7 ms·
Electricity-to-electricity efficiency should not be compared with solar-to-electricity efficiency. The typical solar panel is maybe 25% efficient or less. The
by dragontamer 5y ago
Electricity-to-electricity efficiency should not be compared with solar-to-electricity efficiency.
The typical solar panel is maybe 25% efficient or less. The typical steam engine is maybe 50% efficient. Once things are in the form of electricity, we have a large variety of options for efficient transport and storage.
But sometimes electricity isn't useful. Li-Ion will never be light enough for a serious airplane for example, while hydrogen _IS_ light enough for an airplane. (But maybe too volumetric, as every practical H2 airplane engine relies upon high-pressure storage or even cryogenics to keep H2 at a small enough volume).
EDIT: If we think of it as chemistry... perhaps we can make liquid fuels out of H2 like coal liquefaction turns one fuel source into another. After all, classical fuels are nothing more than carbon + hydrogen + energy... and H2 is a very efficient form of storing energy for that reaction. Or maybe we learn to just use H2 directly? There are fuel cells and engines running on H2 today, but I'm always worried about the volume of H2 (requiring either compression or cyrogenics before you reach practicality).
- aunty_helen 5y agoGreat thing about Jet A, it's actually pretty hard to get burning. Hydrogen: See Hindenburg. I would rather not fly in a bomb. I just don't see it being viable for planes. We're starting to see short distance small planes electrify and then long haul will probably go synthetic fuels over the next 10 years.
- huntertwo 5y agoI read something that says Hindenburg was more about the mix of the gas and the material of the blimp. Properly mixed H2 doesn’t burn (it explodes quickly, which is what powers an ICE). I agree though, planes and H2 probably don’t mix. Jet fuel should not be a priority to replace with H2. Priority should be given to static applications before trying to apply it to moving vehicles.
- R0b0t1 5y agoYou are right. The issue with the Hindenberg was not the hydrogen. It was the coating. The main concern for hydrogen as a fuel now is the high pressures. If the pressure vessel is damaged it explodes due to mechanical forces. This is not impossible to work around. Consider, for example, that gas tanks can already be punctured and lead to fires; it takes a fair accounting of the risks to really rule out hydrogen as a fuel.
- jjoonathan 5y agoRight, but consider a punctured gas tank vs... well, have you played "spot the COPVs in the SpaceX explosion"? They spit fire and zoom around like party balloons. Good fun from a distance, but if I had to pick one to ride with every day, it's an easy choice in favor of the gas tank.
- R0b0t1 5y agoDo you know what the fuel is? Rockets are unique in that they carry a significant amount of oxidizer with them. A hydrogen container is unlikely to zoom around spitting fire, there's too much fuel for how much oxygen there is and it rises very quickly. There are still dangers, but practically I'm not sure they are that much worse than a gasoline fire. There are also systems that reduce the pressures needed, like activated carbon beds. Research on them stalled mostly because there was no good way to generate H2.
- mywittyname 5y agoI thought the fact that H2 burns invisibly combined with the fact that it goes boom once the burning mixture is stoichiometric is the big risk with H2 over typical hydro-carbon-based fuels, which burn a bright orange and are surprisingly hard to blow up.
- R0b0t1 5y agoThe Mythbusters did a show on this exact thing with spraypaint, hairspray, and propane canisters. They didn't explode even when wrapped with flaming rags, but sometimes the released material would combust. In some cases the gas rushing out actually extinguished the flame. You rarely by accident get a stoichiometric mix. With a slow leak into an enclosed container is usually how it happens. Otherwise there is too much fuel to O2 in the atmosphere. People really need to stop trying to sound smart by thinking of imagined dangers. That is what stopped nuclear power, it's what's stopping hydrogen as a fuel, it's what's stopping gene therapy research, etc. Get over yourself.
- oblio 5y ago> I would rather not fly in a bomb. I just don't see it being viable for planes. As opposed to the kerosene fueled bombs we're flying in right now? I'm not sure comparing things to close-to-wartime tech from 90 years ago is a valid approach.
- dragontamer 5y ago> I'm not sure comparing things to close-to-wartime tech from 90 years ago is a valid approach. You might be surprised how good WW2-era scientists were at chemistry and science. The earlier poster has a point. Gasoline, Diesel, and Kerosene have all been studied extensively (especially in the 1930s and 1940s BECAUSE of preparations for WW2). The safety of soldiers was paramount even to the Nazis. War machines: be they airplanes, tanks, or battleships, were all going to be exposed to enemy fire and explosions. These fuels (Kerosene and Diesel in particular) were chosen because they're extremely safe: high flash points and even higher auto-ignition points. That means that kerosene __literally__ can't catch on fire at room temperature. You need to warm up kerosene before its appropriate to burn (Of course, once its burning it will warm up the rest of the kerosene and keep burning. But this isn't some super-explosive volatile chemical we're talking about here) Gasoline is still safe, but not as safe as the other two (-40C Flash Point). Gasoline was safer than a lot of the other petroleum products that were investigated back then, and was still chosen as a fuel for war machines. --------- The same is not necessarily true for H2. H2 will explode at any temperature (even near absolute zero).
- oblio 5y ago> You might be surprised how good WW2-era scientists were at chemistry and science. I'm well aware of chemical prowess in that period, especially on the German part. They had a bunch of Nobel prize winners. However, that's why I said "close-to-wartime". First of all, in case you weren't aware, the Hindenburg was supposed to use helium but due to a lack of helium in Germany (I think it was primarily due to American export restrictions), they had to use hydrogen. I don't know of other limitations for the Hindenburg, per se, but knowing the overall German shortages of the period, I wouldn't be surprised if they had other structural issues with the Hindenburg itself, especially since it wasn't designed to be used with hydrogen. On top of this, the Hindenburg design was from the late 20s, 1929, I believe. If materials science, modeling, etc haven't advanced since 1929, I'll eat a shoe. If we're somehow worse at managing hydrogen after almost 100 years, I'll eat the other shoe.
- dragontamer 5y agoEven if H2 isn't used directly, there are likely chemical processes that can convert it into some form that is more useful. EDIT: That's what its called. H2 is a component of Syngas (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Syngas https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Syngas). Syngas can then be further processed into kerosene, gasoline, or other fuels we use.
- lemmsjid 5y agoThis has some interesting comparisons between hydrogen and gasoline as fuel, in terms of historical experimentation as to the effects of rupturing or destroying tanks holding one or the other: https://hydrogen.wsu.edu/2017/03/17/so-just-how-dangerous-is-hydrogen-fuel/ https://hydrogen.wsu.edu/2017/03/17/so-just-how-dangerous-is.... Not my field so I'd be interested in if this more or less reflective of current knowledge on the subject.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> perhaps we can make liquid fuels out of H2 You're describing hydrocarbons. The most-common element in the universe married to the most-common four-bonding element. Using solar panels to synthesize Jet A is probably a better path forward than redesigning every plane in the world to trawl a balloon or carry a pressure vessel. There's a reason pretty much all of Earth's biology uses hydrocarbons as its fuel of choice.
- Blammar 5y agoYes, exactly! Or any other hydrocarbon. This is a carbon-neutral process also, as the carbon will come from CO2 in the atmosphere. And we get the bonus of extra oxygen in the air...
- dahfizz 5y agoWouldn't the extra oxygen get burned up as you burn the fuel? It would be a carbon neutral and oxygen neutral process.
- xvedejas 5y agoI think you're right, the oxygen would be sourced from water and water is also one major product of hydrocarbon combustion, which can be easy to forget.
- unmole 5y ago> And we get the bonus of extra oxygen in the air... Why would this be desirable?
- samplatt 5y agoLowering the density of surface co2 could result in a reduction of the cognitive impairment caused by the already-increased co2 levels. It would also mean combustible fuels of all sorts would burn more efficiently. /s, mostly
- dragontamer 5y ago
- dv_dt 5y agoThe 25% panel efficiency isn't a particularly relevant metric, and doesn't play in storage. A cost or area metric is more relevant economically.
- VBprogrammer 5y agoI think that's a very important point. For example if generating fuel from algae was only 0.5% efficient, it may not matter if the process can be conducted in open ocean.
- JulianMorrison 5y agoIt's already happening, see https://www.gov.uk/government/news/world-record-raf-flight-powered-by-synthetic-fuel https://www.gov.uk/government/news/world-record-raf-flight-p...
- Someone 5y ago> Li-Ion will never be light enough for a serious airplane Not everybody agrees with that. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_aircraft#Commercial_projects https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_aircraft#Commercial_p... says over a hundred electric designs are in development. I think some of them can be called serious airplanes.
- scarier 5y agoI think what OP meant by "serious airplane" was something that could compete with at least a regional jet for short-distance passenger transport (~50-100 seats with at least 500nm range). Almost all battery-electric aircraft in production or on the drawing board are either proofs-of-concept or geared toward hobby use, flight training, or extremely short-range air taxi services (Harbour Air is a fantastic example of a current company for whom battery-electric aircraft make sense for some commercial missions). They're serious in the sense that some of them will fly well enough to become commercially viable, but not serious in the sense of challenging current turbofan airliners for a significant share of the air transport market.
- Someone 5y agohttps://venturi.aero/#highlights https://venturi.aero/#highlights claims 50 passengers, 1,000 km, and 40% reduction in operating costs. The site doesn’t give much more info that that, so I don’t think they’re further than the drawing board, though. I considered this might be a scam or a “give us money and we’ll see whether this really can be done”, but being a startup with Delft roots (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TU_Delft_Faculty_of_Aerospace_Engineering https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TU_Delft_Faculty_of_Aerospace_...) gives them some credibility, I think.
- scarier 5y agoYeah, I have the feeling that they're still very much in the initial design phase, but even so 100% electric doesn't even imply battery-electric (and even if Venturi does plan on doing battery-electric, as their site vaguely implies, there's a good change they're basing their numbers off of an experimental battery chemistry that's being tested to replace lithium ion). Hydrogen fuel cells offer energy densities comparable to liquid fuels, although as mentioned previously they have volumetric issues due to the requirement for high-pressure and/or cryogenic storage of the hydrogen. I think the approach that these guys (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wright_Electric https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wright_Electric) are taking is more likely to work out in the near term, since their main problem is finding places in an existing airframe to store a bunch of hydrogen tanks.
- Hypx_ 5y agoThe typical mono-si solar panel is about 20-22% efficiency. For poly-si this drops to about 15%, but are cheaper and therefore still sees a lot of demand. Solar water-splitting at 13.8% is well in the range of feasible competitiveness as long as it is cheap to build.
- pfdietz 5y agoMono panels were 75% of the market in 2020, I read. A concern I'd have with this water splitting is getting the water in and the hydrogen out (and separated from the oxygen). Wires are easier than pipes. Doing this with ordinary PV also means the hydrogen production can be dispatchable. When PV output is tight, just stop making hydrogen and use the electrical power directly.
- moron4hire 5y agoKeeping the hydrogen output separate from the water input and oxygen output is easy. You feed water in to the bottom of a U shaped container. You put the hydrogen-producing electrode in one half of the U and the oxygen-producing one in the other. The hydrogen and oxygen bubble up out of the water into separate collectors.
- pjc50 5y agoThat only works with separate electrode systems; in-panel splitting (where the panel has a sheet of water directly over a catalyst) evolve both gases in the same place.
- Hypx_ 5y agoFor larger installations pipes are easier than wires.
- danuker 5y agoWhy is that? I would guess solid-state (electrons in wire) is more reliable than moving-parts (fluids in pipes).
- mr_toad 5y ago> perhaps we can make liquid fuels out of H2 We can make methane, which is a lot easier to store than hydrogen. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sabatier_reaction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sabatier_reaction
- c_o_n_v_e_x 5y agoAnd transport. We already have an existing infrastructure for methane.
- walrus01 5y ago> while hydrogen _IS_ light enough for an airplane If you do the watt-hours per kilogram calculation the very best lithium ion batteries are something like 255Wh/kg right now. Hydrogen fuel cell systems for small to medium sized UAS are somewhere in the 700-800Wh/kg range right now, including the weight of the (rather heavy, seriously engineered) ultra high pressure carbon fiber wrapped tanks needed for it, piping, and fuel cell. Something like a tank of Jet-A fuel is >4000Wh/kg. Hydrogen itself is light, the tankage systems needed to reliably contain a large volume of it on an aircraft are not.
- pjc50 5y agoIf you've got H2 on a plane it's probably lighter to just feed it to the jet engine directly rather than try to replace that with a fuel cell/motor combo which will not buy you enough efficiency gain to compensate for its weight.
- viernullvier 5y agoOr maybe not. It's not the weight of the fuel cell/motor combo that is the limiting factor, but the weight of the H2 storage tanks. An H2 jet engine will probably [0] be less efficient than a fuel cell + motor, so more H2 storage is required in order to reach a comparable performance. [0] Considering the Carnot efficiency of a jet engine at ~30%, a combination of fuel cell (~60%), motor (~95%) and propeller (~80%) will still beat it by a factor of 1.5.