10 ms·
> It's probably still cheaper to avoid emitting the CO2 in the first place, but that does put an upper bound on the cost of reaching net zero. It seems hard to
by AnthonyMouse 5y ago
> It's probably still cheaper to avoid emitting the CO2 in the first place, but that does put an upper bound on the cost of reaching net zero.
It seems hard to believe that removing CO2 from the atmosphere could ever be less expensive than not emitting it to begin with. You're working against thermodynamics.
So the whole thing seems like a fraud. An excuse to keep emitting CO2 while claiming that you'll do something about it "tomorrow."
- civilized 5y agoCapturing it at the point of emission seems like it should be the priority. Way, way easier to get it at that point. But that would make fossil fuels more expensive, and we can't have that right? Maybe we should just massively subsidize point of emission carbon capture for fossil fuels. We need it for some use cases that renewables don't work for anyway (yet).
- adam_arthur 5y agoI suspect the public would be on board with these type of policies if the cost to the poor and middle class were subsidized. Any legislation that increases cost of energy will impact poorest the most, but for some reason cost of energy to the poor is not brought up much in climate discussions. And of course China is the biggest emitter by far, so something special needs to be done there. Likely first world countries would have to subsidize third world country energy costs.
- lumost 5y agoThere are many biological and geological processes that remove CO2 from the atmosphere. Many of which could be sped up. Carbon removal need not involve mega facilities running co2 scrubbers.
- sharp11 5y agoThere is a moral hazard here, but the reality is that we’ve passed the point where emissions reductions alone can get us where we want to be. We will need both reductions and removal.
- mgraczyk 5y agoIt's more plausible to me when you think about centralization vs decentralization. Sure, it would clearly be cheaper to emit less if the emissions were mostly coming from a small number of controlled facilities. But when the sources are millions of tailpipes and smokestacks across the globe, it's at least plausible that a centralized, new recapture solution would be cheaper than decreasing emissions in millions of old places.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoGiven how fast electrification of transportation is occurring, I think those "millions of tailpipes" may go down sooner than you think.
- redisman 5y agoIn rich western pockets like Norway and SF Bay sure. Globally though your median car owner can in no way afford to replace their car with a new one
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoSure, for now. But pretty much all of Europe, large parts of the US, much of China have plans to ban gas vehicles in the near future (< 15 years). Once that happens most of the rest of the world will follow quickly because there will be just less supply chain support for gas vehicles, and what remains will quickly become a diminishing fraction of the total. I definitely see this happening much faster than any attempts at atmospheric capture would even make a tiny dent.
- redisman 5y agoI’m definitely in the strategy bucket of let’s do everything and hope it’s enough
- inglor_cz 5y agoIt also depends a lot on price of electricity. Norway has a lot of electric cars because it is a rainy country with terrain very suitable for dams and cheap hydro production. With enough small modular reactors, we might get to the same point elsewhere. The German renewables mix does seem to drive prices up, especially in certain peaks, because nature is unpredictable and you can absolutely have a freak streak of several windless, dark, cold days in the winter.
- BurningFrog 5y agoRemoving CO₂ is far more doable, because you don't have to convince/force 7 billion people to do something. Anyone with the right equipment can just do it, without asking permission, just like CO₂ emitters can.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoYou don't need permission to pay people to install wind turbines either. What you need is money. And if you have money, and a dollar spent installing wind turbines goes further than a dollar spent extracting CO2, why are you going to spend it on the inefficient thing?
- p1mrx 5y agoA wind turbine is only profitable if you can physically connect it to someone who needs energy while the wind is blowing. That will get harder as more are built.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoAt which point the most economically efficient thing becomes to install batteries or hydro or nuclear. It still isn't carbon capture, is it?
- snovv_crash 5y agoBecause at some point you have enough electricity.
- MaxGanzII 5y agoCO₂ is not the only factor driving ecological damage and indeed, the mass extinction event currently in progress. There are simply too many humans for the way in which we as a species currently behave. Either we need single parent families, globally, for a few generations, to get numbers down to a sustainable level, or, we have to convince/force 7 billion people to accept and adhere to major changes in how they live their lives. CO₂ is a basically easy problem, compared to this, if it is possible to take the route of geo-engineering, because, as you say, it's not necessary to change how people behave; but I think no matter what, there is a need to change how people behave, or billions die from famine and economic failure, induced by ecological collapse. I don't think people will change (indeed, there will be large numbers of people vocally against change), I think Governments will at best effectively do nothing "(we're building lots of renewable! but we're also building lots of gas at the same time!"), or more likely make things worse ("we'll phase out coal by 2070"), so my expectation is human suffering on a scale never seen before in all human history. Humans are kākāpō; we're over-reproducing, having as they did no meaningful natural predators to keep us in check, and sooner or later, that leads to ecological collapse. (The kākāpō went through several cycles of this and evolved to reproduce very, very slowly, and so came into balance with their environment, and then were very nearly almost completely wiped out when humans arrived.)
- scatters 5y agoIt all comes down to the cost of energy. If the current improvements in renewable energy are sustained, or if the promise of fusion comes to pass, or even a considerable improvement in the economics of fission, then yes it could make sense to emit carbon dioxide now and recapture it later.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoI tend to agree, at least from the point of view that even if we continue to burn fossil fuels that it would be much cheaper to require CO2 removal where it is produced, and thus in extremely high concentrations, than trying to waft it out of the atmosphere where it's only 400 ppm. Electrification of transportation would also make this much easier, because instead of having billions of little fossil fuel burners all over the planet, you could concentrate that burning to just power plants. At that point there would be a lot fewer places where it would be difficult to sequester carbon (e.g. planes, large ocean vessels).
- Sankozi 5y agoIf you had process that only needs electricity then you run it only when power is cheap (usually when renewables are producing it). Depending on efficiency this could be better solution than energy storage (instead storing energy you pull CO2 and then burn it later if energy is needed).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- xyzzyz 5y agoCarbon capture techniques do not necessarily allow you to easily burn the captured carbon again. For example, consider a process where calcium oxide is used to capture CO2, converting it to calcium carbonate (that’s how masonry mortars work). You can’t convert calcium carbonate to energy.
- Sankozi 5y agoI did not meant the same CO2, just any available fossil fuels. I find it would be great if we could convert CO2 to something that cannot be profitably burned.
- jorblumesea 5y agoIf taken from a purely economic standpoint, yes. But once politics get involved, a more expensive often can feel "cheaper" if it gets everyone moving in the same direction or produces some level of agreement. Sure, in an ideal world, we would just all do the right thing. But that is not the world we live in.
- notahacker 5y agoIt's also hard to believe that insurance against theft could ever be less expensive than nobody stealing anything, but that doesn't imply insurance is a fraud to allow people to carry on stealing. We live in a world where theft and carbon emissions are going to happen with or without the blessing of the US government, so if they want to spend some money seeing how far they can mitigate the damage then good. I'd rather pin my hopes on technological progress than political magic.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoThe problem is that it's still political magic. Suppose it costs $1 to avoid emitting CO2 (e.g. replace gas car with electric car) and $10 to extract the CO2 after the fact. If you get the latter down to $3, you're still upside down. So where does the $3 come from? Presumably a government, but it doesn't even matter. Anyone would still be better off spending that money to subsidize electric cars or solar panels or something.
- incrudible 5y ago> Suppose it costs X to do Y Don't. You can't predict prices like that. Consider that electric cars roll out of the factory having emitted more CO2 than the equivalent combustion vehicle. It takes a lot of miles to break even. If you put a price on the CO2, you may well figure out that combustion engines end up more efficient, because carbon-neutral fuel is close to being economical. > But then they'd still be better off spending that money to subsidize electric cars or solar panels or something. This is a huge mistake. Don't pick winners. You don't have better information than the market.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> Don't. You can't predict prices like that. You can predict that not emitting CO2 will cost less than emitting CO2 and then recapturing it, because it's the second law of thermodynamics. > Consider that electric cars roll out of the factory having emitted more CO2 than the equivalent combustion vehicle. It takes a lot of miles to break even. It takes about the number of miles that the average person drives in a year. New cars last a lot more than a year. Also, the CO2 it takes to make an electric car has a lot to do with the fact that existing vehicles and power generation emit CO2, which goes away as we get more electric vehicles and non-carbon power generation. > If you put a price on the CO2, you may well figure out that combustion engines end up more efficient, because carbon-neutral fuel is close to being economical. So put a price on CO2. The point isn't that subsidizing electric cars and solar panels is the best solution to the problem, it's that subsidizing carbon capture is strictly worse.
- bryanlarsen 5y agoIf efficiency was ever a concern we wouldn't be burning fossil fuels in the first place. A gasoline engine only extracts a small portion of the energy in the gasoline, most of the energy gets wasted as heat.
- incrudible 5y ago> It seems hard to believe that removing CO2 from the atmosphere could ever be less expensive than not emitting it to begin with. This is the "get rich by saving money" fallacy. Imagine all the CO2 of a century of industrial development had not been emitted. We'd be enjoying a life without man-made climate change, but also without any of the amenities of modern life. Consider that air-to-fuel companies are pretty close to profitability with just a modest increase in carbon taxes. Consider also that countries like Germany spent a lot of money on transitioning to renewables, with very little to show for it. Once you picked the low-hanging fruit, there are no more "savings" to be had without drastically cutting down on production. At that point, you might as well turn some of that production into sequestration. > So the whole thing seems like a fraud. I get the same feeling with electric cars, solar panels and wind turbines. Why? Because these have all rolled out on account of lavish subsidies, not because the market decided they are the most efficient solution. Just put a price on CO2 and watch the market figure that one out. Results may be not what you expect.
- chmod775 5y ago> Imagine all the CO2 of a century of industrial development but also without any of the amenities of modern life. Most people on earth still live in conditions that are nowhere near the kind of development you are likely enjoying. They are also those who will feel the effects of man-made climate change most. That is why this argument falls flat. We didn't buy this kind of living standard with some future self-inflicted suffering: your amenities of modern life are bought with the suffering of others. But the deal is done and over. Now a debt is owed.
- incrudible 5y agoI get that, but what are the implications? Consider that the vast majority of CO2 emissions today are coming from the countries that are still developing to that standard we enjoy. We have no right to ask them to cut down. Therefore, we have no choice but to invest into sequestration, because that's the only way to pay down that "debt".
- 5y ago
- nobodyandproud 5y agoThat assumes a uniform cost for energy spent, which is not an assumption that holds true. The type of energy and even when it’s spent is non-uniform (think about the Texas gas debacle).
- cat_plus_plus 5y agoThermodynamics is about entropy AND enthalpy. A stationary algae bloom using otherwise unused sunlight can be a lot cheaper than trying to fly a heavy battery along with 300 passengers. Earth is also full of natural alkaline minerals that can be used as cements or for soil enrichment while naturally absorbing acidic carbon dioxide. Direct consumption of electricity for carbon capture is not necessarily the main solution, but fine for when renewable or nuclear energy would be otherwise wasted.
- gspr 5y agoIn some sense it's just using the entire atmosphere as a battery. Burn fossile fuels where it's the only reasonable option (currently), such as for planes, then spend energy to pull CO2 out of the atmosphere elsewhere.
- frazbin 5y agoIn a very literal sense, we have been using the atmosphere as half of a battery since forever-- combustion on earth uses atmospheric oxygen as as an electron acceptor.
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> A stationary algae bloom using otherwise unused sunlight can be a lot cheaper than trying to fly a heavy battery along with 300 passengers. The alternative isn't just trying to fit a heavy battery into a plane, it's to scoop the algae up and use it to make carbon-neutral biofuels to run the plane. > Earth is also full of natural alkaline minerals that can be used as cements or for soil enrichment while naturally absorbing acidic carbon dioxide. Then you're trading the thermodynamic problem for an economic one. You have to mine all of that stuff up, do chemistry on it, lose the economic value of the minerals in their existing form and end up with an incredible volume of industrial waste you have to pay to dispose of. It doesn't violate the laws of physics for that to be cheaper, but it's still pretty unlikely. Remember that the alternative doesn't have to cover the full cost of generating electricity from non-carbon sources, only the difference in cost between that and burning coal. That's pretty close to zero, if not negative, as it is, and that's without a carbon tax.
- pharke 5y agoDepends on what the dollar cost of not burning fossil fuels turns out to be. I think being able to close the carbon loop is extremely important, there will inevitably be use cases where burning fossil fuels is the superior or only option. Rocket launches immediately jump to mind and are looking to be an area that will continue to experience explosive growth throughout the next century. We had better have a viable option for capturing those emissions along with the long tail of emissions generated during an orderly transition away from burning fossil fuels.
- WalterBright 5y agoThat's why banning is a bad solution. Tax it. Then when it's really needed, paying the tax is worth it.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoRocket fuel isn't gasoline, it's hydrazine. It's not pumped out of the ground, it's synthetic. This is a good lesson for the carbon capture economics. We know how to make synthetic fuels and biofuels. As a general rule, making them costs around the same as carbon capture. "Grow some plants or something" is actually one of the most efficient known methods of carbon capture. Biofuels cost more than pumping crude out of the ground. They also cost more, in most cases, than electric cars. So if you don't care about CO2 then fossil fuels win over biofuels because they're cheaper and if you do care about CO2 then electric cars win over biofuels because they're cheaper. Basically nobody uses biofuels unless they're subsidized. But we know how to do it; we just also know of something better to use in 98% of cases. Then you have the other 2% of cases. Like aircraft. Existing batteries are too heavy for aircraft and we don't know if or how long it'll be before we have sufficient ones. But we could use biofuels for that. Put a carbon tax on fossil fuels and that's what might happen, because for a plane that might be the most cost effective alternative. So you say hey, maybe it'd be better to keep using fossil fuels in planes and then use carbon capture. If carbon capture has a cost similar to biofuels, that could be competitive. But it's not. Because biofuels produce fuel. With carbon capture you still have to pay to buy petroleum.
- inglor_cz 5y ago
- ithkuil 5y agoMoney and energy are not the same thing.
- opportune 5y agoRenewables don't all have steady load, so it could be an alternative to batteries/hydro batteries. Use natural gas peakers when renewables don't produce enough, use excess renewable power to remove CO2 from the air when they are producing more than you need. Basically it's using the atmosphere as a reverse-battery
- pfdietz 5y agoThe alternative there is to do pre-combustion CO2 capture on the methane, storing hydrogen (or hydrogen + nitrogen) for use in the peaking turbines. Another possibility is to store CO2 underground, and when "charging" use a solid oxide electrolyzer to turn it to carbon. When discharging, it would be run as a SOFC and produce CO2, which would be cooled and stored again. I believe Noon Energy is looking into schemes like this.
- summerlight 5y agoThe point is that upfront investment cost of developing industry specific carbon neutral solution doesn't have uniform ROI and can be (either economically or politically) quite expensive or sometime infeasible. This is an extremely long tail problem and we do need a more general solution applicable even after we exhausted all the low hanging fruits. This is what "upper bound" means in the parent post. So in the ideal scenario, it's more like we eliminate 80% of low hanging emission sources, significant reduce 15% of them and negate the rest with carbon removal to achieve carbon neutrality. In addition to this, removing historical accumulated carbon is also pretty important. The expected cumulative damage at the point of 2050 will be catastrophic even in the most optimistic projection.
- Tanjreeve 5y agoWith the way capitalism works there'll be a lot more takers to solve a harder but more measurable problem that someone will pay them for (remove the CO2 we'll pay by the ton) than there will be to solve a less measurable problem (prevent CO2 being released generally). Perverse incentives for sure but within the existing parameters likely more effective.
- BobbyJo 5y agoIt could never be less expensive in the same way a a sled will continue to slide forever on a frictionless surface: theoretically. Material limitations, and technical limitations may make it cheaper practically. As an example, let's look at rockets. Which is cheaper, removing the CO2 after release, or developing switching technologies, for instance, to using O2 and H. Well, for certain applications, where the energy density and logistics of the fuel matter, pulling the CO2 out afterwards makes more sense. Now, yes, that is a small example, but my point is just to show thermodynamic efficiency doesn't translate directly to cost effectiveness for all applications.
- lucb1e 5y ago> An excuse to keep emitting CO2 while claiming that you'll do something about it "tomorrow." While paying the higher price today to have it removed? That's not much of an excuse, that's buying your way out of it. If people want to go that route and they pay for their own emissions (there, of course, is going to be the problem) then be my guest. If you'd rather go the typically cheaper route of changing the technology or lifestyle (e.g. drive electric or ditch the car altogether), that's also fine.
- DennisP 5y agoBear in mind that (a) you're just pulling it from the atmosphere and burying it, not splitting the C from O2 so you can use it as fuel again, and (b) there are applications like long-haul jets and cement production where eliminating emissions isn't that easy. To put some numbers on (a), David MacKay's book has some numbers[1]: > The laws of physics say that the energy required must be at least 0.2 kWh per kg of CO2.... > Lackner told me in June 2008 that, in a dry climate, the concentration cost has been reduced to about 0.18–0.37 kWh of low-grade heat per kg CO2. The compression cost is 0.11 kWh per kg. Thus Lackner’s total cost is 0.48 kWh or less per kg. Burning a kilogram of coal generates 8 kWh[2] and 2.42 kg CO2[3]. So that's 8 kWh generated, requiring 1.16 kWh to pull 2.42 kg CO2 back out out of the atmosphere. So about 15% of the energy obtained by putting carbon in the atmosphere is needed to remove it. [1] https://www.withouthotair.com/c31/page_244.shtml https://www.withouthotair.com/c31/page_244.shtml) [2] https://www.euronuclear.org/glossary/coal-equivalent/ https://www.euronuclear.org/glossary/coal-equivalent/ [3] https://360energy.net/how-does-using-energy-create-carbon-emissions/ https://360energy.net/how-does-using-energy-create-carbon-em...
- guiriduro 5y ago> there are applications like long-haul jets and cement production where eliminating emissions isn't that easy. I disagree, there's an easy solution to eliminating those emissions: have zero long-haul jets and zero cement production. Before this gets (inevitably) downvoted, the more interesting question is why do we need either, what alternatives are there, how fundamentally we're willing to question our biases and expectations over what counts as a necessity. If saving our environment is an overriding priority, then the extent of the compromises we have to make can be made clearer.
- dools 5y agoI think the idea is that you do both
- initplus 5y agoIt may be easier to develop one efficient process to extract CO2 from the atmosphere than to develop numerous efficient alternatives to every CO2 producing activity.
- fifilura 5y ago> You're working against thermodynamics. I find this aspect of global warming intriguing. I wish som physicist could fill in. Aren't we always fighting the laws of thermodynamics? Is this what global warming is all about if you leave out the details about CO2 etc? Is it even possible to fight?
- ahevia 5y agoSadly the amount of CO2 in our atmosphere even if we stopped polluting today. Will still bring about huge negative effects down the road. We need to decarbonize our society(listed first because it’s the first priority) AND remove CO2. Source & a great read: https://www.orbuch.com/carbon-removal/ https://www.orbuch.com/carbon-removal/ If you want to learn about carbon dioxide removal check out AirMiners: https://bootup.airminers.org/ https://bootup.airminers.org/ they have a useful self paced curriculum
- GekkePrutser 5y agoWe do, but right now we have to start somewhere. It'll take less energy and effort and production resources to reduce emissions than capture the same amount. Once we get closer to zero emissions it makes more sense to think about capture IMO. Edit: oh wait I think you are saying the same as you mention reduction is first priority, sorry.
- robbedpeter 5y agoAt a superficial level of analysis, yes, but you can't turn off all the coal plants, stop oil extraction, convert ice to electric, and distribute sufficient power storage to keep modern life going at a snap of the fingers. If you can offset the emissions while at the same time moving toward renewable and sustainable energy, you're mitigating necessary inefficiencies. Mitigation is better than fantasizing about rapid fossil fuel elimination. There are way too many lives that depend on maintaining the status quo, in terms of power and economics and chemical resources. Progress will be gradual, like cleanup of the pacific garbage patch.