4 ms·
> It doesn't really matter if you add new stock at the top end or at the bottom end, people from the bottom move up, and make space at the bottom for new entran
by seanmcdirmid 5y ago
> It doesn't really matter if you add new stock at the top end or at the bottom end, people from the bottom move up, and make space at the bottom for new entrants.
Only if the old housing stock isn't torn down to make room for the new housing stock. Thankfully property taxes aren't driven in the potential value of land (rather, they are tied to actual value), but most small scale landlords of affordable housing right in it are in it for property appreciation, not rents. Their exit plans are often to sell to a developer as tear downs.
> This means they will only build the most profitable units, the high end today.
There are costs are too high (to acquire property and build) to justify anything but going after the highest end of the market. Once the high end is say satisfied, money (investment) could simply move away from housing if it can't make any money there. Money chases the highest returns between all of the markets, not just one market.
- wan23 5y ago> Only if the old housing stock isn't torn down to make room for the new housing stock This is about zoning too. Normally, if the demand is there for it a smart land owner would build more housing on the same plot, e.g. turning a single family into a two family, but of course that is illegal in many places.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoYes, that is exactly what is happening in Ballard (Seattle area) right now. Those cheap 100 year old low income housing complexes (one or two stories) are being raised for a bunch fo three story townhomes, smart developers can sell each of those town homes for $1 million each, and they could get much less if they kept it as a hotel-like complex. I just bought one of those town homes, so I'm not going to complain too much, but I'm self aware about what is going on here. So poor people are still getting screwed. My daily walk to the grocery store passes by a few places that are pretty shabby (so low income) and right across the street they are building a bunch of luxury town homes. It doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out what will happen to those shabby places in a year or so.
- jjav 5y ago> a smart land owner would build more housing on the same plot This is an uncomfortably extremist position, should maximizing revenue per investment be the one and only consideration society takes into account? I do many things that provide joy in life in other ways, even if I know they don't maximize revenue or savings. I wouldn't want to go through life thinking about nothing else than ROI for every action.
- lmm 5y ago> Thankfully property taxes aren't driven in the potential value of land (rather, they are tied to actual value) That's not a thankful thing at all, it incentivises using the limited land in wasteful (low-value) ways. > Once the high end is say satisfied, money (investment) could simply move away from housing if it can't make any money there. Money chases the highest returns between all of the markets, not just one market. Available capital is practically unlimited these days, anything that's profitable and legal to build will get built.
- imtringued 5y ago>Available capital is practically unlimited these days, anything that's profitable and legal to build will get built. And it's mostly chasing monopolies like location.
- imtringued 5y ago>property taxes aren't driven in the potential value of land (rather, they are tied to actual value) That means multifamily properties have higher tax bills for absolutely no reason. Expensive locations need to provide more housing per area so charging a fixed fee based on the value of the land is a much better approach. You get to build a single family home and pay through the nose or split the bill with a multi family home.
- seanmcdirmid 5y ago> That means multifamily properties have higher tax bills for absolutely no reason. Not true: most localities use a significant portion of property taxes to fund public schools, and more families = more kids.