4 ms·
I lived through the entire HIV cycle (from first announcements in the press to the current situation). There weren't really any credible origin stories for HIV
by dekhn 5y ago
I lived through the entire HIV cycle (from first announcements in the press to the current situation).
There weren't really any credible origin stories for HIV for years after the discovery of the virus and the syndrome it causes (AIDS). Eventually (more than a decade later), a reasonably good origin narrative evolved, but not until there were plenty of now-discredited origin theories: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Discredited_HIV/AIDS_origins_theories https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Discredited_HIV/AIDS_origins_t...
- jacquesm 5y agoIt's a pretty sobering thought that HIV took 40 years to get to 37 million people confirmed dead, and that COVID-19 took only two years to get to 5 million confirmed dead.
- FjolsvithAase 5y agoEspecially sobering when those 5 million dead preempted death by other causes! Meaning that people weren't surviving long enough to die by influenza or motorcycle accident.
- maxerickson 5y agoThe official statistics start the clock in the 1980s when HIV became widespread enough to get noticed, but it probably infected humans quite a lot earlier. (which I think that period is probably relevant in the comparison to COVID)
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> It's a pretty sobering thought that HIV took 40 years to get to 37 million people confirmed dead, and that COVID-19 took only two years to get to 5 million confirmed dead. The transmission mechanism for one of them is "being in the same room with the other person", and the transmission mechanism for the other is "having gay sex with the other person". [1] Almost everyone had pre-existing behavioral immunity. If you can only infect a tiny portion of the population, you can only cause a tiny number of deaths. [1] This is not the primary transmission mechanism in Africa, but it's pretty much the exclusive mechanism as far as the Western history of AIDS goes, with the runner-up being "receive a blood transfusion from the other person".
- mettamage 5y agoWhat about heterosexual sex?
- thaumasiotes 5y agoNot relevant to Western transmission of AIDS. It is the primary transmission mechanism in Africa. The difference is that Westerners generally form small, closed sexual networks, while Africans participate in a gigantic sexual network including most of the local sexually active population. The term of art here is the fairly awkward "multiple simultaneous sexual partners", but that concept isn't quite enough - a typical Westerner with multiple simultaneous sexual partners might be a man with a wife and a mistress, but when neither of them is cheating on him, that's still just a tiny, closed three-person network. But in Africa, the typical case is that most people have multiple simultaneous sexual partners, so even with the low transmission rate from heterosexual intercourse, the paths still exist for the virus to flow from one person in the society to (almost) anyone else. (I don't think mettamage deserved to be downvoted. I specified gay sex for a reason, but the followup question "why not heterosexual sex?" is pretty obvious. It has a lower transmission rate, but that's a minor issue compared to the behavioral difference.)
- gowld 5y ago> typical Westerner with multiple simultaneous sexual partners is a man with many casual dates / FWBs / one night stands, not a man with two long term partners.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoHow common do you think that is? Note that one-night stands can never, by definition, be simultaneous with each other, though a succession of one-night stands can each be simultaneous with a long-term girlfriend.
- telotortium 5y agoFWIW, this is just one paper, but it argues that the important factor for HIV transmission in their rural Africa sample is having many lifetime sexual partners, and less so whether they're simultaneous (although that certainly makes it much easier to rack up the count): https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(11)60779-4 https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(11)60779-4
- dekhn 5y agoCOVID appears very impactful but I also suspect if you integrate over biological time (IE 1+M years) the integral of retroviruses is probably larger than rhino/coronaviruses. I mean COVID killed a lot of people but then several years later, a large fraction of the world is at least partly immunized (by their own immune system). We can't say for sure but it may be that the total sum of COVID after 40 years will be smaller than HIV.
- jacquesm 5y agoThat's a good point and I had not taken that into account. Thank you for pointing that out.
- dekhn 5y agoI've been waiting to point it out until most of the people who ran around say "ohh, COVID, it's terrible, look how many people died". Nothing in public health seems that bad when viewed from the lens of biological history.
- jacquesm 5y agoIt's the 'we can't say for sure' bit that has my full attention, the problem is that these kind of relatively rare events seem extremely improbably until they happen and given that we haven't had a pandemic of this kind of virulent pathogen with the world as closely connected and as populated as we have today that it may be that circumstances have changed enough to invalidate our past experience. Populations go up and up until they crash.
- dekhn 5y agolet's just say I've worked in science long enough to watch many exponential graphs turn to sigmoids over time and that makes perfect sense. Personally I believe that were the flu or cold to arise anew todya, we'd have seen something very similar (a pandemic), but presumably, due to the lower rate of connectedness, local populations evolved (both in the DNA sense, and in the immune learning sense) responses that dull the scale (and even then, some bad flu years are Really Bad, although nobody really freaked out about it). The plague killed what, 1 in 10 people in Europe? The other important thing to realize is that COVID was and isn't and won't ever be a truly existential risk, medically speaking, and the existential risks came more from economic collapse.