9 ms·
Apple and Google transformed mobile into a poisonous experience. Apart from being constantly spied, you don't get to decide what you can do with your own device
by DeathArrow 5y ago
Apple and Google transformed mobile into a poisonous experience. Apart from being constantly spied, you don't get to decide what you can do with your own device. You can't install software unless is approved by them and if it is, you have to also pay them.
As a developer, if you target iOS and Android your app should not compete with their apps, you have to get it approved and you have to get them a 30% cut for nothing.
Why can't installing software on mobiles work exactly like on desktop?
- nyxaiur 5y agoI guess you haven't used windows mobile until 6.0 or palm os until 5.x before. Because that was mobile before iOS and android you can talk as much shit as you want but pretend there was a rose garden before.
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoBut but but malware! People love these shiny handcuffs imposed on them, because they keep them safe from harming themselves! Even here I've had a lot of arguments with people who say it is a very good thing. And of course they don't care about people in countries like Russia or China where the Apple submits to government requests to remove certain apps - leaving their users unable to run them at all.
- jve 5y ago> But but but malware! It's a very valid statement, yet you make it sound like sarcasm. Consumer can makes choice by choosing platform after all (even niche Android distributions if you are after freedom). Ofcourse apple may be too tight by requiring to even identify test devices when you develop apps and no option to install .apk like on Android.
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoImagine a phone virus that jumped from phone to phone over WiFi or BlueTooth and keylogged and screen grabbed everything. Imagine mobile ransomware. If the OS is hackable - and they always are, without strong security - all kinds of nasty things become possible. I do think devs should get a bit more freedom on iOS for testing, but the consumer side is fine as it is. I remember the virus wars of late 90s and early 2000s when you couldn't do anything on a Windows PC without worrying that it was going to be hacked - and most were. There were email vectors, web vectors, PDF vectors, Office macro vectors, banner ad vectors, even antivirus software vectors. It was a complete shit show. The hacking back then was relatively harmless. But now that people run their entire lives from these devices, the modern equivalent would be an economic disaster.
- flohofwoe 5y agoHow do you know that an iOS app doesn't do this exact thing? A curated app store cannot prevent the exploitation of so-far undiscovered security holes in the operating system. Sandboxing is a technological problem, while app store monopolies are a social problem, those two problems must be separated from each other first before they can be fixed effectively.
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y ago> I do think devs should get a bit more freedom on iOS for testing, but the consumer side is fine as it is. Fine as it is? Show me how to launch Signal app on an iPhone sold in China?
- tempodox 5y agoLiving in a free society necessarily entails a certain amount of risk. Leaving it to the megacorps alone to determine where the line between risk avoidance and freedom should be is at the very least undemocratic.
- amelius 5y ago> > But but but malware! > It's a very valid statement No. Perhaps it would be a valid statement if Apple and Google were held accountable for failing to protect the consumer here.
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoIt is not a valid statement. The ones who are afraid of malware might stay within the confines of the AppStore. Why do they think that everybody else should not have the freedom to run whatever the apps they want on their devices? Until the apple lifts off these restrictions, users of iOS devices can not be considered device owners: they are merely renting it from a true owner (Apple), who decides which apps are allowed to run on these devices.
- Angostura 5y agoI absolutely love the 'shiny handcuffs'. My phone is an appliance, I don't want to bother about thinking about keeping it patched, about threats, about malware. I want to use the thing. If I want a general purpose computing device, I've got one of those.
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoYou may love not having freedom to run whatever the app you please. But why are you fine with everyone else not having this freedom? There are people living in actual dictatorship countries who can't access the information vital to them, because Apple and Google happily do business with brutal dictators?
- ericmay 5y agoThis has been beaten to death, but at least for Apple it means degrading the user experience for those of us who love “not being free” or whatever silly slogans people want to use. Why can’t I have the “freedom” to buy an iPhone just how it is today? Why are you supporting courts infringing on a peaceful transaction between two entities? If you want to do the whole screening from the rooftop about rights thing then you’re going to have to respect the rights of others too, not just what you want. With the App Store mechanic Apple can collectively bargain on behalf of users. Do you think companies would allow anonymous signin on a third party App Store? Or post how they collect and use your data? Of course not. Apple makes that happen. If you want to use more than one App Store just buy an Android phone and get on with your day. If the Apple model of a single store is truly the inferior model Apple will be forced by market mechanics to allow others.
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y ago> degrading the user experience for those of us who love “not being free” or whatever silly slogans people want to use. Speaking of silly slogans, how does my freedom to install an app on MY device degrade your experience?
- quitit 5y agoI wanted a sedan, not a 4WD - if I wanted a 4WD I would have bought that instead. I’m pretty tired of people telling me what is “good” for me. When they don’t know my situation or how I use my tools. The product you’re advocating for exists - I didn’t buy it on purpose. I know it exists, I looked into it and it wasn’t for me. I don’t want the product I chose to turn into that other product - that would be a bad thing. That would be anti-consumer and anti-choice - I don’t regret the choices I made and I’m regularly reminded that they were the correct choice to make. I’m educated and mature enough to know what is good for me, I don’t need a random telling me what is good for me. Stop pretending to know what is good for me - you don’t know what is good for me and using jail metaphors doesn’t make you sound convincing - it makes you sound biased with a predetermined outcome. Don’t try to “market” to me using such words, they are transparent. Contrary to your hand waving of the concerns of others - there remains legitimate issues with that approach, and arguably it’s good that both options exist in the market.
- EMIRELADERO 5y ago> I wanted a sedan, not a 4WD - if I wanted a 4WD I would have bought that instead. I have said this a dozen times and I will keep saying it: being able to exercise the same level of control (on a device you own) as the company that manufactured it and sold it is a matter of consumer rights, not choice. In the same way that the law requires car makers to adhere to certain standards and make parts available, the same thing should happen with electronics that have any sort of chip capable of running any code. It should be straight up outlawed that a company can have more control over a device than its end user, even after the end user has bought it.
- acoard 5y agoSo to be clear, your argument is that I have the right to full control of my devices, and that right entails that I _don't_ have the right to buy a locked down iOS device? I understand that I don't have the right to take an unsafe vehicle on the road. That's logical, as it impacts others. But saying that I have a right I must exercise in a certain way (i.e. must have full ownership of devices), even when it affects no-one else, isn't a right, it's a duty.
- thereddaikon 5y agoExcept time and time again Google and Apple have proven themselves incapable of preventing malware from getting on their stores.
- criddell 5y ago> Russia or China where the Apple submits to government requests to remove certain apps - leaving their users unable to run them at all If an iOS device doesn't support the software they want to run, why would they buy an iPhone? Would you also complain that you can't run Microsoft Word on a PS5?
- queuebert 5y agoBecause advertising has convinced people that's better to be cool and have an iPhone than have all of the apps they want.
- d3nj4l 5y agoYou're making it seem like it's a travesty that Apple doesn't allow you to do whatever you want with your phone, but you're dodging everyone who correctly points out that Apple is far and away in the minority of smartphones in the world. People who want to run whatever they want on a mobile device have their choice: they can buy Android phones and sideload APKs, or buy experimental cutting edge devices running Linux. If anything, the example you cite - that of Apple removing apps in Russia or China - should be in your favour: if people in Russia and China want to run apps without their Government's approval, they should not buy iPhones, thereby hurting Apple's position in the market. Those who don't clearly don't care, and who are you to decide what they should care about?
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoPeople in Russia trusted Apple to allow apps to run when they were buying the phones, but THEN found out that Apple decided to cooperate with Putin and removed certain apps they were using. It IS a travesty. Apple didn't advertise beforehand that they would cooperate with dictators and block apps which dictators don't like.
- threatofrain 5y agoWere people in Russia hoping that Apple would pull out entirely, or that they should have the power to contend with Russia? If Apple pulled out entirely, people in Russia still wouldn't have their smart voting app. If Apple resisted the Russian government, they would've been banned. And you still wouldn't have your smart voting app. Do people imagine a world where Apple has the power to forcefully ask the Russian government to yield on their domestic affairs?
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoIf apple wouldn't insist on controlling what users are allowed to run on the devices that apple sold to them, users wouldn't have this problem. Seriously, Apple acts as if still owns the devices after selling them. If that's so, maybe they should refund the devices to users and honestly call such devices 'rented'? It is perfectly understandable why you can't install the music system of your choice on a rented car. Not quite understandable if you bought that car.
- the_other 5y ago> But but but malware! People love these shiny handcuffs imposed on them, because they keep them safe from harming themselves! It's less about harming yourself and more about harming your phone. This is your personal emergency lifeline device. It cannot go down. I know they do, but my point is that everything about the software experience should tend towards 100% uptime. This is key. It's more important than almost any other aspect of the device. It's way more important on mobile than it is on a desktop. If your desktop locks up, you can hit reboot and make a tea, or go chat to your boss. If your mobile locks up, you might stay buried in that avalanche longer than is healthy.
- petre 5y agoBezos' phone was trojaned with malware, supposedly using a mp4 video file and WhatsApp, despite being an iPhone which doesn't allow sideloading. https://www.wired.com/story/bezos-phone-hack-mbs-saudi-arabia/ https://www.wired.com/story/bezos-phone-hack-mbs-saudi-arabi...
- skoskie 5y agoIt’s a perfectly valid point in general, but most of us aren’t up against state actors, who seem capable of getting into any target.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- throwaway946513 5y agoWhile not against state actors, if you're a U.S. resident/citizen, you're still actively being spied on regardless.
- fsflover 5y ago> Why can't installing software on mobiles work exactly like on desktop? It can! https://puri.sm/products/librem-5 https://puri.sm/products/librem-5
- piyush_soni 5y agoI'm not sure. On Android phones you can still install any third party android app just by installing its apk.
- skohan 5y agoYeah and the worst thing about this is that if anything, the trend is towards having less ownership rights on the desktop as well. Windows 11 and newer mac OS versions make it harder to run arbitrary software, under the guise of security. A legal battle around securing the rights of ownership is severely needed in the 21st century, the same way the creation of the EPA and workers rights legislation were needed in the 20th.
- nouveaux 5y ago"under the guise of security" Security is a tradeoff between freedom/convenience and safety. This is true outside of desktop OS as well. The reason there is a trend to having less rights and more security on the desktop is because of the rising cost of getting hacked. So unless you have a better solution, organizations and consumers will all advocate for more security and less freedom.
- skohan 5y agoI think the solution is a better access control model for operating systems. If applications are sandboxed effectively, and users are asked to opt in to specific permissions in a granular way, the risk is not so high. To paint an example, as a default an a process should only have access to its own memory, and maybe a sandboxed directory in the filesystem. If the process wants to access the network, or access other directories, it should ask me as the user permission before it can do so. You could then imagine extending this through a federated trust model. I.e. if I as a user don't want to bother with granting fine grained permissions each time, I could give blanket trust to all applications verified by a given source. This could be for instance a 3rd party app store, or something like a package manager, which I trust to vet the applications which it hosts. There are always going to be challenges with security, but the solution cannot be that 3 corporations get to unilaterally decide which code is allowed to be executed.
- masklinn 5y ago> Apple and Google transformed mobile into a poisonous experience. On the other hand Apple and Google created mobile, as more than the built-in platform. Before they arrived and nuked the whole scene getting third party software was browsing shifty sites for weird archives (leaving your CC details everywhere to pay for it) you’d then try to decompress on the phone, possibly sideloaded from a computer connection, and definitely never updated. The experience for both installing and removing software was ridiculously dreadful and the waste of time immense. The pre-appstore landscape was an experience in the sense of getting mauled by a bear being an experience.
- flohofwoe 5y agoThe problem isn't curated app stores - those were great additions to the mobile ecosystem - but when there's only one app store allowed on the platform, especially when that app store is operated by the same company that owns the rest of the platform.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoThe pre-iPhone experience with a smart phone was to buy among a handful of company-offered apps like Solitaire. I am unaware of any 3rd-party software you could install to those early phones. You could argue Apple just followed the "canned phone" approach but, later, decided to allow 3rd parties in as a marketing way to grow/differentiate the iPhone ecosystem. I don't fault early-Apple in this regard.
- masklinn 5y ago> I am unaware of any 3rd-party software you could install to those early phones. There were lots on nokia, in part by necessity given how dreary S60 was (I remember having to install third party software in order to have an alarm, as well as opera mini because the built-in browser was unusable on edge). But even “legit sites” looked like warez, not just because it was 2005 but also because there was basically no ecosystem so this was mostly lone devs doing their thing on the sly, and of course we had little graphical taste (as demonstrated by wielding nokias). And the install / update experience as I noted above was quite awful.
- wongarsu 5y agoOn Android the experience of manually installing an App is better than the average Windows installer. You download an apk, open it, click on install, wait, click on done. If it's your first time you get redirected to a settings page where you have to flip a clearly labeled switch before you can proceed. Better than the Windows experience of clicking "next" way too often while getting tricked into the bundled McAfee trial. Yet most Android apps are only available over the Play store. It's a classic platform effect: all the customers are on the Play Store, so all the Apps are the, so all the customers are there. Windows never managed to get this kickstarted (not for lack of trying). For app categories that aren't allowed on the Play store providing the apk works and it doesn't seem to be too much to ask of people. But if your competitor is on the Play store and you aren't then you lose on convenience. And of course the mobile app pattern of updating your app every other day only really works with the auto-updates of app stores. I'm not sure I can fault Google for any of that. We can fault them for preventing other App stores from gaining traction by withholding features from them in the past, but the decision to use an App store at all isn't forced on anyone (on Android, iPhones are a different story)
- foepys 5y agoGoogle requires you to use their infrastructure unless you want to have significantly reduced battery life. There is no energy efficient way to listen for notifications unless you use Google's solution that they baked into the kernel.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoVery true. Every talk about app 'sideloading' should include the capability to make a device run an alternative push notifications service. It isn't much to ask, actually, such services are pretty easy to create.
- undefinedzero 5y agoIt will always take more energy to monitor two sockets than one, especially one that's less optimized. What is the downside of using Google's? You can E2E encrypt messages and using firebase for notifications is free.
- jeroenhd 5y ago> Why can't installing software on mobiles work exactly like on desktop? I don't understand, you just tap an APK file and hit "install". Is that really different? You need to click a single button to allow the file explorer/browser app to show the install popups, but that's it. Just don't buy an iPhone if you want control over your phone. If you want to get fancier, get an alternative store like F-Droid or one of its competitors. XDA-Developers once had its own app store built right into their forum app. The reality is that Apple has been badmouthing installing software as "sideloading" and convinced their customer base that if software doesn't come from their store, it's obviously evil and malicious. Google has ridden the app store wave, not saying much but certainly not speaking out against Apple. Now they've managed to condition users that installing apps using alternative methods is either bad or complicated, so the end user doesn't want to do it. That's a problem between you and your end user, and I don't think there's a good solution for that. I certainly don't think Android should remove the security popup for installing downloaded APK files because malicious ads would start smuggling apps onto your phone like crazy. The button "allow this app to install other apps" is fine to me, as is the popup that says "are you sure you want to install <x>".
- dabenski 5y agodont forget the amount of times google had to remove malware infected apps from the play store cause they barely screen them
- JKCalhoun 5y ago> Why can't installing software on mobiles work exactly like on desktop? A naive explanation is because AT&T (the iPhone's first carrier). Or rather more broadly, mobiles use the carrier's network and carriers did not want a repeat of demon-dialing, rampant computer viruses (etc.) taking down their network.