6 ms·
Every person deserves the freedom to criticize their leaders and to speak out against abuse without fear of reprisal. This is a shame.
by echelon 5y ago
Every person deserves the freedom to criticize their leaders and to speak out against abuse without fear of reprisal.
This is a shame.
- chrischen 5y agoDang, tell that to Edward Snowden.
- gentleman11 5y agoLong list of people here saying Snowden deserves to rot in jail for revealing a massive, illegal domestic spy program. Even with his documents, no citizen has been able to challenge this in court because of secrecy rules. There’s no such thing as a whistleblower without evidence, that’s called a parish who gets ignored. Are you all also in favour of prosecuting the journalists who publish this material?
- throwaway19937 5y ago> Long list of people here saying Snowden deserves to rot in jail for revealing a massive, illegal domestic spy program. Even with his documents, no citizen has been able to challenge this in court because of secrecy rules. There’s no such thing as a whistleblower without evidence, that’s called a parish who gets ignored. I'm in favor of prosecuting Snowden because he did substantial and potentially permanent damage to our intelligence gathering abroad. > There’s no such thing as a whistleblower without evidence, that’s called a parish who gets ignored. He could have gathered information, contacted appropriate members of the Senate, and launched an investigation such as the Church committee (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Church_Committee https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Church_Committee). > Are you all also in favour of prosecuting the journalists who publish this material? That depends on what they publish and whether it's determined to be illegal. Hopefully the courts would allow publication as in the Pentagon Papers case (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pentagon_Papers#The_Supreme_Court_allows_further_publication https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pentagon_Papers#The_Supreme_Co...).
- whatever1 5y agoHalf America was publicly making fun of the previous president. Try that in China. Snowden while having noble intentions he broke the law and he should face the consequences of his actions. If I kill the guard to break into the CIA HQ and expose a massive scandal do I deserve jail time or a Medal of Honor? I would argue both.
- chrischen 5y ago100 years from now you think historians will care which society was slightly more dystopian than the other? Saying he broke the law is pointless, when the law is designed to be broken by dissidents.
- whatever1 5y agoDemocracy comes with rights but also responsibilities. The main responsibility is to follow the law. The other responsibility is to vote to select the correct laws to follow as a society. Nobody knows what the correct set of laws for a society is. That is why we have regular elections to iterate upon them. In very few cases you can see a clear cut and say definitely that a law is fair or unfair. Most of the laws lie on a spectrum, and I would argue that it is impossible to find a set of laws that are fair to all of the people, forever. That is why dictatorships even if they start with start with good intentions (some did) they end up being oppressive regimes.
- coldtea 5y ago>Half America was publicly making fun of the previous president. Try that in China. If the whole establishment and the deep state was similarly with you, you could do that in China too.
- whatever1 5y agoSo now that Biden is the laughingstock of the Right, I guess they have the establishment and the deep state on their side and that is why they are not exiled?
- googlryas 5y agoSnowden went on the run for stealing government documents, not for speaking out.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoFalse equivalence. Edward Snowden ran afoul of the boundaries for freedom of speech in a first world country. If he did the same thing as a Chinese in China, they would have sent a squad to repatriate him long ago (being in Russia is just a minor inconvenience). Just because the USA and China both have problems in this area doesn't make them anywhere near having the same scale and severity.
- mc32 5y agoAgreed. If Snowden had been Chinese and had exposed Chinese secrets like that and he escaped to Russia, Russia would have found reasons to return him and then there would have been a quick farcical trial and he'd've been executed and the family billed as well as ostracized. Had he escaped to Canada or Australia, etc., they have found a way for an accident to happen to him. Russia, China, N Korea, KSA, Iran deal with dissidents quite harshly.
- sudosysgen 5y agoIf he went to the USA and got governmental assistance he would be safe. In Russia he is definitely getting a lot of government protection otherwise he would have been "extraordinarily renditioned".
- mc32 5y agoAssange even though isn't protected by the UK isn't getting extraordinarily renditioned. Yes, the UK has treated him badly and we know Hillary wished him dead via drone, but so far, that has not happened (either extraordinarily renditioned nor droned) though it may come to pass that he gets extradited someday.
- sudosysgen 5y agoAssange is currently in a maximum security prison. Beforethen he was in an embassy. It is physically impossible for him to be extraordinarily renditioned. Therefore it's not a signal any way or another.
- lowkey_ 5y agoI support Snowden, but "Every person deserves the freedom to criticize their leaders and to speak out against abuse" is not equal to "Every employee of secret government intelligence agencies deserves the freedom to steal thousands of government documents and release them to the press." Peng Shuai's situation is so far from Snowden — if you're trying to point to a parallel between the US and China, it doesn't work. The US equivalent would be if the women who accused Trump, Kavanaugh, Cuomo, etc., of sexual harassment were kidnapped by the government.
- hnfong 5y agoHow did Epstein die?
- throwaway19937 5y agoThere's a big difference between leaking intelligence information and criticizing your country's government.
- simonh 5y agoIf Snowden had simply spoken out against abuse and criticised leaders he'd be fine. People do that in the US in social media and on TV every day.
- HenryKissinger 5y agoThe Party couldn't care less, unfortunately.
- xdennis 5y agoWhat makes this worse is that it's not even political criticism. She accused him of a crime.