4 ms·
So, just like Apple, Facebook, and Twitter regularly policing their platforms and stop apps, websites, etc., according to their national interests and political
by coldtea 5y ago
So, just like Apple, Facebook, and Twitter regularly policing their platforms and stop apps, websites, etc., according to their national interests and political/cultural fashions?
"It's ok when we do it" - and when you point it out, ofcourse "that's whatabboutism" (plus, "our targets deserve it").
- shrewduser 5y agoI'm not sure you would find censorship of terms like “Democratic Movement” and “Long live Taiwan’s independence.” on Other platforms. not sure if you're intentionally comparing things like child porn to democracy as equally deserving of censorship but that's how i read it.
- volgo 5y agoI'm not sure you would find censorship of terms like "Uighur are not in camps" on Twitter and Facebook. Because as per US foreign policy, "denying" those claims is not allowed
- convery 5y agoKind of scary how whenever someone comments on censorship a lot of peoples minds immediately go to CP.. Like, out of the millions of things one could somewhat legitimately censor, it's always CP..
- usui 5y agoW-What? Are you suggesting that an instrument for censorship could be used for anything other than its stated purpose?! The West has always been the place for free speech and tolerance!
- shadowgovt 5y agoCP is the exception that proves the rule in the concept of liberal communication. ... In the old definition of "proves" as in "tests," because any process that greenlights CP is wanting. So it's the one you go to as a litmus test for whether or not the question of censorship vs. open speech on the table is worth spending energy discoursing on.
- fsckboy 5y ago> Kind of scary how ... it's always CP kind of hilarious given the present context that where I come from, CP means Communist Party
- carrolldunham 5y agoTwitch etc have precisely such lists of words. Democratic movement is an idea that threatens the Chinese power structure - things that you probably don't like are a threat the American power structure. Just because you also personally find them kooky or immoral is irrelevant
- coldtea 5y ago>I'm not sure you would find censorship of terms like “Democratic Movement” and “Long live Taiwan’s independence.” on Other platforms. Yeah, on US tech platforms you can promote Taiwan's independence and criticize China's national interests, I'll give you that! It's like the old joke, where the American says that he's free-er as he can go to Times Square with a bullhorn megaphone and openly criticize the US Predident. To which the USSR guy counters that he's equally free, as he is also perfectly allowed to go to the Red Square and openly criticize the US Predident. >not sure if you're intentionally comparing things like child porn to democracy as equally deserving of censorship but that's how i read it. I wrote censoring based on "national interests" (not to mention petty political partisan censorship), but you took it that I was complaining about them censoring "child pornography". "Think of the children", much? I don't think that censoring people from Snowden and wiki-leaks (banned on several instances, which corporations even disabling their way to accept donations), to people writing on the wrong side of the political and being banned for "fake news" (while the "legit" sources touted BS like the Steele Dossier, that now, years after it doesn't matter anymore, do a 180-turn on), amounts to "child porn".
- colordrops 5y agoPeople get content deleted on American platforms for lots of content that is no where near child porn in obvious reprehensibility.
- cassonmars 5y agoThere’s a huge difference between a private company banning someone from their platform and a government that has a secret police which takes you away at night to a labor camp because you didn’t simp for the People’s party.
- mysecretaccount 5y agoThis article isn't about labor camps or the CCP's secret police. If you look at the censorship itself, the gap is much more narrow.
- cassonmars 5y agoThat’s not the point. OP tried to draw a comparison that private enterprises in the US do the same thing — they do not. The false equivalence ends at the point where the CCP actively controls what these companies do in terms of enforcement, and the mass surveillance apparatus is intrinsically linked.
- mysecretaccount 5y ago> That’s not the point. OP tried to draw a comparison that private enterprises in the US do the same thing — they do not. FB/GOOG absolutely do. You may trust the USG or the companies it pressures into this domain of behavior more than the CCP/Xiaomi (or may not - it is not relevant to this point) but the comparison is there.
- colordrops 5y agoIt's amazing that people still have their heads in the sand about this when evidence to the contrary comes out regularly, e.g. PRISM, CIA coordination with the LA Times and New York Times, and Biden's press secretary Psaki directly saying they work with social media companies to determine censorship policies.
- cassonmars 5y agoPlease cite a source where discussing American historical atrocities on social media gets you whisked away by the secret police.
- rudian 5y agoYou’re an idiot or a spy if you think Facebook’s blocking is in anyway similar to China’s censorship. Facebook does not block anything like “Winnie the Pooh” and you don’t risk disappearing by posting on Facebook.
- ycombigator 5y agoHope you don't play tennis. Could end badly for you.