7 ms·
The decline of baleen whales has led to a decline of krill, researchers find
- rembicilious 5y agoSo whales poop krill which feeds algae which feeds krill. Add in sunlight and saltwater microorganisms and I guess it’s possible that whales eating then shitting krill = even more krill. But like so many complex systems it’s hard to draw any conclusions. Whales are beautiful creatures and it would be great if the oceans were so full of them again!
- thaumasiotes 5y agoIn general, it's difficult for a process that takes krill as the only input to have more krill in the output than there were in the input. If whales cause a net increase in krill, it has to be through some other means than eating krill.
- jazzyjackson 5y agomaybe krill reproduce faster when they’re under threat, like how WWII preceded the baby boom (i am not a krill expert)
- pvaldes 5y agoOh, I have it! I have it! What if somebody would be fishing all this krill and sending it to floating factories to feed pets?
- danielheath 5y agoFor example, wolves eating deer meant more deer (because losses to illness decrease when sick deer are caught and eaten before they can infect others).
- thaumasiotes 5y agoOK, but that would seem to fall under "through some other means than eating the deer". If instead of eating sick deer the wolves exiled them, or vaccinated healthy deer, presumably you'd see the same increase in deer population.
- choeger 5y agoThat's too simplistic. The moment wolves start vaccinating healthy deer, there'll be a 20-30% anti-vax deer population.
- EdwardDiego 5y agoYeah, but then there's the impact of too many deer on the forests that they browse (assuming it's a species that's a browser rather than a grazer) - when there's overpopulation, they'll eat everything they can as they grow desperate through hunger. A forest with all the seedlings eaten out struggles to recover from the death of mature trees, which is normally an opportunity for an explosion of growth - the decaying trunk restores nutrients to the soil, the sunlight streaming through gives the seedlings an opportunity to grow as fast as they can. So continual overpopulation ultimately leads to the head of deer a given area of forest can support dropping significantly. Predation, whether by wolves or humans, can reduce the deer population to the extent that allows the forest to recover, which in turns leads to the forest being able to sustain larger populations of deer.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- foerbert 5y agoNot necessarily. It's not immediately intuitive is all. For example, maybe krill do a poor job recovering nutrients from dead krill, while they do great job of it with whale waste. In this case, whales would keep the overall amount of nutrients available to krill high while also consuming them. Who knows what's actually going on here, but it's really not difficult for these sorts of highly interrelated systems to end up with counterintuitive dynamics.
- choeger 5y agoLogically, it cannot work via pre-existing nutrients alone. Even if wales poop out 100% of the relevant chemicals they ingest from krill again, because they do not need it, krill won't be able to eat it completely as it is diluted in the sea. There's always losses. So someone has to produce something. For instance: Krill need chemical X when young but create it when older in large quantities. Wales poop out X then. Or wales create X, while krill do not.
- EdwardDiego 5y agoYou're missing the phytoplankton bit - they need iron for photosynthesis, krill eat phytoplankton, whales eat krill, whales poop bioavailable iron.
- Retric 5y agoThe limitation is on biomass not numbers of krill. Replacing a X million with average weight 2g with a population that weighs 1.8g and numbers could increase even if biomass decreased. But even that’s assuming a uniform static population. Suppose in area X there is an abundance of Krill and iron, but in area Y they are heavily limited. Whales migrating through Y might cause a net migration of iron from X to Y even if they aren’t 100% efficient. Another possibility is recycling. Suppose the rate of iron addition via dust seeding is A tons per day, the rate of iron lost when a krill dies of old age is 60% and the rate of iron lost when a krill is eaten by a whale is only 30%. If the average age of krill dropped by say 20% then the biomass of krill should significantly increase.
- EdwardDiego 5y ago
- crazydoggers 5y agoYour forgetting one more input… the sunlight. The intermediate step is the phytoplankton. The whale poop (the iron specifically) is a limiting factor that limits how much phytoplankton can photosynthesize. It’s like fertilizing soil with the dead… it could in theory support ever growing populations.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoSunlight is a source of power; by assuming unlimited sunlight input we can rearrange as much material as we want, but we can't add or subtract any. If we arrange more material into phytoplankton, that would seem to leave less material available to be krill. > It’s like fertilizing soil with the dead… it could in theory support ever growing populations. But this cannot work in theory. A population cannot grow if its only nutrient input comes from dead members.
- crazydoggers 5y ago> But this cannot work in theory. A population cannot grow if its only nutrient input comes from dead members. That’s the point your missing. The nutrient input is coming first from the sunlight. The phytoplankton nutrient for the krill is limited by the available iron. > Sunlight is a source of power; by assuming unlimited sunlight input we can rearrange as much material as we want, but we can't add or subtract any. Photosynthesis creates nutrients at the base of all food webs (except deep sea geothermal vents) It’s able to allow plants to take carbon dioxide out of the air and fix it as a source of chemical energy. The sunlights radiative energy then is converted to chemical energy which then acts as a nutrient for other living things. The nutrient addition is literally arriving out of thin air. (C02 into sugars) However, organisms and in this case the phytoplankton doing that photosynthesis, are limited by specific nutrients, otherwise known as regulating factors. [1] In this case sunlight, carbon dioxide, etc would allow for massive growth of phytoplankton in the ocean. However, even given unlimited amounts of those, the phytoplankton will hit a growth wall when it runs out of iron. That iron, in this case, was locked up in vast amounts of krill. Krill from my knowledge can live up to 10 years. So that means that a balance will be reached between the krill and phytoplankton in terms of population densities and where that limiting nutrient of iron is stored. Whales change that limiting nutrient balance. By eating the krill and releasing the iron, the phytoplankton is able to increase its growth rate. Krill then, feeding on the phytoplankton blooms will reproduce quicker. Iron that was once locked up in krill for 10 years allows faster reproduction rates of new krill. The energy input that allows both populations to grow in this scenario is the sunlight. Again, the iron is only a limiting factor. The limiting factor is not 100% of the energy input. The iron is not “used up” meaning it’s availability to allow increased photosynthesis remains. The end result is that a significantly larger proportion of sunlight is captured and converted to living matter which allows a net positive gain in both populations. This is possible because the regulating factor for increased photosynthesis is maintained in the ocean at higher levels with whales. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Limiting_factor#Ecology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Limiting_factor#Ecology https://sciencing.com/effect-limiting-nutrient-ecosystem-5170836.html https://sciencing.com/effect-limiting-nutrient-ecosystem-517...
- EdwardDiego 5y agoThe process's starting inputs are sunlight and dissolved carbon dioxide that phytoplankton convert to biomass. But a limiting factor is the trace minerals they need to do so - iron is key to photosynthesis. In fact, people have proposed deliberately seeding the ocean with iron to stimulate phytoplankton blooms to fix carbon dioxide... not sure I agree with that, given the risks of harmful algal blooms. The krill eat the plankton, the whales eat the krill, the whale poop contains iron that the phytoplankton need, it's the great circle of life.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoAre the krill sequestering more iron than they need? Assuming they aren't, then in this model processing by whales can lead to fatter krill (more biomass per unit of iron), but not more krill.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- noselasd 5y agoIn most of biology, abundance of food would lead to more individuals as well.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoYou're talking about a fixed amount of iron. It can be in algae or it can be in krill. But it can only be in one thing at a time. More algae can't lead to more krill if the existence of the larger krill population precludes the existence of the larger algae population. Suppose I told you that by draining the iron from a bunch of humans we could promote the growth of iron-bearing plants that would feed a bunch of new humans. How much surplus iron could we drain from a living human? How many new humans could sustain themselves on that amount of iron?
- SuoDuanDao 5y agoBut it's not necessarily true that both populations are limited by iron availability. These iron-hungry plants could be producing more, say, zinc than they themselves need, which could allow the human population to expand even with less iron available. Give it a long time for coevolution to take place, then have something suddenly happen to the mosquito population that was extracting the iron from the people, and we could see the same dynamic.
- WithinReason 5y agoA theory I read is that when whales dive to the deep ocean they induce currents that bring iron to the upper layers. A sibling comment points out that iron is the bottleneck food for algae, so even a small amount of iron can create a huge mass of algae and krill as a consequence. Just some quick Googling found this: "Other types of whales, such as sperm whales, migrate to waters much deeper than the euphotic zone and they can scavenge iron from below and then return to the surface layer to defecate."¹ ¹: https://theconversation.com/bottoms-up-how-whale-poop-helps-feed-the-ocean-27913 https://theconversation.com/bottoms-up-how-whale-poop-helps-...
- Nasrudith 5y agoWouldn't that mean we could also blame whales for occasionally causing red tides? Not the main causes of course, I believe it is mine and fertilizer runoff which are the current leaders.
- adrian_b 5y agoThe likely reason is that when krill die by being eaten by whales, their remains are spread at the surface of the ocean, and algae can use the scarce elements that were sequestered in the krill bodies, allowing the cycle to continue. When krill die due to old age, they might sink to the bottom and be buried in sediments, so the elements stored in their bodies will exit the cycle, causing reduced biomass in the cycle, and this loss will not be completely compensated by what river water brings from the erosion of the continents.
- Robotbeat 5y agoThat makes some sense. Thank you.
- snowwrestler 5y agoSunlight and iron are also inputs. Sunlight from the sky, obviously, and iron from transported sediment. A system that uses either more efficiently could result in a net increase in biomass, even if the system is “processing” more krill per unit time while doing so.
- zeristor 5y agoI understand the limiting factor is iron, which the plankton require. This can be blown in from the Sahara occasionally. The whale faeces float, whales eat at depth but due to the high pressure of the deep ocean they can only defaecate at the surface. If they’re in an eddy and grouped as a pod the nutrients are concentrated in an area the plankton can then use the iron, and the krill which live for six years or so feed on it. The idea being to seed the oceans with simulated whale faeces this should jump start the plankton and ideally the krill giving the whales an opportunity to feed should their numbers expand, a trial in the Arabian ocean is planned to start. Currently iron levels are only sufficient near the coasts, the hope being that all far more of the oceans could start to support life instead of being deserts. This Inside Science podcast has a good bit about it all: https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m00114n7 https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m00114n7 Just thinking about it, this sounds slightly like Dune. The whales being the sand worm of the oceans, reprocessing krill into plankton food which is thought to have a huge effect in sequestering carbon.
- naravara 5y agoIt sounds like what's happening is the whales are working as a sort of churn, cycling material from deeper in the water up to the surface where plankton can metabolize it.
- denton-scratch 5y agoIsn't whale poop also known as "ambergris", a very valuable commodity used in perfume manufacture? I wonder how much of this recycled krill nutrient is removed by humans in the form of ambergris, to meet the requirements of wealthy women. [Edit] Apparently it is excreted, perhaps by pooping; but it isn't quite poop. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ambergris https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ambergris
- opwieurposiu 5y agoAmbergris comes from sperm whales, a toothed whale that mainly eats squid, not krill.
- pvaldes 5y agoI would suggest an alternative possibility. Whales eat squids. And ships are made of iron. Humans are probably putting more iron in the sea than whales do.
- Alan_Dillman 5y agoA different type of whale eat squid. The baleen combs of baleen whales is unsuited for chewing squidy bits. Rusty ships are avoided, some of the iron is molecularly bonded to other metals and minerals, and rust from ships will sink immediately, and isn't really very bio available anyway. Rust flakes and particles are kinda difficult (and large) for crustaceans to rend and digest. Irony whale poop has buoyancy, and the iron is bio available.
- denton-scratch 5y ago<pedantry> The plural of "squid" is "squid", as the plural of "sheep" is "sheep". Perhaps "squids" refers to multiple superconducting quantum interference devices. </pedantry>
- kulikalov 5y agoWhile I’m sure you are not eating whales, you may be consuming some resources that consecutively affect whales population, so it’s might not be as easy as it sounds.
- fallingknife 5y ago> Through eating krill and then defecating, whales release iron locked within krill back into the water, making that iron available to phytoplankton, which need it to survive. So sounds like removing the whales has removed iron from the system permanently and it can't recover then.
- ajmurmann 5y agoSeeding the ocean with iron had previously been suggested for carbon sequestration as well https://edu.rsc.org/feature/iron-ocean-seeding/2020176.article https://edu.rsc.org/feature/iron-ocean-seeding/2020176.artic...
- _3u10 5y agoI believe the numbers work out to sequestering 1/3rd of CO2 output for around $4 billion per year and creating hundreds of billion in fish as well as untold benefits for the ecosystem
- gscott 5y agoCanadian tribes have tried it https://www.q13fox.com/news/canadian-tribes-ocean-fertilization-project-attempts-to-boost-salmon-population https://www.q13fox.com/news/canadian-tribes-ocean-fertilizat...
- beloch 5y agoWould having more whales boost CO2 sequestration, or just increase the ammount tied up in the oceans at any given time? If the former, gradual seeding could leave a persistent effect behind in the form of increased whale populations. Seeding wouldn't just be a one-time exchange of money for CO2 sequestration.
- goda90 5y agoDoesn't carbon get sequestered on the ocean floor quite a bit? I imagine more in the ocean would mean more getting trapped in the ocean floor.
- 29athrowaway 5y agoSonars are bad for whales and other cetaceans.
- hirundo 5y agoI wonder if our own species would be improved by the return of predators, say one t-rex or sabertooth per every x population. The population control would reduce our carbon footprint. Spending on chronic medical conditions that make people slower would be reduced. There would be more incentive to exercise, less lassitude and boredom. Increased violent sudden death could be considered a drawback, but look at the big picture.
- mc32 5y agoThat’s ridiculous. In parts of India and Africa, people live among tigers and they fend themselves off just fine. In rural America we have bears and we fend them off. Sure cities lack those predators, but cars make up for that. You just want more Covid, but I bet you don’t actually want more covid.
- kadonoishi 5y agoOh bullshit. Next you’re going to say we need genetically-engineered dragons that go around frying cities and devouring maidens! Just out of some delusional idea that the fundamental problem with the world now is that one species has escaped normal population biology due to lack of effective predators and is sending the world off-kilter like the Azolla fern! How do you idiots come up with these completely unrealistic, historically ungrounded, unphysical unprincipled delusional fantastical notions!?!
- picture 5y agoThere is no need to be inflammatory
- jazzyjackson 5y agoright, i bet prey species experience less inflammation overall
- throwawaylinux 5y agoCould we release a couple of tigers in your house for the greater good, or would they mainly inhabit places with higher contentrations of paupers and other such undesirables?
- mcbishop 5y ago> ...which uses sound waves at several different frequencies to measure how much prey is around. Cool use case for echolocation.
- dredmorbius 5y agoDiscussed yesterday, 64 comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29101594 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29101594
- ummonk 5y agoAren’t baleen whale populations rapidly recovering though? Humpback whales more so but blue whales also improving. Will krill populations return or does iron need to be added back to the ocean to return both krill and whale populations back to where they were?
- mellavora 5y agoKrill has become an important commercial product, which means we have the risk that humans end up harvesting so much krill that the whales starve. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Krill_fishery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Krill_fishery
- zeristor 5y agoHere’s a Nature paper on it: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03991-5 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03991-5
- snowwrestler 5y agoThis might seem counterintuitive but it’s not really a new concept in ecology. For example it is well-understood how hippos contribute to biomass in African rivers despite being ravenous consumers. As with the whales hypothesis, it’s from their poop. It’s not that crazy a concept that increasing consumers can increase biomass. We all learned about scavengers and decay—life that consumes life, but in doing so, frees nutrients for other life. By short-cutting between the end of a complex life, and the beginning of a simple life, such creatures contribute to the overall efficiency with which the ecosystem captures solar energy and applies it to arrange environmental chemicals into living things. The difference between a predator and a scavenger is just timing. If anything, predators take an even shorter cut between the end of a life (they cause it) and the availability of nutrients via digestion. And as a gut check, things must work this way in general because the earth started with simple producers (photosynthesis or something like it), and consumers came later. Yet the overall biomass increased over time since then, even as consumers increased.
- raducu 5y agoThe same with scything meadows. Apparently if you let a meadow uncut, the plant/biodiversity rapidly declines. Anecdotally I've found this to be true, my grandparents had mountain meadows that they didn't harvest for tens of years and indeed, the hay there seems to be almost "monocrop" compared to the ones that are harvested.
- dorfsmay 5y agoTangentially related... Large animals store considerable amount of carbon. > if we restored global whale populations to pre-whaling levels, they'd sequester 1.7 billion tons of carbon/year. https://twitter.com/lauraetam/status/1453054149583462405?fbclid=IwAR1suAO6uWHWj3k1f7i8D5vz3kCW6bUsc7aeFc6wYkeUMLOs_u_LT5M-Pgw https://twitter.com/lauraetam/status/1453054149583462405?fbc...