11 ms·
This is exactly the sort of thing that YouTube, Twitter, et al are suppressing. Someone thoughtfully listening seriously to what the proponents of Ivermectin ar
by roenxi 5y ago
This is exactly the sort of thing that YouTube, Twitter, et al are suppressing. Someone thoughtfully listening seriously to what the proponents of Ivermectin are saying, weighing it up and saying "looks good but you forgot...".
You can't get this sort of excellent rebuttal without allowing a site like https://ivmmeta.com/ https://ivmmeta.com/ into the debate.
- jacquesm 5y agoMeanwhile, ivmmeta.com will get passed on from person to person that wants to sustain their delusion and the website here will be preaching to the choir.
- roenxi 5y agoI changed my mind. I was making pro-Ivermectin comments just yesterday. This is the first serious anti-Ivermectin argument I've seen.
- bayesian_horse 5y ago"Most scientists/doctors believe it to not work against Covid-19" wasn't a serious argument for you? It is a strange phenomenon that people are so ready to disagree with people who spent decades achieving exactly that kind of knowledge.
- roenxi 5y agoThat literally isn't an argument. It is a statement. And if anyone who said "many scientists/doctors believe it to work against Covid-19" is getting banned, then that statement has 0 signal. As Scott points out in this article, without knowing about the parasitic worm situation https://ivmmeta.com/ https://ivmmeta.com/ is both reasonable and moderately convincing.
- jacquesm 5y agoThis article doesn't move the needle at all for those that have a basic understanding of the mechanisms at work and who don't fall for the first conspiracy theory that gets lobbed their way. What you should do instead is to listen to your medical authorities who even if they do make mistakes have your best interests at heart, contrary to those that are pushing the quackery in an attempt to further destabilize our societies. You made yourself a willing collaborator in that, something to think about.
- fallingknife 5y ago> who even if they do make mistakes have your best interests at heart They, like every other person, have their own best interest at heart, which, if you're lucky, aligns with yours. "Just listen to the authorities" is probably the worst advice ever given.
- jacquesm 5y agoIn the case of a pandemic it is probably pretty good advice, unless you are of the opinion that your authorities are acting against your interest. The problem with this pandemic is that a lot of people in places of power have made mistakes, sometimes really bad ones (for instance, such as pursuing herd immunity) rather than to follow the WHO expert advice. This could easily be construed as authorities acting against your best interests and in fact in quite a few places people have died that need not have died at all. But there is a difference between 'political authorities' and 'medical authorities', the WHO has been fairly consistent and sensible in their advice to date, what political authorities locally do with that advice is another matter entirely, that runs the gamut of Bolsonaro to Boris Johnson to Jacinda Ardern and everything in between.
- fallingknife 5y agoYeah, I agree, that in the case of a pandemic, the health authorities interests are pretty well aligned with a member of the general public. However, there are always issues in this kind of situation when the authorities got it wrong. In a political environment, changing course is seen as an admission of being wrong, and a loss of face. So we continue on with the initial policy. We are currently facing this problem as all experts seem to agree that covid will be endemic, but we are still flailing around with (increasingly half-assed) prevention measures as if we are still going to stop the virus. I disagree that pursuing herd immunity was a bad decision. With every day the pandemic drags on, Sweden's decision is looking better and better.
- m0zg 5y agoMost scientists/doctors believed at one point that ulcers were caused by "stress". My father lost half his stomach to an ulcer surgery. Nowadays ulcers are cured with antibiotics in the span of a week. Don't put much stock in what crowds "believe" to be true, _especially_ when _not_ believing it means they can't work in their field.
- jacquesm 5y agoThat's science working as intended: theories getting replaced by better theories. There is plenty that we are probably going to find out more about in the future that will invalidate some of what we believe today to be true. But that's fine, as long as we stick to the scientific method that will all come out, even if it takes a while. Science has brought us further in 400 years than anything that came before. Right now it has given us vaccines, which are the best way to deal with COVID-19, and the anti-vaxx crowd and the pro-hydrochloroquine and pro-ivermectin crowd show large overlap. Fortunately during the polio years we didn't have the internet, the carnage would have been incredible.
- m0zg 5y agoSure, but my point is "consensus" doesn't necessarily mean "truth", even though the vast majority of people use the terms interchangeably. "Everyone but one person is wrong" is a situation we've seen numerous times before in the history of science. And when the matters of social acceptability, prestige, politics, and just plain ability to make a living enter into the consideration, very, very few people would even be willing to challenge the status quo. I wouldn't. I have mouths to feed. I'm fully resigned to the fact that we won't know for sure if Ivermectin helps with any of this shit for at least another decade until tensions subside. Could be that millions of people died while they didn't have to. Could be that it's total horseshit. There's no way to know, and "consensus" means next to nothing in these circumstances.
- jacquesm 5y agoThe consensus in the medical world is that if there is a link it is extremely weak, far weaker than you'd need to establish that 'millions died while they didn't have to' as you write, and that if it works it probably needs very high doses, higher than considered safe. At the same time, we have vaccines, which do work (though the slow roll-out and the many, many hold outs certainly don't help, as well as that it leaves the question of how to deal with children for the moment mostly unanswered). And propagating this Ivermectine (and Hydroxychloroquine as the predecessor) nonsense has caused a lot of people to forego their vaccinations. And that does have very clear effects. So even if consensus doesn't mean truth typically it is the experts that go against the grain with hard proof in their pocket that win out over the long term. It is very rarely going to happen that new scientific truth will come from conspiracy theorists rather than from the establishment, though I guess if you live long enough that too will one day happen.
- nzmsv 5y agoThe conclusion of the article deals with this very question.
- jacquesm 5y agoBecause people will happily discard evidence that contradicts that which they want to believe. There is apparently something attractive about 'miracle cure suppressed by vested interests' that pretty much guarantees its spread. All you need to do is plant the seed with some gullible people and they'll run with it and parrot it to everybody that will listen, doing a boatload of damage in the process. Between hydroxychloroquine and Ivermectine you are (worldwide) probably looking at a few hundred thousand extra people dead because they (or in some cases their leaders) chose to believe that bullshit rather than to get vaccinated.
- nzmsv 5y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ignaz_Semmelweis https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ignaz_Semmelweis
- jacquesm 5y agoAre you suggesting that we didn't adopt his methods?
- astrange 5y agoI don't think we adopted handwashing because of him. Actually, the reason people didn't believe him is interesting because they were using an earlier scientific method - he didn't have a good explanation for the mechanism, so they dismissed it with "correlation is not causation". We're better at using things whose mechanism we don't understand now, like Tylenol.
- jacquesm 5y agoThere is a whole industry in off-label use of medicine, and there are also quite a few studies that try to move off-label use to on-label use once the link is clear. What is interesting (to me) is that which we now consider to be common sense was at one point controversial.
- nzmsv 5y agoChain got too deep to reply. We did adopt his methods, but many years and hundreds of deaths too late, and not before declaring him insane for his beliefs and putting him in an asylum. What I'm saying is that authority has a dark side. Sometimes the establishment is actually wrong. Regardless of right or wrong, it always chooses to erase its critics. Some of us disagree with the erasure, even in cases where the critics are wrong.
- jacquesm 5y agoYes, so you trust in the scientific method in the long term and in the expert consensus in the short term. The thing where the case you linked went off the rails for me is that there was no downside to trying his methods earlier, but ego got in the way, and ego is by definition unscientific. But people will be people, that you won't be able to fix, I'm afraid.
- jacquesm 5y agoThis is the first anti-Ivermectin argument that you want to believe, but there have been many serious anti-Ivermectin arguments in the past. It's just that you don't have the background knowledge to digest them, but that doesn't stop you from wanting to believe that there is some kind of miracle cure that 'they' are suppressing. Now consider that this is just one example of a class of such issues and that there is an enormous echo chamber for such bullshit which extends right into hackernews. The way it works: - posit some bullshit miracle cure - recruit useful idiots to help promote the issue, sow division - downplay all of the arguments against, make it seem like it is the establishment that does this - eventually, give up and move on to the next miracle cure - go back to step one It is interesting to see that it is the same people that over-and-over-again allow themselves to be recruited like this. Note that you were making 'pro-Ivermectin comments just yesterday' without knowing what you are talking about. Why were you making those comments? What were you trying to achieve by amplifying something that made no sense? Don't you feel any responsibility for pushing such stories when the end result can be that people end up harming themselves or others on account of this?
- gardnr 5y ago> many serious anti-Ivermectin arguments in the past I haven't seen any of these. I just run into irrational and offensive people like you that accuse me of wanting to drink bleach when I bring up the topic of Ivermectin. This article removed all doubt for me. I needed to see the thought process while pouring over the studies. You shouldn't make so many assumptions about people based on your political bias. Some people want to understand. That doesn't make them foolish or antivaxers.
- jacquesm 5y ago> Some people want to understand. So go study medicine, assuming you have 10 years to burn and are willing to take a massive pay cut. The average HN'er probably knows how to program a computer and some of them may even know how to program one well. If a guy that runs a fishing boat with not even the most basic idea about programming, hardware, software, satellite systems, general relativity and integrating all of the above into a working solution came to them with a request to really understand how his GPS works before he would put it to use we'd likely tell them to just trust the experts.
- panny 5y ago>Ivermectin doesn’t reduce mortality in COVID a significant amount (let’s say d > 0.3) in the absence of comorbid parasites: 85-90% confidence That simply armchair science blogging psychiatrist's hypothesis. He even admits as much, >But this theory feels right to me. It feels right to me because it’s the most troll-ish possible solution. Everybody was wrong! None of the studies looked at worms. It is correlation == causation logical fallacy to conclude this based only on speculation. If you want to start arguing with that approach there is no bottom as there are just as many correlation == causation counter examples like https://i0.wp.com/noqreport.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/Ivermectin-Africa.jpg https://i0.wp.com/noqreport.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/I... You simply cannot dismiss that Ivermectin only works because worms until you have studies proving that. You can only say that it works, but you're not sure about why. Good to see that even after he cherry picked all the studies as hard as he could, he still had to reach this basic conclusion.
- kaba0 5y agoNor you can assume any sort of effect on curing COVID without a fair and square trial. The default null hypothesis is that it doesn’t work, period.
- panny 5y agoAs the blog post indicates, there is data proving a positive effect. That's not in question. The author is simply speculating why that is the case at this point, the specific reason for the positive effect.
- kaba0 5y agoThere is data with bad methodology on all fronts. The only thing they prove is the lack of knowledge of the scientific method of their writers.
- jacquesm 5y ago> As the blog post indicates, there is data proving a positive effect. No, there is data that might point to a positive effect, that's something completely different than data that proves a positive effect. Note that this is exactly how these things happen, someone writes something with a particular audience in mind and then others will come along, cherry pick it, distort it and then pass it on as fact. You are step #1 of the Chinese Whispers game and it has already meaningfully changed.
- spamizbad 5y agoPersonally I'm naturally skeptical of any suggested COVID treatments because they tend to be trendy. Before ivermectin, it was hydroxychloroquine. And before hydroxychloroquine, it was vitamin D, melatonin, and diluted bleach. And before that it was that it was only harmful to people who lead unhealthy lifestyles: It was less a disease and more like cosmic justice for living an indulgent, gluttonous sedentary lifestyle. Meanwhile over the last 11 months most of the vaccines have been extremely effective at reducing hospitalization and death. My 3yo son caught COVID from one of his classmates at preschool - my wife and I are fully vaccinated - and we were both able to avoid an infection while under quarantine with our son.
- murderfs 5y agoIt would be hilarious if just like this argues fairly convincingly for ivermectin, all of those (well, the first two) actually turned out to be true, but only for malaria infected and vitamin D deficient patients.
- bayesian_horse 5y agoThere is little evidence of such analysis being suppressed. I think it is just relatively rare, because it is a lot of work and takes particular skill. Most people who care about this research are indeed crackpots, unfortunately. Those who aren't have mostly moved on from Ivermectin because they have better things to do. Ivermectin is being tested in large RCTs, as it should. If it works, it will be used. If it doesn't, it won't. Until we know, doctors will do what works.
- RubberMullet 5y ago>There is little evidence of such analysis being suppressed. ... >Most people who care about this research are indeed crackpots, unfortunately. Where is the evidence to support this statement?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- oblio 5y agoHe replies to your question afterwards: > Those who aren't have mostly moved on from Ivermectin because they have better things to do. Ivermectin is being tested in large RCTs, as it should. If it works, it will be used. If it doesn't, it won't. Until we know, doctors will do what works.
- gunapologist99 5y ago.. which many doctors believe is ivermectin based on their own mini-trials, so we're right back to where we started.
- aantix 5y ago>There is little evidence of such analysis being suppressed. Why did this post get flagged on HN? https://imgur.com/a/GgDVfNe https://imgur.com/a/GgDVfNe
- 5y ago
- VBprogrammer 5y agoI wonder if YouTube would have been better to implement a no medical advice policy. Not a no advice which runs contrary to the official guidelines policy.
- jacquesm 5y agoThis is going to the heart of the problem: Youtube has replaced TV, and what people see on TV they tend believe to be real, and even if they don't believe that at the moment they see it they may well remember it as fact later on. I think youtube is great for showing people DIY stuff, for home videos and so on, but it has clearly allowed itself to be hijacked as a platform for politics and it was/is ill prepared for the attempt at weaponizing the immense audience that it commands.
- commandlinefan 5y ago> This is exactly the sort of thing that YouTube, Twitter, et al are suppressing I fear that if it had any name except Scott Alexander's attached to it, it would have been flagged/dead on here within a few minutes as well.
- ImaCake 5y agoThis is maybe true. But I have seen more than a few dubious COVID articles gain traction on HN. There are several times I have tried to clarify basic statistical points as well. So it’s not a given that it would have been flagged/dead.
- Rastonbury 5y agoIvermectin pushers are such a mysterious group, its a generic drug cheap drug, there is no apparent personal incentives for whoever is pushing it. It seems to be a result of the fractured us vs them conspiratorial types who truly believe they are doing good in the world.
- kaba0 5y agoThe thing is, 99 out of 100 people repeating conspiracy theories don’t have a single coherent thought behind the whole thing. It will be a straw man, but it is statistically like that: They may start by how research grants decide the results of studies and thus your study is one of those payed ones, but then jump ship and go that this sea snake extrude homeopathy will treat covid, just go look it up yourself, and then even if there is a “paper” for that, it is from goddamn Atlantis with no peer-review and was tested on 2 parrots.
- Imnimo 5y agoIf Twitter is suppressing this analysis, why does the article cite many tweets from people doing the actual legwork?