5 ms·
I only have a limited understanding of nuclear reactors, but IIUC these would have produced nuclear waste, which we currently don't have any long-term storage p
by dekhn 5y ago
I only have a limited understanding of nuclear reactors, but IIUC these would have produced nuclear waste, which we currently don't have any long-term storage plans for. Not having storage plans for this waste (beyond "put it in pools of water near the reactors, or maybe send it to south carolina) suggests to me that nuclear power may not actually be a workable solution. Sorry to sound ignorant, but it seems like building 500 plants would exacerbate that problem dramatically.
Doesn't it seem like solar + batteries is a much better solution? We could cover large parts of the US with solar panels, store it during the day, and charge large fleets of electric cars overnight. Then, the issue is one of non-radioactive toxic waste storage instead of radioactive toxic waste storage, which seems a bit more tractable.
- rich_sasha 5y agoStoring nuclear waste is a problem, but seems somewhat exaggerated. We have been doing it quite successfully. Waste reprocessing drastically reduces that amount too. Renewables + batteries, why not. This technology is not at a stage yet where we can use it. There are literally no “guaranteed power on demand” facilities from renewables+batteries. Nuclear technology is mostly old and boring by now.
- vkou 5y ago> I only have a limited understanding of nuclear reactors, but IIUC these would have produced nuclear waste, which we currently don't have any long-term storage plans for. We currently have an inefficient long-term storage plan for it - store it on-site. We had an efficient, cheaper long-term storage plan (Yucca mountain) that failed for political, not technical reasons.
- PaulHoule 5y agoNuclear waste is not waste. The LWR extracts about only 1% of the energy from uranium. Next generation reactors like https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V8ApH-0YHkA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V8ApH-0YHkA can burn much more of the fuel and even destroy much of the dangerous fission products. Looking at it that way we've already mined enough fuel to run our civilization for a few hundred years. It's good news.
- Yoofie 5y ago> but IIUC these would have produced nuclear waste, which we currently don't have any long-term storage plans for. As with most of America's problems, this is an entirely political problem, not a technical one.
- PaulHoule 5y agoThe cost of batteries is declining rapidly, but it is still an order of magnitude too high. Will it get low enough? We don't know. Most of the time you can get away with a relatively small amount of storage but sometimes you get an extended "dry spell", so you might need two weeks or more storage to be entirely reliable. Renewables have been workable so far because of low-cost gas turbines fired by methane that take up the slack: we know now that methane is 80 or so times more potent a global warming gas than carbon dioxide, so if you lose 1% of the gas in handling it is a big problem. The fact is that nuclear waste is not waste. The light water reactor extracts about 1% of the energy that a fast reactor could extract from uranium. In fact, molten salt fast reactors can not only consume plutonium and other actinides but also destroy a good fraction of the most dangerous fission products.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoCoal and oil also release methane as part of the production process. Gas isn't as good as renewables, but a shift to using gas produced electricity for heating and EVs etc with or without renewables is still a good move.
- ekiwi 5y ago> nuclear waste is not waste There is a lot more to nuclear waste than just the fuel rods. Lots of materials that are either used by workers at the plant or part of the plant become radio active and can no longer go to a regular landfill of other trash processing facilities. That is why some energy companies are trying to default rather than pay for decommissioning plants once they have reached the maximum age that they were constructed for.
- oceanplexian 5y agoThere's a much bigger problem with solar than storage: Energy Density. And energy density isn't a problem we can solve, it's bounded by the laws of physics. An average nuclear power plant puts out 1GW of energy in under 2.5 square kilometers, or 1 square mile. To achieve the same output (Since you'd need double the panels + storage to produce energy at night) you'd need to destroy 450 square kilometers of natural habitat to generate the same energy with solar panels. Realistically you'd need much more than that to account for cloudy days, and even more to offset electrical transmission losses because no one is building a solar farm in latitudes that see 100+ cloudy days per year. Detractors of nuclear will argue "Why don't we do rooftop solar".. well, 56% of the world's population lives in cities where that's not possible, and that number isn't decreasing. NYC for example uses on the order of ~50GW or 51 Terawatts per year. You'd have to cover 15% of the state in silicon glass to get anywhere close to powering it. Personally, I'd rather take a chance on nuclear in lieu of the the massive amount of environmental destruction required to power modern society with solar energy.