17 ms·
Will the climate crisis force America to reconsider nuclear power?
- peter_retief 5y agoNuclear is the only clean option, we need to spend a lot more money making it safer and cheaper.
- mhmmmmmm 5y agoModern Nuclear reactors are incredibly save.
- gefhfff 5y agoHow can you call it clean when there is a unresolved waste problem?
- midrus 5y agoWhat other feasible/realistic cleaner alternatives do you propose?
- gefhfff 5y agoWind, solar, rivers joining with salt water, river streams, tides, gas (from waste), geo thermals ...
- csee 5y agoWind/solar has a variability problem and storage is expensive. Hydro is bad for the local environment. Nuclear has a minor waste problem which isn't really that bad. None of these are perfect solutions. Nuclear shouldn't be ruled out of a green mix.
- gefhfff 5y agoNuclear has a huge waste issue, persisting between hundreds and a million years. Storage isn't that expensive, E.g. through gas. E.g. Germany maintenances Gas storage (currently filled with non renewable gas) that can power the entire country a Quarter of a year. Without the actual need through renewables. Nuclear with waste management would have to be cheaper than that. (Aside from the subjective evaluation of the associated risk of nuclear energy)
- csee 5y agoSource that storage isn't that expensive? What I've read has said the opposite. If that's true then I'll adjust my views accordingly.
- smileysteve 5y agoA similar way we can with solar or wind? With per megawatt waste for nuclear per 20 years being exponentially smaller in volume. And where the alternative is coal /natural gas (rather than wind or solar) where these produce more volume of waste in a month/year than nuclear does in a decade. (And in the case of coal, we store worse waste in ways it often enters our fresh water supplies.
- lordnacho 5y agoThe timing of the cold war and the climate change crisis have been unfortunate. A lot of people in the west were opposed to nuclear power, often due to the association with our struggle against the communist world. If we'd kept going with nuclear, we'd have more investment and more experience in it and it's hard to know for sure, but you could make an argument that we'd be in less of a pickle with the carbon reduction goals. We'd know more about how to make it safer and we'd know more about how to make it better.
- moksly 5y agoI don’t think anyone is afraid of nuclear power, I mean, some people are but no one serious. What anti nuclear movements in my country fear isn’t the technology but rather the people who have to maintain it. I’m not sure that last part can be easily fixed.
- allendoerfer 5y agoAlso the million year commitment to storing trash. Globally building nuclear power plants will be too slow to solve climate change. We still should keep it to solve future problems. Like conquering the universe and stuff.
- bottled_poe 5y agoThere's a fine garbage dump in the centre of the solar system.
- Akronymus 5y agoNo, the sun isn't viable at all for waste. It'd take an unreasonable amount of fuel for that, https://van.physics.illinois.edu/qa/listing.php?id=43694&t=launching-a-rocket-to-the-sun https://van.physics.illinois.edu/qa/listing.php?id=43694&t=l... Along with that, we have enough geographically stable regions for long enough storage.
- 5y ago
- throwawaysea 5y ago“Why the pro-nuclear movement is winning” https://michaelshellenberger.substack.com/p/why-the-pro-nuclear-movement-is-winning https://michaelshellenberger.substack.com/p/why-the-pro-nucl... Some selected quotes: > The main reason for the success of the pro-nuclear movement is the failure of renewables and the global energy crisis. The share of global energy from fossil fuels is unchanged since 1980 because solar and wind do not replace fossil fuel power plants, and, in fact, depend upon them. Only baseload hydro-electric and nuclear power plants can replace fossil fuels. And over-investment in unreliable renewables and underinvestment in nuclear, hydro-electricity, and natural gas, over the last decade, directly resulted in today’s energy shortages, skyrocketing electricity prices, and a return to coal around the world. > The most important thing is to tell the truth about nuclear, I argued to friends and colleagues, starting in 2016, and build an honest pro-nuclear movement worldwide around the truth. Anti-nuclear people have been lying about the technology for decades. > The renewable energy industry has financed misinformation efforts against us. We have been censored by Facebook. And we have lost some supporters. But through it all, EP kept up our work, directly supporting and championing the work of pro-nuclear advocates around the world, giving popular TED talks, and writing a best-selling book, Apocalypse Never, which has been translated into 15 languages
- cyberpunkdyst 5y agoIn Finland 18% of all energy is produced with Nuclear, which almost the double of the global average (~10%). We don't have earthquakes or other very strong weather phenomena (apart from freezing temperatures up to -40C/-40F), which makes Nuclear a very feasible option.
- qwerty456127 5y ago> We don't have earthquakes Nevertheless one should never take this as guaranteed. Nuclear power plants should be carefully designed everything-proof wherever they are built.
- roenxi 5y agoThat is blowing the risks out of proportion. Normal houses won't be earthquake proof, and people will actually be living in them and get squished if there is a bad earthquake. There will be death and destruction. Whether or not the nuclear plant survives intact is a bit of a minor issue. It just has to fail without being orders of magnitude worse than the earthquake. Citing Fukushima - Fukushima was bad. Bud the mounds of corpses caused by the natural disaster that also caused Fukushima are a far more important thing to spend resources preventing than Fukushima itself was.
- crooked-v 5y ago> without being orders of magnitude worse than the earthquake You're overlooking the exaggerated panic-and-horror reaction of the public to literally any kind of nuclear incident. If you design merely for statistically acceptable results it's basically guaranteeing political blowback at some point.
- politician 5y agoThe Dominant Media has an exaggerated role in this when they whip up paranoia for ratings (really no different than Facebook prioritizing angry posts in your feed — eyeballs get ads).
- YeBanKo 5y agoNuclear energy is clean, until it is not. When something goes wrong it can easily go terribly wrong. Such 180 degree swings in public opinion seems dangerous. In 2018 Macron talks about reducing France' reliance on nuclear energy [1], now he declares its a tool to achieve energy independence [2]. Building, maintaining, upgrading and dealing with issues caused by nuclear reactors is a very engineering and science heavy. I am curios if there is enough talent to be able to do it? Will this rhetoric be attended with enough investment in education to make sure that we have talent to service this need for generations? Nuclear energy skill is akin to space exploration, just because the nation had Apollo program and could put a man on the moon 50 year ago, does not mean it can do it now. If it were not for Elon and SpaceX US would not have an ability to bring astronauts to ISS without a third nation. Financial investment alone won't solve it, as you need time to establish pool of qualified people. "We are going, for the first time in decades, to relaunch the construction of nuclear reactors in our country and continue to develop renewable energies," – so people who launched it in the past have long retired? The newes reactor in the US was launched in 2016, the newest plant is 1996, so 20+ years ago. And there are still problems to be solved with nuclear energy. The most obvious one – nuclear waste. No one wants to have in their backyard. Once it is stored, it is essentially a permanent commitment to keep it safe there until a better option emerges. A better option will emerge if there is a constant effort to find it. But what if something goes wrong, how will the public and politicians react? Are they going to reverse 180 again? Fukushima scared politicians, that were afraid of saying "nuclear energy" in public for 10 years. [1] https://phys.org/news/2018-11-france-nuclear-reactors-macron.html https://phys.org/news/2018-11-france-nuclear-reactors-macron... [2] https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/macron-says-france-will-build-more-nuclear-energy-reactors-2021-11-09/ https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/macron-says-france-w...
- ncmncm 5y agoIn the US, nuclear goes wrong before construction even begins. Typically, many billions of dollars, sometimes tens of, are spent, rolling into a broad selection of pockets for years before the project is, finally, ignominiously cancelled. Often a great deal of concrete has been poured. No one is indicted. The money is just "gone".
- natch 5y agoIf we could get away with it, I would prefer if we could stick to options that are not so centralized. Unfortunately the sun doesn't shine everywhere all the time (especially in higher latitudes during their winter), and wind power is not perfect everywhere either, so nuclear will be a necessary evil as part of the mix alongside other low carbon options. I say necessary evil not only because of safety and proliferation issues, both of which can be mitigated by some designs although choice of those designs is not assured, but rather because of central control, large budgets, political lobbying, and the corruption and massive consumer and taxpayer costs that all that tends to bring on.
- 00deadbeef 5y agoRolls-Royce are developing small modular reactors which will help decentralise nuclear power as you’d have fewer small reactors spread over a larger area.
- 00deadbeef 5y agomany small reactors*
- p_l 5y agoSVBR design has been around since 1995 or so. Other than geopolitical issues, main problem is that any mass production would eat considerable percentage of world's bismuth production. However the design is safe and based on battle-tested submarine reactors from Alfa class attack subs.
- tcmart14 5y agoI love the aspect of rolling out more nuclear as a solution, but the centralization issue is a good point. While I love the idea of rolling out more Nuclear, I still don't see it as a forever and always solution. Nuclear at the very least, should be a viable option until other green energy sources get further along in their development where needed. I would love to see a day when people could generate most of all their energy needs themselves.
- 5y ago
- HamburgerEmoji 5y agoThere is no climate crisis.
- qwerty456127 5y agoIMHO America should reconsider public transport vs cars first, to increase overall energy efficiency. This is a naïve view but why not.
- 00deadbeef 5y agoThey should reconsider footpaths too
- bart_spoon 5y agoBecause ultimately that’s a drop in the bucket. Vehicle emissions are only a small part of overall emissions, which includes power generation, agriculture, manufacturing, etc. And even among vehicle emissions, personal transportation makes up only a portion. Lots of emissions come from logistics and supply chain transportation. And to revamping public transportation in the US requires overhauling infrastructure and systems 80 years in the making, which will take time. So while reconsidering public transportation is a good thing in the long term, it will do very little in the short to medium term, which is when we need results.
- onion2k 5y agoChina have an experimental molten-salt Thorium reactor going live very soon. It's only small, but if it's successful there are plans to build a much bigger one by 2030. That's really interesting tech, notably because the supply of Uranium is very limited and there isn't enough in nature for every nation to go all in on nuclear power. Using Thorium and turning it in to U-233 for power generation is a good idea. Plus, there's loads of Thorium on the moon, so if we get good reactors on Earth the tech will apply to our extra-terrestrial expansion plans.
- vonadz 5y agoOn top of this there have also been big recent developments in fusion reactors. Probably still 50 years out for them to be useful though.
- ahevia 5y agoI remember when I was kid hearing fusion reactors are impossible. What breakthroughs finally made them potentially possible?
- go_elmo 5y agowe are getting closer to it, slowly but steadily. But it is still a substantial way to go. Putting all hopes into it is definitely the wrong decision.
- OneTimePetes 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-temperature_superconductivity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-temperature_superconducti...
- sandworm101 5y ago>> What breakthroughs Superconducting magnets and faster computers to accurately model magnetic containment.
- jillesvangurp 5y ago
- vonadz 5y agoNuclear is just cleaner when it's done right. Look at the top producing plants in the US (https://findenergy.com/power-plants/ https://findenergy.com/power-plants/). All fossil fuels, mostly around 1,000 KGs of CO2/MWh produced. Nuclear is around 15 KGs/MWh. Just for reference, the #1 polluting plant in the US produces more CO2 than all of the passenger vehicles in the US combined.
- runeks 5y ago> Nuclear is just cleaner when it's done right. The question is whether “doing it wrong” (Fukushima) outweighs the benefits of “doing it right”.
- hdjjhhvvhga 5y agoIt's hard to say Fukushima was a case of "doing it wrong." You can only protect against a certain level of natural disasters. Even if you get totally paranoid and put the plant deep under earth you can never be sure an earthquake doesn't damage it. We just can't be 100% sure. On the other hand, can we afford not doing it? We don't yet have clean and efficient energy storage technologies that would allow us to switch to renewables completely. So if the alternative is to burn coal and worsen our already bad situation, the nuclear risk seems much smaller.
- pvaldes 5y ago> It's hard to say Fukushima was a case of "doing it wrong." If you tsunami safety plan in a country prone to have tsunamis fits in one page and has not been updated in the last 9 years to include the new scientific data, yes, you are doing it wrong. If your plans calculate less than 6m high waves as a maximum and there is a 14m high wave event. If your calculus failed for more than 50%, not, this is not a good job. You could have done much more. Can blame the nature or the bad luck, or the constellations, but you are just lying to yourself.
- hdjjhhvvhga 5y ago
- jillesvangurp 5y agoI think the current nuclear attention actually has more to do with oil and gas price instability scaring consumers, and more importantly voters, than with the climate. Climate is a vague threat in the future for most people. But high gas and electricity prices are something to be feared right now. Of course the irony is that nuclear is actually more expensive than gas powered electricity and it will be consumers and tax payers that will pay for it. The key metric to focus on is $/kwh. Anything else is just noise. People will wield terms like base load and speak in very assertive terms about how important it is to have it. Ask them 1 question: how many GWH at what price? It's a simple question with a simple answer for nuclear: not a whole lot at great cost. Anything above 10 cents is ludicrously expensive. It's not competitive. It can't be done without raising energy prices and taxes or increasing national debt. I'm not talking consumer rates but actual cost per kwh for the producer. The difference is their profit. Profitability of nuclear plants in a market with dirt cheap renewables, is going to be a challenge and the mitigation plan for that is charging consumers and tax payers for it. It's beyond stupid to support that. Put a price on it and do the math. It doesn't add up to anything good. Slightly below 2 cents is about the best you can get right now. E.g. solar in the United Emirates is bidding close to 1 cent in recent years (unsubsidized). Offshore wind is a few cents more expensive (5-6 cents). Onshore is actually cheaper but less reliable. Consumer cost is much higher than that. Which is why relatively expensive roof top solar (15-20 cents/kwh) is attractive to consumers paying much more than that for grid energy. Prices are trending down over time (learning effect, improved technology, etc). Probably half a cent is a good cost target a few years from now. I.e. by the time these planned nuclear plants become operational. Certainly less than 1 cent. The most rosy projections for new nuclear plants tend to be closer to 10 than to 1 cents per kwh. Emphasis on rosy. Nuclear plants never get build on time and on budget. So that's an order of magnitude difference in cost in the best case. Worst case (i.e. what you should plan for), it's much worse. And that's of course on top of raised taxes needed to pay for all this. Nuclear plants are expensive and not really doable without vast amounts of subsidies. The reason they are being lobbied for is, ironically, that they are that expensive and that it involves vast amounts of government handouts to build them. Good old greed is the main motive here. The nuclear lobby represents many billions of interests and they'll be happy to take your tax money. They'll take the money and then make you pay again on your monthly bill. And they are spending billions on lobbying to make you believe that's a good thing.
- diordiderot 5y agoWhen you think about the risk / rewards to society of nuclear power, compare it to cars. Which is more absurd. Environmental and physical impact, cost of human life, etc. It's a much worse ratio but 99% never think about it
- rich_sasha 5y agoNot directly related to the article, but I wonder if the renewables industry being so hostile to nuclear is actually because renewables don't make sense with nuclear. We started off with 100% of power generation being either fossil fuels or nuclear (+hydro etc. but these are minor for most places). As part-time renewables enter the stage, they take priority over the fossil fuel plants when they do produce, and simply go quiet when the wind don't blow and the sun don't shine. We accept that, because we're fundamentally still in a fossil fuel energy mindset. So what does the post-fossil fuel world look like, with a nuclear+renewables mix? Well, we have as much renewables as we'd like, but really (and here's the kicker) we also need enough nuclear for windless nights (or winter days which in e.g. Northern Europe barely count as daytime). So really, we need to be able to power nearly 100% of the economy through nuclear alone in those cases. But then, that begs the question, do we still need the renewables at all? Right now it probably makes sense, because it lets you throttle back the fossil fuel burning, so is a net win. But if your baseload generation is carbon-free (at the margin anyway), it doesn't matter. You just don't need the renewables. This is somewhat oversimplified, perhaps. E.g. the times when you are less likely to have wind and solar are at night, when energy use is lower (though will that remain the case when everyone's electric car is then charging?). Also, winters drive heating demand. Perhaps some small amount of storage makes a big difference; e.g. if we could store a week's worth of power, that takes us through all but the biggest troughs in power generation, and you need less nuclear (though again, not sure how that works with winters). I'm not nuclear-crazy, if we could do solar+wind+batteries, why not. But I find the renewables lobby just says "yeah prices will fall, we will solve energy storage, just go all in on renewables, perish nuclear", which just seems like crazy wishful thinking. Whereas nuclear is always described based on 1970s technology and with the most exaggerated (un)safety numbers.
- Hypx_ 5y agoThere's only two viable paths to a zero emissions society. One is nuclear and the other is hydrogen. We have to pick one or the other (or both) as all other ideas have fallen far short of the goal.
- rich_sasha 5y ago
- LatteLazy 5y agoNo. By the time it bites, it will be too late to do anything other than adapt. And there definitely won't be money for long term morally driven projects like cutting co2 or nuclear in general (which is more expensive than pretty much any other power source)
- Waterluvian 5y agoI don’t believe America will be capable of making large, rational, difficult decisions for many decades to come. Change will happen where regulatory capture isn’t strong.
- lowestprimate 5y agoWhy not use nuclear for decarbonizing the atmosphere and for production of liquid hydrocarbons for industrial uses when the wind is blowing and sun is shining and when the renewable are not available use nuclear for base loads?
- thelastgallon 5y agoDeaths per thousand terawatt hour is the correct unit to compare.[1] Coal: 100000 Oil: 36000 Nuclear: 90 Solar: 440 (rooftop) Wind: 150 Nuclear is the clear winner, closely followed by wind and solar. [1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/494425/death-rate-worldwide-by-energy-source/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/494425/death-rate-worldw...
- yodelshady 5y agoThe article briefly mentions an enormous practical difference between the US and Europe: >Third, a heatwave in August of 2020 led to rolling blackouts across [California] as demand for electricity (to power air conditioners) outpaced supply. Dry hot places have a better power solution, trivially. Cold places, for the same reason, do not. Meanwhile, parts of the former USSR have heat that really is too-cheap-to-meter.