17 ms·
Oh please do. This seems like the perfect time to bring this up: I had a piece of software that used Discord for support. They required that users be verifie
by jedberg 5y ago
Oh please do. This seems like the perfect time to bring this up:
I had a piece of software that used Discord for support. They required that users be verified, which requires you to give you phone number to Discord. I gave them my Google Voice number, which is the only number I have, and they rejected it because they don't support VOIP numbers. I asked them if there was any other way to verify my identity.
They told me, "Just use a friend's phone to verify. As long as they don't try to verify on Discord in six months it should be fine, we won't check again".
Their official answer to identity verification was to impersonate someone else!
- raxxorrax 5y agoThat is bad enough, but the worst part is that the content is not really discoverable outside of Discord. Sometimes you don't want that of course but I have seen communities pretty much dying because they only met there with no influx of new users.
- errantspark 5y agoI constantly run into this problem, I've used my google voice number for everything for years (yeah it's not a great move but very hard to migrate away from) and a frustrating number of services recently have been rejecting it for verification. I end up having to take the sim out of my laptop and put it in my PinePhone. It's such a hassle. This whole "you're not a human unless you have a phone number" thing sucks. Same thing with having a credit score. You're just assumed to participate in these systems even though there's no mandate to do so or protection for you if you don't.
- perryizgr8 5y agoUsing SMS as a login verification thing is just so irritating. My bank asks me to enter an SMS OTP every time I login to the website. I know my username and password! Let me into my bank account!
- Plasmoid 5y agoThey're trying to do that to break 3rd party financial integrations. Not for your security but because they think they deserve to get paid for your data and these other people haven't paid up.
- Zak 5y agoCredential stuffing is a widespread problem. Im sure everyone on HN uses a password manager and different passwords for every service, but many people don't. It's makes a lot of sense for a high-value target like banking to require 2FA, but SMS is the worst way to do it.
- giancarlostoro 5y agoWait what? You literally put a sim card into a phone for it to be treated as a cell number? Thats odd and interesting to me how does that work?
- kreeben 5y agoInstead of "phone" do you actually mean "laptop"? Interfacing with a SIM through a computer seems pretty Futuramaistic to me. How does _that_ work?
- errantspark 5y agoMy laptop has a built in cellular modem, I find that being connected to the internet constantly is much more useful in a laptop form factor. Phones mostly just try to serve me ads in invasive ways and I'm not here for it.
- mindslight 5y agoAFAIK cell modems generally have functionality to send/receive SMSs, and you should be able to do that with the right software. Completely agree about the walls of commercial surveillance closing in though.
- errantspark 5y agoYeah, I'm sure it's possible to do so, but unfortunately my BIOS locks me into the OEM modem, there is no linux driver for it and the windows one is not documented so no luck for me in that regard. At some point I'll pour some more sweat into it and try to unlock the bios or something but sadly for now this functionality that my computer absolutely has is unavailable to me. Same with getting NMEA sentences off the GPS, I have to use windows' idiotic location API for that. 9600 baud serial worked just fucking fine, I don't understand why that isn't available as well. It's so annoying that I have to fight this hard for functionality my hardware already has.
- 5y ago
- kingcharles 5y agoI tried to log into the IRS.gov portal, but it says I can't because I don't have any credit score. (I don't have any credit because I'm an immigrant)
- jedberg 5y agoYeah same. ETrade recently changed their phone verification system and can no longer send me a text message to verify my identity. I'm actually ok with that because it forces them to use the security token instead, which they should be doing anyway! And often I'll run into problems with silently failed messages because they don't accept the number.
- KennyBlanken 5y agoYep, the latest example was my credit card company rejecting my GV number. They easily have the means to see that I've been using it for 10+ years and it's definitely me. Luckily they wanted my business more than they cared about that policy; a CS droid was able to "force" the system to allow it. Requiring cell phone numbers isn't about anti-spam or 2FA or anything else these services and sites claim. It's about linking your account to a real person identity, so they can sell that to someone - either live, or later when they get bought out (privacy policies almost always have a clause that allows them to just fork over all your info to whoever buys the company.) "Where was phone number 111-555-1212 at any point in time" is really valuable these days. SMS for 2FA is less secure because cellular accounts are almost trivial to take over. Carriers never intended for their accounts to become so important to security. These days you can get a second password added to prevent shipping out a new SIM or transferring the account, but that's bypassable by a cellular store on the corner, and poorly implemented (my carrier just adds it as a CUSTOMER VISIBLE AND EDITABLE comment on my profile. WTF?) If you get someone's unlocked cell phone or a SIM card, you can get access to their email account, their bank and credit cards...damn near everything. How fast can you lock and wipe your phone if it was ripped out of your hands while you were using it in a public place?
- est31 5y ago> It's about linking your account to a real person identity, so they can sell that to someone - either live, or later when they get bought out Yeah, this can't be emphasized enough. Phone numbers are established as universal identifiers. Discord is sitting on a giant heap of personal information including DMs from millions of young people. It is all centralized, both in terms of data, and in terms of accounts (instead of them having to correlate an account between multiple forums, most of which volunteer run and they don't turn over non-public data for money), and also associated with phone numbers. Making multiple accounts for different areas of life is made hard. Beautiful for whoever has access to the data.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 5y ago
- thaumasiotes 5y agoJust a couple of days ago, I signed in to a gmail account using the correct username and password. Gmail intercepted me and claimed to be worried that they couldn't recognize the device I was using. According to the flow, they wanted me to verify my identity in one of three ways: (1) I could verify the backup email address associated with the account; (2) if unable to do that, I could provide the 2FA code sent to that same backup email address (how would I be able to know this without being able to know what the address was?); or (3) I could provide a phone number -- previously unknown to Google -- on the spot, and then provide the 2FA code sent to that brand-new phone number. (How is this supposed to help them verify my identity?) I went for option (2), the email 2FA code. After providing the code, I was informed that, before signing in to my existing gmail account, I must also provide a phone number and enter the 2FA code sent to my new phone number. So I went back and went for option (1), typing in my backup email address. Same thing happened. Because Google "couldn't recognize the device I was using", I was not allowed to sign in to an account I obviously controlled without providing a phone number with absolutely zero authentication value. I did find a workaround. If you attempt to sign in to an account afflicted in this way in an incognito browser window, Google will, for the moment, allow it. "Don't be evil" is long gone.
- jiggunjer 5y agoI seem to recall fb doing similar. It's similar to banks or telecom providers requiring a persons home address (or worse: to prove it using a utility bill).
- zippergz 5y agoI had this problem this week too. I have a secondary Gmail account that is forwarded to my main one. I tried to login to it, they demanded a phone number (even though I do have access to the backup email), and wouldn't let me in because the only number I have is one that's already in use on my main account. I guess now you need one unique fully-functional phone number for ever Google account you have?!
- geektips 5y agoI think you can verify 6 Google accounts with a single number.
- Buttons840 5y agoMeanwhile the community is having a big debate over the CoC, deciding what exact wording they should use to say "be nice and include everyone".
- imwillofficial 5y agoWhy just communities be forced to accept everyone? Or even be nice? When in a group of friends we can often times not “be nice” however because we know each other, we understand it comes from a place of love. Perhaps it’s a military background thing, but exclusivity has its benefits.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tomc1985 5y agoBut that goes against the current zeitgeist where you absolutely must love everyone (except your political and ideological opponents)... or else!!!
- kiklion 5y agoI think this is completely different than having a credit score. I’ve never ‘needed’ a credit score unless I was requesting a line of credit. I’m which case a credit score is better than the alternative where I need to personally know someone that the lender already trusts and trusts their ability to trust other people. You don’t ‘need’ a credit score but if you want a line of credit then it’s good to have. Otherwise you get the products that they offer to high risk individuals which costs a pretty penny.
- errantspark 5y agoA credit score is used as a trustworthiness analog in arenas other than lending. For example renting a house or car, and some phone companies won't give you access to a post-paid plan, all of which can have a stratifying effect. The idea that because I don't take on debt that I am not trustworthy is wrong. I can pay a larger security deposit to offset risk, but often times that's not an option. I've also heard tell of employers using credit checks to evaluate potential employees though I haven't researched that.
- true_religion 5y agoPost paid plans are credit. It’s allowing you to consume goods, then pay for them after the fact. Sure, it’s short term credit (sub 30 days), but it’s still credit.
- acka 5y agoI believe that grandparents point was that by not taking on any debt they don't have a credit score which can be verified. You can't verify something that doesn't exist in the first place.
- true_religion 5y agoI thought their complaint was that without a credit score, businesses don't see them as 'trustworthy'. The OP separated 'trust' from 'credit score', and says they shouldn't be conflated. However since all of the OP's examples involved credit (car rental post-pay, phone usage post-pay, etc.) then in those cases trust===credit score. Without a credit score, you're basically asking someone to trust blindly that you'll pay back a debt since there's no track record of your ever paying back debts.
- zamadatix 5y agoHow does this work for Fi users? I've had a Google Voice number for so long it's the only voice number I have these days. I can't say it's a recent experience that it doesn't work with certain things though it has been a recent experience the things are aware it doesn't work and will alert you. Overall though I've yet to run into anything I couldn't use an alternative method for authentication be it luck (e.g. got into Discord before they required phone numbers) or email or calls being a thing (and working when text doesn't). Ironically the biggest PITA I had was when I decided to migrate my primary cell number to Google Voice it was my fallback contact number. Thankfully I only ran into that as an issue once and was able to get back in to set up Google Authenticator (which was also new and hip at the time).
- govg 5y agoI'm not sure if there are any issues on Google Fi, since they're an MVNO, so identical to any other cellular network.
- mdaniel 5y agoAs one point of anecdata, the IRS refused to honor my Fi phone plan because it didn't have my name and mailing address registered on it (or at least to their satisfaction). I don't know if they still require a post-paid cell phone plan for their auth scheme or not, because I gave up trying to make it through after about 6 months of requesting magic codes through the USPS Anyway, that's a lot of words to say "MVNO" is for sure not identical to "any other cellular network" for a certain class of interested parties, in the same way that pre-paid credit cards are not the same as other credit cards
- thewebcount 5y ago> This whole "you're not a human unless you have a phone number" thing sucks. Oh it’s even worse than that. I have a land line that I use exclusively for when I’m forced to give a phone number (and also for faxing doctors and lawyers which is apparently still a thing). Many internet forms reject it because it can’t accept text messages. Yeah, that’s the fucking point. I don’t want text messages from your shitty service. It’s still a legitimate phone number you can call. Don’t ask for a phone number if you won’t actually accept a valid phone number! FFS!
- nindalf 5y agoI’m sorry you ran into that problem. I ran into the opposite problem, of thousands of fake accounts a day using VoIP phone numbers to create accounts. Almost all of them were fake/abusive when they were investigated manually. Blocking these numbers felt like the sensible thing to do, because it made the abusive account creators spend more time, money and energy creating their accounts. I’m sorry it impacted you.
- njarboe 5y agoEvery one used to use your social security number instead to uniquely identify people but that was made illegal because of the many problems this caused. But company's want a unique identifier for people. Now that everyone has cell phones people never change their phone number so it is a great unique identifier that is legal to use. Not enough edge cases, yet, like yours too worry about. Maybe it will be made illegal in the future.
- b3morales 5y agoIt's never been made illegal to use, or even ask for, an SSN. You can refuse to provide it (unless it's required for tax/employment purposes) but whoever's asking can then just refuse to transact with you.
- njarboe 5y agoThanks for the info. I guess I remembered when companies stopped printing out social security numbers on everything (badges, informational letters, etc.) and using them generally due to, probably, this California law[1]. [1]https://www.kmm.com/articles-195.html https://www.kmm.com/articles-195.html
- TonyTrapp 5y ago> I end up having to take the sim out of my laptop and put it in my PinePhone Just in case you are not aware, you can receive verification SMS on your laptop as well! On Windows 10 there is a built-in app simply called "Messaging" which shows you all the SMS received on that number. I'm sure something different exists for other OSes. This is what I do when asked for a verification number and there is absolutely no way around it, I just put the phone number of my laptop's SIM card, that way I don't have to worry too much about spam too because I will never use that number in a real phone.
- glenneroo 5y agoThere are laptops with SIM card slots?
- TonyTrapp 5y agoSure, WWAN modems are not only a thing that exists inside mobile phones. ThinkPads (and I'm sure other business-oriented brands as well) often (always?) have optional slots for WWAN modems, so you can use them for a mobile internet connection without tethering. I've been using that feature for over ten years now.
- Symbiote 5y agoI had one around 2009. It even came with Linux. They seem less common nowadays, since a tablet or tethered phone covers most use cases.
- GoblinSlayer 5y agoIt looks like this: https://www.amazon.com/Huawei-E3372h-153-Unlocked-External-Antenna/dp/B013UURTL4/ https://www.amazon.com/Huawei-E3372h-153-Unlocked-External-A...
- glenneroo 5y agoAh yes, thanks! I have used a similar USB dongle. I was wondering if it was a special built-in tray or slot in the laptop.
- dopamean 5y agoI had been using my gv number for 9 years for everything as well. I recently ported it out of gv into my mobile carrier since no one knew my carrier number and I was running into too many annoying voip restrictions. So far I don’t miss gv.
- jrootabega 5y agoIsn't it a shame how the world got Google Voice backwards? The savvy among us saw it as a way to present our one true phone number/identity to the world, and have options for different back end phones and services we could use. Cell phones, land lines, Hangouts, computer voicemail, all that. But the average schmoe sees Google Voice as a way to get multiple disposable numbers to sacrifice to spammers and bar hookups and commit minor fraud. So it became useless for its main purpose: being your phone identity.
- jetpackjoe 5y agosounds like they are more interested in keeping bots out than verifying identity
- jedberg 5y agoQuite possibly, but they should still have an alternative other than "impersonate someone else".
- selcuka 5y agoWhy not? It still limits bot creation (same number can only be used every 6 months). They don't actually want to know if the number belongs to you. Not much different than using a burner number.
- jedberg 5y agoNot everyone has a friend with a phone that doesn't use discord that they can use.
- selcuka 5y ago> Not everyone has a friend with a phone that doesn't use discord that they can use. I believe Discord can afford to ignore those 3 people. Not saying it's convenient for the user, but it's not enough of an issue to encourage Discord to find a solution.
- ejj28 5y agoAny alternative would have to be inconvenient by design in order to work though, that's why phone numbers are used in the first place. An effective verification system usually involves money at the root; verification in the style of phone verification works using proof of ownership of a limited resource, and most limited resources cost money (phone numbers, IPv4 addresses, etc). In the real world this is analogous to charging money for access to an event purely in order to ensure it's not overrun with attendees,improving the experience for people who care enough to pay to get in. There are similar downsides to this; people who don't have money are left out.
- blibble 5y agoevery time I sign in at asks me to input my university email address I cancel it then it comes back next time I'm in my 30s...
- jdlshore 5y agoYou’re probably deleting its cookies. I had the same problem until I set up a (Firefox) container for it and whitelisted its cookies in that container. Now, no university reminder and no need to re-login either. (I use the Cookie AutoDelete extension to automatically delete cookies.)
- Minor49er 5y agoI've just been filling out the form with bogus school names and pointing the invite email to (randomword)@discord.com.
- ascar 5y agoI don't think it's really about identification. Binding user accounts to SIM-based phone numbers is an effective way of limiting account creation as it's effectively binding it to a physical token. I can only guess why Discord wants to do this (fighting scam bots?), but for example for Tinder this is a very effective way of preventing abuse on the huge early discovery boost after signup or long inactivity.
- jedberg 5y agoI understand why they do it, and I have no problem with that. My problem is their lack of an alternative. Either have an alternative way for me to verify, or a way for an admin to let me into their channel without verification.
- chii 5y agowhat if that alternative was "worse" than the phone number method? Would you then complain that there's no "easier" alternative? For example, a photo-id as an alternative, which imho is way worse? The problem with presenting an alternative is that if it is "better/easier" than phone number, then it gets exploited by the spam bots. If it's worse than the existing phone number method, then you'd have the exact same complaints, or worse.
- jedberg 5y agoI would be totally fine with a photo ID alternative or any other "harder" alternative. At least there is an alternative.
- ejj28 5y agoPhone verification can certainly be annoying, but anyone who's been part of large Discord communities will know that spambots that DM users with all kinds of scams are a huge issue. Phone verification stops someone from raiding a server with it enabled with hundreds of bot accounts. As for VOIP numbers not being allowed, that also makes sense; VOIP numbers are extremely cheap and allowing them to be used would defeat the whole purpose of phone verification. Personally I think that giving server admins the ability to require phone verification is a good thing. It's not mandatory and it's only used if the server admin enables it. I don't think it's fair to blame Discord when it's a choice made by the server admin, plus a forum could have the same requirement.
- PeterCorless 5y agoIf they allow the user a chance to send an appeal or out-of-band alternative method to verify then this becomes less of an issue. It's when people presume certain baselines — like a phone number — that it becomes a showstopper to community.
- ejj28 5y agoI have seen Discord servers that use 3rd party verification systems, but very rarely. An alternative to phone numbers would be ideal, but there will always be flaws similar to the flaws of phone verification in my opinion.
- Gigachad 5y agoI totally get all the frustration over phone number verification but it simply is the easiest and most effective method. It's really hard and expensive to get more phone numbers while every other method is easy to get unlimited accounts. Almost every country has phone numbers tied to ID as well so you can report the worst of users to local police.
- jedberg 5y agoMy problem isn't with the phone verification. I totally understand why they do that. I don't even have a problem with not accepting VOIP. I get why they do that too. My problem is that they don't have an alternative, and there is no way for channel admins that turn on that feature to know how many people can't get in because of their choice. They should either have an alternative way to verify oneself, or a way for the channel admin to allow you in without the verification, or both.
- harha 5y agoI have a regular phone number in Singapore from a new range of numbers that doesn’t work with many services, even with some government services. Customer care typically replies by having me first prove that the number is real (by showing a phone bill for getting an verification OTP, think of the irony) and then goes silent because they can’t work around their (human) robot way of thinking when something is unaccounted for in the handbook. (Already shifted a significant portion of my regular spend on groceries to a different provider, but they don’t seem to care) It’s very frustrating because there are other ways to prove my identity (government even provides a digital Id / signature app) and contacting me. Services should work with the minimal needed set of properties from the user, discord and slack are very annoying , there’s no need for all this hassle for a small question. I would spend the extra time looking for an alternative product where I can than signing up. What happened to people caring where users drop off in the funnel? Losing a user or customer once you’ve spent all that time, effort or money acquiring them by having barriers that don’t have any benefit is just silly.
- judge2020 5y agoOn the other side of there are bots that impersonate users to send spam or raid servers to overrun moderation and “DoS” the server’s communication. Part of the value proposition of running on Discord or Slack is that they handle offloading a large amount of user verification/spam prevention and moderation tooling. The only one you really have to do is manage rules and have some sort of rotation so at least one moderator is online to handle potential issues.
- harha 5y agoIs this the only viable solution today? Fully opt in to a provider that isn’t user friendly? For a free service maybe ok, but then you typically shouldn’t have the bot problem to such an extent if it’s small enough. For a paid service: no way, please find a way around this or I’ll find a way around your service as soon as a problem pops up and causes me extra inconvenience just to sign up.
- nightpool 5y agoThis is super frustrating. Discord requires server operators to enable phone number verification if they want any of the additional "Community" features. It's a hugely backwards requirement and it's the main reason I haven't given the community feature set a second look for any of the servers I run.
- exists 5y agoFrom what I see the only verification related setting you need to enable for community features is the member email verification requirement - Please correct me if I'm wrong.
- brw 5y ago> Members of the server must have a verified email on their Discord account before sending messages or DMing anyone in the server. (Note that this doesn’t apply to users that have assigned roles!)[1] I also help with running a community server which doesn't have the phone number requirement enabled either. It's also not required for partnered servers as far as I'm aware. You can even get around the email requirement if you just add a bot that gives every new user a role, since any role will automatically verify you as mentioned here. [1] https://support.discord.com/hc/en-us/articles/360047132851-Enabling-Your-Community-Server#h_01EEJW06BWCBBNNSM2SNW17GBW https://support.discord.com/hc/en-us/articles/360047132851-E...
- nightpool 5y agoAh, I was misremembering whether email or phone verification was required. Either way, it's still a very heavy-weight requirement for what's basically a drop-in drop-out support channel for us.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dragontamer 5y agoI have to imagine that most SWATTING is done using a VOIP number of some kind. No one would use their cell phone or land-line connected to their real identity (also: your real identity likely isn't physically located in the area you want to perform swatting. You wanna change your area-code to match the target)
- lytedev 5y agoMicrosoft does the same thing. Crazy beans.
- infogulch 5y agoThe real issue parent and many sibling comments are running into has answers all the way down in individual liberty and sovereignty. Technology companies have pulled out the rug from under us to deliver the illusion of convenience and safety. Benjamin Franklin seems to be ever relevant: "Those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." But we're here now, and as much as I might fantasize I can't make myself believe that anyone would willingly accept a significant regression on the convenience front. The only way out that I see is to reconstitute sovereignty in a modern form. We need "something" and I think we're getting close. Web3, dapps, and cryptocurrency are all aiming in that direction, and even if some instances are a miss I think we'll hit it eventually.
- dheera 5y agoI used a VoIP number with Discord, because, f them, "I don't [need to] have a mobile phone". Also I think we should call ADA violations on any company that requires people to have a mobile phone. It's possible to use a VoIP number. Happy to share how if you can prove to me that you don't work for them.
- subhro 5y agohttps://www.burnerapp.com/ https://www.burnerapp.com/ ? Note: no affiliation, just a satisfied user. Also, not free.
- aorth 5y agoHmm, something in my uBlock Origin filters blocks their signup page. Anyways, I've been using https://www.numberbarn.com/ https://www.numberbarn.com/ for SMS-based 2FA for a few years. Works great for stupid services that demand a US phone number (I'm an American who lives abroad, grrr) and don't have time-based one-time passwords.
- EdwardDiego 5y agoWhat I like about forums is that a) they're indexable by search engines! and b) because there's no expectation of an immediate response, people tend to put more time into their requests for help. I support a FOSS project via Slack, and information sparse requests are sadly the norm, I found that 95% of my responses are "Can you please provide more logs/configuration/actual description of what you were expecting, and what happened instead".
- jrootabega 5y agoSlack is great for the masses to get someone's attention. Not much else. I'm betting most of those requests start with: "Hey, I have a problem, can someone help?" No actual information follows, just minutes idle, waiting for someone to respond. Slack is like a bird's nest. Baby birds chirp loudly, open up their mouths, and hope you'll regurgitate some worms into them.
- black_13 5y agoAnd a cuckoo bird managers who said „i implemented slack on this project“ then threw out those little birds you mentioned and put his little bird in
- jrootabega 5y agoI have often thought of cuckoo bird analogies in this context.
- GoblinSlayer 5y agoFor me it starts with: "Hello."
- jrootabega 5y agoI wish it wasn't suicidal to point people to nohello.net in professional contexts.
- 5y ago
- sneak 5y agoI simply don't use services that demand a phone number to use them. It won't get better if we keep caving.
- jrootabega 5y agoAnd hope we can find a way to educate the staggering masses of children who are growing up thinking this is normal and good.
- sneak 5y agoOne of the best ways we can educate people is not being reachable on these sorts of platforms. Delete your Facebook accounts so you can't be reached on Messenger or WhatsApp or Instagram. Delete your Discord account so you can't be reached on Discord. Delete your Clubhouse account so you can't be reached on Clubhouse. The choices we make affect those around us.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bryanrasmussen 5y agojust wait til they roll out 2FA with the phone number being needed for a confirmation call (no authenticator app, there was a bug found in auth app 7000! voice calls only way!)
- kitkat_new 5y agothis won't happen on Slack or Matrix though
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]