3 ms·
> The real problem as always is zoning. If the real problem was always zoning, wouldn't dense cities like NYC and Shanghai be cheaper than average, not way ove
by seanmcdirmid 5y ago
> The real problem as always is zoning.
If the real problem was always zoning, wouldn't dense cities like NYC and Shanghai be cheaper than average, not way over average?
> Check out Japan housing CPI - a market where supply meets demand thanks to federal zoning rules, and is also centrally banked.
Japan went through a huge bubble in the 1980s. Also, housing (the structures at least) rapidly depreciates in Japan, which prevents them from being used a speculative asset as in countries (even then they still went through a huge bubble in the 80s). It is definitely an alternative model to our own, but I'm not sure how many people will want to experiment with that. Japan also much more strictly restricts immigration than other countries, which makes it, for example, a bad place for Wenzhou house wife real estate speculation.
- meowtimemania 5y agoZoning is also an issue in NYC. The suburbs are unable to become dense do to zoning which causes the prices to go up.
- nine_k 5y agoBrooklyn increases the density steadily. I see a lot of construction around me, mostly higher-density replacing low-density, but it's relatively slow.
- TulliusCicero 5y ago> If the real problem was always zoning, wouldn't dense cities like NYC and Shanghai be cheaper than average, not way over average? It's not about supply by itself, it's supply vs demand. Big cities have big populations and economies, which means a lot of demand. But as far as zoning goes, note that like other metros, NYC has actually effectively downzoned areas over time; in fact, a huge proportion of buildings there would now be illegal due to different types of density restrictions: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/05/19/upshot/forty-percent-of-manhattans-buildings-could-not-be-built-today.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/05/19/upshot/forty-... A lot of NIMBY's tend to go, "well, there's still some areas where it's possible to build more, so there's no real issue there". This is approximately like restricting car manufacturing to one state, and then when car prices go through the roof, saying "well, there's still more land to build car factories there, so I don't see the problem, it couldn't possibly be this rule".
- mapme 5y agoIt’s wild that manhattans population was ~2.5 million in 1910 and is now only ~1.6 million.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoDoesn't it make sense though? In 1910, manhattan was expensive but a lot of people still lived/worked there. The apartments would be crazily subdivided so you could fit 10 people into a 3 or even 2 bedroom. Now they are all owned by wallstreet bankers with small families, and they spend much of their time somewhere else (they might not even list their manhattan apartment as their "main domicile" during the census).
- bobthepanda 5y agoyeah, the two big changes are * multigenerational to nuclear households * decline in number of kids This pattern of living is still common to a lesser degree in outer-borough immigrant neighborhoods, which is why they were so hard hit during NYC's massive COVID wave.
- TulliusCicero 5y agoDemand for Manhattan apartments is crazy high, it's just illegal for taller ones to be built to meet demand most of the time. People think Manhattan is mostly skyscrapers, but the reality is very different. Only a small portion of the land has high rises on it, just glance at Google Maps with 3D view on.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoManhattan is mostly multi level apartment buildings, at least 4 stories or so. I don't know why your point would contradict mine. Yes, units in the taller skyscrapers are more expensive and sell for tens of millions of dollars, if not more. I wonder how NYC would do with cheap 30 story Chinese concrete apartment blocks? (30 stories, because any taller requires steel, at least with construction practices that use cheap migrant labor).