10 ms·
Astrophysicists unveil glut of gravitational-wave detections
- markus_zhang 5y agoJust curious, if we have gravitational waves, what are the wave lengths?
- queuebert 5y agoThe orbital period of the merging objects is ~ 1 ms near the end, and gravitational waves propagate at the speed of light, so I'd estimate that the wavelength would be ~ 3e5 x 1e-3, or in the neighborhood of hundreds of kilometers.
- ww520 5y agoThat depends the period of the body’s movement. The wave is generated by the body’s movement.
- markus_zhang 5y agoOK I probably got some wild thoughts. I was thinking, since light has different wave lengths and human can't see many types of light because of that, maybe dark matter is similar? Just some uneducated thoughts lol.
- ww520 5y agoBut it’s a very good question. It leads to what’s the nature of gravitational wave. The frequency is certainly a key characteristic. It can lead to how LIGO works.
- bil7 5y agoradios or other technology can be used to detect EM wavelengths humans can't. No tech can currently observe dark matter
- foo92691 5y agoThere is no upper limit to the wavelength of gravitational waves. However, the lowest frequency that we can currently detect is around 10-100 Hz. Diving the speed of light (3e8 m/s) by (10 Hz) gives 3e7 meters. 30,000 km. The upper end of our frequency range is currently around 8 kHz which corresponds to 37.5 km if I did the math right. LISA will be sensitive to much lower frequencies (longer wavelengths). NanoGrav also searches for these lower frequency signals. We expect most gw's to be of very low frequency. High frequency g.w.s require tremendous mass and acceleration to generate. They are only generated in the final moments of black hole collisions as far as we know.
- SavantIdiot 5y agoDo gravitational wave interferometers create a single pixel of data, or do they create an "image" of gravitational distortion in a 2D region? The first few Google/Wiki hits talk about the physics of interferometry, but not the actual resulting output from real hardware. I'm assuming there is no image, otherwise there would be some associated with the articles, rather than artistic renditions?
- phreeza 5y agoThey measure the total distortion over the baseline, so in that sense it's a single pixel. But I think measurements from several interferometers can be combined to give some very limited spatial resolution.
- foo92691 5y agoYou can think of each individual detector producing a single-channel audio signal. By combining the signals from multiple detectors it's possible to determine where the signal is coming from. But the output is neither a picture nor a single pixel: it's a brief blip of a few seconds of audio-frequency time series. A decent analogy is to think of each LIGO detector not as a camera but a microphone.
- secondaryacct 5y agoOr a 3 pixels camera whose pixel color changing is what matters :D The only difference between a camera and a mic is the number or vibrating thing it cares about (mic only cares about the vibration of its single membrane, cameras create millions of membranes sensitive to photon vibration on a grid) LIGO 3 interferometers care about the time-variation of the difference of distance measure in 3 groups of 2 mirrors. So it's more than a single mic, and it's a derivative of 2 distance measures, in time. It would be like a 3-pixel video, with white as a baseline for the 3 pixels, and it would varies towards green or blue depending of the negative or positive difference (random colors) between the mirror distances. Or yeah, a 3 channel sound :S
- foo92691 5y ago
- daot 5y agoshameless plug on a project I did with a High School physics student plotting gravitational waves inspired by the "joy division" plot: https://moleksak.com/ligo/ https://moleksak.com/ligo/ ... we'll have to update it with the new data!
- Invictus0 5y agoInteresting how, even with three LIGO observatories, there is still a 15% false positive rate. How many more observatories are needed to reduce this to a negligible number?
- pinko 5y agoLIGO collaboration member here: this is a tunable knob, independent of the number of detectors, that we've set very intentionally based on feedback from astronomers who want to follow up with optical/gamma/neutrino instruments following our BNS detections. We could reduce our false positive rate to a negligible number today, at the cost of _not_ reporting many likely discoveries. Also, a minor point but there are only two LIGO detectors online at the moment, with a third sister detector in Italy (named Virgo), and a fourth coming online soon in Japan (named KAGRA). There does in fact exist a third LIGO instrument, but it's currently mothballed, awaiting construction in India.
- gus_massa 5y agoDo you publish some number about how sure you are?
- pinko 5y agoYes, we carefully explain the statistical confidence of our detections in each discovery paper, and there are dozens of methods papers that go into excruciating detail on those techniques. Prior to our first detection, the overwhelming prime directive of our collaboration was _not to make a false detection_ and we went to insane lengths to avoid one; e.g., we had a small team of people secretly injecting false signals -- "blind injections" -- into our data, so that we all expected to be regularly seeing them and wouldn't be tempted to gin the analysis to find a detection where there wasn't one. (Amusingly, because of this, it took weeks for many of us to believe the first detection was real, even after the blind injection team swore it wasn't one of theirs. In the end, we charged an independent team to do a forensic analysis of everything from the security cameras and seismometers in the observatories, to every computer and disk the data passed through, to convince ourselves this couldn't possibly have been maliciously injected by hand by a rogue scientist. It was a wild few weeks!) Now that it's clear gravitational waves exist, however, we focus on optimizing the false alarm rate for astronomers (who want it well above zero so they don't miss anything) rather than optimizing for ~zero false detections.
- netcraft 5y agothe Gravitational Observatories are so impressive to me - I can remember reading about them being theoretical well before LIGO ever started construction, and the fact that theyre here and working just like we expected is so amazing. I can't wait until we have LISA in space! But its so strange when we shut it off to do upgrades and stuff - like I totally understand why we have to do it, but its like we finally turned on a microphone and could hear things that were always happening but we could never observe before, and then we turn it off for a little while - the thought that there are events that are going on right now that we will never be able to detect because we arent listening gives me major FOMO.
- jaspax 5y agoWhy would you have FOMO? Why is any particular gravitational wave important enough that you'd worry about missing it? I'm not trying to hassle you here, I'm genuinely perplexed by this attitude.
- wpietri 5y agoI used to work in a library and we all had a similar feeling about books. They were all valuable and to be preserved! Objectively, that's not practical. But that base irrational feeling is still useful and important.
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoTechnically we've missed at least four billion years of gravitational wave events, so a week of shutdown for an upgrade isn't going to make a huge difference to that.
- nharada 5y agoLIGO blows my mind whenever I hear news about it. The sensitivity alone is insane -- it can detect a change in distance between its mirrors 1/10000th the width of a proton. This is the equivalent of measuring the distance to the nearest star (4.2 light years) to an accuracy of 1 human hair. Those are bonkers numbers. How the hell did we even come up with this thing?
- gabagool 5y ago*the second nearest star :)
- queuebert 5y agoInterferometry has a long history in experimental physics. The Michelson–Morley experimental design scaled up to large distances and using modern technology, like lasers and computers, gets you LIGO.
- foo92691 5y agoAnd resonant cavities, the best mirrors ever made, and a huge amount of cleverness and work over 40+ years.
- jjoonathan 5y agoSpeaking of which, I can understand how interferometry gets you to, say, 1/1000th of a wavelength, but the wavelength is 1000nm. How do they go from 1nm to 1/10000th the width of a proton? What's the trick? Is it an integral transform thing, like how spectrum analyzers can claim super low noise floors if you sort of gloss over the "noise is proportional to badwidth" part and look in a tiny bandwidth without normalizing?
- sleavey 5y agoCavities. We trade off bandwidth for peak sensitivity by sending the same light back and forth between mirrors in the arms of the interferometer hundreds of times. As the gravitational wave passes, the same light samples it over and over and picks up additional phase shift, enhancing the signal. The downside is that we can't see gravitational waves at signals far above the cavity pole frequencies at a few 10s of kHz, but the most promising sources we aimed at when the detectors were designed were considered to be below that. We also use techniques called power and signal recycling to enhance this bandwidth-sensitivity tradeoff even more. Combined these techniques give you what remains between your 1/1000th wavelength and the actual sensitivity of LIGO and Virgo.
- ww520 5y agoLIGO is a huge milestone. Turning it on is like the moment Galileo pointed his telescope to the moon. This is a new class of instruments observing the universe in a medium that was never utilized before. Using gravitational waves can observe things that cannot be seen before, like stars behind the dust clouds. It opens a new window to the world. We might finally be able to “see” dark matter. May be able to see the gravitational imprint from before the Big Bang, the gravitational leak from extra dimension or other universes.
- sdenton4 5y agoHere's one (negative!) result on trying to detect dark matter with LIGO: https://www.ligo.org/science/Publication-O3DarkPhotons/ https://www.ligo.org/science/Publication-O3DarkPhotons/
- ww520 5y agoI thought LIGO is kind of crude, i.e. it's being used to measure in the scale of blackhole level gravity. The dark matter experiment is trying to measure the gravity of a photon? May be too optimistic?
- sdenton4 5y agoSounds like they're looking for dark photons interacting with the detector, and, thanks to its extreme sensitivity, able to place upper bounds on the strength of the interactions (since none were observed). This means dark photons have very very weak interactions with normal matter.... or that they don't exist. :)
- metalliqaz 5y agoI hope to live long enough to see the evolution of interferometers that will be to LIGO as HST was to Galileo's telescope.
- foo92691 5y agoThis is what you're waiting for: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laser_Interferometer_Space_Antenna https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laser_Interferometer_Space_Ant...
- mrfusion 5y agoCould we be seeing warp drive signatures?
- pwned1 5y agoWhy would anyone downvote this? I love this type of out of the box thinking.
- queuebert 5y agoAliens are trolling us by doing burnouts near our planet.
- wussboy 5y ago/r/idiotsinspaceships
- dredmorbius 5y ago/r/alienworldproblems
- foo92691 5y agoSo far all of the signals observed by LIGO are from sources that we expected would exist. The most exciting thing would be to observe an unexpected signal.
- baq 5y agodid you model how an alcubierre drive would look like on the waveform? (only half joking ;))
- aardvark179 5y agoThe original solution field equation is for a constant speed drive, which I believe does not emit any gravitational waves. I’m not sure how much work has been done on the formation of the bubble and what effects that would produce, or indeed how a ship could change its heading, which are events that I think should produce gravity waves.
- mabbo 5y agoThe article mentions the new KAGRA detector in Japan joining the group. Does anyone know: how does the accuracy improve as more detectors come online? Will we see a day where we have 20, 50, 100 detectors around the globe and events are near-certain because so many detectors see them? Or is the diminishing returns, and 4 detectors is already too many?
- BurningFrog 5y agoThe current ones are Louisiana, Washington state, and Italy. So having another as far away as Japan should improve triangulation substantially.
- pinko 5y agoAdditional detectors improve our ability to detect somewhat (assuming they're of similar sensitivity -- otherwise they can actually hurt our overall network sensitivity!). But the _real_ advantage is in source localization to guide multi-messenger (optical/gamma/neutrino) followup, which is where many of the most important discoveries will come from. It's like triangulation. Given that an observatory costs on the order of ~$1B to build and operate for a few decades, we probably won't see more than five current (second generation) instruments (2x LIGO + Virgo + KAGRA + LIGO India). There are also two proposed but not yet funded 3rd-generation ground-based instruments ("Cosmic Explorer" and the "Einstein Telescope"), one planned space-based instrument ("LISA"), and early efforts at proposing a future moon-based detector (the Gravitational-Wave Lunar Observatory for Cosmology, the Lunar Gravitational-Wave Antenna, and the Lunar Seismic and Gravitational Antenna). To get to tens or hundreds of detectors, someone will have to invent a fundamentally different technology that can be produced at dramatically lower cost. Maybe next century...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- prox 5y agoI can donate my raspberry Pi if you need it ;) Seriously, impressive cutting edge technology!
- 5y ago
- jliptzin 5y agoHow do they know it’s black holes colliding and not just large stars?
- skulk 5y agoMaybe electromagnetic signals can disambiguate the two phenomena?
- foo92691 5y agoExtensive computer modeling is used to predict the expected waveforms, and then we fit the observed waveforms to the expected ones.
- jliptzin 5y agoCool thx
- still_grokking 5y agoIsn't it more like you fit actually noise to expected forms, and out comes the expected form? At least someone explained it like this to me.
- toss1 5y agoThe resolution of these instruments is astonishing - and literally a new window on the universe. Obviously, being able to detect amplitudes so small is key to this whole project, as the sources are so distant (and presumably the inverse square law applies). This makes me wonder how these phenomena would appear much closer to the events - how close would we need to be to perceive with our senses the passing of a gravitational wave, and what would it look like? I'm guessing some kind of passing tidal forces would be felt — has anyone done modeling to figure out what that might be like? How close and how much amplitude (or would frequency be the killer?) would be required to start damaging ordinary material objects? Is it so close to the source that you're already doomed in the black hole's grip anyway, or would an event at the center of our galaxy be perceptible here? Would the waves rip apart nearby stars (for what value of nearby), or be noticeable in their spectra as some kind of ripple? It'd be cool to get some kind of a sense of the scale of these events' affected zone.
- 2bitencryption 5y agoquestion: according to Wikipedia, LIGO was built between 1994-2002, and didn't detect gravitational waves until 2016. I never heard about LIGO until the discovery in 2016, so for almost 20 years it was off my radar, so to speak. What multi-decade experiments are being created today, which will be ready to produce amazing results in 20-30 years? What's currently under construction, but I'll never hear about it until 20 years from now, when it makes an amazing discovery?
- BbzzbB 5y agoAccording to another commenter, LISA will be the successor to LIGO's line of gravitational-wave astronomy. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laser_Interferometer_Space_Antenna https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laser_Interferometer_Space_Ant...
- mr_sturd 5y agoMy head instantly went to fusion experiments[0]. There are planned experiments in that space which, if they go ahead, won't produce results until the 2040s. [0] - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fusion_experiments https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fusion_experiments
- ww520 5y agoFrom the talk by the Caltech professor leading LIGO, the theory was good on paper but the engineering problems were very tough. The platform to make measurement has to be absolutely still. But the Earth always has some movements due to seismic activities. For years they just couldn't get the passive vibration isolation tech stable enough for the measurement to work. The project was almost canceled. Finally they went back to the drawing board and partnered with some companies to build new active vibration isolation technologies. It took years to get it working. Their active vibration isolation technology is insanely good. It basically detects tiny seismic movement of the Earth far away and actively compensates the stable platform. This is one instance of scientific project spawning off new technologies, which will have many other uses in the future.
- rkagerer 5y agoThis is such a great thread. Enjoyed reading it 10x more than the article!