11 ms·
> This is the first anti-Ivermectin argument that you want to believe... I discounted a highly biased echo chamber in social media and more traditional media a
by roenxi 5y ago
> This is the first anti-Ivermectin argument that you want to believe...
I discounted a highly biased echo chamber in social media and more traditional media and went with 30-odd studies that appear to have been assembled in good faith even now. I changed my mind immediately on seeing "Parasitic worms are a significant confounder in some ivermectin studies, such that they made them get a positive result even when honest and methodologically sound: 50% confidence".
You are describing how you want me to be thinking, not how I am thinking.
- jacquesm 5y agoI have a pretty good memory for comment histories and you've been pushing this for far more than it is worth. That this single article would change your mind is fortunate, but I do not suspect that to hold true for the bulk of the conspiracy peddlers that remain.
- roenxi 5y agoFor the spectators, here is the comment I am thinking of: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29235165 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29235165
- nzmsv 5y agoIsn't this an example of some rigid and ineffective thinking patterns? Article publishes sound arguments, doesn't talk down to the audience, admits problems with appeals to authority... and converts a conspiracy believer! ...No way, there is no way that can possibly work, the others are way too dumb, and the convert is a bad person... basically anything to just go back to pretending appeals to authority work. Despite clear evidence to the contrary. Or lamenting that they don't. I'm drawing some parallels with miracle cures here ;)
- jacquesm 5y agoI've been following with some amazement the number of conspiracy peddlers on HN for the last 18 months or so and one case of conversion isn't going to make me overly happy. It is a bit like the story about the lie getting halfway around the world before the truth puts their shoes on, in the extreme long term the truth will come out, meanwhile, the damage is done. This guy until yesterday wanted his mother to take some ivermectin, 'just in case'. I want my mother to take her doctors advice, not mine. edit: just one exhibit: https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=mewpmewp2 https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=mewpmewp2
- roenxi 5y agoYou could try spreading the truth instead of bullying people? I do care about my mothers health you know. And if a doctor isn't convinced by a large number of studies I want them to explain why not rather than call me a conspiracy peddler. The way someone gets ivermectin is to walk a doctor through the evidence they've seen and then ask them to prescribe it.
- jacquesm 5y agoIf you care about your mothers' health then you shouldn't engage in quackery. > The way someone gets ivermectin is to walk a doctor through the evidence they've seen and then ask them to prescribe it. That is factually incorrect, no doctor in their right mind will allow the patients to effectively prescribe their own controversial and in some cases downright dangerous medicine.
- ddingus 5y agoIs that not what the ADS we see on TV are helping patients to do? I am being dead serious here. Confused. And to be clear, it should not work that way at all. I think it does work that way a lot more than many of us would care to admit. Happy to be shown I am wrong.
- jonnycoder 5y agoEnlighten us on how it is "dangerous" medicine. Sources please.
- croon 5y agoThis is a blogger who took time out of their day to do this. Why do you have to be catered to to be convinced? The blogger didn't produce any new data, it was already there, you chose to ignore it, or rather, picked something else to be convinced by. It's not bullying or "talking down to" to simply ignore bullshit, it's effective use of your time.
- reissbaker 5y agoThe blogger didn't produce any new data. I was never an ivermectin proponent — although I thought the "horse dewormer" rhetoric was self-defeating, because it's obviously and well-known to be also a human dewormer (amongst other parasites), and the "horse" part just seemed to be played up to make ivermectin supporters look stupid — but this article is indeed the first one I've seen to make the parasite-COVID-comorbidity argument. It's not, in fact, the first time that argument has been made... But it seems like the first time that link was made was within the last month, as the blog post links to the following Twitter thread from a medical researcher: https://twitter.com/AviBittMD/status/1456376484180922368 https://twitter.com/AviBittMD/status/1456376484180922368 It's not ridiculous to me that this blog post would be someone's first encounter with that argument, considering how recent the link is. I have a little bit of experience with reading lots of research papers about COVID safety measures, and coming to the opposite conclusion of medical experts: in early 2020 I read lots of papers on masks, and tried to convince most of my family to mask up even when the CDC said that masks didn't work. I happened to be right, and to my parents, I now look like a smart and forward-thinking, science-driven person. But that's only because I was right! I could see someone doing the same with the ivermectin studies, and while it appears that they were wrong, I don't think it deserves dismissal or derision — especially when it comes from someone willing to change their mind and admit they were wrong when presented with compelling evidence to the contrary.
- hef19898 5y agoConsidering how many people are actually using hose doses instead of those intended for humans, I guess that characterization isn't too wrong.
- raxxorrax 5y ago"Listen to science!" is ironically a profoundly unscientific statement.
- danans 5y agoNobody claims it to be a scientific statement. It's just a best practice in many circumstances.
- azinman2 5y agoWhat’s a better practice is to explain the rationale per situation, what is known and what is not known. The right turned science into a culture war flashpoint, which meant the left blindly preaches “believe in science” as if it’s about faith. This is all very disingenuous and not at all what science is actually about. It’s very unfortunate that Covid started under trump because being anti-science was part of his marketing message to his base, many because of the risk to certain jobs with caring about climate change (aka the great “hoax”) and the association of science/medicine and abortion. Unfortunately explaining the rationale in a way that people can comprehend and not tune out is very very difficult, and far more time consuming than whatever 2 syllables Trump could come up with as a retort.
- danans 5y ago> The right turned science into a culture war flashpoint, which meant the left blindly preaches “believe in science” as if it’s about faith. These two perspectives are not equivalent opposites though. "Believe in science" is not a religious statement. It is a shorthand for "trust in the scientific institutions that have proven their track record via decades of public health progress, and not in anti-scientific rhetoric with a culture war agenda". That concept wasn't even controversial on most of the political right until their recent nationalist turn.
- azinman2 5y agoKnowledge and understanding of the world is constantly growing. There are endless examples of how scientists and other intellectuals have a current paradigm of how something must work, only to be disproven in the future (usually by someone who gets castigated until held up years later). So to say 'believe in science' is actually dogma. It makes me cringe when I see it as a political banner, or along side signs like 'in this house we believe in....' It would be more accurate to say 'the scientific method works', but it really only works in the long run. At any point in time our understanding is incomplete and erroneous. The facts are out there, whether you believe it or not, and eventually the scientific method will catch up. Of course if you're not a trained scientist, then it's hard to appreciate how the scientific method works, and that even when we're very sure of something, true scientists will always hedge their statements. This will be misinterpreted by those who are outside this world as there being more gray than actually exists, and those with an agenda will drive a truck right through it.
- mgamache 5y ago"Conspiracy peddlers" -- IE People with a different standard of evidence than yourself.
- jacquesm 5y agoNo, people who will amplify bullshit because they want to believe in miracles rather than to face the music. As long as it is just about yourself go wild, do whatever you want. But keep your mental viruses to yourself, lest they destroy the lives of others.
- kaba0 5y agoDo you mean no standard of evidence under different?
- thaumaturgy 5y agoMay I ask, completely sincerely, what approach you would settle on for trying to discriminate truth from fiction if you believed you couldn't get reliable information from reading 30-odd studies?
- astrange 5y agoReading 30 studies certainly seems to be a bad way to learn anything unless you're conducting a meta-analysis of them. For one thing, you'd get tired. But just shoving 30 pieces of information into your head and forgetting some of them doesn't help you find out which of them were correct.
- nomel 5y ago> For one thing, you'd get tired. Suggesting that there's no way someone could have the mental stamina to read 30 papers, over the course of two years, is completely ridiculous, insulting, and invalidates your viewpoint, in my opinion.
- astrange 5y agoI was talking about all at once. If it’s over years I would rather wait for a meta analysis, but it depends on the reliability of the early papers.
- nomel 5y agoWhy are you assuming they tried to read it in one sitting? Nothing remotely suggests that in the comment thread. All we know is that they read 30 papers sometime within the last two years or so. You chose a perspective, and just reinforced it, that they were incapable of extracting anything useful from reading those papers, which is insulting. It could be that they read a paper every couple of days, or perhaps when they became available. For some reason, it seems you've already decided that they're incompetent.
- jacquesm 5y agoEspecially in a field in which you are not trained, do not have the background knowledge required to understand the various qualifications and established best practices in. That gap can be absolutely enormous, even for fields that are peripherally related. Specialization is there for a reason, the body of knowledge that we now command is way too large for any single individual to absorb to a substantial depth.
- mcguire 5y agoAn interesting theory with no backing evidence changed your mind?
- roenxi 5y agoIt is obvious that ivmmeta.com is picking up something that is a real signal. The only question is a signal of what. Fraud? Bias by the site authors? One of many complex statistical effects? A working drug? There were loud, even unreasonable, voices in the debate but nobody was raising an actual problem with the results. Ivermectin has a respectable safety profile. "Maybe it works, no obvious downside" was a reasonable position. It was always a long shot, the evidence was weak. But loudest voices in the anti-ivermectin crowd are people like, eg, jacquesm in this thread. A lot of bluster, a smidge of bullying and a weak-sauce appeal to authority for why statistical evidence should be ignored. And YouTube et al. believe it to be convincing evidence or they wouldn't bother to censor discussion of it. If that is the opposition then they don't seem to have uncovered a methodological problem yet or they'd raise it. But Scott raises an interesting theory that would be enough to explain ivmmeta.com. Since it was only ever weak evidence that is enough for me to change my mind.