10 ms·
I ordered an M1 Max the day after it was announced. It's supposed to arrive today. The route it took to get to Portland, Oregon, was Shanghai to Zhenzhou (where
by noduerme 5y ago
I ordered an M1 Max the day after it was announced. It's supposed to arrive today. The route it took to get to Portland, Oregon, was Shanghai to Zhenzhou (where it spent a week), on to South Korea, then Anchorage, then a weekend in Louisville, Kentucky. How this makes any sense in terms of efficiency is totally beyond me.
As a side note, I'm mildly paranoid about new Apple devices spending a week held up in Chinese customs. Is the CCP throttling exports, or installing backdoors?
- paxys 5y agoIf the CCP wanted to install backdoors they would do it at the factory rather than at customs. Also Apple's logistics game has always had these weird efficiencies. I remember ordering an iPod like 15 years ago, and I got a FedEx tracking number where I could see its progress flying overnight out of China. It was pretty wild at the time.
- sneak 5y agoI think if the CCP wanted to install backdoors, they would simply ask Apple to do it, as they did for iCloud. Apple would, of course, comply, as they did for iCloud. In the default configuration of a mac, Apple retains full remote code execution ability on the machine.
- onethought 5y agoThey didn’t install a back door for CCP. Edit: Back door exists for all gov, in that keys to encryption are stored in country. So back door always existed. But apparently that’s only bad when China have access to it. I guess because of the US long record of cyber trustworthiness.
- kalleboo 5y agoApples compliance in China applies to Chinese customers only. They would most likely be less willing to comply if it meant compromising foreign customers. As lucrative as the Chinese market is, losing the US market would be sudden death for Apple.
- sneak 5y ago> Apples compliance in China applies to Chinese customers only. Effectively everything Apple sells is made in China. Apple is nothing without China. They are, unfortunately, required to do literally anything the CCP demands of them, push comes to shove, to continue existing as we know them. Losing the Chinese market would be sudden-er death for Apple. China is Apple's largest market, and will be the vast majority of their revenue growth for the next 15-30 quarters. More importantly, losing the Chinese market means losing ~100% of all of their manufacturing. (Anyone know how many iPhones are being made in India these days?)
- vmception 5y agoMy M1 Max Pro from announcement day arrived last week. A month early from initial estimates. Shenzhen to Kentucky to west coast. No problem from my perspective.
- londons_explore 5y agoI'm really surprised Apple let Shenzhen, China show on the tracking. For a premium product, I would expect them to be focussing on the "Designed by Americans in America" bit of the message rather than the "Made in China".
- zitterbewegung 5y agoIts not their choice they use UPS for shipping which would tell you where the package is. Also, on the back of my iPad Pro 12.9 2021 it says "Designed by Apple in California Manufactured in China". Apple doesn't hide this point at all. The Mac Pro though is Manufactured in Texas domestically and outside of the US it is manufactured in China.
- intricatedetail 5y agoYou can't find that on the website in the product specs. It's only when you actually buy the product and physically inspect the labels. I know few people who thought they make it in California and were shocked it's actually made in China.
- JCharante 5y agoWould people be surprised? I think foxconn factory conditions which manufacturer apple products have been on the public conscious for several years.
- op00to 5y agoI’m confused - are you suggesting Apple somehow hide the fact that their products are made in China? Where else would the tracking indicate stops?
- spike021 5y agoThat's the typical new-release Apple products route. I remember my iPhone 12 last year made the same stops.
- 0des 5y agoI want to make a joke about the spyware not installing itself, but it was hitting too close to home, and besides that's probably too obvious, so instead, I will leave you this anecdote about how packages make it from east to west: A package from abroad often changes hands through various regional carriers, and is sometimes bumped or combined or divided by many criteria depending on where it is and what it is. I found this out by ordering electronics that also had single items that required special shipping that arrived far far later (the trigger for me, is batteries, which always take more time)
- hef19898 5y agoLi-ion batteries are dangerous goods, so kind of makes sense that those can take longer.
- quickthrower2 5y agoWhy would that be weird? It's probably the most efficient money-wise (and emissions wise as a result). Taking a route on vessels that have spare capacity. Probably a form of algorithmic 'hitchhiking'. Did you pay for a premium posting service, or just regular?
- londons_explore 5y agoIt can also happen because there is significant extra cost to packing and unpacking boxes. If your parcel is in a box of other parcels with other destinations, it makes sense to send the whole lot to one place to split it up and reorg packages, even if the end result is more airmiles, because there are fewer unpack-sort-pack events.
- jeromegv 5y agoAnchorage is because they found out that they can fill their planes with more inventory and less gas if they stop in Anchorage instead of doing the full pacific route. Good article here: https://www.zdnet.com/article/why-your-ipad-comes-via-anchorage/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/why-your-ipad-comes-via-anchor...
- dredmorbius 5y agoWendover Productions details FedEx's Anchorage hub here: https://yewtu.be/watch?v=y3qfeoqErtY&t=5m50s https://yewtu.be/watch?v=y3qfeoqErtY&t=5m50s Anchorage is also not all that far off the Great Circle route anyway. I recently discovered Nullschool's new (or updated) NO2 channel. This is even more effective than the SO2 channel for identifying global shipping routes. See for example (time-stamped for earlier today): https://earth.nullschool.net/#2021/11/15/2100Z/chem/surface/level/anim=off/overlay=no2/orthographic=-168.01,48.35,903/loc=-170.802,43.998 https://earth.nullschool.net/#2021/11/15/2100Z/chem/surface/... Note that trans-pacific routes from both Seattle/Vancouver and Los Angeles/San Diego meet near Kodiak Island along the Aleutians. I'm fairly confident those represent sea traffic rather than air, given similar traces through the Indian Ocean / Red Sea. I'm presuming relatively little air traffic traverses Suez. Similarly Panama, and traffic from Europe to South Africa. Anchorage is located slightly north of that trace and has its own NO2 track.
- winslow 5y agoI'm having a hard time understanding this snippet: The intermediary stop in Anchorage, as opposed to flying from Shanghai to Oakland, CA, actually increases total flight distance by around 144 miles but allows the aircraft to carry an additional 45,000kg of cargo (instead of extra fuel) increasing revenue for the trip by around $90,000. Why would traveling an extra 144 miles allow the aircraft to carry 45,000kg of cargo instead of fuel? I feel like I'm misreading it.
- jcims 5y agoBecause they can fill their tanks halfway and not fall into the ocean. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_747#Specifications https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_747#Specifications
- mig39 5y agoThat's been the standard route for Apple products for many years now. Probably more than a decade.
- dekhn 5y agoWell, hub and spoke can be more efficient than point to point. Louisville KY is a major cargo hub https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Louisville_International_Airport#Cargo_hub https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Louisville_International_Airpo... for UPS and it's cheaper to maintain one major hub than multiple (say, a west-coast based one). That explains the last two steps. For the rest of them, no idea; but I can speculate: it looks like zhenzhou is a major shipping hub and occasionally there are long delays: https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/stuck-in-zhenzhou-for-5-6-days-anyone.2089157/ https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/stuck-in-zhenzhou-for-5... (note that sometimes my packages say they are in china but are actually landed in the US already). South Korea and Anchorage: maybe it's cheaper to take more short-hop flights? Haha, I had to look it up (TLDR: yes) Well: https://www.zdnet.com/article/why-your-ipad-comes-via-anchorage/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/why-your-ipad-comes-via-anchor... (note in that case it went to memphis before the final US destination, memphis is the Fedex hub). Some things look inefficient from a distance, especially if you look at just a few random samples, but then turn out to be efficient when you compute overall measures like "package throughput divided by shipping costs". Never underestimate both the efficiency and ineffiency of modern transport systems.
- secabeen 5y agoThe South Korea and Anchorage stops are pretty close to the Great Circle route for Shanghai to Portland: http://www.gcmap.com/mapui?P=sha-pdx http://www.gcmap.com/mapui?P=sha-pdx Kentucky is the UPS International Air Hub, nearly all UPS cargo flights go there. FedEx is Memphis, both because they are well positioned relative to the densest parts of the US population with the earliest delivery requirements.
- thetinguy 5y agoAnchorage is a common stop over location for both UPS[1] and FedEx[2]. [1] https://www.adn.com/business-economy/2019/12/06/ups-plans-major-cargo-expansion-at-anchorage-airport/ https://www.adn.com/business-economy/2019/12/06/ups-plans-ma... [2] https://www.bizjournals.com/memphis/news/2019/08/15/fedex-negotiates-deal-to-triple-its-presence-at.html https://www.bizjournals.com/memphis/news/2019/08/15/fedex-ne...
- mikeInAlaska 5y agoI visited China in 2018, I live just outside of Anchorage. First we flew to Seattle, and then after a layover, flew directly over Anchorage to Beijing via the great circle route. About 10 hrs and maybe 3800 miles into the journey, I was looking down at my home town.
- 14 5y agoThat’s a fair assumption in my opinion we already know the US government was rerouting packages to install spyware why would we not assume China does the same. But what I do doubt is that they would do it to every phone and not just target individual actors.
- seany 5y agoVariations of that are pretty common for APAC -> CONUS cargo. Anchorage and Louisville are both major cargo hubs. If it doesn't _require_ the speed, you're probably better off (from a cost perspective) carrying more packages, than the fuel to do longer directs. http://www.gcmap.com/mapui?P=PVG-CGO-ICN-ANC-SDF http://www.gcmap.com/mapui?P=PVG-CGO-ICN-ANC-SDF
- zitterbewegung 5y agoThere are seals in the package that you can visually inspect if you believe that your package has been modified. If you still suspect that someone repackaged the device I would say to put it in DFU mode (if you have another Mac or have a friends Mac) and reinstall the device firmware and then reinstall Macos in recovery mode. Or just go to an Apple Store and let them do it for you if you can't get access to another Mac.
- movedx 5y agoThe seals won't be very helpful if tampering is being done at a state sponsored level: https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2014/05/photos-of-an-nsa-upgrade-factory-show-cisco-router-getting-implant/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2014/05/photos-of-an-nsa...
- spicybright 5y agoThen image what 12 years of well funded R&D to improve the process does.
- movedx 5y agoAnd 12 years of even better funded R&D by an aggressive team of spies acing outside of the law (legally) to over come that progress.
- xattt 5y agoWould a state-run operation just not be able to replicate the seals, considering that the seals are just as likely to have been manufactured there?
- bitexploder 5y agoThey might even just have exact replica boxes and such. Boxes are easier to produce than computers.
- 5y ago
- op00to 5y agoThat’s literally the path that almost every electronic device I’ve purchased directly from China to the US has took for at least 10 years.
- ralph84 5y agoPre-pandemic it may have gone Zhengzhou-Anchorage and skipped the Korea stop, but pretty much all US airlines are now doing stops in Korea or Japan for their China flights to change the crew. The crew flies Korea-China-Korea and never leaves the plane in China so they don't have to deal with China's covid quarantine rules.
- Aperocky 5y ago> The crew flies Korea-China-Korea and never leaves the plane in China so they don't have to deal with China's covid quarantine rules. Business finds a way.
- eCa 5y agoEven on the yacht transporters (ships carrying smaller ships) across the Atlantic the crew don't get off the ship in the US[1] due to Covid. [1] https://youtu.be/GcsbsCK7ogc?t=543 https://youtu.be/GcsbsCK7ogc?t=543
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoUntil the plane breaks down while in China...
- dragontamer 5y ago> How this makes any sense in terms of efficiency is totally beyond me. 1. Hub and Spoke. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spoke%E2%80%93hub_distribution_paradigm https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spoke%E2%80%93hub_distribution...) 2. Optimized traveling salesman looks very suboptimal locally. ---- For more details: try playing OpenTTD with cargodist (OpenTTD 1.4.0 and above, roughly June 2013 or later). This is where mail / passengers / cargo will automatically route themselves and plan where to go rather than the default pathing algorithm. You'll find that the most efficient route is to fill up your trains such that they're full. __Not__ necessarily for individual packages to take the shortest path. In fact, many routes are locally suboptimal (ie: moving away from the destination) so that you can reach a hub. Sending a train with 100% of cargo down your rail-lines is far more efficient than sending two trains with 50% cargo. Similar issues happen to airplanes, busses, trains, and ships in real life.
- neilfrndes 5y agoI'm a huge fan of Open TTD! I never play with the computer, since it made horrible choices. But that was pre 2010. Your post convinced me to try playing with cargodist.
- irjustin 5y ago> Is the CCP throttling exports, or installing backdoors? The 2nd half seems absurd on too many levels, conspiracy level thinking. Changing software? Super easy to detect. Changing hardware? insanely expensive to do it en masse, esp outside of the factory. There's no target, but mass surveillance? This checks so few logic boxes.
- lazide 5y agoWhy would there be no target? His name is literally printed on the outside of the box in machine readable form.
- irjustin 5y agoGoing to take it a few steps further. Now we're targeting a specific person. 1. CCP needs to hack shipping label system to track a specific person (DHL/CCP shipper/Fedex) which method? We need to interject against them all. 2. CCP was waiting for this person to buy a Macbook Pro?! 3. CCP was lucky enough that the exact model was back ordered via China shipping routes. We were lucky because normally they could just walk into any Apple Store and buy it and walk out. No ability to target a specific person. 4. What if the target "returns the laptop?!" Our years of hacking setup didn't work. There are insane amounts of difficulty for this target vector which make it effectively impossible to go after a specific person via supply chain, specific order. So we're back at mass surveillance. That doesn't work because given enough people, someone pen/security check the laptops coming out. Apple will recall.
- lazide 5y agoActually it’s much easier than that, and what the TAO group [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tailored_Access_Operations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tailored_Access_Operations] here does on a smaller scale. There is undoubtably easier and better scale in China since so much tech is manufactured there. They can get the firmware source (or require things be included), and chip masks pretty easily, even easier than the CIA or NSA getting them here. And I doubt any TLA has much problems with that here if they care. The way you do this, is you have ‘partnerships’ with the major shippers where they match against known person of interest on your list. When someone has an interesting shipment to one of your targets, it gets flagged and set aside in a known location. Since all new style equipment needs a basic plan to add targeted hardware/firmware attacks anyway, since if you need the capability to compromise any given target at will (which they do) you need the capability to compromise pretty much all common equipment readily available, at a minimum. All available equipment being a realistic requirement too. Some bored tech will then take the already developed playbook for that specific piece of equipment, write the firmware or glue on the specific special chip to the board, pack it up, and hand it back to the shipper. A physical version of room 641a [https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A] essentially. The Snowden leaks showed it happened regularly, what, a decade ago? If you think China doesn’t have something like that too, I have a bridge to sell you. So then the question is - are you interesting enough to make the list? That I don’t know.
- reaperducer 5y agoMine went Shanghai → Japan → Memphis → destination. Which was strange. Usually all of my Apple kit goes through Alaska. Not this time.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- secondaryacct 5y agoI live in China, I m paranoid like you but about Google trying to map out my activity so I degoogled everything... It's likely we both are not the main concerns of our respective surveillance apparatus :D
- elorant 5y agoThere’s no need to install a backdoor on your computer, which is super risky and requires high specialization. All they have to do is install one on your wifi lamp, or your vacuum cleaner.
- intricatedetail 5y ago> Is the CCP throttling exports, or installing backdoors? They can order workers to do that in the factory. Apple won't be able to do anything about it apart from removing anything that shouldn't be there when it lands in the US. Chinese workers can't say no to CPC orders and Apple has to agree if they want to continue to exploit cheap workforce and lax environment regulations.
- Robotbeat 5y agoApple can move operations elsewhere. China is better at electronics than essentially everyone else BUT they’re no longer the cheapest workforce and Apple has lots of resources that would be worth nothing if it’s found out (ie by US intelligence, etc) that Apple’s hardware is full of backdoors from CCP.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- underscore_ku 5y agoyou worry about CCP buy you use a proprietary software LMAO, you should worry more about Apple
- dylan604 5y ago>then a weekend in Louisville, Kentucky. How this makes any sense With that destination, I'm assuming UPS delivery. I spent 24 hours at the sort facility there shooting a documentary about the delivery service. There's a reason UPS picked Louisville and FedEx picked Memphis. Knowing that reason it does make sense. Fun fact, Lousiville's airport is an international airport only because of UPS. No international passenger flights use that airport.
- radmuzom 5y ago> Is the CCP throttling exports, or installing backdoors? Even if they did, there is nothing to fear in the short toi medium term. Unlike US, China does not go about conducting war crimes, human rights abuses and atrocities all around the globe.
- captainredbeard 5y agoCOVID-19 has entered the chat, along with organs from Falun Gong members