthday about 50 years ago. There are a few other examples.
- Shacklz 5y ago> 01215 Why are you prefixing the years with a zero, is that a thing? Are you preparing for those who might read this in a few millenia after us?
- Jensson 5y agoIt is octal, write '01215' in a browser javascript console and you get '653'. (Not sure if that is what he meant, but if he did that for ease of parsing it will just make it harder)
- lordnacho 5y agoMakes it easier to cater for events in the span of 30-40k. I'm the grim darkness of the future, there will in fact be long lived institutions.
- catlikesshrimp 5y agoYou are the grim darkness of the future?
- lordnacho 5y agoHaha thanks auto-correct!
- DeathArrow 5y agoHistory is accelerating, events happen faster and empires will last far less than they used to.
- catlikesshrimp 5y agoty. And the French monarchy. Can we consider all European monarchies as part of the same institution? They did have some similar titles and sucession rules
- ethbr0 5y agoBanking (call it 2500+ years, in the sense of marks in a ledger being equivalent to some method of stored value)
- daveguy 5y ago"...but instead optimized for the continuation of the organization..." This sums it up. It takes a very narrow / well-defined focus to avoid optimizing for the organization. Power corrupts. I wonder if it would be possible to have a built-in / designed reset. Or if it's even possible to have a narrow enough or well defined enough focus that the target of the reset is understood and agreed upon.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> What human institution has endured? Those were Malthusian times, before industrialisation and widespread literacy and the internet. We don’t have evidence that this time is different. But we can’t reject that hypothesis, either. The biggest thing we currently lack is a culture that believes it can break the cycle.
- daveguy 5y agoWhat, other than belief, do you think it would take?
- toomuchtodo 5y agoFortitude and grit.
- daveguy 5y agoLiterally every culture believes they have fortitude and grit. That's just another platitude. I was talking about what implementable standards would it take. Elections and democratic rule were a pretty big advance. I think built in transparency may also be helpful.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoDo you think more transparency would have changed recent US politics events? Do you believe objective measures and systems would solve for certain belief systems? It’s easy to argue my points are platitudes, but I’d argue that the problems we face are collectively emotional.
- daveguy 5y agoI don't know. That's why I was asking the question. I agree that much of the problem is emotional, but I do believe technocratic solutions exist. We probably aren't anywhere near those solutions because we still can't separate emotion fr governance (maybe we never will). I didn't mean to insult your response, just that I was looking for something more concrete -- opinions about solutions.
- paxys 5y agoThe Catholic Church has done pretty well for itself (~2000 years and counting).
- CameronNemo 5y agoHow did you arrive to that number?
- kragen 5y agoThe Roman Catholic Church is less than 1700 years old. The Council of Nicea was in 00325 CE, and the bishops derived their authority from their local congregations rather than from a pope until roughly the Council of Chalcedon in 00451. If you believe that it's closer to 2000 years old, you must also believe that its original purpose was to prepare for the end of the world and the Day of Judgment within the lifetimes of the first Christians. More plausibly, its original purpose was to remove the threat Christianity posed to the political stability of the Roman Empire. The Roman Empire fell in 01453, almost 600 years ago.
- sofixa 5y ago> The Roman Empire fell in 01453, almost 600 years ago. The Eastern Roman Empire, more commonly known as Byzantium or the Byzantine empire, fell in 1453. They weren't under the authority of the Catholic church ( great schism and all that). The Western Roman Empire fell much earlier.
- solresol 5y agoQuite a few companies. Many universities. Many schools. Many temples and religious communities.
- kragen 5y agoThere are surprisingly few that are more than a few centuries old.
- Jensson 5y agoPrinting presses became popular about 500 years ago, any large scale organization was really hard to run before then as there was no cheap and easy way to create and distribute large amounts of information.
- kragen 5y agoYou'd think small-scale organizations would be more stable, though.
- joebob42 5y agoOver a long enough time period, a small scale organization is kind of likely to just get blown up by a catastrophe because it isn't big enough to absorb it. At least that would be my guess.
- kragen 5y agoWell, consider my example in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29286002 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29286002 of al-Azhar University, which is 1050 years old. It was founded under the Fatimid Caliphate, which fell 200 years later after a century of civil war, replaced locally by Saladin's Ayyubid Sultanate. Another 80 years later Cairo fell to the Mamluk Sultanate, which held Egypt for 270 years until the Ottoman conquest, which the Ottomans lost 350 years later to Napoleon. Five more governments later (if we count Nasser, Mubarak, Morsi, and Sisi as a single government), here we are, and al-Azhar has survived the fall of nine governments, all of which entirely ceased to exist. This suggests two points: 1. There are a lot more small organizations at any given time than large ones. There were only two Caliphates at the time of the Fatimid Caliphate (the other being the Sunni Abbasid Caliphate, to which we owe Western Civilization, such as it is), and they covered the entire Middle East. But at the same time and in the same place there were thousands of schools and universities, some of which did get blown up by catastrophes (like the House of Wisdom in Baghdad) and some of which did not. 2. There are a lot of catastrophes that are harder for a big organization like the Fatimid Caliphate to absorb than for a smaller organization like al-Azhar University. More generally there are certain kinds of organizations, such as universities, that are very resilient.
- a_bonobo 5y agoAustralia has had people living in it for 60,000 years, with basic animal husbandry, fish traps, basic agriculture, a messaging network, a national trading network - we don't know how long each of these aspects existed of these 60,000 years (for wooden evidence doesn't conserve well) but it'll definitely be much, much longer than European institutions
- datavirtue 5y agoFreemasonry