11 ms·
Firefox 94 has No Visible Border on unfocused tabs
- SubiculumCode 5y agoOn the one hand, it slightly makes it easier to see which tab is in focus, on the other hand, it bugs me any way.
- jonnycomputer 5y agoIt does make which tab is active easier to see, and that is the only reason i like it. My eyes are worse than they were and I hate fighting for clarity in the interfaces I use. Sometimes low contrasts themes are just more cognitive load.
- SrslyJosh 5y ago"Make the active tab stand out more" feels like a problem that could be solved without making the UI for inactive tabs less accessible. :-/
- dredmorbius 5y agoSome liberties with the title for fit. Original: "please tell me #firefox 94 has not flattened the display to the point there is NO VISIBLE BORDER on unfocused tabs."
- slmjkdbtl 5y agoNext step is to make the text the same color as the background
- dredmorbius 5y agoThat's what Google Chrome has done (in Incognito mode) on Android. Been that way for most of the past year. It is literally impossible to read the URL, or edit it reasonably. (I'll typically copy it to some open edit-box somewhere to do so.) The depths of idiocy across the development landscape are ... depthy. Firefox / Fennec remains my general very strong preference, though on this specific older Android device, Firefox/Fennec performance remains abysmal. On a newer Android device, Mozilla's aversion to keyboard shortcuts is another major pain-point. On e-ink devices, EinkBro is superior for some tasks (Chromium-derived), though it also has its annoyances.
- mattl 5y agoDo newer Android devices have keyboards?
- sp332 5y agoBluetooth keyboards are pretty common. When I was using one with an Android-based set-top box, I really missed having keyboard shortcuts in Firefox.
- mattl 5y agoI’ll check it out. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29236519 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29236519
- dredmorbius 5y agoI'm using an external Bluetooth keyboard. I'd originally bought the device with a paired self-supporting case/keyboard combo. That ... was already failing from purchase. The current keyboard doesn't mate with the device, but if used on a desk is acceptable. (Logiteck K480, multi-device, PC/Mac, fairly decent reviews, chicklet keys though. I'm ... dealing with that.)
- mattl 5y agoI hadn’t thought about using a keyboard with my phone but I’ll check it out. I have a new Logitech (can’t keep track of model numbers) and iOS.
- dredmorbius 5y agoIt's a huge boost in productivity. My estimate is that trying to use a soft keyboard drops my effective intelligence by at least half. Typing is slower and far more error-prone. I'm staring at the keyboard rather than what I've typed, so if there's an error, I don't see it as it occurs (which would enable me to correct it immediately), and navigation is exctremely imprecise. My error / typo rate with a software keyboard is through the roof. With a keyboard, all of that is much more fluid, and I can focus on what I'm actually trying to say. Being able to toggle between apps and access application hotkeys is another huge bonus. Downside is that many applications literally don't know what the fuck to do with a keyboard. Apparently keyboard entry is not a consistent low-level Android feature. - The Pocketbook e-book reader interprets spaces when writing notes or search expressions as "page scroll" events. This is always delightful. - The Mozilla Pocket app loses focus on each motherlovin' keystroke when entering tags. My enthusiasm for this behaviour is utterly without bounds. - Depending on the keyboard and perhaps Android version, input of escape (hullo, vim), function keys, and other modifier keys ... is variable ... with Termux. The Logitech keyboard largely functions as advertised, though there are some workarounds required for function key usage (say, with Midnight Commander). I'm sure you'll discover other fun surprises in your own preferred apps / workflow. That it's easier to write longer pieces with a keyboard may or may not be a feature, though on balance I'd consider it a plus. Using Termux or remotely accessing a Linux / *nix system with a real keyboard is also a huge improvement over soft keyboards. Termux (Linux userland available through F-Droid) remains the one thing on Android that does not precisely suck.
- krater23 5y agoJust remove the text. Icons should be enough. Wait, I think we have this somewhere...
- svnpenn 5y ago> black print, black background. it's the coolest possible color scheme https://i.imgur.com/41biB.jpeg https://i.imgur.com/41biB.jpeg
- The_rationalist 5y agoThey've gone too far.
- dredmorbius 5y agoWith apologies to Warren G. Bennis: The UI/UX department of the future will have only two employees, a hipster and a dog. The hipster will be there to feed the dog. The dog will be there to bite the hipster if they change the UI/UX.
- rgrmrts 5y agoSince the new Firefox UI updates, I really feel like I’m maybe the only one who actually likes the new look. Everything I read about Firefox lately is overwhelmingly negative. Either that, or it’s just the negative opinions being amplified and folks who are happy/satisfied just keep it to themselves. From the posted image, is it really that hard to differentiate the not active tabs? There’s a clear pattern: icon, title, close “x”. I’ve liked the direction Firefox has been going in. It’s my primary browser again after a few years of Chrome. I can’t be alone in preferring the updated look, I’m sure there are dozens of us.
- JohnTHaller 5y agoSame here. I feel like every UI update is pretty minor tweaking. But then I see comments that people are going to change browsers over it.
- hypeatei 5y agoAgreed, I recently switched from Brave and like the UI much better than any Chromium based browser.
- artdigital 5y agoI went the other way - after years of boycotting chromium browsers I switched to Brave (and turned off all the BAT ads stuff). Stuff like built-in IPFS (including ipns domainlink), TOR, crypto wallets, adblocker, CMD-SHIFT-A to jump to recent things. It feels like it's the browser that's innovating the most and tries out new things all the time, kinda what firefox used to do in the past.
- BMorearty 5y agoI haven’t tried Brave but speaking of CMD-SHIFT-A (which also works in Chrome), I’ve learned that Firefox has a CTRL-TAB feature that works better IMO (easier keystroke and it works just like CMD-TAB). It’s optional. The option is called “Ctrl+Tab cycles through tabs in recently used order.”
- 5y ago
- kryptiskt 5y agoUsually the complaint is about modern designs putting form over function, but that doesn't even look good.
- sneak 5y agoEver since Firefox added nonconsensual telemetry and spyware, I just stuck with the spyware browser that's way more secure. I can't imagine pinning my hopes on such a clownshow.
- brink 5y agoThis makes no sense. Firefox adds telemetry, that upsets you, so you go to a browser with even more telemetry?
- sneak 5y agohttps://github.com/Eloston/ungoogled-chromium https://github.com/Eloston/ungoogled-chromium
- behringer 5y agoBy using a Chromium based browser you're making it more difficult for Firefox to stay up to date and you make it more difficult for websites to see the need to support Firefox at all. Once Firefox is out of the race, Google can do whatever it likes with its browser.
- sneak 5y agoFirefox doesn't matter at all. Google already does whatever it likes with its browser. Firefox exists only because of Google money, so Google can credibly point at a competitor.
- vehemenz 5y agoPersonally, I can't imagine hand installing crx files every time an extension is updated. I can't imagine not having sync or container tabs. I can't imagine having "experimental settings" instead of about:config.
- sneak 5y agoI don't update my extensions but once per year when I reinstall the machine with a fresh OS.
- mgbmtl 5y agoOn the other hand, when using "Tree Style Tab", it looks much nicer without borders (old TST screenshots have borders, but my current version does not).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- CountHackulus 5y agoI don't really have have any complaints, it's really easy to tell which tab is where and the mouseover makes it even clearer. Does it look better? Maybe. Does it function worse? No.
- Amezarak 5y agoI am not sure why, because I don't actually remember how it used to work, but this version of Firefox is the first time I can remember where for some reason I keep getting confused about what tab is active and end up closing the wrong tab. If I slow down and pay attention I'm OK, but it's definitely less functional for me.
- Gigachad 5y agoIt seems extremely clear to me. There is even only one tab that has an x icon so the only way to close it is to middle click the tab.
- pseudalopex 5y agoIt depends how many tabs are open.
- SrslyJosh 5y ago> Does it function worse for me? No. Fixed it for you.
- chrisseaton 5y agoAnd the old-style clutter works better for you and worse for them. What are we to do? Obviously we have to design for the majority. I presume there are high-contrast modes that can be enabled if you need that.
- r-w 5y ago> Obviously we have to design for the majority. That isn't obvious to me. Why remove things that were helping the minority and not hindering the majority?
- Animats 5y agoUbuntu 20.04 made console windows borderless, which is seriously annoying when several console windows are open. Doesn't matter which one has focus, either.
- Sohcahtoa82 5y agoThis trend to flatness needs to stop. I hate it so much. It makes it unclear what elements are interactive. It doesn't even look good. It doesn't even look "clean" or "sleek". It's just sterile. Dead. Non-functional. I use Windows Blinds to make my Win10 look like Win98, and certainly I don't expect anyone to go that far, but some time between then and now, we've lost the plot.
- krater23 5y agoThe look of the UI is now fewer functional than before DOS.
- wackget 5y agoThat should be "less functional".
- StuffMaster 5y agoWindows 3.1 at least didn't hide buttons and tabs from your eyes...
- stavros 5y agoI don't know if that's just nostalgia speaking, but I think Windows 95 was the peak of UX. Everything interactable was clearly a button, everything had keyboard "accelerators", and all UIs were consistent (no Electron apps).
- orangepurple 5y agoThis trend lasted until just after Windows 7 when aesthetics went downhill.
- ComputerGuru 5y agoWindows 2000 was arguably better. But yeah.
- stavros 5y ago
- loxias 5y agoYeah, apparently in modern design "affordances" are a relic of the past. Everything has this problem. I upgraded to Android 12 and now I have no idea what's clickable, because my world consists of floating text, and I'm just "supposed to know" how to operate it. I miss having blue underlined links, and raised "faux 3d" buttons so I know what I'm supposed to be able to click. x.x
- mleonhard 5y agoIt's because Google's UX designers don't care about their users. They only care about getting promoted. Redesigning everything to be flat is a lot of work so a lot of people can get promoted doing it. We can all blame Matias Duarte for creating and launching Material Design without performing any usability testing. A few days before the public launch, he presented Material Design at the Google all-hands meeting and admitted in the Q&A that they had just started usability testing. I predict that everything will be flattened by 2024 and they will begin adding back the affordances. Then it will take a few years for other companies to start adding affordances back. Everything will be usable again in 2029.
- SrslyJosh 5y ago> It's because Google's UX designers don't care about their users. They only care about getting promoted. Redesigning everything to be flat is a lot of work so a lot of people can get promoted doing it. Arbitrary UI changes also help generate buzz for corporate marketing events.
- ploxiln 5y agouserChrome.css is the way to get good tabs back (for now) https://www.userchrome.org/firefox-89-styling-proton-ui.html#tabstyler https://www.userchrome.org/firefox-89-styling-proton-ui.html... (go to the home page for general instructions on enabling this mechanism)
- amanzi 5y agoAlso, they're not even tabs - just floating buttons. Firefox is still my primary browser, but right now I have Chrome 95 and Firefox 94 open, and the tabs in Chrome just look perfectly normal - they look like tabs, you can see a visible border between inactive tabs, and the active tab stands out. The Firefox "tabs" just look ridiculous - I can think of no logical explanation as to why Mozilla decided on this look. It's neither functional nor pretty. Really frustrating...
- archsurface 5y agoI don't care much about such things. I use Firefox for its history, bookmarking, and because it's not grubby big tech.
- WatchDog 5y agoMousing over the tab shows it's border, looks fine to me.
- baud147258 5y agoWith every Firefox update, I'm less and less interested in switching my personal browsing from Chrome to Firefox (I'm already using FF at work, so I follow the changes as they arrive). In theory I'd support the change to a more privacy-focused browser, but I can't really be bothered if the UX is way inferior
- authed 5y agoWhat is the best Firefox alternative today ? for mobile and desktop?
- soundnote 5y agoI like Brave and Vivaldi for both, depending on whether you prioritize maximum tinfoil or want every settings toggle in the universe, respectively.
- rabuse 5y agoOn iOS you have Chrome (Safari), Opera (Safari), or Firefox (Safari), so pick your poison. /s
- authed 5y agoImagine if Microsoft did that back in the day when it got hit with an antitrust lawsuit because it was bundling Internet Explorer with Windows. The Government is pro-corp today.
- bryan0 5y agoEveryone using FF should do themselves a favor and install Tree Style Tabs[0] and hide the top tabs in userChrome.css 0: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/tree-style-tab/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/tree-style-ta...
- stavros 5y agoDoesn't work for portrait screens :(
- kafkaIncarnate 5y agoTHANK YOU! I used to use this extension, but when they went to WebRTC I couldn't find this extension anymore and gave up looking for it. Haven't used this in years but is easily one of the best tab interfaces ever invented. Edit: https://gist.github.com/colejd/665fdf388e3b80ca614187d1901d8835 https://gist.github.com/colejd/665fdf388e3b80ca614187d1901d8...
- bryan0 5y agoCool. Just a note that if you’re modifying userChrome you need to enable toolkit.legacyUserProfileCustomizations.stylesheets in FF advanced settings
- arsome 5y agoCan we go back to the good old days when you could install extensions that could actually do useful things without jumping through hoops? I swear we're going to have to start DLL injecting web browsers like game modding tools soon...
- perryizgr8 5y agoI feel that the trend of UI/UX regression has been going on for some time now, and it is not limited to Firefox. I recently fished out an old laptop with windows 7 on it. I turned it on after years. Although it was pretty slow (I think it was underpowered even when it was new), the UI in windows 7 looks absolutely beautiful. Pretty icons with lots of detail, copy and move dialogs with amazing animations, pleasing translucent window borders, sensible control panel, perfect start menu. Windows 10/11 feel amateurish by comparison.
- zmix 5y agoWhy do they need to change it at all?
- kstrauser 5y agoUnrelated: I think this is the first link I've seen from HN to a Mastodon post.
- usr1106 5y agoIf you click on the domain you'll see that there have been 4 submissions from that domain. The first one from 2018. That it's the first one you have seen is just one data point, not an unlikely one admittedly :)
- yissp 5y agoA work-around I've been using on Linux is to set the GTK_THEME environment variable to the "high contrast" theme. With that theme it will draw a black outline around the focused tab.
- usr1106 5y agoDidn't something like this change already a couple of releases ago? I found it annoying for a couple of days and after that I have not really noticed any more. I have Xubuntu and run the Firefox release they give me. Last week there was an upgrade, but I did not notice any major change to tabs. Maybe the same change I saw a while ago ended up in ESR now? Just a wild guess, have not checked their release status for ages.
- orangepurple 5y agoEvery time I see an article like this I light a candle and hold a vigil for Skeuomorphism
- aembleton 5y agoEditing userChrome might be more effective
- Waterluvian 5y agoIs there perhaps a fundamental issue where some teams of UI/UX designers design for the sake of design? Maybe as a form of job preservation or having creative sessions on someone else's dime or something else? I've wondered what happens when you stand up a team of people who mostly aren't necessary after a while and how good some might be at making themselves necessary. I feel like a reasonably competent designer can make user studies and tests and research point to whatever conclusion they want about the need for more changes. But do we really need the change? Or put it this way: how often does a team conclude, "our studies revealed that we're in good shape. Don't change anything!"
- nathanaldensr 5y ago"It is difficult for a man to understand..."
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pkulak 5y agoEh, I hide the tab bar anyway. Tabs are for your window manager, not to be implemented from scratch in every single app.
- pseudalopex 5y agoThe people in charge of the desktop environments >99% of people use don't agree unfortunately.
- pkulak 5y agoI'm not bothered by having a minority opinion. Especially when I'm right. :D
- tyingq 5y agoIt's pretty awful if you have some tabs open to sites without a favicon. Or some without a favicon or <title>. Like happens in a dev environment quite a lot.
- AlexandrB 5y agoWhat is it with UI design slowly creeping to the extremes? Before "The Great Flattening" there was a series of prominent, increasingly skeuomorphic UI designs, culminating (in my mind) with the ridiculous Calendar app in OSX Lion[1]. Around this time, there seemed to be a growing sense that maybe things had gone too far. But instead of just backing off the skeumorphism a little we got a complete reversal and a trend towards increasingly flat and abstract UIs. Now most buttons have no affordances at all and we get decisions like this to remove useful visual cues for no apparent reason. What's seems to be missing here is any sense of moderation or restraint. [1] https://www.anandtech.com/show/4485/back-to-the-mac-os-x-107-lion-review/15 https://www.anandtech.com/show/4485/back-to-the-mac-os-x-107...
- fbhabbed 5y agoAnd the problem is?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rickstanley 5y agoIf you use Firefox on GNOME and don't mind an overhaul, I suggest Firefox Gnome Theme[0] [0]: https://github.com/rafaelmardojai/firefox-gnome-theme https://github.com/rafaelmardojai/firefox-gnome-theme
- jonnycomputer 5y agoYeah, I don't like it. But the tabs don't bother me as as the insufficient contrast between the search and url boxes and the rest of the menu in light theme.
- SubiculumCode 5y agoI installed Firefox Color, which is an official Mozilla add-on, which lets me pick colors...which helps with your problem tremendously.
- jonnycomputer 5y agoI like it!
- makecheck 5y agoA very good test of a multi-item interface is to imagine it with exactly TWO items and see if it makes perfect sense that way. Or if it’s a toggle button, look at a single button and see if you know its state. Now in this context, imagine the inactive item is invisible and clickable, and the active item looks like a button (that is traditionally clickable) but is not clickable. Imagine furthermore that you still have freaking buttons elsewhere in the same UI that look the same as the unclickable thing but are clickable, well, you have a problem. Now imagine the even bigger problem of reusing the exact same style for things like text fields that have an entirely different function. This isn’t just Firefox, a lot of this is what Safari tried to pull, too. Or the entire concept of flat UIs. I really, really want to respect the field of UI design and imagine that this stuff is hard, etc. but frankly some of this stuff is really not that hard to get right. There needs to be discipline, some science, some user testing, and someone with enough power to shoot down the truly dumb decisions, for a start. And barring all that, I want a config file (or back in the day, ResEdit) where I can undo all the madness.
- mmis1000 5y agoIn this case. It is wrong to just test 2 tab, you need two at its 'narrowest' size. You will find nothing is even differentiable in this situation. The icon is now at middle of two title. And even worse, the gap is so big so you won't have confidence which tab will you hit unless you hit exactly on text or icon (at the cost of hit area reduced to 2/3 of original tab) or hover to see which tab lit(at the cost of delay due to visual check). As someone who likes to open many tabs, the experience sucks.
- up6w6 5y agoI don't know if it's because my screen is small (~11 inches) but I hated how Firefox made the tab bar so "important" and attention taking. I'm one of the people who liked when Apple tried to change the safari tab bar [1]. [1] https://www.theverge.com/2021/9/21/22686070/apple-macos-safari-tab-groups-redesign-change-back https://www.theverge.com/2021/9/21/22686070/apple-macos-safa...
- hasbot 5y agoHuh. I didn't even notice.
- samplenoise 5y agoReminds me of being a classical percussionist. me: *plays quietly* conductor: can you play that a little more piano me: *plays very quietly* conductor: a little more piano even me: *pretends to play* conductor: perfect
- pyaccount 5y agoWhy was there even an edge there to begin with? Did it do anything? Hopefully one day they can remove the edge of the window as well. Imagine thinking that was a good idea.
- robotburrito 5y agoI did not even notice this until I read this here on hacker news inside of Firefox. I'm not sure what that means.
- masswerk 5y agoTabs are actually a great UI element, both visually and functionally – and are easily readable (how form and function combine). Moreover, these non-tab buttons are not only lacking definition, they also occupy precious visual bandwidth by their clutter. (Bandwidth clutter and aesthetic clutter are quite different beasts, and for some reason, this knowledge seems to have been lost recently.) This war on tabs in browser UIs has to stop. There is no such thing as a functional square wheel. I'm also speaking of you, Safari.
- karmakaze 5y agoSimple answer: The change is a cargo cult. They see how Apple does this with their products and keep increasing uptake. They don't know that it isn't only the visible change itself that motivates adoption. Apple is keenly aware. Apple's customer isn't the person using Apple's product--that person can be inconvenienced (plus they tend to self-brainwash). The real Apple customer is the person watching an affluent/influential person using an Apple product and imagining how nice it must be based on the (superficial) clean simplicity of it all.
- SrslyJosh 5y agoLots of people here defending making the tab bar less accessible who have probably never thought "gee, I wish those tabs didn't have lines delineating where one ends and the next begins!"
- sigmonsays 5y agoThe lack of visible tab bothered me, I ranted to a friend, then googled. i just switched my theme with a firefox color theme. Here, click this link if it bothers you and move on! https://color.firefox.com/?theme=XQAAAAIkAQAAAAAAAABBqYhm849SCia2CaaEGccwS-xMDPsquuHuWr6Up9Wewwm1qczR1ft5ki5womZMGeZAJXpLiwv1T4W0j1hOUvwsg-6Kyf087iUx688YuWI8prBudNx1dUA-32y8Qp0NXrq2pRDdZRq36-dI3iLO0DdS79v0LuH_lFpv2EoEokAPMKRWwTEhxgqypaA0PrXGztQ42HTFqhDCuT5G_3lBOabwItQb-Qurd5Bo8oL0Vf_-eZdY https://color.firefox.com/?theme=XQAAAAIkAQAAAAAAAABBqYhm849...
- s9w 5y agoYay, blue haired SJWs turn up the destruction to 11, more of it! Kill it!
- 271828182846 5y agoI really like Firefox. But this Tab design decision is smelling like function follows form instead of the other way around. Seems to be the Zeitgeist that utilities are designed to look good instead of being as useful as possible.