9 ms·
Does the Linux ecosystem really need yet another desktop environment? I get that sometimes a group of volunteers and enthusiasts get together to start such a pr
by jeroenhd 5y ago
Does the Linux ecosystem really need yet another desktop environment? I get that sometimes a group of volunteers and enthusiasts get together to start such a project, but how does it make sense for a business like System76 to write their own instead of forking a different DE with decent support already?
There are so many desktop environments already, all causing grief for anyone trying to switch to Linux with their own stupid choices and incompatibilities. It's probably too early to say anything about System76's project, but I fear it'll only complicate Linux adoption more, hurting their own sales in the long term.
- agumonkey 5y agoMaybe a whatwg equivalent for desktop ux is needed ?
- fulafel 5y ago> There are so many desktop environments already, all causing grief for anyone trying to switch to Linux with their own stupid choices and incompatibilities. The current desktop environment situation is more uniform than ever and the situation is quite good and easy for users. Ubuntu and Fedora + RHEL are all-in on Gnome with no changes to the situation in sight, and KDE is a high quality runner up with users enjoying good compatibility between these. Most specialized desktop distros like SteamOS, Clear Linux, etc are also Gnome.
- landemva 5y agoI agree that yet another desktop is not needed. Jeff Booth's recent book discusses that a challenger needs a 10x advantage to overtake a large incumbent. Can another desktop, this with Rust, bring 10x? This looks like another distraction and splintering of focus.
- sjcoles 5y agoFeels like we're in a bit of a local minima when it comes to the design and functionality of a desktop. Getting out of that local minima will take a lot of effort. I don't know if there's much advantage to give outside of a paradigm switch in how windowing works a la tiling. Even then tiling isn't for everyone or every task. I do have many users in my day job on Linux laptops/VDI (Gnome 3/Mate) with no experience prior and they have adapted fantastically. So much easier to support than Windows.
- southerntofu 5y ago> Can another desktop, this with Rust, bring 10x? I believe so. Rust is a much higher-level language than C so it's easier to hack on, but at the same time has much stronger guarantees. Overall, its type system prevents many many bugs (it is my personal experience that when code compiles, it just works) and enables "fearless refactoring" which for something as complex as a desktop environment is a killer feature. I don't know if counting on GTK as a toolkit is a good choice (though it has certain benefits eg for accessibility) but for sure writing a desktop environment in Rust is an interesting experiment.
- beowulfey 5y agoTo an end user buying their laptop, it probably won’t matter as long as they put the effort in.
- sho_hn 5y ago> Does the Linux ecosystem really need yet another desktop environment? I think it's a recent trend that as established Linux distributions have largely gone beyond their phase of trying to differentiate through changing the desktop, now sticking much closer to an upstream default Plasma or Gnome, the idea of "we need our own HMI to differentiate our integrated product offering" is coming more from the folks doing hardware. A lot of these products are boutique offerings that need higher margins to compensate for lower volume, likely driving the thinking toward software as value-add. e.g. Purism with Phosh for the Librem, System76 doing this, etc.
- southerntofu 5y ago> "we need our own HMI to differentiate our integrated product offering" I don't think it's so much about differentiating. It's about funneling resources towards innovation. Some distros have become pretty conservative over time. Don't get me wrong, i like that my distro doesn't just apply thousands of random patches introducing subtle bugs. But at the same time, System76's PopOS appears to be among the few spiritual descendants of Mandriva's user-friendliness: if these few corporations who have a few bucks to spare are not investing in bettering the desktop experience, who will? I'm personally unconvinced by current desktop environments: they're either too complex/opinionated and ridden with bugs (GNOME/KDE) or too minimal and not packaged with user-friendly apps (i3/openbox). Those that aim for the sweet spot in the middle usually don't have enough resources to iron out all the bugs (MATE/Cinnamon/Budgie/LxQt...), and rustc compiler is pretty good at ironing out all the bugs you write before they end up in a "usable" binary.
- DrBazza 5y agoOn the other hand... suppose they get it right? A desktop on Linux that looks good and works, and is shipped pre-installed on desktops and laptops like.... Windows and MacOS? The chances are pretty small, but if they want to write their own desktop, then good luck to them. There are enough Rust enthusiasts, that if they choose to also open source it, they'll likely make a lot more progress too. This is the kind of thing that the 'rewrite it in Rust' crowd get excited about.
- cle 5y agoGet what right? The existing DEs are rather excellent.
- DrBazza 5y agoHit the sweet spot for consumers. It’s been the year of the Linux desktop for a couple of decades now.
- cle 5y agoIMO the DEs themselves are excellent, the problems that keep consumers from adopting Linux have nothing to do with DEs themselves (network effects, hardware support, etc.). The only reason my wife doesn't use Linux is b/c it doesn't have the apps she wants, and hardware issues (Bluetooth headsets don't work without ruining the audio quality, sleep/hibernation is hit-or-miss, etc.). I just don't see any issues with DEs that are preventing people from using Linux...I would love to shown wrong, because I would love to see more Linux adoption. But this just seems like a waste of time.
- TacticalCoder 5y ago> It’s been the year of the Linux desktop for a couple of decades now. Funnily enough, since when Linux started and somehow some people thought it'd be the "Windows killer", Linux now powers pretty much the entire real world (servers / routers / phones / appliances). There are billions of devices running Linux. And still... Because somehow Linux never got to more than 2.5% desktop market share, many see Linux as a failure. This is both funny and mindboggling.
- southerntofu 5y ago> Does the Linux ecosystem really need yet another desktop environment? It depends. If you're talking about one written in C/C++ with JavaScript bindings, there's plenty of those already. And they all suffer the same memory/type bugs that make them unreliable and resource-intensive. I'm not saying rust is a silver bullet, but in my experience the compiler is pretty good at preventing footguns, and the strong type system makes it easier to fork and extend than C-style "send raw bytes to this memory region and pray your gods" APIs. Overall i'm curious to see where this goes! > hurting their own sales in the long term I don't think people buy a laptop for a specific desktop environment. In any case, switching desktop environment / distro should take under an hour.
- cle 5y agoI use a lot of different DEs because I'm a tinkerer, and I've never encountered a single memory bug in any DE I've ever used.
- vips7L 5y agoGnome used to have a giant memory leak in its JS implementation [0]. It’s actually what caused me to go back to windows. [0] https://phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=GNOME-Shell-Memory-Leak-Fix https://phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=GNOME-Shell-...
- southerntofu 5y agoMemory leaks are not uncommon on GNOME, and i assume on other desktops as well. But Rust is not just good for preventing memory bugs: strong typing prevents lots of logic bugs as well. Also, rust's "fearless refactoring" paradigm enables for incremental optimization which i've found much harder to deal with in other programming languages. I think that's a point worth considering for a big piece of engineering like a desktop environment. EDIT: Also memory bugs are not just "memory leaks". There's plenty of subtle bugs introduced by off-by-one errors and undefined behavior. Just because memory usage doesn't rise unexpectedly doesn't mean software is working as intending. I don't know about you but i personally have had weird bugs with all desktops i've tried so far.
- II2II 5y agoEven though the Linux ecosystem does not need another desktop environment, creating a new desktop environment is very much in the spirit of how the Linux world does things. It allows for the introduction of new ideas without disrupting existing users or fighting battles to get those ideas incorporated into existing projects. If the ideas do turn out to be popular, they will either be adopted by other desktop environments or the adoption of the new desktop environment will grow to fill its niche. I find it paradoxical that people would question the need for a competitive marketplace of ideas in societies that tout competitive marketplaces for businesses. I also find it paradoxical that societies that tout individuality and freedom would question the need for others to express those very values, in preference of conformity and centralized decision making. We have seen the consequences when it comes to both commercial products and open source projects. Just consider the uproar of when KDE, Gnome, or Windows changes the user interface in controversial ways. Yes, it does cost Linux in terms of user base. On the other hand, it is better (in my opinion) for the open source community to differentiate itself based upon its core values and to ensure its long term viability because of that. The past is littered with failed companies that tried to take on the juggernauts while Linux has survived. A big part of the reason for Linux's survival is it's fluidity. When one project stalls, another can take over. When one group's needs are unmet, a new project can emerge.
- toyg 5y agoThe main problem is manpower scarcity. Every time fragmentation increases, typically each project gets a bit weaker - from a situation where they are already very very weak. > When one project stalls, another can take over. Desktop environments are too big an effort to see this sort of dynamic. And it shows: the two major projects after 25 years are still the very first two. Around them we have a plethora of little projects who typically die as soon as their main sponsor dies, and contribute very little "R&D" to the main two - in fact, KDE and GNOME more often than not push experiments that the minnows then implement or reject.
- mattarm 5y agoThere is often strength in inefficient redundancy. For one, it allows smaller groups of people to act in empowered ways without a lot of communication and coordination overhead. I also don't see it as necessarily a zero sum game. The choice is not always "do thing A or contribute to a similar incumbent project B" but "do my own thing A or nothing at all, because B doesn't want my idea."
- goodpoint 5y ago> Does the Linux ecosystem really need yet another desktop environment? No, and fragmenting the community even further only hurts the ecosystem as a whole. Sometimes putting your ego on a side and contributing to existing projects does wonders. Unfortunately the RIIR crowd might be unable to do it.
- AtlasBarfed 5y agoIt needs a winning desktop with a real corporate sponsor. Gnome and kde are too bureaucratic for a "good" desktop. A leading hardware vendor is a great starting point. It can force shame other DEs to support nonsexy but necessary features, it might spark other Linux hardware vendors to join / contribute. If a viable high end Linux hardware market can be spawned with apple-like margins then things can progress. But it might just be a other dead end. At least someone with resources is trying.
- quinnjh 5y agoSure its another name in the hat but i would argue that also is the benefit. Projects go unmaintained without warning, switch ownership, etc. If system 76 provides extensibility , a good LTS, and eliminates or replaces a lot of "up stream" code then its less code that can change hands or have embedded exploits. Wether it makes it harder to linux or not depends on the documentation.
- jillesvangurp 5y agoNot in itself. But the lack of uniformity across linux distributions has held it back quite long and you could argue that the recent convergence on things like snap, flatpak and Steam to distribute common software packages and games instead of the native packaging that each linux distribution has, is actually a good thing and has made Linux somewhat more of a common choice on laptops in the industry in recent years. If you have any linux distribution with snapd installed, there is a wide range of commercial and OSS software that you can install. E.g. Slack, which is used in many companies. Chrome, Spotify, and many other things. Of course the experience is not always that good and there might be better ways to get the same software, depending on what distribution you are using. But it's a nice baseline way of getting what you need going without too much fuss. And at least you are not dealing with n different packages for n distributions in various states of obsolescence, support, and brokenness, etc. anymore. Not quite as easy as installing stuff on a Mac but it definitely narrowed the gap a lot and makes it easier for developers to support their software on Linux as well. The status quo for linux desktop environments has been for many years that there are many options to choose from and that most software tends to work across them without much issues. So, having another one is probably not that harmful. Though you could question whether it will move the needle in any way. It's a nice way for System 76 to show that they care at least and who knows they might actually do a decent job of it and gain some fans. If I'd be buying a laptop to run linux, I'd probably want to install it myself and not be locked into vendor specific software choices. But that's just me. I'm sure they would not stop me from doing that.