11 ms·
Metallurgist admits faking steel test results for US Navy subs
- capableweb 5y ago> This offense is unique in that it was neither motivated by greed nor any desire for personal enrichment. How... What? What was it motivated by, if not to still be able to sell material that didn't live up to the requirements of the purchaser? Why would you sell something you know is not what you say it is, if you're not motivated by selling just that thing?
- tyingq 5y ago"she thought it was "stupid" that the Navy required the tests to be conducted at -100F (-70C)" I'd be curious to know what that requirement is for too, though I'd likely not just ignore it.
- newacct583 5y agoWhich is sort of the same thing. "I don't want to run this expensive or complicated test because it's stupid" is certainly a kind of cost cutting.
- tyingq 5y agoMaybe, but not necessarily. I bet many of us paper over requirements we think don't add value, where we can get away with it. Solely because we think it adds no value.
- alistairSH 5y agoWhile both might be illegal, there's a massive difference between papering over a requirement for a business application and papering over a requirement for a mechanical specification. The former might cost a customer money; the latter puts lives at risk.
- tyingq 5y ago>the latter puts lives at risk Maybe. There are certainly past cases of the military creating unreasonable/unhelpful specifications. Edit: Not justification for what she did. Just curiosity, having spent a fair amount of time in the military.
- NikolaeVarius 5y agoIt is not the job of an individual to simply just ignore a spec instead of bringing up a complaint.
- tyingq 5y agoYes, I'm not justifying what she did. I am, however, curious if the requirement was "stupid" or not.
- NikolaeVarius 5y agoThere is always a chance it is, however without some deep knowledge on the reasons for the spec, its impossible to say why a spec exists in the first place. Many of these large scale engineering specs are "take the worst possible situation you can ever think of and design it so that it can survive 1.3x of that". Yes it sounds stupid to the layman, but this is how you make shit that survives everything you toss at it. Ignoring "dumb specifications" is the reason why SpaceX lost a payload. They used non aeronautical grade metal, which did not conform to the requirements for spaceflight, causing a mission failure.
- NikolaeVarius 5y agoAnyone who would paper over requirements that involve lives is a terrible engineer and should be blacklisted from anything resembling engineering.
- QuarterReptile 5y agoIt probably significantly improved her return on brain damage.
- capitainenemo 5y agoAccording to other coverage it was not a failure to run the tests, it was changing failed grades to passes. https://www.wavy.com/news/military/navy/metallurgist-faked-steel-test-results-for-navy-subs-for-decades/ https://www.wavy.com/news/military/navy/metallurgist-faked-s...
- Nasrudith 5y agoI don't know about how cold deep artic waters may be (I doubt that much), but strength-stress curves are likely why. The easiest way to make something last long and not have unexpected accidents is to overrate it big time - such that any wear would need to become blatant. To take an ergonomically silly exampke shovel handle could be a three inch diameter of solid steel that can take five metric tons per square centimeter as pressure without bending. If it wears out enough that it could snap by human body weight it would have to be worn quite a bit.
- jhgb 5y agoSalt water won't go much below zero. At oceanic salinity levels I doubt there's any place with liquid water below -2C.
- soco 5y agoSubmarines don't stay all the time under water.
- jhgb 5y agoThey're designed to spend as much time under water as possible (i.e., months, basically). That's the whole reason for nuclear power on submarines.
- soco 5y agoThe official requirement of the US Navy seems to disagree and I tend to trust they know better than us what they design their gadgets for. The metallurgist also thought they knew better, because they're operating submarines for their lives... oh wait.
- jhgb 5y agoWe have no knowledge of what those castings were used for. It's impossible to judge whether the requirement for these parts was excessive/copy-pasted, or not, and if it was, then by how much.
- cmurf 5y agoSouth pole mean winter low is -76F but -128F has been recorded. While the water isn't going to get that temperature, subs need to surface periodically. I bet they've looked at the probability of needing the ability to operate in extreme cold, and -100F is the compromise.
- tyingq 5y agoI had assumed the tests were related to pressure and depth, where the temp isn't much off of 0C. Not an area of expertise for me though.
- LeifCarrotson 5y agoA submarine cannot surface at the south pole.
- simcop2387 5y agoYet. Give it time. Though, i believe they just meant the waters surrounding Antarctica.
- VistaBrokeMyPC 5y agoYet? There's land underneath the ice at the south pole.
- sfifs 5y agoI believe yet refers to https://www.sciencealert.com/scientists-think-earth-s-next-supercontinent-might-look-like-one-of-these https://www.sciencealert.com/scientists-think-earth-s-next-s...
- yodon 5y agoI used to design and build scientific equipment for the South Pole. We had to do all our own materials testing because manufacturers would only specify their products to the bottom of the MILSPEC temperature range and the South Pole goes below that. I remember one spool of cabling in particular - it was beautiful stuff, highly flexible, high current carrying, just what we needed. It stayed awesome right to the bottom of the milspec temperature range, at which point the exterior sheathing went through some kind of phase transition and froze solid, followed by the interior insulation having a different coefficient of thermal expansion than the exterior sheathing resulting in the whole thing shattering itself into pieces just a few degrees below military operating temperatures.
- ortusdux 5y agoThere are plenty of things to control for when designing and producing steel. An important consideration for some applications is the brittle to ductile transition temperature. Some steels have a DBTT around 0°C, which means that they loose most of their impact resistance below that temp. By adjusting the chemistry, processing methods, and post-processing methods, you can adjust the DBTT of steel down below -70°C. My guess is that they were being paid to supply steel with a DBTT below -70°C, and that the contract included proof testing. The standard testing method would be a Charpy impact test at various temperatures. It sounds like they were making complex castings, so they probably had some non-standard testing requirements. More info: https://www.punchlistzero.com/dbtt-ductile-brittle-transition-temperature/ https://www.punchlistzero.com/dbtt-ductile-brittle-transitio... https://knifesteelnerds.com/2018/12/21/why-cold-steel-is-brittle/ https://knifesteelnerds.com/2018/12/21/why-cold-steel-is-bri...
- tyingq 5y agoSo sounds like designing for surface collisions (other vessels, icebergs) in a very cold area maybe?
- ortusdux 5y agoThe Navy is understandably cagey about how they surface through ice-sheets, but this Smarter Every Day video is the best summary I have seen. https://youtu.be/XFJnWp1tAdU https://youtu.be/XFJnWp1tAdU Basically, some part of the sub needs to be strong enough to reliably break ice at sub-zero temps. The rest needs to maintain its strength at those temps.
- jeffdn 5y agoYes, U.S. Navy nuclear submarines go under the polar ice caps somewhat frequently -- as did Soviet (and do Russian) nuclear submarines as well. It's a good place to hide from prying eyes, as not only can ships not (easily) follow you there, but the sound produced by all the ice moving and grinding makes passive sonar quite ineffective. The YouTube channel Smarter Every Day recently had a video series on a nuclear submarine under the arctic ice.
- jjk166 5y agoLikely it has to do with the scaling of the actual property being measured. For example with decreasing temperature, steels become less and less able to resist impact damage. Thus getting hit by something small at cryogenic temperatures is equivalent to being hit by something big at normal temperatures; so if you want to test whether a submarine can survive an impact that would be impractical to simulate in a lab, you could instead cool your test sample down a lot and test it with a smaller, cheaper device. My knowledge of shipbuilding is limited but I believe the navy suffered quite a bit during WW2 from certain steels undergoing a transition in the low temperatures of the north atlantic that caused brittle fracture. I would imagine testing at ultra low temperatures accelerates the rate at which such brittle fractures can be detected.
- belorn 5y agoIt would be interesting to know how cold the ballast tanks (and connected pipes) gets when the compressed air get released. Air going from high pressure to low can quickly drop the temperature, especially if its already at a fairly low point to start with.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoIT is entirely possible the requirement was stupid, over-specified, and irrelevant, but that is beside the point.
- albrewer 5y agoBrittle fracture toughness for carbon steels (resistance to cracking) gets really bad below about -20 °F. The colder you get, the more things you have to do to keep that toughness up, or else steel will crack like cast iron instead of bending and stretching like it's supposed to. I come from the pressure vessel industry where impact testing is routinely required at temperatures below -20°F, sometimes at -320 °F for cryogenic applications. Fracture mechanics and low temperature behavior of steels is a relatively "new" field in engineering, only emerging sometime in the last 80 years, so I can see why the metallurgist may not have known too much about it. Widespread study was kicked off in the US with the Liberty ship disasters: https://metallurgyandmaterials.wordpress.com/2015/12/25/liberty-ship-failures/ https://metallurgyandmaterials.wordpress.com/2015/12/25/libe... If you want to know more about stuff like that, ask away; it was far and away the most interesting part of my mechanical engineering education and career before I switched over to tech :)
- Nasrudith 5y agoSloth perhaps and seeking the path of least resistance? If they receive no sales commission just check the box and get it done and them out.
- capableweb 5y agoIf it was a random employee, then I'd agree with you that it would be possible. But she is/was the director of metallurgy at the foundry, so hard to remove her from any responsibility.
- aritmo 5y agoIndeed, it's a very silly statement. As if the specific requirement was not meant to be taken literally but the metallurgist should abide to it anyways. The metallurgist just wanted to save some $$$ by selling rejected/out-of-specs products.
- Narretz 5y agoThat's a giant leap in logic. She wouldn't even save money, the company would. I doubt this was the only test they did on the steel. It might have been that from her perspective she got the same steel over and over again, and just didn't do the work, because she was lazy.
- hacknat 5y agoIt sounds like it was motivated by laziness.
- LeifCarrotson 5y agoI've operated environmental testing chambers for automotive customers. It's comparatively quick and easy to do the +85C high-temperature testing, but it takes a long time and/or an expensive, oversized refrigeration unit for a chamber and the parts in it to reach the target -40C/F low temperature. -70C/-100F would probably take a very, very long time. Even in the brutally suspicious automotive industry, it's common to have an operator manually copy the chamber temperature or thermocouple reading to the test report. Especially if you believed that the test requirement was excessive, there would certainly be a temptation to lie and say that the temperature had reached the target. I wonder how the lie got discovered. Did her successor notice that they were less productive than she had been, because the chamber was slower than what she claimed it could do? Was the chamber incapable of reaching the target temperatures? Did the measured test results come out different?
- capitainenemo 5y agoOther coverage says the tests were run, but fails were reported as passes. https://www.wavy.com/news/military/navy/metallurgist-faked-steel-test-results-for-navy-subs-for-decades/ https://www.wavy.com/news/military/navy/metallurgist-faked-s...
- didntknowya 5y agosometimes people are just lazy
- capableweb 5y agoThen you would just say "No, I won't do that, we can't offer you this service/product" instead of "Yes, I will do that, pay us and we make it happen", and then don't do it.
- xyzzy21 5y agoWhy would someone even do this?
- zz865 5y agoHas anyone here worked in a big bureaucratic organization where you have to approve stuff? I get this every day, sometimes I have to "check" a list of 15,000 users to make sure they are correct then sign off. How many times have you given a big document to sign without reading most of it. We wont even talk about online "accept conditions" on sites.
- tokai 5y agoSounds like you should do your job properly CeeCee. But it isn't really comparable to sign off on the material that will incase hundreds of men under the sea.
- wpietri 5y agoNah, because in the circumstances zz865 describes, taking the time to do the work right would get people mad at you. They don't actually want the work done. They want someone to say that the work was done so that blame won't fall on the higher-ups.
- toss1 5y agoNo, as someone who actually produces parts under DOD contracts, they really DO want the work done. Corrolary to Gen. Patton's statement, they are not in the business of getting our sailors to give their lives for our country, they are in the business of getting the enemy sailors to give their lives for their country. I can also say that there are a range of engineering specs, and some are absolutely critical and some are just specified out of habit. It IS our job to communicate with the customer (whether DOD or prime contractor) and determine which is which, and charge appropriately. I.e., if there is some spec that will cost a lot to build into the component and there is a more efficient or cost-effective way to get sufficiently similar results, then we should (and do) propose that change, and if they say "OK", get it in writing, and if they say "nope, we really need that feature as spec'd", then charge properly for it and make damn sure it is done and documented. Plus, get all the exchanges in writing, it doesn't always have to be formal proposals & change orders, often just email is fine. I'd say that the vast majority of the time when something creates a production problem, or some subcomponent, coating, etc. is unavailable (like one time a handful of component X was now out of production and the new minimum order quantity was like 20K parts, so a line item that should have been maybe $50 would now be $25K+), a quick discussion will usually resolve issue, such as "yes, it's ok to increase the radius there", "yes that other component/coating is an acceptable substitute" or "what do you recommend as a substitute?". But there are those times where the answer is "we really need it with those crazy tolerances to mate to this other component". So, yes, unless you have some direct evidence of the CYA behavior you describe, I'd strongly recommend against treating it as you suggest.
- sharmin123 5y agoSnapchat Safety Tips: Secure Snapchat Account: https://www.hackerslist.co/snapchat-safety-tips-secure-snapchat-account/ https://www.hackerslist.co/snapchat-safety-tips-secure-snapc...
- jqpabc123 5y agoMaybe the ultimate "stupidity" is for someone to pass judgment on testing requirements without any real motivation or basis for doing so. Imagine if the doctor in the prison this woman is going to decides it is "stupid" to give her decent medical care.
- dariusj18 5y agoDoctors do that kind of thing all the time.
- jqpabc123 5y agoDoctors get sued and lose their license in some cases too.
- arielweisberg 5y agoDoctors (and nurses) get sued for tiny fraction of their blatantly wrong decisions that cause real harm. Take it from someone whose wife had a stroke at 35 and the triage nurse decided it wasn't worth her seeing a doctor or treating with TPA because they didn't bother to find out when the stroke occurred. They write the history and it is your word against theirs. This is an industry where insurance fraud is business as usual. They are excellent liars.
- gorbachev 5y ago...especially prison doctors.
- kingcharles 5y agoAs someone who has been to jail, would be surprised to find any prison doctor who gives decent medical care.
- wly_cdgr 5y agoWhat makes you confident she had no basis?
- wly_cdgr 5y ago"Ms Thomas suggested that in some cases she gave metal positive results because she thought it was "stupid" that the Navy required the tests to be conducted at -100F (-70C)" - was she right, or was there a sound rationale for this?
- smitty1e 5y agoIn general, testing systems outside of their normal operational profile is a risk mitigator. Because that black swan event can happen. Also, there are lives ate stake--not just reputations.
- lumost 5y agoIt's a submarine, -70C means it's been frozen into a colder iceberg than exists on this planet. I am curious if this is a mitigation for repeated stress cycles or an analogue of metallurgical properties in deep ocean water.
- detaro 5y ago... or it's sitting at the surface at a very cold place. (yes, it obviously won't completely cool down to that temperature, but is exposed to temperatures at least close to it)
- myself248 5y agoMy assumption is that very cold temperature conditions may be a proxy for some other set of conditions which are classified. Do cold temperatures mimic something like neutron bombardment, in a way that would be metallurgically useful?
- QuarterReptile 5y agoThe short version is, no, there is almost no chance that this is related to anything exposed to a relevant radiation flux.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- alksjdalkj 5y agoIt seems like she just skipped the test because it made her job easier. I feel like most of us have probably taken shortcuts before and justified it after the fact with "well it wasn't really necessary anyway"
- capableweb 5y agoI know that if I was producing materials for the government/army, I'd stay way clear of anyone willing to cheat checklists. Not only can people die, but you'll get sued to oblivion as well as the government will make an example out of you so others don't screw them in the future.
- scarmig 5y agoI'd be curious about more details about how this was discovered. It says a lab employee reported discrepancies to corporate management after seeing evidence of altered test results etc. And from there it was relayed to the US Navy, which then fined the company. Which is how it should work. It's just I'm surprised how the institutional incentives worked out: there are many places where the fraud could have been covered up. If the Navy levied a debilitating fine on the company for good faith reporting of issues, it'd create incentives for the company to lie. And the fine was $10M... is that lower than might have been done if not for the good faith reporting?
- Isthatablackgsd 5y ago> And from there it was relayed to the US Navy, which then fined the company. Which is how it should work. US Navy should take the step further; terminate the contract and blacklist the company permanently (include the board of directors to ensure no hopping between companies to take advantage). Blacklist should be shared with federal agencies. This would be more effective for the company not to fuck around with it and cut off that "it is business as usual" mentality. The benefits of this is accountability.
- Ensorceled 5y agoThat provides a lot of incentive to bribe employees from your competitors to falsify data ... totally destroys their company and they can't even create a new company to compete!
- krisoft 5y agoAnd that in turn puts a very good incentive on companies to design systems where a single employee can't falsify the data!
- Ensorceled 5y agoI bribe TWO employees at my competitor ...
- ahi 5y agoI am curious how this story ended up at the BBC. The company settled for $11m over a 30 year fraud. I would be surprised if this was more than an ancillary supplier. Note the wording: they "supplied steel castings used by Navy contractors to make submarine hulls". I haven't followed the row closely, but I wonder if this isn't a clever story placement by the French: https://www.reuters.com/business/cop/french-ambassador-accuses-australia-deceit-over-submarine-deal-2021-11-03/ https://www.reuters.com/business/cop/french-ambassador-accus...
- donarb 5y agoThe story comes from the Associated Press who wrote the article following the announcement that the metallurgist plead guilty in a court the previous day. The BBC has stories from all corners of the globe, unlike our major media who only print foreign stories if it has an American angle to it.
- shapefrog 5y ago> but I wonder if this isn't a clever story placement by the French of course - because the british press are famous for being sympathetic to the french /s the daily mail picked it up as well - and if the comment section are to be believed this is clearly the fault of biden and 'Cackling Kamala' https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10182839/Metallurgist-admits-faking-steel-strength-test-results-Navy-subs.html https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10182839/Metallurgi...
- h2odragon 5y agoDebating whether or not its stupid to do the steel test at -100F misses the point, the performance of the steel is plotable as a curve on a graph, and the cold test is one point of data that goes into the interpolation that makes that curve. If you're assuming inputs to that equation that dont exist it has implications beyond just "how does that steel perform cold"; it means that you might actually have a quite different curve but won't know it because your data was bad to begin with. Of course we hackers know how to avoid such obvious and silly mistakes; and make things like Zillow's home buying algorithms work perfectly...
- sofixa 5y agoIs it just me or is it entirely wrong to have a contractor test themselves? It just begs for failure, like Boeing certifying the 737 Max or this. The incentives are all wrong, and they know they will get away with it with minimal fines.
- clircle 5y agoMilitary testing starts the contractor testing and progresses into development testing and operational testing. As acquisitions pass through the wickets, there is an increasing amount of oversight from the both the Services and from independent testers.
- poulsbohemian 5y agoI still can't wrap my head around there being only one individual involved here and this playing out over decades. Surely there was more than one person working to test and verify here, and an auditor involved somewhere. Then, once discovered something seemingly so impactful yields a paltry fine? Feels like there's a chunk missing from this story.
- mzkply 5y agoAll it takes is an auditor that can't see the minute discrepancies and on it goes for years.
- treeman79 5y agoSpeculation warning. I would imagine a higher up got very angry every time a batch failed. After awhile you learn to just keep your head down. Many people don’t feel safe enough to push back. Or they stop questioning after awhile. Maybe someone was failing batches, and they kept getting replaced until the batches “improved” At any rate. This is what audits are for. Did this person never take a vacation, where someone else would come in and see issues? Banks force people to take a month off to force they issued out in the open
- croutonwagon 5y agoLast time I worked I the banking sector, the requirement was not a month, but just a week. It just had to be a contiguous week and not stacked on a banking holiday, or if it was you just needed an extra day. For example if this was going to me my week. I’d have to take Monday off since Thursday is a holiday.
- SamPatt 5y agoI've seen this happen first hand, albeit with far lower stakes. I was a wire puller in a factory that refurbished subway cars. High voltage cables cannot have any breaks in insulation because they're carrying a huge amount of power and you could get shorts and fires. Our supplier frequently shipped damaged cables. Our manager tried working with them to change their packing and shipping method to prevent this, but it still kept happening and it would cause serious delays on the line. Our manager was under serious pressure from the top staff to straighten this out and would get livid if a new batch of cables came in damaged, often blaming us for improper handling. Eventually employees learned to "fix" cables coming in with heat shrink and electrical tape to keep manager happy. This was dangerous and when eventually discovered by quality assurance it became a big issue. Manager was moved somewhere else.
- GordonS 5y agoIncredible they got away with this for so long! I worked as a developer, then architect, at oil and gas tooling companies for several years, and got to know many parts of the business. Something of note here is that they took their supply chain very seriously - some of their equipment will sit subsea for decades, and failures could be catastrophic for the environment as well as in monetary terms, so you can understand why. For suppliers involved with fabrication or testing (e.g. pressure testing, weld inspections and xrays), our logistics people would routinely physically visit the supplier to audit their records and watch the process with their own eyes.
- mikewarot 5y agoI think back to VW and the faked diesel test results... and strongly suspect that this is yet another case of trying to pin something, that was sponsored/supported higher up in the food chain, on the low person on the totem pole.
- 1cvmask 5y agoThis from the article: When confronted with the falsified results, Ms Thomas suggested that in some cases she gave metal positive results because she thought it was "stupid" that the Navy required the tests to be conducted at -100F (-70C), - Could someone explain to me why the tests would need to be at that temperature as well. I also find it pointless as it is way below the freezing point of water and also most of the coldest parts of the world when surfaced.