7 ms·
Smart appliances are a good idea in principle but rolling them out will take a long time. Water heaters last 10+ years. I don't think there are even any widely
by nradov 5y ago
Smart appliances are a good idea in principle but rolling them out will take a long time. Water heaters last 10+ years. I don't think there are even any widely available on the market today which will automatically increase the temperature at mid day in anticipation of an electricity shortage later. And it's a safety hazard in homes with small children; hot water temperature should never be hot enough to cause burns when someone turns on the faucet.
Most homes don't have enough free space for a big pile of rocks to increase thermal mass. My home has pretty good insulation but on hot days we're going to be miserable without AC in the evening regardless of how much we chilled the house down earlier.
- WalterBright 5y ago> Water heaters last 10+ years. Again, we're just talking the thermostat for it. > I don't think there are even any widely available on the market today which will automatically increase the temperature at mid day in anticipation of an electricity shortage later. Why should there be? Electric rates are fixed 24/7. All the power company has to do is provide an API to get the spot price, and start varying the electric rates according to supply. The market will adapt. > Most homes don't have enough free space for a big pile of rocks to increase thermal mass. Criminy. Do I have to design it, too? Most homes have a basement or a crawl space.
- LudwigNagasena 5y ago> Electric rates are fixed 24/7. They aren’t for some people in some countries.
- entrep 5y agoIn Sweden there are two providers I know of that charges market price by minute, greenely.com and tibber.com.
- WalterBright 5y agoI guess it's not a crazy idea after all!
- WalterBright 5y agoYes, I'm sure somewhere, someplace, there are exceptions.
- HNo 5y ago>Most homes have a basement or a crawl space. Not sure if this is true or not in total, but in the Southern US, the vast majority of houses have neither.
- WalterBright 5y agoPlaces with damp ground need a crawl space. Attics are another place to put it.
- themaninthedark 5y agohttps://www.basementguides.com/why-are-there-no-basements-in-some-states/ https://www.basementguides.com/why-are-there-no-basements-in... Since 2000 most homes have been slab construction 60/40 by 2013 78/32. It is cheaper and quicker to build slab and the way the housing market works means that developers choose what to build.
- WalterBright 5y agoYour cite is about basements, not crawl spaces. In Arizona, everything was slab-on-grade because the ground was very, very dry. That's not so in most other areas. The crawl space keeps the wood off the ground where it wicks up moisture and quickly rots. Cement wicks up moisture, too. Try a slab in Seattle, for instance, and your house will soon be uninhabitable from mildew.
- themaninthedark 5y agoHere you go, same info for crawl spaces as well. > 30 percent of new single-family homes started in 2013 have a full or partial basement, 54 percent are built on slabs, and 15 percent have a crawl space. https://eyeonhousing.org/2014/10/what-foundations-are-built-across-the-nation/ https://eyeonhousing.org/2014/10/what-foundations-are-built-... I think you are looking at a small subset of data.
- 5y ago
- bryans 5y agoWalter, the things you're saying are patently untrue. Many, many countries and municipalities do not have fixed pricing, so you're looking at this from inside a personal bubble, which does not reflect reality for the rest of the world. So with that in mind, what you're actually proposing is a solution that works for some homes, in some municipalities, under very specific circumstances. I can't imagine anyone wanting to start a business strictly based around a last-mile solution, when other solutions already exist and are substantially more efficient and scalable. You're also assuming that the regulatory bodies for each municipality inherently want things to be efficient and customer-friendly, but that's just not how it works. In the US alone, all you need is to look at the disaster in Texas this past winter, where prices jumped to 180x their usual rates -- and for brazenly nefarious reasons.
- WalterBright 5y ago> Walter, the things you're saying are patently untrue. Want me to show you my electric bill? Fixed rate, 24/7, in every place I've lived, for my entire long life. California, land of the rolling blackouts because they can't match demand with supply, also has fixed electric rates. > is a solution that works for some homes, in some municipalities, under very specific circumstances. Oh come on. > I can't imagine anyone wanting to start a business strictly based around a last-mile solution, when other solutions already exist and are substantially more efficient and scalable. Look at the endless variety of thermostat innovation for your HVAC system. Even internet connected ones. Why would you suggest that simply automatically adjusting the thermostat based on spot prices for electricity is inefficient and unscalable? > You're also assuming that the regulatory bodies for each municipality inherently want things to be efficient and customer-friendly I infer no such thing. I suggested making changes. > where prices jumped to 180x their usual rates And I bet none of those customers had thermostats connected to the spot price of the electricity. Do you know that the pump price of gas varies every day? That's demand shaping. And it works.
- bryans 5y agoGive me a break, Walter. I explain that you're viewing this from within a bubble, and your response is to insist that you're not in a bubble because you, personally, haven't lived somewhere without fixed rates? That's the definition of a bubble argument and self-centeredness. If you really think your ideas are unique and revolutionary and "correct," then I recommend going down to your local utility and pitching them heated rocks, instead of trying to convince the internet that you're right about everything -- see how long it takes for them to stop laughing. As an aside, my father invented, developed and sold a heated rocks system over 40 years ago. It definitely worked, but the concept itself proved to be too inefficient, impractical and non-scalable, and because of that it never got adopted beyond a few off-the-grid folks. So, when I say that your ideas would only work in very specific circumstances, that's based on actual historical information, not some imagined universe where the entire world is exactly the same as you, personally, have experienced.
- simiones 5y ago> Criminy. Do I have to design it, too? Most homes have a basement or a crawl space. In Europe at least, the vast majority of people live in high-rise blocks, which barely have adequate parking space, never mind any room for electricity storage. None of your solutions are even close to practical from this point of view alone. Not to mention, relying on the market to be rational really can't be the solution to keeping the grid functional. Blackouts are massively disruptive and potentially life threatening.
- WalterBright 5y agoAgain, I'm not talking about storing electricity. Just storing heat or cold. If you have a hot water heater, you already have a heat storage device that can be used to shift demand.
- simiones 5y agoI don't, and most don't either: there is no room. We have hot pipes through which hot water is pumped. At best, the high-rise itself has a hot water heater, but even that probably only holds a few hours worth of water. Serious storage is only there at the neighborhood level.
- tw04 5y ago> Any it's a safety hazard in homes with small children; hot water temperature should never be hot enough to cause burns when someone turns on the faucet. That’s a matter of forced mixing. The temp coming out of the hot water heater itself should have very little to do with the faucet temp in 2021. (Yes I realize it still does)
- caf 5y agoThe device is called a tempering valve. It's already necessary if you want a child-safe temperature in the bathroom, because such a temperature is below the leigonella-inhibiting temperature of the storage.
- pjerem 5y agoIn France, every electric meter have been (or is going to be) replaced with a new one named Linky. Linky is an electric meter connected to the grid through PLC but it embeds the required hardware to eventually drive appliances consumption. It provides a dry contact which can be open or closed remotely via the grid’s PLC. So it can be open or closed even without internet. You can imagine to use this contact to drive a power line dedicated to your water boiler, electric car … IIRC, atm, the only provided possibility is to open/close the contact via a web API / a smartphone app. But in the future, it may become controllable by the electricity provider to be automatically opened / closed based on the grid’s state (and the electricity price)
- Lichtso 5y agoThat's great! While probably hard to watch anywhere outside of Germany, there is a mini TV series about what will happen when we all got our smart electric meters: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt11470588/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt11470588/ https://next-episode.net/blackout-2021 https://next-episode.net/blackout-2021 https://www.themoviedb.org/tv/136365-blackout https://www.themoviedb.org/tv/136365-blackout And before anyone replies that it won't come that far, please consider three things: - We are using an AC power network, not a DC one. - The power grid is the backbone of modern society. - Try to find one big technology deployment which was deemed "safe" and actually kept that promise. Because I can easily find countless counter examples reaching from the Titanic to your latest game console.
- pjerem 5y agoThe dry contact I'm talking about is totally opt-in. It's a physical contact that is not used by default. You can, if you want, wire it to a power line on which you can plug a subset of your appliances. So the surface attack of this feature is that an hacker could stop you water boiler to heat or your car to charge, but you'd just have to plug them to the rest of your (still working) network. And yes, the electricity provider could probably switch off your provisioning remotely. But that's not a novelty. That was always possible. Now it can be done safely. And I'd like to add that the Linky is NOT connected to the internet. It's connected to the electricity provider network so you need to control the electricity provider in order to hack the meter. But at this point, if you gain control of the network, there is no interest in hacking the meters.
- GlennS 5y agoI'm not sure if they count as widely available yet, but here you go: https://octopus.energy/works-with-octopus/ https://octopus.energy/works-with-octopus/ (Disclosure: I work for this company, although not on these products.)
- narism 5y ago> I don't think there are even any widely available on the market today which will automatically increase the temperature at mid day in anticipation of an electricity shortage later. Our house built 7 years ago has an Enefarm fuel cell/hot water heater. Every house in our neighborhood and every house I’ve seen by the same builder has one. It approaches things a little bit differently but to the same effect. It learns your energy use patterns and turns on the fuel cell (using LP gas) when you usually use electricity, generating hot water as a side effect. The future is already here, it’s just not evenly distributed yet. https://www.j-lpgas.gr.jp/en/appliances/index.html#ENE-FARM https://www.j-lpgas.gr.jp/en/appliances/index.html#ENE-FARM > it's a safety hazard in homes with small children; hot water temperature should never be hot enough to cause burns when someone turns on the faucet. Internally it stores water at 65 degrees C but mixes it with cold water to to supply all water to the house at a certain temp. We have ours set to 40C but you can change it on a control panel. Of course, there are mixing taps at the sinks/showers. It’s very common for shower temp controls here to have a extra stop at 40C that requires pressing a button to exceed. > Most homes don't have enough free space for a big pile of rocks to increase thermal mass I don’t know about cooling but the ones that take advantage of cheap electricity at night to store up heat and release slowly over the day are not massive. https://catforehead.com/2014/02/17/getting-warm/ https://catforehead.com/2014/02/17/getting-warm/ https://www.sanica.co.jp/aldy/products/rdf40.html https://www.sanica.co.jp/aldy/products/rdf40.html