12 ms·
Lithium iron phosphate batteries have about 95% round trip efficiency. Some manufacturers say 98%. AC-DC-AC conversion is around 98%-99% efficiency now. So batt
by Animats 5y ago
Lithium iron phosphate batteries have about 95% round trip efficiency. Some manufacturers say 98%. AC-DC-AC conversion is around 98%-99% efficiency now. So batteries are way ahead on efficiency.
Tesla is switching from lithium-ion to lithium iron phosphate for fixed battery installations.[1] The energy per unit weight is somewhat lower, but that doesn't matter much for fixed installations. The safety is better, too - lithium iron phosphate batteries don't have the thermal runaway problem. BYD, which is the biggest producer of batteries in the world, sells shipping container sized lithium iron phosphate sized battery packs for large scale solar backup.
[1] https://www.utilitydive.com/news/tesla-shifts-battery-chemistry-for-utility-scale-storage-megawall/600315/ https://www.utilitydive.com/news/tesla-shifts-battery-chemis...
- beerandt 5y ago>So batteries are way ahead on efficiency. Conversion efficiency is a different thing than storage efficiency or transmission efficiency. Unless your gas tank is leaking, it's efficiency as a portable energy storage device approaches 100%, especially for modern vapor sealed vehicles.
- xorcist 5y agoSolar cells are inefficient, and we should just get power off batteries instead? That's not an argument for anything, and doesn't have anything to do with the article.
- dragontamer 5y agoElectricity-to-electricity efficiency should not be compared with solar-to-electricity efficiency. The typical solar panel is maybe 25% efficient or less. The typical steam engine is maybe 50% efficient. Once things are in the form of electricity, we have a large variety of options for efficient transport and storage. But sometimes electricity isn't useful. Li-Ion will never be light enough for a serious airplane for example, while hydrogen _IS_ light enough for an airplane. (But maybe too volumetric, as every practical H2 airplane engine relies upon high-pressure storage or even cryogenics to keep H2 at a small enough volume). EDIT: If we think of it as chemistry... perhaps we can make liquid fuels out of H2 like coal liquefaction turns one fuel source into another. After all, classical fuels are nothing more than carbon + hydrogen + energy... and H2 is a very efficient form of storing energy for that reaction. Or maybe we learn to just use H2 directly? There are fuel cells and engines running on H2 today, but I'm always worried about the volume of H2 (requiring either compression or cyrogenics before you reach practicality).
- aunty_helen 5y agoGreat thing about Jet A, it's actually pretty hard to get burning. Hydrogen: See Hindenburg. I would rather not fly in a bomb. I just don't see it being viable for planes. We're starting to see short distance small planes electrify and then long haul will probably go synthetic fuels over the next 10 years.
- huntertwo 5y agoI read something that says Hindenburg was more about the mix of the gas and the material of the blimp. Properly mixed H2 doesn’t burn (it explodes quickly, which is what powers an ICE). I agree though, planes and H2 probably don’t mix. Jet fuel should not be a priority to replace with H2. Priority should be given to static applications before trying to apply it to moving vehicles.
- R0b0t1 5y agoYou are right. The issue with the Hindenberg was not the hydrogen. It was the coating. The main concern for hydrogen as a fuel now is the high pressures. If the pressure vessel is damaged it explodes due to mechanical forces. This is not impossible to work around. Consider, for example, that gas tanks can already be punctured and lead to fires; it takes a fair accounting of the risks to really rule out hydrogen as a fuel.
- jjoonathan 5y agoRight, but consider a punctured gas tank vs... well, have you played "spot the COPVs in the SpaceX explosion"? They spit fire and zoom around like party balloons. Good fun from a distance, but if I had to pick one to ride with every day, it's an easy choice in favor of the gas tank.
- R0b0t1 5y agoDo you know what the fuel is? Rockets are unique in that they carry a significant amount of oxidizer with them. A hydrogen container is unlikely to zoom around spitting fire, there's too much fuel for how much oxygen there is and it rises very quickly. There are still dangers, but practically I'm not sure they are that much worse than a gasoline fire. There are also systems that reduce the pressures needed, like activated carbon beds. Research on them stalled mostly because there was no good way to generate H2.
- huntertwo 5y agoBatteries have much lower capacity, lower cost efficiency of storage, and lower weight efficiency of storage. They’re also slower to charge and slower to discharge. Batteries are great for storing electricity efficiently as you say, but that only matters when electricity is marginally expensive (sourced from fossil fuels for example). However, if you have a cheap enough marginal cost of electricity, hydrogen is a better option because of the much cheaper fixed cost of hydrogen storage per kWH. A good way to see this: what option would you choose for storage if electricity on demand was free but only during certain parts of the day? A hydrogen tank or batteries? A hydrogen tank is cheaper. And clean energy is essentially free besides the fixed cost of the windmill/solar panel.
- jacquesm 5y ago> They’re also slower to charge and slower to discharge. Yes, but this is changing and there are a number of very interesting options. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium-titanate_battery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium-titanate_battery
- huntertwo 5y agoVery cool, there are definitely use cases where batteries are necessary (like moving vehicles) and it’s great to see advancement in battery tech. EDIT: These batteries seem to be even less energy dense than Li-ion which is one of the weaknesses of batteries in comparison to hydrogen.
- jacquesm 5y agoYes, that is their shortcoming for now, but for solar storage and such they are an interesting option.
- Someone 5y ago> Batteries are great for storing electricity efficiently In some cases not even that. Modern Lithium-ion batteries are quite good, but self-discharge still is 2-3%/month. So, if you want to store for months (say charging a battery using the summer sun to heat a house in winter), you easily lose 10% to self-discharge, in addition to what you lose between charging and discharging. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-discharge#Typical_self-discharge_by_battery_type https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-discharge#Typical_self-di... says NiMH batteries even lose 30% per month.
- superjan 5y agoFor renewable energy, low efficiency is not a problem per se: you can make as much as you want. The article also mentions that they don’t need rare materials for the electrolyser, which means it will be cheaper. Lithium, that modern batteries require, is quite rare.
- thinkcontext 5y agoThere is plenty of demand for millions of tons of hydrogen for uses that batteries are not useful for, notably, nitrogen fertilizer. Thus, advances in hydrogen production are interesting irrespective of ones views of hydrogen vs batteries.
- p1necone 5y agoTalking about efficiency with solar seems purely academic to me. Considering it's just there, it doesn't really matter what percentage of the potential energy you're capturing, just the absolute cost per watt of extraction.
- jacquesm 5y agoThere is another dimension at play here: solar is about 1KW/sq meter so efficiency directly translates into less area for the same output.
- bee_rider 5y agoAn interesting bit about the original paper linked -- from the abstract: > The trimetallic NiFeMo electrocatalyst takes the shape of nanometer-sized flakes anchored to a fully carbon-based current collector comprising a nitrogen-doped carbon nanotube network, which in turn is grown on a carbon fiber paper support. This catalyst electrode contains solely Earth-abundant materials, and the carbon fiber support renders it effective despite a low metal content. I don't know anything about chemistry so I'll have to take their word on the fact that the elements they use are abundant. The two concerns for area are: 1) The cost of panels to cover the area 2) The cost of the area itself, and the availability of a ton of empty space in a convenient location If they are using abundant materials, the first is not as much of a concern, compared to photovoltaics. Since they are producing some sort of fuel rather than directly producing electricity, transmission efficiency is not really a concern*. So maybe we could plop a bunch of these things down in some sunny middle-of-nowhere desert. * I guess is we consider vehicles to transport fuel, which must themselves burn fuel, to in some sort of abstract sense be part of the transmission efficiency, this computation could be pretty complicated.
- lazide 5y agoTo answer your question regarding commonality/ready availability - Carbon, Nitrogen, and Iron are cheap and easy (you’re likely within body length of a large quantity right now). 32% of the earths mass is estimated to be Iron. $1/lb or less in massive quantities. Nickel and Molybdenum are slightly harder to find, but not by much - nickel makes up 1.8% of the earth by mass and is a reasonably common metal in everyday manufacturing. It’s currently at $3.97/lb spot price at tonne quantities. Moly is in everything from greases to steels, and while typically not used in large bulk quantities alone, is available for such [https://tradingeconomics.com/commodity/molybden https://tradingeconomics.com/commodity/molybden] at looks like $23/lb give or take. So all commonly available elements, albeit (nanotubes) not necessarily in the form desired just yet.
- rektide 5y ago> The safety is better, too - lithium iron phosphate batteries don't have the thermal runaway problem. Relatedly, LFP are just rugged as heck batteries. They tend to have double or more the life-cycle count. 5000 cycle count before getting down to 80% capacity? In many cases yes. That's pretty impressive, and a great boon to overall lifecycle/long-term costs. Even if you're getting less energy-density, or even less energy-store/$, that battery is going to live at least 2x the effective lifespan (barring accidents, major defects, &c). In general, anything built for high current tends but lower energy density tends to have much more ruggedness. Sanyo’s UR18650E is Li(NiMnCo)O2, for example, but in one paper shows 4X the lifecycle count of the extremely well regarded O.G. of LFP, the A123 ANR26650M1-A[1]. Even though it's considered a "lithium ion". And uses some of the rarer/more expensive materials. (Edit: re-reading the paper more closely, I'm less willing to embrace this conclusion. The A123 remains around 2000 cycle count regardless of depth of discharge pattern, while the li-ion drops to 1000 around 50% DoD.) Not that phosphorous (The P in LFP) is projected to remain cheap/available forever. 2 days ago, talking more about phosphor's availability specifically with regard to agriculture (and rather alarmistly), "Phosphorus is essential to life and the world is running out of it"[2]. [1] http://www.jocet.org/vol7/511-C0056.pdf http://www.jocet.org/vol7/511-C0056.pdf [2] https://medium.com/climate-conscious/peak-phosphorus-may-be-more-alarming-than-climate-change-c6fd0fc69414 https://medium.com/climate-conscious/peak-phosphorus-may-be-... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29244529 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29244529 (2 days ago, 2 comments)
- rektide 5y agometa-note: this post has bounced up and down, 1, 2, 1, 2, 3, 1, 2. something like that. i just find that weird. hn has some weird downvoting behaviors that i really don't understand at all. maybe there's something legit downvotable or that people don't like? this seems like an innocuous post to me. i don't see the reason for it to keep getting negged. apologies. i know discussing meta-topics is against the rules. i just really dont understand why there's an ongoing basis against this content becoming popular. it's so weird to me. i want to believe there's genuine real authentic behavior behind the votes happening here & elsewhere, but it feels so so weird to see this kind of straightforward telling constantly bounded, rising, then flattened back down, again and again. it instills a larger sense of disbelief, feels like there are vulgar reactionary forces about, which is not at all a conspiracy mindset i want to fall into.
- HWR_14 5y agoYou left out the solar to electric efficiency. If that's 30% (which is an upper limit if you produce the best solar cells you can) batteries have twice as efficient a round trip loop from the sun. In return, they are far less mobile and heavier to ship once loaded. Meanwhile, we can talk about moving around H2 via pipelines. Or simply higher energy storage for big uses. (Less energy spent dragging around batteries). Plus, the batteries do require lithium, which is pretty nasty stuff to get.
- apendleton 5y agoOther people have responded about circumstances where hydrogen-as-fuel (or fuel component) might still make sense; without commenting on that, it's important to also note that hydrogen is an important industrial feedstock, independent of its potential energy applications (it's critical to producing fertilizer, among other things), and industrial hydrogen pretty much all comes from natural gas at present. Given that we need at least some hydrogen anyway, figuring out better ways to produce it is worthwhile. In that scenario, total levelized cost is the more important criterion that efficiency -- if these things convert solar energy less efficiently, but the contraption is cheaper than solar panels plus conventional electrolyzers because it's simpler or uses cheaper materials or whatever, it might still be the more economical bet.
- fghorow 5y agoAnd where exactly does the energy stored in a battery come from, do you imagine? This is PV powered production of hydrogen. Yes, the PV electricity could go directly to a battery, granted. But the PV cell is only about 20% efficient in that conversion. (Lab results are up to 30%.) There are use cases where rather than an electrical transmission line needing to span an ocean, energy could be stored chemically (e.g. in hydrogen, or hydrocarbons produced from them) and transported like LNG across an ocean. The claim of 95% round trip efficiency is basically relevant if the the energy is to be consumed (or placed on a grid) near the point of production. Otherwise 65% (13%/20%) efficiency for chemical energy that can be physically transported is not too bad. Hydrogen is a battery from the perspective of a renewable energy system. If it is produced as a byproduct of a fossil fuel (as is commonly done) IMHO, it is not a renewable resource at all. Producing it from solar PV is a completely different kettle of fish.
- exyi 5y agoyea, but batteries are still quite expensive (I mean on a grid scale) and the cost does not get better with scale. Storing H2 is much cheaper and will also probably scale sublinearly (simplified: you pay for the wall of the tank and the wall is only volume^(3/2)). Also, h2 can be transported, traded, ... whatever, batteries are impractical for this and cables also have limitations. However, I see one big down to hydrogen. You can't tell how it was made, you rely on a promise that it's green, while it may actually be from methane... maybe with carbon storage, but you never know when that is gonna leak out. This might be a big loophole for fossil fuel corps / states
- elihu 5y agoApparently there are also some major patents that have expired or are expiring soon, which I hope means that costs will drop and we'll start seeing more LiFePO4 battery manufacturers outside of China where the vast majority are made now.
- cronix 5y ago> BYD, which is the biggest producer of batteries in the world, sells shipping container sized lithium iron phosphate sized battery packs for large scale solar backup. Tesla has been playing in that space too with their Megapack. https://www.tesla.com/en_AU/blog/introducing-megapack-utility-scale-energy-storage https://www.tesla.com/en_AU/blog/introducing-megapack-utilit... There was a pretty bad fire with them in Australia. https://www.reuters.com/technology/tesla-megapack-fire-australia-blamed-undetected-coolant-leak-2021-09-28/ https://www.reuters.com/technology/tesla-megapack-fire-austr...
- stubish 5y agoIt is a stretch to call it a bad fire. One of the battery containers caught fire, and caused a second to be lost for reasons I don't know. The fire didn't spread, did not destroy the facility and did not require extensive downtime for repairs. Which is pretty nice to know as the fear was that one spark would send the whole facility up in a fireball.
- cronix 5y ago> It is a stretch to call it a bad fire. One of the battery containers caught fire, I suppose it's relative, but it seems it's a very good thing that only one caught because > A giant Tesla battery pack caught on fire at a building in Australia, and it took 150 firefighters and four days to contain the blaze. https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/technology/after-tesla-megapack-battery-burst-into-flames-it-took-150-firefighters-to-put-fire-out/ar-AAMQSNQ https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/technology/after-tesla-megapa... 150 firefighters taking 4 days to put it out. It certainly could have been worse, but I don't think it's a stretch to say it was pretty bad.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jtsiskin 5y agoThat's not a comparison. Hydrogen goes Sun -> storage -> DC. Solar panels go Sun -> DC -> storage -> DC. You're comparing (Sun -> storage) against (DC -> storage -> DC). You need to include hydrogen fuel cell efficiency and solar panel efficiency for a (Sun -> .. storage .. -> DC) comparison.
- iso1210 5y agoThis method goes Sun -> Hydrogen -> DC 100kwh of Solar energy generates 13.8kWh of Hydrogen, which is about 50% efficent thus generates 7kWh of DC Going direct to DC is 23%, and the battery layer drops that to 20%, so 20kWh - about 3 times as efficient if you are using storage. That's not bad, there are many applications where you'll take the extra land/solar take to provide the flexibility and density hydrogen can provide. Sure not for normal grid connected and static usage, but for mobile and temporary usage. And that's not to mention all the other uses of hydrogen in industry that, without this method, would have to be generated by Sun->DC->Electrolysis
- andrew_ 5y agoLiFePO batteries are also getting a lot of love from the marine community. I recently installed one on my boat to replace three lead acid and the weight savings alone will make up the difference in cost in fuel savings over the course of the year, not to mention the current generation last longer than lead acid in that environment.
- newyankee 5y agoI love LFP batteries and feel they are not given enough importance in the energy transition future. I was wondering by chance if there is a way to estimate the material amount used in these batteries to check if their limiting factor in scaling is lower than typical high Nickel batteries. I was wondering if Phosphate is a concern if not Lithium.
- scythe 5y agoThe original technology is properly lithium-nickel dioxide. Elements such as manganese, cobalt and aluminum appear as minor constituents. Both Li-NiO2 and Li-FePO4 are based on conduction of lithium ions in the electrolyte ("Lead-acid" would be sulfate-ion by this naming convention; alkaline batteries are hydroxide-ion).
- walrus01 5y ago> AC-DC-AC conversion is around 98%-99% efficiency now. I'd really like to see some citations with specifiic BOMs of equipment that can accomplish this, because the datacenter industry would like to have something like that, but it's my understanding that the efficiency is nowhere near that 98-99% figure.
- teekert 5y agoIt's also about energy/kilogram, especially in Aviation.
- GuB-42 5y agoPedantry alert. Lithium iron phosphate is lithium-ion. What Tesla is doing is changing the cathode material from Lithium nickel cobalt aluminium oxides (NCA) to Lithium iron phosphate (LFP). Other cathodes materials include LMO, LCO and NMC. NCA has the best energy density, LFP is the best in everything else, including price, NMC is somewhat in the middle and LCO and LMO are becoming obsolete.
- TomK32 5y agoI might be mistaken on storing hydrogen, but all that takes in a high pressure container. I can imagine putting those solar-to-hydrogen plants up at sunny but remote places with plenty of space. Once a month when the containers are full a train comes along, unhooks cars with empty containers and goes off with the full ones. If you were to do that with any sort of battery you'd need two batteries, one be charged, one being used/discharged elsewhere, and your battery (for lack of a better term) efficiency (Total cost of usage?) basically halves.
- iso1210 5y agoLikewise the other way, say you need power at a building site for a couple of years, you can do that by delivering hydrogen bottles to replenish your generator, rather than having to take charged batteries and swap them out somehow.
- raxxorrax 5y agoThis is electrical to kinetic energy, which is an entirely different story. The sun basically provides unlimited energy, so efficiency isn't as important.
- ncmncm 5y agoThis is a critical point. All of the hottest utility-scale storage technologies have really quite poor round-trip efficiency, but it doesn't matter. Lower efficiency requirements so radically reduce the system cost that you add more cheap generating capacity on top, and come out ahead. There is not now, and never will be, any shortage of available land area for solar panels. Almost every place you can think of to put them improves the place. On a reservoir, crop land, pasture land, canal, they reduce evaporation, and run cooler than in the desert. On crop and pasture land, they reduce heat stress and water demand in the plants, improving yield and irrigation efficiency. On roofs and parking lots, they slow sun damage. On parking lots they even keep the rain off.