25 ms·
Space debris forces astronauts on space station to take shelter in return ships
- GistNoesis 5y agoWhy not using a bigger bomb to vaporize the thing instead of creating debris ?
- garmaine 5y agoThat'll just make more debris spread out over a larger area. Things don't literally get vaporized, unless you're talking megaton nuclear explosions.
- saiya-jin 5y agoAlso, if the cloud is now 40km big and growing as I read someplace else, the all-vaporizing fireball would have to be ridiculous, much stronger than Tsar bomb and probably blast a massive hole in our atmosphere and all outer layers. A properly bad idea.
- GistNoesis 5y agoNukes would definitely do the trick (it's impressive how strong they are compared to traditional explosives), but it's probably a bad idea because of some treaty about their usage in space. On earth, I did some quick calculations (maybe I'm wrong), energy of vaporization of 1kg of steel, (heating solid steel at 20C to 1500C melting point then melting it then raising to 2860C then boiling it) => 8x10^6 J/kg = energy equivalent of 2kg TNT/kg of steel. I don't know how big was the thing they destroyed but they would just need to have a bomb twice as big as the thing they are trying to destroy. (But with explosives the bottleneck is probably heating the thing sufficiently fast before it disperse). In space it's probably even more favorable, because like water boiling in vacuum at room temperature, the phase diagram of iron https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/5/59/Pure_iron_phase_diagram_%28EN%29.png https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/5/59/Pure_iro... mean that to vaporize it you just have to melt it to a liquid at 1500C (attach lot of thermite to it to make a giant ball of melted thing) then disperse it violently to use the vacuum of space to vaporize it. There are maybe also ways to reuse the kinetic energy of the satellite in motion to help vaporize it.
- anshumankmr 5y agoStrapping a nuke to a large rocket storing tonnes of highly flammable rocket fuel is a recipe for disaster. And the radiation it would release would quite possibly interfere with the Van Allen belt and that would cause issues with satellites.
- phendrenad2 5y agoAs impressive as nukes are, they're nothing compared to the energy of the van allen belt.
- Yizahi 5y agoMaybe this will get some western attention about Russian fuckery everywhere.
- cblconfederate 5y agoHigh inflation with high international tensions are an explosive mix. Despite dumb actions (which have always happened with the same frequency), one should not give in to aggressive rhetoric.
- elurg 5y agoI'm happy to see everybody hate Russia. They truly deserve it.
- mrjin 5y agoHmmm, I guess we'll only need a couple of more actions likes the following before we are blocked from going to space again. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_West_Ford https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_West_Ford
- anshumankmr 5y agoThis is going to make the US use CAATSA even more punitively now.
- pvaldes 5y agospiders, we need a lot of spiders here.
- Sosh101 5y agoStrange headline, leaving out such key info.
- ByThyGrace 5y agoImagine if the JWST gets delayed for another year because it won't find safe passage amid the new debris field.
- chriselles 5y agoThis i becoming quite surreal. First the Russians use very limited budget/capacity to beat Tom Cruise in making the first film in space for optics. And that’s after a series of serious quality control and operational errors. And now the Russians appear to be re-acting the first act of the Sandra Bullock space film Gravity, where a Russian ASAT is the plot device to kick off the film.
- credit_guy 5y agoSome random comments on the Kessler syndrome [1] * a Kessler syndrome would not impact Medium Earth Orbit and Geosynchronous orbit satellites. So, no, we would not lose GPS navigation. * LEO satellites would be impacted, but at least Starlink claims to have a very advanced system of collision avoidance without humans in the loop [2] * a Kessler syndrome would certainly not prevent an exchange of nuclear ballistic missiles. So, Kessler cannot be used in a defensive mode [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kessler_syndrome https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kessler_syndrome [2] https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/44765/starlinks-autonomous-collision-avoidance https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/44765/starlinks-au...
- belter 5y agoDebris field is 40 Km (25 Miles) wide: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29233180 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29233180
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoOK, help me out here... If I blow up a satellite in orbit, I expect a bunch of debris radiating out from the point of collision. I don't expect a bunch of debris moving on parallel trajectories over a span of 40 km. Is that a snapshot of how wide it is in time? Is that peak width of a collection of debris that more-or-less follow the same trajectory? Or what?
- belter 5y agoThe data was collected from radar signals. But you are correct it is much worst than that, and these are probably just the bigger fragments. These simulations (just with two objects/satellites) shows how bad it is. Now add 3 or 4 .... https://youtu.be/7oRC9dHKI9Y https://youtu.be/7oRC9dHKI9Y https://youtu.be/u0NEnPOx6ic https://youtu.be/u0NEnPOx6ic Edit: From this event "2009 satellite collision" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2009_satellite_collision https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2009_satellite_collision
- skykooler 5y agoDue to how orbital mechanics work, debris will move away from the initial trajectory and return to it an orbit later. Since all the pieces have different velocities, by the time an orbit has passed they will have spread out significantly. The trajectories are not completely parallel, but the relative velocities away from the point of impact are insignificant relative to orbital velocity - thus they are all moving in roughly the same direction.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoDo the pieces have the orbital velocity of the satellite? Or that of the interceptor? Or a combination of the two? And if it's a combination, why would they all have (approximately) the same combination?
- Jeff_Brown 5y agoWas it a surprise, or did they know when they went into space that it would happen?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jdavis703 5y agoWell the knew there was a non-zero risk of space debris. But were they expecting the Russian government to deliberately endanger even their own cosmonauts as part of a weapons test? Probably not.
- elliekelly 5y agoThis seems like more than a non-zero risk? I don’t know much about physics or missiles but it seems like debris would be a fairly obvious outcome?
- freeflight 5y agoBeing able to predict and control the trajectories of the resulting debris is something that's quite possible. Particularly if the anti-satellite weapon is designed, and maneuverable enough, to blow a target up into a certain direction.
- chasd00 5y agoThey had to have known a years long debris cloud would be the result of the test. Also, I don't think a nation on earth ever doubted Russia could shoot down a satellite. The whole thing is baffling. Maybe someone got drunk and just hit the button / gave the order?
- MerelyMortal 5y agoIf anything happened to the cosmonauts on the ISS, then Putin could use that as an excuse for Russia to build its own station. I wonder what a modern Space Race would look like.
- Me1000 5y agoThis wasn't just any space debris. This debris was created when Russia blew up one of their own satellites earlier today! https://www.theverge.com/2021/11/15/22782946/russia-asat-test-satellite-international-space-station-debris https://www.theverge.com/2021/11/15/22782946/russia-asat-tes...
- denkmoon 5y agoWe're going to Kessler syndrome ourselves over some trivial dispute on the ground "requiring" a satellite to be taken out, then retaliation has to occur by the opposing party to save face. Repeat a few times and now you can't get into orbit.
- elihu 5y agoIn a major-war-between-superpowers situation, maybe "nobody can get into orbit" is preferable to one side controlling space unilaterally? Though I suppose things would have to be really bad to deny access to space even on a short-term basis. The more plausible scenario maybe just that most of the commercial satellites get destroyed by and become debris, and nothing can occupy certain orbits for any significant length of time without getting hit eventually. Which means that short-term use of space for military objectives would be the least-impacted use case.
- yread 5y agoyou have a point, ICBMs fly up to 2000km so if there is a ton of debris at 400 km we are good. Well, unless you need to worry also about nuclear cruise missiles, torpedos, short range ballistic missiles, hacking civilian infrastructure and conventional weapons.
- PeterisP 5y agoI'm not sure if Kessler syndrome would prevent ICBMs - it wouldn't prevent things from getting to space, it would prevent things from getting to space safely. If there's a 50% chance of a destructive impact, manned flights are right out, but firing hundreds of ICBMs would still be reasonably effective.
- dangle1 5y agoSuch a sad, destructive act from a country facing the upcoming insignificance of its space program as China has shown disinterest in partnering with them in space and SpaceX has freed NASA from paying dearly for US astronauts to fly on Soyuz to the ISS.
- anonporridge 5y agoThings that are dying and becoming irrelevant often have violent fits as the end draws near. I hope for myself to walk with eyes wide open into my end with courage and peace.
- AutumnCurtain 5y agoI feel confident for several reasons that nobody will ever say I went out like the Russian space program
- gadders 5y agoWe could freeze your body and launch it at a satellite?
- boringg 5y agoMaybe noone will say that but I could see a band called "The Russian Space Program" similar to Led Zeppelin name origins....
- anonporridge 5y agorage, rage against the dying of the light.
- kwhitefoot 5y ago> band called "The Russian Space Program" Make me think of band called "British Sea Power". Sadly they have now changed the name to "Sea Power" to avoid being associated with isolationist nationalists who don't appreciate the joke.
- jacquesm 5y agoThat was an incredibly dumb thing to do. Let's hope that the bulk of it de-orbits soon.
- toss1 5y agoIt won't be quick. Seems that average de-orbital time from the 400km altitude of the ISS is about a year [1] Considering they already had to shelter less than 24 hours after the debris cloud was created, and the debris cloud will only spread out, I'm wondering if real question is how soon it becomes unsafe to inhabit. Send up a lot of fuel and boost it into another orbit? I don't see how this isn't incredibly bad. [1] https://www.spaceacademy.net.au/watch/debris/orblife.htm https://www.spaceacademy.net.au/watch/debris/orblife.htm
- 0des 5y agoTo what degree, I wonder, does this negatively impact our atmosphere, pollutionwise
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoVery close to zero. The earth's atmosphere is bigger than 5 * 10e18 kilograms. Burning up a satellite's worth of debris is a non-event.
- toss1 5y agoThis one event? I'd be mildly surprised if it were even detectable, other than the brief fireball. There is a constant rain of meteors and meteorids - estimated 139/day more than 10 grams hit the surface of the earth every day [1]. I don't know how many more thousands of small bits burn up every day without ever coming close to the ground. So, I'd say it is at least far down in that noise. Also, if the total mass of the satellite is a ton, vaporizing all if it in the atmosphere would make make a change of less than one part per 1000 trillion, considering that the atmosphere weighs, 5.5 quadrillion tons[2]. So maybe if it was all made of some element that is very rare in the atmosphere, it might get up to a 1-in-a-trillion concentration when it all burned up? But then, it also is now scattered all over so won't even burn up at once, so heavy elements from the first chunks may have already settled out from by the time the later ones arrive. There's no way I can concoct anything that it is an atmospheric pollution risk. But space pollution, we might be talking Kessler Syndrome [3]; I don't think this will do it, but I'm worried. [1] https://universeexplained.com/how-many-meteorites-hit-the-earth-every-day/ https://universeexplained.com/how-many-meteorites-hit-the-ea... [2] https://www.britannica.com/story/how-much-does-earths-atmosphere-weigh https://www.britannica.com/story/how-much-does-earths-atmosp... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kessler_syndrome https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kessler_syndrome
- ianhawes 5y agoNew satellites should be equipped with appropriate armor and shielding at this point. Space debris isn’t going anywhere and will likely increase exponentially.
- Rebelgecko 5y agoI suspect that it would take an impractical amount of armor to defend a satellite against a missile with thousands of kph relative velocity
- tempestn 5y agoThey meant against debris, not missiles. Still easier said than done though. If nothing else, armor would add a lot of weight, which is a major factor when you're launching things into orbit.
- zardo 5y agoAn ASAT weapon isnt going to hit much harder than debris. For circular orbits of the same altitude, just a few degrees off on the orbital planes and the velocity difference is in the km/s.
- tempestn 5y agoTrue. Armoring against either one isn't going to be practical.
- perl4ever 5y agoI think this is another one of those (sub) threads based on a false premise. Shielding on spacecraft and the ISS is totally a thing, because there is a clever way to make practical armor that is light weight. The keyword is "Whipple shield". "There are over 100 shield configurations on the International Space Station alone"
- BHSPitMonkey 5y ago
- jp42 5y agoFor those who dont know already, such activity contribute to the possibility of Kessler Syndrome/Effect in future. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kessler_syndrome https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kessler_syndrome
- MisterBiggs 5y agoThis was likely due to the anti satellite test performed by Russia. There really needs to be international law completely forbidding tests like this. Kessler Syndrome would do much more damage than just keep us from getting to space. Life as we know it today does not exist without satellites.
- PeterisP 5y ago> There really needs to be international law completely forbidding Just to note, there's literally nothing of this form currently existing or possible - international law consists of treaties to which the countries have agreed, so such a treaty forbidding something would be binding to Russia if and only if Russia agrees to sign the treaty. In international law, sovereignty is the ultimate power, authority and/or jurisdiction over a people and a territory. Like, there is treaty forbidding landmines, but it don't forbid landmines to those who haven't signed it e.g. Russia, USA and China; there's a treaty prohibiting proliferation of nuclear weapons, which does not prohibit it to those who haven't signed e.g. India, Pakistan and Israel, and so on. Countries are sovereign and have full rights of self-determination, there isn't any world government that would be somehow superior to the countries and there are no ways to pass some "international law" to forbid them something unless they choose to. Well, unless you can "motivate" that choice which credible threats of excessive violence, but that doesn't apply to countries who have the nuclear veto power.
- LogonType10 5y agoHopefully the space force gets abolished just as other commenters want so that no one is left to enforce this international law.
- anadem 5y agoYou can't seriously imagine that "the space force" could enforce something? Space farce.
- jazzyjackson 5y ago> Life as we know it today does not exist without satellites. Pilots and ship captains will have to navigate the old fashioned way, and I could be wrong but I believe radio is still the default for communications, weather reports etc. so i’m curious what i’m missing besides Google Maps not holding my hand to the grocery store. an economic impact surely, but life as we know it?
- rasz 5y agoFirst we had holes drilled in Russian module then we had a fire in same Russian module then Russian supply ship rammed ISS and now this. Someone in Russia is really trying hard.
- thanatos519 5y agoThe ISS would have fallen out a window if it wasn't in orbit.
- dragonelite 5y agoDon't think the Russians really care about the ISS for now its just a stop gap until the Chinese space station is more developed. At least relationships between Russia and China is warm and the leaders respect each other. Don't think Russia and EU really see eye to eye and EU leaders are really disrespectful in their diplomacy(if you can call what the west does diplomacy). Super weird because the EU and US aren't really talking from a position of strength in 2021 as Milley said we are now in a period where there are 3 great powers the US, China and Russia.
- panick21_ 5y ago> leaders respect each other I don't think they respect each other at all. China sees Russia as a large province that they will eventually absorb. The only reason why Russia is going towards China is because China doesn't care that its a dictatorship. Russia has every strategic reason in the world to not go in the direction of China.
- adipginting 5y agoThey seem to try to tell something to the world, but I don't know how to interpret it.
- wly_cdgr 5y ago"If we can't have a seat at the space table, we are willing to destroy the table"
- osivertsson 5y agoStrong words in press-release from NASA: https://www.nasa.gov/press-release/nasa-administrator-statement-on-russian-asat-test/ https://www.nasa.gov/press-release/nasa-administrator-statem...
- djohnston 5y agoEndangering their own cosmonauts? What an own goal
- tamaharbor 5y agoCan they adjust the ISS orbit so it is not in jeopardy every 90 minutes?
- Kye 5y agoOrbits are chosen for a reason. Changing it to one that's less ideal is expensive in money and fuel, and complicates things for the support system on the ground. Going higher is probably more efficient for the station itself since there's less drag, but it costs more to send a rocket there.
- ericbarrett 5y agoHigher is also closer to the Van Allen radiation belts, which are pretty intense. They start at ~680km above sea level, though this is highly dependent on latitude and space weather; ISS orbits around 400km.
- sp332 5y agoThe satellite was around 450 km up, and the ISS stays around 400 km. The bulk of the debris should still be above them. The bits that traveled down 50 km in a day should clear out soon; one astronaut said tomorrow will be quieter.
- trixie_ 5y agoIt's crap like this that makes WW3 a real possibility with these demonstrations of recklessness.
- hunterb123 5y agoIf Uighur camps doesn't do it, this won't.
- PeterisP 5y agoUyghur camps have no direct impact on the main strategic, military and economic interests of major players, significant damage to satellite infrastructure certainly does. It's quite reasonable to assume that this would be treated by the decisionmakers as more important than whatever China does with its citizens.
- hunterb123 5y ago> whatever China does with its citizens. Never seen genocide downplayed this hard But sure, releasing a bio attack on accident then. Basically a bio version of Chernobyl, worse scale more deaths. Plus the concentration camps. If that doesn't do it, this small thing from Russia won't.
- PeterisP 5y agoWhat I hear you saying is essentially "If nations don't react to large scale genocide, then they won't react to mere harm to economic interests" - do I understand you correctly? Because if that's the case, then I think you are extremely mistaken, because all the history evidence shows that the major nations care much more about their geopolitical interests than humanitarian factors even to the scale of genocide. The world has repeatedly ignored genocide while at the same time violently reacting to relatively tiny economic or strategic threats! Cambodia, Rwanda, etc... Heck, the world definitely would have let Hitler get away with Holocaust if they weren't already in war with Germany. I'm not trying to downplay anything, what I'm saying is that the scale of atrocities is irrelevant because even if China or anyone else would do public horrific torture-murder of most of their population, it would still have less likelihood of triggering an intervention than if they threatened the USA network of satellites; It's very, very plausible for a genocide not to trigger a reaction but for an economic threat to "do it". I'd rather say the opposite - genocide will get a reaction if and only if there other (strategic/economic/political) factors that make an intervention desirable; at least that's how it has always been in practice.
- akomtu 5y agoI think Putin has just sent a simple message that he won't tolerate starlink sats flying across his land.
- panick21_ 5y agoIf you make outrage claims, please provide actual evidence or at least reasoning.
- jazzyjackson 5y agohas putin expressed anything to this effect? i cant imagine why he would care
- no-dr-onboard 5y agoIsn't it ironic that an industry dominated by highly educated, scholarly individuals is plagued with a problem analogous to something as primitive and short sighted as ocean dumping? Who will scold the scolders?
- bulbosaur123 5y agoIt might be in Putin's interest to create conditions favourable for eventual Kessler Syndrome. If this happens, is there some long list of all the implications on international politics, relations and just our daily lives in general?
- dainiusse 5y agoThe russians will make a mess even in space...
- jl6 5y agoLots of commentary about this being stupidity or madness. But it’s also possible this is a calculated recklessness, part of a strategy of appearing fearsome and unpredictable. It sends the message that Russia is willing to make sacrifices in order to project its power. Some of its own assets are endangered, sure, but the USA has far more space assets at risk. This is a pawn sacrifice to threaten a rook.
- nabla9 5y agoIt's called brinkmanship. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brinkmanship https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brinkmanship
- beachy 5y agoSomething like Richard Nixon's madman theory [0]. I don't see what the threat could achieve though. 0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Madman_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Madman_theory
- Tepix 5y agoThe recent A-SAT tests make it clear that there is a strong asymmetry: One single actor can make LEO very dangerous or unusable for the rest of the world. It's a condition that terrorists love. There's an argument to be made that A-SAT tests are terrorist acts (perhaps unless in very low orbit with decays of a few days - even then some debris is likely to reach a higher orbit)
- edf13 5y agoAt what stage would this become a chain-reaction event, causing major satellite issues?
- immmmmm 5y agocannot find the link but remember a NASA official saying the Kessler syndrome was already happening, which is not surprising since you only need that the rate of replenishing an orbit is higher than cleaning by atmospheric drag to get something that evolve in an exponential manner