12 ms·
What does microblogging give you that forums didn't?
- agumonkey 5y agoSome interesting views here. Simple things I never considered :) Thanks
- ggm 5y agog+ but with boolean operator terms on the circles so you could say "to @friends && not Joe" to say "surprise birthday party for Joe" I never understood why google (of all people) think we're too dumb for simple logical expressions on and/or/not with bracing for precedence. They are applicable to almost everything they do, in search and in services with search features (gmail) or selection/specification features.
- wheelerof4te 5y agoMan, forums are a time-sinker already. Imagine spending even more time running and managing your own micro blog. Also, why even contribute to micro-anything?
- Spooky23 5y agoYou get the illusion of a private resource but access to the Public.
- dredmorbius 5y agoFor an alternate view of the thread: https://www.solipsys.co.uk/Chartodon/107293553460323203.svg https://www.solipsys.co.uk/Chartodon/107293553460323203.svg
- pndy 5y agoA svg file?
- dredmorbius 5y agoIt's a graphviz-generated thread visualisation using a tool created by ColinWright.
- Grumbledour 5y agoI am always amazed people liked g+ circles so much. I often found them rather clumsy and isolating. Maybe I just don't get what people want out of these platforms? I was always more of a forum type and also more reader than participant. Looking at circles specifically, I often saw patterns of "Everyone tell me what you want to read about so I can put you in the right circle" which meant you had to manually subscribe and unsubscribe by private message and could often see nothing at all if you didn't want to contact that person. This is of course nice for privacy and getting to personally know people, but I found it really hindering to discussion and a having a usable archive of a community. Of course, google+, like most modern social media, was also people-centric instead of topic centric, which always annoyed me, but many people seem to like? It still was a network where I read many cool things and had interesting discussion, but I felt like it was a watered down replacement of forums even back then.
- ghaff 5y agoOne obvious use case of circles was having a personal and a professional circle. While I just have a single handle on Twitter, my personal content is also highly innocuous. There are definitely situations where you don't want to swizzle everything together.
- dredmorbius 5y agoFor that, though, you ultimately want groups. The problem with G+ Circles (or Diaspora* Aspects, which were an earlier version of the same thing) is that the people and profiles in your circles have no idea how you've classified them. One persistent argument in the early years of G+ was some Circler yelling at other a Circlee whom the Circler had classified invisibly to the Circlee that "they (the Circlee) were holding it wrong" --- not posting to G+ in the way in which the Circler had anticipated. It turns out that what you actually really want are groups, not Circles. (Preferably some kind of light-weight group with an easy join/quit dynamic and little overhead, but also robust moderation tools for larger cases, another aspect G+ never delivered on.) I ranted about G+ failings for a long time, but ultimately reached a rather frustrated equanimity about it. At one point I commented to the effect that "It's a simple tool, designed for simple problems." That is, it lacked many features I and others would have liked to see. One of the people +1'ing that particular post was Google+'s chief architect. The best use I've found for Circles is to group profiles very roughly by interest level, usually into 2--4 tiers, from greatest to least interest. This permits following a fairly large group (though I prefer keeping even that limited) but without being overwhelmed by content. I've used that model on G+, Diaspora*, and Mastodon, pretty effectively.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoI think what we've lost on the modern Internet from forums is a stable-ish social order. You knew people in a different way, remembered names and faces, understood personalities and attitudes. Some came and went but for the most part, there was some sort of community with social hierarchy and structure, agreed-upon values. I think losing that is a large part of why Internet discussion has kind of turned to shit. Lacking real belonging, people create ephemeral tribes out of their perceived identity instead.
- mettamage 5y agoIt's a little bit ironic that you mention that here, since I do feel that way on HN. And yes, I do recognize usernames occasionally and I also get recognized (and emailed!) on occasion :)
- marginalia_nu 5y agoHN sort of straddles old forums and new social media. I think a large part of what made people so recognizable was avatars and signatures. It's a bit of a shame they went away.
- reidjs 5y agoI disagree, I think avatars/signatures added a lot of noise to the conversation and made it harder to follow. I like HN's approach where if you want to check someone's profile, it exists, but it requires a small amount of effort (one click).
- Agentlien 5y agoI feel like HN has more of the feel to it of a typical forum but it's missing a bit in the relationship building department. I was quite active in a few forums many years ago where I knew all the regular folks and made a few lifelong friends. But despite being quite active on HN for 6 years (and lurking much longer) I only recognize a handful of names, rarely see them comment, and don't think anyone is aware that I exist. I believe it's because, like Reddit, it's a bit too big for that type of interactions.
- strogonoff 5y agoSome individuals gravitate to self-centered mediums—“their own” blog, microblog, and so on. They seek a platform. Perhaps they find it daunting to fit into an existing community. Perhaps they don’t want to deal with figuring out the unwritten rules and being rejected by unknown human moderators—they’d rather learn the technical tricks of the platform. Perhaps they think their thoughts are worth more than a drop in the sea of a big community. Perhaps they have something to promote or are better at strategy and creating a personal brand. Other people find it easier to participate in a forum. They seek a community. Perhaps they’d rather defer to human moderators they trust for sustaining the community and maintaining the vibe. Perhaps the prospect of setting up a self-centered medium—and then networking, learning the techniques of promotion in order to get any readers, locking themselves into a fixed public “personality”, etc.—feels daunting to them. Perhaps they consider bits of attention (karma, responses) granted to them as a result of community participation to be worth more.
- dredmorbius 5y agoI've used both types of platforms, often with differing goals in mind. Creating my own space enables me to provide or define a structure into which contributions are placed. I've found the structures (or structurelessness) of virtually all third-party platforms to be ultimately highly distracting and unsuited. (My own structures also usually show their own weaknesses over time. This doesn't keep me from trying to improve on them, and perhaps find a different form (e.g., non-hiearachical, multiple dimensions or facets) that affords greater utility.) Organising and managing all of this is incredibly time-intensive. (The fact that I've been more-or-less attempting to do this under a set of increasingly adversarial external circumstances for much of a decade ... rather proves this point.) If a personally-managed platform gives structure, then large public fora give reach, exposure, and increased potential for engagement (though very often of a much lower quality than a specifically-focused space). These are trade-offs. I make them with a strong awareness of them. Virtually any general-public forum becomes immensely noisy. Whist illuminating tangents are gold, irrelevant or very tired ones are rather less so (see HN's own guidelines for avoiding shallow and/or dogmatic diversions). Having to repeatedly address the same very basic points becomes tiresome, and the inability to bundle, aggregate, and address in mass repetitive and tiresome points is a particular source of pain. Temporality is very often the principle (or only) organising mechanism, and any substantive discussion developing over time is actively deprecated and pushed out of public view by newer material, that almost always of vastly lower interest. (Power laws: high value is of much lower frequency.) Time-ordered presentation inherently promotes low-quality content. (This affects HN as well. I've commented that at least via Algolia Search it's possible to find the highest-ranked (if not necessarily best) stories of a given period: day, week, month, year, or other: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28806795 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28806795) An extreme frustration I have with federated protocols to date has been their lack of effective search. Mastodon and Diaspora* both exhibit this. HN has been more useful to me in many ways due to its excellent Algolia-based search capabilities. Reddit has no comment search at all, but pretty powerful post-based search, which for "self-post" based subreddits proves reasonably useful. I've remarked for years on how the instructional method used by the Scholastics of lectio, meditatio, and quaestio seems as if it might be very useful to resurrect, though how to do this effectively in an asynchronous distributed format is a real challenge. Paraphrasing slightly: - lectio is Reading the Fine Article. It emerged as practice because books were literally worth more than gold, and too expensive to grant students their own copy. A university lecture was often literally the professor reading the book to the class. - meditatio was an interval in which the content was considered and reflected on, before questions and disputes were raised. - quaestio was a submission of questions based on the passage. Thse were asked, but not immediately answered (a practice still observed by some institutions, the London School of Economics comes to mind where 5--6 questions are asked, then answered in one pass by the speaker). Disputationes were explorations of controversies. It's all very ... mediaeval ... but also at least ensures that the disucssion 1) is based on having been exposed to (if not informed by) the material and 2) questions and commentary are moderated and managed in a way that should encourage substance and minimise disruption. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scholasticism#Scholastic_method https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scholasticism#Scholastic_metho... What we have now faces markedly different circumstances: - Reproduction of content (textual, audio, images, video) is trivial. Getting everyone to access that at the same time is ... harder. (Oddly: in the broadcast world, especially before personal recording systems were prevalent, this was less the case.) - Conversations occur with participants distributed across space, and often at least staggered in time. Most significantly focus and attention are rarely concentrated on any one specific discussion. Spatial orientation, literally gathering participants within a single chamber, affords far greater attentive orientation. We are trading reach for focus. - Assuring and assessing RTFMedness is difficult. Much discussion is initiated by little or no awareness of the actual material at all. (Mind: I do this myself as much as anyone, though I try to be aware of it and chide myself not to.) - Questions and discussions tend to be less rather than more moderated. There are exceptions, but they're rare. Odds that a given discussion remains productive and reasonably focused on a large / general-access site are quite low. Where threads can be personally-managed (e.g., Diaspora*), I've managed to at least have a few smaller-scale, longer-term, and productive discussions (often 4-10 participants, but lasting over days or weeks, occasionally months). All of this of course assumes that substantive discussion (or even just good shitposting) is a primary goal of such platforms. Most often it's not; advertising reveue is the overarching consideration. Sadly this is sort of an anti-Midas touch: everything it comes in contact with turns to shit. It's also long struck me that pairing a discussion and wiki (or other distillative format) site would be a superpower of sorts. Reddit's exceedingly anaemic Wiki functionality offers the merest of hints of this potential power, and the fact that that's not been more significantly developed remains a major disappointment.
- aethertron 5y ago"Microblogging" (or "social media") has life in it, as long as people like to blather on, but forums are dead. Why are they dead? Because their lifespans were limited. The Death of Discussion by icycalm explains how that happened with videogames forums: https://www.patreon.com/posts/end-of-20685789 https://www.patreon.com/posts/end-of-20685789 (paywall'd) The deeper discussion-worthiness of each forum's respective subject matter was exhausted. All that's left is rehashing the same old topics ad nauseum, or scholarish cataloguing work, or reacting to news.
- julianlam 5y agoI disagree with this wholeheartedly. To think that a discussion is meritless simple because it has already been discussed is so short-sighted! Even on HN, multiple times monthly a link will make the front page whose content was originally posted years (even decades) ago. Does that mean the follow-up discussion is pointless? No.
- aethertron 5y agoSure, some re-hashing is meritorious. But there are diminishing returns.
- giantrobot 5y ago> But there are diminishing returns. Why? Just because some topic was discussed on some site once doesn't mean all possible ideas were expressed on that topic. Unless the users of a site are static and unchanging there's going to be new members seeing that old topic for the first time. It's ok to talk about old things. I like that HN allows reposts (within reason) and people typically link to previous discussions in the new discussion. You can see the old points made about a topic but then take a look at the new ones. A lot of forums have similar policies on thread necromancy. And it encourages discussion and even just revisiting interesting topics. The social media All New All the Time content treadmill leads to shallow discussion.
- 5y ago
- mogadsheu 5y agoIn one word, distribution. Unlike forums, social media has an unlimited audience.
- raspyberr 5y ago>Unlike forums, social media has an unlimited audience. What does that even mean?
- Uberphallus 5y agoCritical mass. FB groups are a dumpster fire for topic discussions, but the fact that they're just there means loads of communities end up there anyway.
- dredmorbius 5y agoAn interesting observation I took away from Google+ Communities engagement data (I had a full database of 8 million+ communities, most with membership counts, and the interactions on the most recent posts (up to 10) for each. What I observed, loosely, was: - There were far fewer very large communities than a strict log-log relation would have estimated, by a factor of roughly 3--10. - Interactions per post seemed very loosely to peak at about 10,000 members. Given user attrition and various participation heuristics (e.g., the 90-9-1 rule), a 10,000 member community might be expected to have about 100 active members, and maybe 1,000 occasional participants, with the remainder nominally lurkers, and quite possibly entirely absent. 100 people is pretty close to the Dunbar Number, and would give an activity rate that would be sufficient to provide meaningful interactions but also a social cohesion. I'd have had to look at the actual historyof these communities to see what trends and tendencies actually existed. I didn't, and the data are no longer available AFAIU. But what I did not, just from plotting activity against membership, was that there is such a thing as "too big". It'd be interesting to see what the corresponding situation for FB is.
- mogadsheu 5y ago> What does that even mean? It’s provocative (s/o Blades of Glory/Jay Z and Kanye) But in all seriousness, the audience of a forum is basically limited to the forum, because there are hurdles to sharing beyond most standard forums. Most social media platforms however, encourage sharing and the networks are connected, so posts there have larger potential audiences and fewer barriers to go viral.
- onion2k 5y agoVery simple - the ability to read something without needing to sign up first. Twitter is public. I can read and share things without an account. That's a massive benefit (and a massive downside). The terse nature of microblogging limited what people posted about in the early days too. There was a lot less 'deep' content. That changed for the worse with the advent of longer tweets and proper threads; now many people treat Twitter like it's essentially just a weird blogging platform.
- ajsnigrutin 5y agoMost forums needed you to be registered only if you wanted to post stuff.. so the same as twitter... but without the character limits, with file uploads, etc.
- Lifelarper 5y ago> Twitter is public I'd highly suggest you logout of twitter and try instead using it in private mode in a browser manually navigating. Bonus points for trying on mobile. I remember trying to explain to a store that I couldn't access their Facebook business page because I didn't have an account and she still found it hard to believe even after me demonstrating it. Many inside the walled gardens only see the pretty plants.
- wffurr 5y agoA non crappy UI is the big one. Forums almost universally suck.
- dredmorbius 5y agoCare to define "non-crappy", and/or what specific elements suck?
- raspyberr 5y agoIn the link's discussion someone mentioned they liked the shorter character limit. I frequently see people posting what are essentially full-length articles broken up into chunks.
- frosted-flakes 5y agoBut each chunk is a fully-formed thought that can stand on its own, and has its own reply thread. It's like Medium's highlight replies, except not clunky.
- streamofdigits 5y agoHow different is really microblogging from forums? Given how simple this entire domain (we are really talking about different database views of rather simple sets data points) it should be really easy to structure things so that people get the "slice" and experience they are interested in and comfortable with.
- tester34 5y ago>How different is really microblogging from forums? From user standpoint? Significant. No any "modern" approach, let it be - reddit, twitter, hackernews, fb groups, discord, mailing lists maybe? gets even close when it comes to quality/merit of discussions that forum can enable
- streamofdigits 5y agoI mean from a technical server / client perspective. I agree that from a user perspective it can create very different "illusions" and (over the long run) even modify people's behavior - which is scary if you think about it: simple choices at the technical level can change society
- tester34 5y agoIf you added "Categories" to HN (group by business, startups, programming, yada yaa) added notifications on reply removed three-like structure and allowed threads to be bumped then you'd have forum which would mean that you'd have longer and deeper discussions
- dredmorbius 5y agoThere's a view that takes a hybrid approach and utilises microblogs (typically Twitter or Mastodon) to provide / curate comments on blog posts or essays. To that extent, the approaches are complements. I'm very leery of unmoderated comments these days, but combining focus of a blog with reach of microblogging seems a reasonably decent match.
- jacobmischka 5y agoI have almost entirely given up Twitter, though I often miss the ability to just send passing thoughts into a void. I'm currently casually working on a home-rolled microblog I plan to embed on my personal site as a replacement. Writing these silly thoughts down and just saving them in a document is another option, but doesn't quite feel the same. At the same time, they're often too silly for me to want to send them to a friend directly. Microblogs fill an interesting niche between those two.
- catlikesshrimp 5y agoForums are for people who have something to say. Tweets are for people following others and mostly grunting. When I imagine people "participating" in microblogs, I imagine middle and highschoolers wearing several tiny badges they might not even know the meaning of. Greenpeace, Boyscouts, NERV leaf, Red Cross, Smiley Face, Che Guevara, and so on
- wheelerof4te 5y agoNERV leaf? Oh God, I'm having nightmare flashbacks to the End of Evangelion. What are they, EVA zealots?
- kubb 5y agoThe ability to share a link to your post on HN, or other social media.
- nirui 5y agoSpeak of G+, I personally really love the idea: You have a personal space to post private stuff, you can set permission on who can read and who can't, and beyond that, G+ supports group where it functions like a forum where you can do your forum stuff and meet new people (Yeah... just like Facebook). However, the implementation was rather poor. It's slow to load (under my network), it's unfriendly for long contents, it's almost impossible to have detailed discussions, and you still need multiple accounts to separate your personal and professional profile (Just like... you know, Facebook). I'm not actively using Mastodon, but I'm a fan of their general idea where they're trying to let the information to flow from one site to another. However, if I got it right, Mastodon is trying to be "(just) another Twitter" if you look beyond the aspect of decentralization. Now, if I put my Hat of Imagination on, personally, I think what the Internet really need, is a place/service/network where people can gather, explore and then got inspired. Those "web 1.0" forums are designed to do exactly that. So if it was me who's designing these kind of system: - I'll put discussions related features as the utmost priority, and follower&following comes the second or third - Not just a "forum-like" flat page discussions, I mean a structured discussions that lets you trace all conversations to figure out "Why we're talking about this now?" quickly and allows you to filter out "non-important" replies, that's the core of the system - The "Twitter-ish" feature can be build on top of that discussion system - I'll make it so everybody can host the system. You can put it on a 128MB memory router for you and your family, or a cluster of servers to provide service for the public, all the same good experience - The systems exchanges data automatically between sites based on user interactions and follows etc. That also means the user can read contents from remote sites all on their local site.
- 0xdeadb00f 5y agoI made heavy use of G+, circles and whatnot. It was genuinely a pretty decent experience. And there's quite a few more people on there than you'd expect.
- julianlam 5y agoMicroblogs give you the network effect - which is not an insurmountable problem with forum software, it's just one that hasn't really been explored effectively. So, "reach". The other part of it, I think, is that microblogs are quantity over quality. It's not mutually exclusive, of course. You'll see deep-dives in microblogs, and meaningless drivel on forums, but the system itself is built in such a way to promote either long-form content, or not. It's much easier to fire off a thought with minimal substance on a microblog. Not that that's a bad thing at all - sometimes a fleeting thought shouted into the wind is what you really want.
- toddwprice 5y agoADHD
- MisterBastahrd 5y agoDecentralized topic moderation is better than centralized topic moderation because it allows users to choose what they want to talk about instead of waiting for admins to approve those topics.
- riantogo 5y agoI'm very much a forums person (reddit, hn etc.) and never "got" twitter even after many attempts. But I think on forums front there is a missing economic model. Currently the platforms make all the money on the back of content generated by the community. I think the time has come to focus on enabling forum owners to monetize. Over covid I built https://discoflip.com https://discoflip.com to validate this. I would be very interested in your feedback.
- abruzzi 5y agoI fequently see the comment that forums are dead, and there is no one on them, so i want to ask--what type of forum is your experience with? i.e. what is the topic or field the forum is dedicated to? I ask because the 5 or 6 forums I frequent are very active. I just checked the online stats for one of the bigger ones and it currently has 1288 registered members online with 1491 guests (out of a total registered members of 405,506.) That one is big, so it requires a lot of subforums to keep the information orderly, but there are smaller ones that are still active too. The smallest I frequent (on a very esoteric topic for most) currently has 103 members online with 896 guests. I can keep up with most of the posts on that one, but 2/3rds are on topic that don't interest me, so the forum layout makes it easy to stick to just what interests me. The reason for my question, is I wonder--topic dictates audience, are some audiences more microblogging friendly and so have jumped ship from forums, where the topics I'm interested in are more old-guy friendly so us luddites stick to the forums we've been on since 1999?
- Grumbledour 5y agoWhile I am not in the "forums are dead camp" per se, I just yesterday searched for forums on vintage/retro computers and found some that didn't look very active. Granted, they had far to many subfora, so maybe I just missed the active corners, but there was very much a "last post 3 months ago" vibe, including threads about the question if the scene was dying. Though really, the main problem with good forums is actually finding them in the first place. If no one points you at one, google might just be no help at all. Of course, discourse invitations seem even more obscure these days, so its probably just the way things are now?
- fsflover 5y ago> Though really, the main problem with good forums is actually finding them in the first place. If no one points you at one, google might just be no help at all. Try https://wiby.me https://wiby.me.
- abruzzi 5y agoIt is a delicate balance maintaining the right number of sub fora. One of my favorite a decade ago (electro-music.com) is still there but is very very dead, I think because they have something like 100 sub forums, so you would need a 1000 daily posting users to make it seem active. On the other hand, you have forums (gearspace.com) which don't seem to have enough subs so the main forums (I mostly go for the Electronic music forum) which makes it seem a little too busy or chaotic.
- TehShrike 5y agoThe ability to filter what you see by unfollowing low-value posters is vastly underrated by most readers. This pushes me towards something like Twitter or Mastodon. Most people don't like to unfollow people for various reasons – forums have the advantage of (typically) putting culture enforcement in the hands of a group, not on the casual reader.
- wink 5y agoI don't even understand the question. I went to forums because there was stuff about a certain topic. I follow people on twitter because I like what they write. Sometimes that is about a certain topic, but usually not. Maybe it is the entry point how I got to know them, but not more. Twitter for me is 90% about personal connections, people I've known from work, from IRC, from conferences and sometimes people I've not interacted before. So it's the same as following people's blogs, just micro. I am not subscribing to any curated lists, not following trending topics, etc.pp. Disclaimer: I am following < 150 and < 100 people on my 2 disjunct twitter accounts.
- MisterBastahrd 5y agoMicroblogging allows users to express themselves without the confines of being stuck within the boundaries of a particular topic. Microblog moderation tends to be a hell of a lot more hands-off than forum moderation for that reason. Microblogging does not need to wait for a topic to be approved before it can be discussed, and people are free to follow microbloggers for their insights in a way that doesn't really exist in forums. Forums are walled gardens. Microblogs are blank canvases. We don't need a "forum protocol." We have Usenet. Also, many people don't really want to have in-depth discussions with their friends on the internet. What they REALLY want to do is follow famous people and intellectuals and share their thoughts to THOSE people in the hopes of getting noticed.
- mikewarot 5y agoIt's all about timeframe and feedback for me. If you want to just throw things out into the universe, and hope that someday it will help someone... put it on a blog, and Google will eventually find it, and it might help someone, eventually. If I want to discuss an idea, and get feedback on a shorter timescale, I have to leave out Google, and go where the audience is.
- skuthus 5y agoconsistent uptime, apparently
- rchaud 5y ago> @tindall honestly... mobile versions. forums just stopped being developed and then that was that I didn't think about this, and it's a really good point. Around 2011 or so, we were at the inflexion point where blog comment sections and forums were losing audiences to social media. It's true that many forums simply did not have a mobile theme, because they were set up by hobbyists who accidentally became webmasters. Not sure if vBulletin and phpBB saw the need for mobile themes. I remember that the biggest Liverpool FC forum online had a desktop only theme as recently as 2014. That gap ended up being filled by an app called Tapatalk, which pulled in data from message board APIs in a native app setting. It was the dominant forum app because it supported all the big messageboard frameworks. And wouldn't you know it, it started filling the app with ads and subscription upsells. I can imagine many people abandoned the app, and maybe threw out the baby with the bath water by abandoning the forum as well.
- JeremyReimer 5y agophpBB added a mobile theme that works pretty well, but many sites didn't bother to upgrade. Mostly this was because the upgrade was difficult and required multiple steps (first updating to the latest sub-version, then to the major version, then to the latest sub-version of the major version) and if anything went wrong in any of the steps you could take down your board. And if you had any custom code, as the forum operators at Ars Technica had, it was just too difficult and too much of a time investment to even attempt. So phpBB, which was one of the most dominant forum software applications when forums were at their peak, became known as "old-school" and "non mobile-friendly" when that was technically not true but it was de-facto true. The Ars Technica forums today still exist but they are difficult to view on mobile, and as a consequence their traffic has declined significantly in the last ten years, despite traffic to the main site increasing.
- powersnail 5y agoMicro-blogging gives you a chance to be an introverted extrovert. There is a different mental model: posting to a personal timeline that is free to be read, rather than adding your voice to a stack of existing discussions. Posting on a forum is an open invitation for discussion, and it requires a level of preparedness that is defined by the culture of that specific forum. It implies two requirements: to provide something talk-able, and to talk with people. Posting irrelevant or untalkable content is frowned upon, and ban-able if frequent enough. People treat forum as a community blackboard, and don't like it when someone is drawing random dots every day. Second, the necessity of Q&A is implied. You expect people to interact with you, and people expect you to interact with them. Dropping a post and never replying to the comments is bad etiquette. A micro-blog, on the other hand, is your blog. It's almost entirely yours, and it's you alone who define the culture of interaction. Well, the platform has moderation policies, but beyond that, you are free of expectations. You can post non-sense, bad jokes, or randomly generated words. Many micro-bloggers only make announcements and never replies. Some replies some times, to a selected a few. And if some nosy commenters criticize your posting habit, it's on them to unfollow you. The blackboard is in your own yard after all. Who cares if it's all noise and no signal? Why go out of your way to follow me if you got a problem with my posts? --- That is not to say that no one uses a forum like a micro-blog, or vice versa. But the normative behaviors tend to gravitate towards different places.
- lostgame 5y agoReddit has found a nice in between, I’ve found - of forums and social media. The best part of finding a forum was finding a very small group of people with the same obscure niche interest as you, and communicating with the community around that. This is what - say - Twitter, lacks - while Reddit does an okay job at it. :) Anyone else feel this way?
- dredmorbius 5y agoNumerous very conscious Reddit design concepts and mechansism actively thwart intelligent and considered discussion. That's why I've virtually entirely curtailled my participation there. I'd noted this long ago. It's gotten worse since. https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/20yhxc/reddit_and_community_what_works_what_raises_flags/ https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/20yhxc/reddit_...
- jeffreyrogers 5y agoThe only real advantage that I see is that it's where all the people are. The discussions on forums are better than what you get on twitter (even today) and it is easier to find old content. HN is sort of a cross between a forum and something like twitter. Content moves off the front page pretty quick so it rarely makes sense to reply to a post that is more than a day or so old if you want people to reply to you. Since most forums are relatively slow places you can catch up on things at your leisure and important threads stick around for a long time as people debate things and add to them.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jrm4 5y agoI was very hesitant about Twitter -- but I've had wonderful little micro-interactions with the likes of Nassim Nicholas Taleb, MC Hammer, Killer Mike, Jean Grae and Tucker Max to pretty much name all the cool and famous ones. Not that fame is the greatest thing in the world to chase, but this is, like, EXACTLY the level of interaction I want with them, and probably the same for them with me. If we could somehow port this "reach" through a thing like Mastodon, that would be amazing.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- BeFlatXIII 5y agoIMO, the single login of Reddit is what killed off forums. Twitter+Tumblr "communities" are mostly people who never were active on forums in the first place.
- sircastor 5y agoI’ve been contemplating that problem in relation to Facebook. I had a forum that had relatively low activity, and the sole admin disappeared. When I finally got ahold of him, he suggested start a Facebook group. While I think this would have less friction to discover, I find Facebook groups to be super disjointed. It feels more like a bunch of people talking at the group, rather than conversations, and it feels very transitory - which falls in line with Facebook’s approach: the most important thing is what’s next.
- BeFlatXIII 5y agoI agree with your thoughts on FB groups. They are also even more prone to repost spam and unintentional circlejerking than Reddit because the half-life of visibility of each post is even shorter and both have non-functional search buttons. While Reddit posts get hard-locked after six months, FB posts simply disappear into the datacenter.
- 0xdeadb00f 5y agoI used to have an account on cybre.space. Then one day after not logging in for a month or two my account was gone. I assumed there was some major mastodon upgrade I missed or something and they nuked all the accounts.
- FalconSensei 5y agoSounds more like something with your instance. I didn't use my mastodon.social account for a couple years and when I went back a few weeks ago, everything was still there
- hlbjhblbljib 5y agoI hate having to make accounts for every fucking forum, so I don't. Didn't even have an HN account, but thought that was so cogent I would create this throwaway
- renewiltord 5y agoForums are centralized planning. Microblogs are the free market. Your feed is precisely what you design it to be. If you say "4chan /b/ is terrible", it can have meaning. If you say "Twitter is terrible", it doesn't have meaning because ultimately you only receive things you subscribe to on the latter. You can only say "The Twitter feed I've made is shit". Of course, Twitter isn't perfect. You can click through to the replies and see replies from people you dislike to people you like.
- lovefeature 5y agoyes,I will create two social network named: https://www.alovez.com/ https://www.alovez.com/ : support public and private groups,events,public page,person home,person store.
- timvisee 5y agoI hate microblogging with a passion. I find those threads extremely annoying/cumbersome/unusable to read, because it always has a lot of noise around it. Especially on Twitter.
- jrnichols 5y agoI still use a few forums, but what lured me away from some of them years ago was the fact that either reddit or Facebook had groups about everything in one place, and without all of the spam that the forums were starting to suffer from. Same with usenet. Groups are great but the spam was relentless and difficult to filter out after a while. after some very negative experiences with reddit as a whole, I barely use it and now seek out dedicated forums. Same with Facebook. I no longer feel that the single sign on world has the benefit that it used to.