15 ms·
> This is a completely novel molecule... Then do we understand the risk profile of this thing? That sounds like the sort of innovation that people would want t
by roenxi 5y ago
> This is a completely novel molecule...
Then do we understand the risk profile of this thing? That sounds like the sort of innovation that people would want to be at the back of the queue for.
Side effects don't have to happen in the next 6 months.
- matsemann 5y agoIf the consequence of not taking it is death, I think people would run to the front of the queue, though.
- blackbear_ 5y agoSoo, kinda like for a vaccine? (And to clarify what I am saying, even though the vaccine does prevent death, there is still considerable push back. Not sure why it will be different for this drug)
- pell 5y agoFrom what I understand it's taken once an infection is already established. Maybe it's easier to convince the "skeptics" under those circumstances to take potentially life-saving medicine.
- roywiggins 5y agoSure, those same skeptics, once they're sick, happily line up for an hourlong infusion of experimental monoclonal antibodies, which have similarly unknown "long-term side effects" or whatever they're worried about. It turns out that long-term side effects (which are a possibility with every livesaving medical intervention- what are the long-term side effects of CPR?) are a lot less scary compared to short-term death.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- foolfoolz 5y agothis drug (and all covid medicine) at this point is no longer about people hesitant to take the vaccine. this is about going back to a pre covid life. the vaccine does not protect you fully from covid 19. states in the u. s. and some eu countries have very high vaccination rates and still saw a wave of covid go through them, examples: vt, nh, de, nl. in all these places roughly 70% vaccination rate and many vaccinated people testing positive, some vaccinated dying. when this happens governments get scared. they start doing mask and vaccine mandates. things shut down. what if you could still have these waves but nearly eliminate the chance of anyone dying? then we could start treating this like an endemic cold or flu. i think these waves in high vaccine areas show convincing “vaccine skeptics” is not the gate to get there. we could be 100% vaccinated in areas and still see covid waves. the question is can we make it less risky to the point where we can go back to where we were
- mostertoaster 5y agoOh I think it will be gladly accepted by unvaccinated folk. The reason being is most unvaccinated people don’t believe it isn’t effective, they don’t like being forced to protect themselves by a bunch of moral busybodies. I just accepted as soon as we saw that covid was spreading so quickly, welp I’m gonna get that. I figured I wouldn’t be that affected by it and wasn’t. Our parents said, well if I get it I get it, and if I die, I die, now let me see my grandkids. When the vaccine came out they were like sweet I’ll get it, can we stop these stupid mask wearing and social distancing crap. No, we can’t. So now us younger folk who aren’t afraid of covid aren’t getting vaccinated because we’re being forced to, and they’re going to keep up all the stupid rules like wearing masks everywhere anyways. An anti viral drug that is this effective gives even less reason to have any mandates around vaccines, so unvaccinated people will cheer this.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoNice story. Meanwhile at least 5 million are dead - 750,000 in the US alone. How does your story help their families?
- mostertoaster 5y agoI don’t think it helps their families. You know what does though, vaccines and this new anti-viral. So can I live my life and worry about own family and not someone’s I don’t know?
- imajoredinecon 5y ago> So can I live my life and worry about own family and not someone’s I don’t know? Unfortunately, no. We live in a society where sometimes we have to take collective action to prevent collective harm. Taking personally inconvenient measures to help fight an epidemic is a prime example.
- tomatocracy 5y agoAway from the debate about who will or won't take the vaccines and why, isn't this is a huge positive for the small (but not tiny) number of people for whom vaccines don't provoke immune response (severely immunocompromised, etc)? That group are also more vulnerable to bad outcomes from Covid.
- greedo 5y agoThat's one of my hopes. I don't know if this would have an adverse reaction for immunocompromised patients, but if not that would be fantastic.
- thehappypm 5y agoIt’s not really like a vaccine. A vaccine is almost more abstract. You’re not sick, and to continue not being sick, take these shots. With this treatment, you ARE sick. To become well, take these pills.
- HWR_14 5y agoThere are a lot of hospital bed requests for the vaccine(1) from people who thought COVID wasn't a big deal. I'm fairly sure they'll take this drug once they experience the alternative. 1) Obviously, it's too late then. So it's only the most ignorant of people who changed their minds we have anecdotes of.
- djrogers 5y agoSounds like the consequence of not taking it is a 0.5% chance of death, so probably not a lot of running for those who understand COVID death rates.
- johnday 5y agoIf the drug has got this far into testing, there is no chance in hell that it has >0.5% chance of death (or other awful side-effects) on ingestion. So it's an upgrade either way.
- matsemann 5y agoIt seems to me that you're one of those not understanding COVID death rates, though. Firstly, even though I doubt your number a bit, even a 1/200 chance of death is mighty high enough for most people to seek treatment for something. Secondly, if you're already infected, the pill is probably less risky than those 1/200. Thirdly, the chance of death isn't equal for everyone. A healthy young person might have a 10x reduced risk, while an older person with an existing condition a 10x increased risk. So at least for one of them the new medicine is clearly worth trying.
- aj7 5y agoA 1/200 chance of death is gigantic.
- xanaxagoras 5y agoSo are the people who land in that numerator - a correlation that's not permitted in the public discourse apparently.
- ddingus 5y agoRight! It floors me to see so many not internalizing what that means.
- bellyfullofbac 5y agoPeople think 0.5% is low, but e.g. JFK airport has about 500 takeoffs a day, if on average every day 2 or 3 planes that flew out of JFK crashed, how would they feel about air travel?
- dontcare007 5y agoBut that's just it, there's less than a 2% chance of dying even if you get COVID.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- s_dev 5y agoA 2% chance of death is actually very high risk for most people. Obviously with a name like dontcare007 I'm sure you've a huge appetite for risk that others don't.
- bena 5y agoIf 2% of domestic flights in the US crashed, that would be about 100 plane crashes. Per day. An accident rate of less than 1% grounded the Boeing 737 MAX. In a study of the aircraft, the FAA estimated there would have been 15 crashes over 30 years. This was seen as unacceptable.
- tinco 5y agoThere's a 40% chance Mr. Bond here would have died before his latest film "No Time To Die", if he had a 2% chance of death in each movie ;)
- adrianN 5y agoThere is a much higher chance of dying when you're in the ICU with Covid and a doctor thinks it's appropriate to prescribe this new medication.
- makomk 5y agoThe trouble is that the new medications probably don't work by the time you're in the ICU with Covid. I'm not sure it was tested with this one specifically, but at least one of the recently-approved medications was previously trialled on ICU patients and showed no benefit - they had to do another study giving it to people who hadn't been hospitalized yet to get any useful reduction in deaths, and there's some reason to think this is an inherent limitation of drugs that try and reduce viral replication. This study only seems to cover patients who haven't been hospitalized at the point when they start the treatment.
- peakaboo 5y agoIf you watch the mass media, that's the impression they love to give, yup. :)
- wbl 5y agoThis isn't a chronic exposure kind of drug where you really care about those things. This is a horse pill where safety is pretty directly measurable in a short time.
- peakaboo 5y agoI'm not touching any Pfizer drugs with a 10 foot pole. I guess I'm one of the few actually wise humans left.
- jjuel 5y agoSo if you get strep throat you are going to turn down the Z-pack?
- nradov 5y agoThe first line treatment for strep throat is penicillin or amoxicillin. Z-pack (Azithromycin) would typically only be used in case of a penicillin allergy, or maybe resistant bacteria. https://www.goodrx.com/blog/z-packs-still-good-for-infections/ https://www.goodrx.com/blog/z-packs-still-good-for-infection...
- yosito 5y agoThere is selection pressure against your type of actually wise human.
- dbsmith83 5y agoHonestly, if you don't want to take any Pfizer drugs, nobody cares. More for the rest of us
- wonderwonder 5y agoInteresting. From a quick google search: Pfizer brands include Advil, Bextra, Celebrex, Diflucan, Lyrica, Robitussin and Viagra You never take an advil?
- darthvoldemort 5y agoPfizer also made Celebrex, the anti-inflammatory that they knew caused health issues but they buried them and claimed it was safe. We are living in an upside down world now. All of a sudden the drug companies are the "good" guys. Since when did the drug companies suddenly become the heroes? https://corporatewatch.org/pfizer-six-scandals-to-remember/ https://corporatewatch.org/pfizer-six-scandals-to-remember/ 1986: Pfizer had to withdraw an artificial heart valve from the market after defects led to it being implicated in over 300 deaths. The US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) withdrew its approval for the product in 1986 and Pfizer agreed to pay hundreds of millions of dollars in compensation after multiple lawsuits were brought against it. 2003: Pfizer has long been condemned for profiteering from AIDS drugs. In 2003 for example, it walked away from a licencing deal for its Rescriptor drug that would have made it cheaper for poorer countries. 2011: Pfizer was forced to pay compensation to families of children killed in the controversial Trovan drug trial. During the worst meningitis epidemic seen in Africa, in 1996, Pfizer ran a trial in Nigeria their new drug Trovan. Five of the 100 children who took Trovan died and it caused liver damage, while it caused lifelong disabilities in those who survived. But another group of 100 children were given the conventional “gold standard” meningitis antibiotic as a “control” group for comparison. Six of them also tragically died because, the families said, Pfizer had given them less than the recommended level of the conventional antibiotic in order to make Trovan look more effective. 2012: Pfizer had to pay around $1billion to settle lawsuits claiming its Prempro drug caused breast cancer. Prempro was used in hormone replacement therapy, usually for women going through the menopause. The settlements came after six years of trials and hardship for the women affected. 2013: Pfizer paid out $273 million to settle over 2,000 cases in the US that accused its smoking treatment drug Chantix of provoking suicidal and homicidal thoughts, self harm and severe psychological disorders. Pfizer was also accused of improperly excluding patients with a history of depression or other mental disturbances from trials for the drug. Later, in 2017, a coroner in Australia ruled that the drug had contributed to a man’s suicide. The man’s mother campaigned to change the label on the drug. 2020: Pfizer reached an agreement with thousands of customers of its depo-testosterone drug in 2018 after they sued it for increasing the likelihood of numerous issues, including heart attacks.
- jjuel 5y agoPretty sure we don't understand the long term risk of getting COVID either right? I mean it has not even been around for 2 years. Plus we do know it is possible only 1 infection would kill you.
- b0tzzzzzzman 5y agoOr injection, bias is an odd thing.
- lettergram 5y agoThat’s a straw man argument, when you take this drug you already have 100% covid19. Presumably that means you’ll have that risk, plus additional unknown risk. Perhaps the drug works like advertised, but we’ve seen better and more successful studies for things like ivermectin and anti-body treatments. Which have a known risk profile. It’s the same for the vaccine. You still have the risk of what ever the vaccine risk is, PLUS covid19. Supposedly it reduces the covid19 symptoms, but doesn’t reduce risk of infection (or at least unclear), it just improves the immune response.
- nextaccountic 5y agoThis drug might actually save the patient from the risk of dying from covid. It would be the same for the vaccine: the vaccines reduce the risk from dying.
- woodruffw 5y agoThis is a strange additive error to make: proactive or reactive treatments for COVID-19 don't produce additive unknowns in the presence of a COVID-19 infection, since their entire purpose is to improve healthcare outcomes (whether by reducing infection severity or incidence altogether).
- davidw 5y ago> Presumably that means you’ll have that risk, But greatly improves the odds of not dying, which is pretty important for a lot of people.
- 5y ago
- yosito 5y ago> Side effects don't have to happen in the next 6 months. If this is a molecule with a short half-life that is broken down and expelled by the body, it isn't going to have random side effects that show up months in the future.
- jb1991 5y agoUnless it were to change something in the body while it was still active, and those changes didn't show any signs for a long time. I'm just playing devil's advocate, but it doesn't seem impossible.
- darthvoldemort 5y agoPrions are "just" proteins that should get broken down by the body. But they don't, and they cause Creutzfeldt-Jakob in over 10 years after ingesting.
- cglace 5y agoAre you suggesting that every new molecule should be treated as if it were a prion?
- yosito 5y agoI'm not an expert, but I think if a molecule is isolated, it is possible to determine whether or not it is a prion. IIRC, prions are basically misfolded protiens that cause other protiens to misfold, like a corrupted file that passes the corruption on to every copy or derived file until the system crashes. But you can examine them before systemic problems show up. And I believe a prion has to be a protien-like molecule. Again, not an expert.
- julbook 5y agoYes, this makes sense. Innovative, but it will alert some people because of this.
- tut-urut-utut 5y ago"Please don't talk about risk with so much at stake. Just push that code you wrote this morning to our mission-critical production system." "We can do proper code review, unit testing, integration testing and full test cycle later on, when the pressure fades away." We engineers all understand the risk of pushing untested code to production, but when it comes to medicine and other fields, we forget everything and rush it out. We basically act based on fear and hope.
- wbl 5y agoDuring an incident you break glass if you have to. Because the risks of inaction outweigh action.
- HWR_14 5y agoThis already went through Phase III trials. It's closer in analogy to having the entire QA team on standby at their desks to do a full test as soon as you submit a PR at 1:38am for a feature that has to go live ASAP.
- rangoon626 5y agoLol did you not see the revelations about what was going on inside of Ventavia, the contractor that did the trial research for pfizer? They broke all sorts of protocols, covered it up, had it reported to the FDA, who in turn just sat on it.
- HWR_14 5y agoThe contractor that did a small percentage of the research, yes. Failures and fraud occur, and thankfully this one was small enough that it didn't matter.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ralmeida 5y ago> Side effects don't have to happen in the next 6 months. If you're willing to go that route, the same could be said for COVID itself.
- thehappypm 5y agoWhat’s good about this pill is that it’s only given to people who have tested positive and likely it’ll only be prescribed to people with risk factors. In the trial, the placebo group saw a 7% hospitalization rate. That is very high, and many of the other 93% surely had a bad time as well. The risk of possible long-term side effects when weighed against a very real risk of hospitalization is an easy choice. It’s different from vaccines in that way. Vaccines are given to healthy people, so there is basically zero risk tolerance.
- shusaku 5y agoI don’t think this is nearly as easy a question to answer as the other replies suggest. Pfizer will be required to make the case for safety whenever they apply for approval. It is premature to discuss this without reviewing the actual evidence they put forth. That being said, one of the reasons that protease inhibitors are considered the way to go is that “no human proteases with a similar cleavage specificity are known, such inhibitors are unlikely to be toxic.” [1] [1] https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abb3405 https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abb3405
- ricardobayes 5y agoWhy do I feel like this will be the new mouthpiece for antivaxxers?
- dang 5y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29119057 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29119057.