6 ms·
Honestly though: the idea of loading 20MiB of JS to read a 24KiB message is weird. Like: I get it, traditional mail clients kinda suck, they feel bloated and j
by dijit 5y ago
Honestly though: the idea of loading 20MiB of JS to read a 24KiB message is weird.
Like: I get it, traditional mail clients kinda suck, they feel bloated and janky. But the more I think of it, the more I think that webmail was a mistake, especially webmail as heavy as GMail has become.
- vbezhenar 5y ago> Honestly though: the idea of loading 20MiB of JS to read a 24KiB message is weird. What about downloading 70 MB of compressed binary code for Thunderbird? > Like: I get it, traditional mail clients kinda suck, they feel bloated and janky. But the more I think of it, the more I think that webmail was a mistake, especially webmail as heavy as GMail has become. I don't see how does it differ from traditional e-mail clients, except that you don't have to install, configure and allow unlimited access to your computer.
- jeffbee 5y agoIt differs very greatly from traditional desktop mailers in that the search on gmail is fast (because it brings thousands of machines to bear on your request for an instant) and the search in desktop apps takes forever (because your little computer no matter how beefy does not have a million cores).
- still_grokking 5y agoI have a few GB of mail folders. I can search them more or less instantaneous, using Kontact (KMail). Full-text indexing isn't dark magic at all.
- jeffbee 5y agoI guess we have different requirements of scale. My gmail is over 300GB (one of the reasons I have a Google 1 subscription).
- still_grokking 5y agoEver considered to archive parts of it? I have difficulties to believe all of that is currently needed mail. (I know, it piles up over the years! :-)) Also most of it will be likely some bloat form HTML mail and attachments (especially with their inefficient encodings). My point was: Handling full-text search indices over even dozens of GB of plain text isn't anything a mediocre computer couldn't handle nowadays.
- jraph 5y agoHave you actually tried search on Thunderbird? The quick filter finds messages in seconds in a folder with > 10000 mails. Not instantaneous, but not forever. The global search is instantaneous because Thunderbird indexes the mails. Not having to rely on the Internet to find your stuff is a feature, not a bug.
- themaninthedark 5y agoBut then my search is not powered by the cloud! Snark aside, I sometimes feel like we reinvent the wheel using new technologies just because we like the new hotness. I see the OS battles take place and my only thought is..at work, I want an OS that: Boots and then gets the hell out of my way so I can do my work. I don't want it to try and sell me things or re-arrange things or have to spend time tinkering or fixing it. Now in my free time, sure! I set up a computer with pass thorough GPU so I can game in Windows while running Linux. It was fun and a learning experience.
- winrid 5y agoThe reason search is slow on your computer is just that the app doesn't use the right kind of index, or maybe no index, for whatever reason. I can index hundreds of gigabytes of text on my laptop and have full text search take a couple milliseconds. The problem is mail servers. They usually don't support search this way, so the client has to download or cache each message to do the search. Gmail gets around this by having their own protocol and the indexes ready.
- zinconfire 5y agoIMAP does support server-side full-text search of bodies. (In mutt, this is invoked with the =b operator of the l command.) Amusingly enough, this works well with real mail servers like dovecot, but it seems to sometimes miss matches with gmail, because gmail's indexes aren't very good.
- winrid 5y agoThe more you know, thanks!
- dhosek 5y agoIn apple mail, I can search all my mailboxes for all my accounts in one search and it's pretty much instantaneous. Most of my email accounts are hosted in gmail, but I generally use Apple Mail to access them (the only times I go into the web interface is for the account I use for submitting writing where I apply multiple tags to each message indicating publication/piece submitted/response type or to clean out the spam folder since I worry a little that if I delete messages from Apple Mail I might be inadvertently telling gmail that the spam wasn't actually spam).
- pchangr 5y agoI personally would prefer a one time 70 MB thunderbird download rather than a recurrent 20MiB download every time it loads. I value my time more than I value my data, I guess.
- jeffbee 5y agoIt obviously doesn't transfer 20MB of anything. With a hot cache it needs about 300KB of traffic to load the initial thread list.
- djxfade 5y agoBrowsers caches that kind of assets. So in practice you only only download it once every time it gets updated
- KronisLV 5y agoUnless you only use web applications in private browser windows and/or clean your browser data every time you close the browser and/or have cache disabled (though this one's more by accident, since Firefox gives you the checkbox under network tab, but it doesn't work for just the site that you're developing locally, but seems to persist globally for all of the browser). Of course, that's not the use case of most people, but that's also one that shouldn't be dismissed entirely - for people who don't trust the modern web in any capacity, local system software is indeed a better choice.
- still_grokking 5y agoWhich is likely more than once a day given today's web-development practices (continuous integration and such).
- jraph 5y ago> What about downloading 70 MB of compressed binary code for Thunderbird? You do it only once, do not risk having to do it when being on a metered or spotty connection because your cache is not warm or the webmail got yet another update, which can happen at any time. You can apply Thunderbird updates when you are on a good connection. You can access your mails offline, you don't re-download them each time you open them. It's faster, even on a good connection. > configure The configuration part for most providers is essentially typing one's email address and password, so there is not much to say. > allow unlimited access to your computer That is why I am reluctant to run non-free software, but Thunderbird is free, I can reasonably trust it. Especially the version packaged by my OS vendor. I agree a better isolation for native desktop apps may be desirable though.
- green-eclipse 5y agoIs it true that you only need to download Thunderbird once? Don't you need to download new versions? Security updates? https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/security/known-vulnerabilities/thunderbird/ https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/security/known-vulnerabilities...
- jraph 5y agore-read my comment
- johnisgood 5y agoYou can also firejail programs on Linux and so forth.
- vbezhenar 5y ago> You do it only once I just checked and my second gmail login downloaded 500 KB before it became usable. Browser allows for caching of downloaded code. > do not risk having to do it when being on a metered or spotty connection because your cache is not warm or the webmail got yet another update, which can happen at any time. You can apply Thunderbird updates when you are on a good connection. I agree with your point. I think that it's possible to implement a separate update for web apps with explicit request, but it's rarely done and unusual for web. > You can access your mails offline, you don't re-download them each time you open them. It's faster, even on a good connection. Web browser allows for local storage and offline work which could be utilized for those features. You can enable offline mode in Gmail. I just checked, it works.
- ranguna 5y agoOn one side, you download 70MB of thunderbird once and update it every once in a while without losing access to your emails while it's updating. On the other side, you have to download 25 MB of Gmail more frequently because cache is invalidated at a higher rate than thunderbird updates and you have to wait for your browser to download most of the page before you gain access to your emails. Don't get me wrong, I use webmail all the time with protonmail, Gmail, outlook and purelymail, because it abstracts installation and updates, but your argument doesn't seem to be valid.
- kiwijamo 5y agoIt's not just that the cache is invalidated, I also suspect Google changes the JS code fairly frequently enough that the browser needs to download a fresh copy (even if the cache it has is not that old and could otherwise have been reused). Compiled apps on the other hand are much more static.
- kiwijamo 5y agoTo be fair you only have to download the 70 MB once (+ the occasional updates). Gmail instead pushes its JS over and over again. Every time I load Gmail it feels like it's starting from Square One all over again but even actually using it (opening, replying, etc) feels slow. Thankfully one of my several $WORK email accounts is 365 based so I just redirect my two other $WORK_RELATED Gmail accounts there. Big productivity boost that way since I get instant access to my emails without having to wait for the JS to load over the network.
- a5aAqU 5y ago> I don't see how does it differ from traditional e-mail clients, except that you don't have to install, configure and allow unlimited access to your computer. Most people are using Google's client in some form (Chromium), so they do pretty much have unlimited access to your computer, unless you use Firefox or Safari. Most people are logged into the browser itself, so it's even worse. With Thunderbird you aren't linking every single thing you do online to your email account.
- dredmorbius 5y agoThunderbird downloads once. (Or at least, once per upstream update.) If you stick with mutt, the binary is < 1 kB.
- DonHopkins 5y agoZawinski's Law of Software Envelopment states that "Every program attempts to expand until it can read mail. Those programs which cannot so expand are replaced by ones which can." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jamie_Zawinski#Notable_quotes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jamie_Zawinski#Notable_quotes >Some have interpreted this as commenting on the phenomenon of software bloating with popular features. Zawinski himself has stated: https://twitter.com/jwz/status/1331287160738070528 https://twitter.com/jwz/status/1331287160738070528 >My point was not about copycats, it was about platformization. Apps that you "live in" all day have pressure to become everything and do everything. An app for editing text becomes an IDE, then an OS. An app for displaying hypertext documents becomes a mail reader, then an OS. So it follows that most programs that can read email are enormous ("expand" being the operative term, with Emacs and Thunderbird being the archetypal examples)!
- moring 5y agoThe web is a runtime platform and a distribution medium for the client software here. The "bad" part of it isn't web mail per se, but that the client gets downloaded every time. OTOH, you don't have to find the software itself on some site, download and install manually, then configure, and so on. App stores try to solve this, but they suck in other ways (e.g. security -- at least the web has a security model. Native apps just expect some kind of ill-defined and unrealistic "trust" in the app's author).
- leoh 5y agoThe 20 MiB is cached
- jraph 5y agoThe case is often invalidated though, because these 20 MiB are often updated.
- Griffinsauce 5y agoYou don't download that much for every message, there's caching. It's strange to compare content to an application, I see this more often and it looks logical for a second because of the matching units but it's like calling a car heavy because the gasoline only weighs 50kg... what?
- shp0ngle 5y agoThe funny thing is… if you are using gmail app on your phone, you don’t use webmail, because webmail is indeed too janky and bloated for phones, and native is just faster.
- enraged_camel 5y agoOn a related note, this is one of the joys of using Fastmail: it's actually blazing fast, not just on desktop but also on mobile. It's probably the best web app I've ever used in terms of UX.
- KronisLV 5y ago> I get it, traditional mail clients kinda suck, they feel bloated and janky. I'm actually not sure about this, Thunderbird to me seems like it's pretty good: https://www.thunderbird.net/en-US/ https://www.thunderbird.net/en-US/ The only bloat that i can think of is the calendar functionality that i simply don't care about, but that's easy enough to get out of the way. Maybe one could also have gripes with the account administration section, though that's not necessarily touched in the daily usage. Apart from that, it does everything i need, in the simplest way possible and is as boring as it is usable. Contrasted with lots of the modern day software, i'd instead put it into the category of "workhorse" software, where LibreOffice, GIMP, KeePass, Notepad++, SourceTree/Git Cola and others live - dependable pieces of software that do what i need without many breaking changes and all that many bells and whistles. The kind that you install and forget about, maybe updating them once every few years if at all needed.
- selfhoster11 5y agoCalendar support is actually a desirable feature for me. I'm sad to find that there's nothing fully outlook-compatible in the open source world. Evolution gets very very close, but it still lacks support for viewing/changing some of the meeting data, and I believe background colour for meetings (which I miss a lot).
- still_grokking 5y agoEver tried Kontact? I'm using it as daily driver and wouldn't switch to webmail nor Thunderbird or Evolution.
- selfhoster11 5y agoI think I tried it (for non-Exchange calendaring), but I didn't like it for some reason. As far as Evolution goes, I don't see myself moving away from it for now. I can't afford to have reminders not showing up, or have my calendar not syncing for half a business day because something has gone wrong. Evolution is the only program that I've tried that gets both of these right, and I've tried many, many applications both native and Electron-based. Don't get me wrong, I'd switch in a heartbeat if I discovered a superior solution. But as-is, the few issues are found, aren't enough of a motivation to switch. A few cosmetic/UX glitches and nice-to-have missing features (highlighting background entries with their category's colour, busy/free/out-of-office setting on meetings) are tolerable when the alternatives are so, SO much worse.
- redwall_hp 5y agoI like Apple Mail way more than webmail clients. Thunderbird is okay, but I'd still choose it over a 20MB webjank.
- seoulmetro 5y agoI've only felt that with non-traditional mail clients. Traditional ones are fast, instant and work without any resource hogging.