7 ms·
If all software was licensed that way, 5-15 years would pass then suddenly there'd be a whole bunch of "Wow, Stallman was right again! We should have been using
by roenxi 5y ago
If all software was licensed that way, 5-15 years would pass then suddenly there'd be a whole bunch of "Wow, Stallman was right again! We should have been using free software licenses!" style articles.
Restricting software use to only people approved by the creators is a terrible idea. Society has to operate with some level of trust that even people we disagree with, using methods we don't approve of, have the potential to improve the world. Otherwise the situation will get worse.
- nuerow 5y ago> Restricting software use to only people approved by the creators is a terrible idea. Isn't that the whole point of author's rights/intellectual property in general and software licenses in particular?
- mananaysiempre 5y agoNo, the (original) point is a time-limited monopoly on the use of a creation in order to compensate for creativity (for copyright) or public disclosure (for patent rights; note the use of the word “patent”, originally used for certificates affirming government-enforced monopolies of other kinds as well, e.g. for the exploitation of a colony). Though the French droits d’auteur line of thought works differently, or so I’m told.
- nuerow 5y ago> No, the (original) point is a time-limited monopoly on the use of a creation in order to compensate (...) No, not really. Author's rights and intellectual property are not a price tag on an open market. They establish that the author has exclusive rights over his own work, and thus anyone who is interested in accessing said work needs explicit authorization from the author and covering explicitly the intender use. You don't just press a button and get a license that the author did not specified.
- mananaysiempre 5y ago> exclusive rights ... Generally called a monopoly, yes. (The original Copyright Act 1710 had a hard upper limit of 28 years on the duration, the modern near-eternal copyright is a recent thing; patents are around 20 years max even today, or using the LAME codec would still be illegal.) While I don’t think I called it a price tag (if anything, it’s only the right to set one if desired), note that the practice of copyright assignment (required among others by most publishers, both of books and of periodicals) precisely amounts to selling this exclusivity at some sort of market-determined price. The Berne Convention’s inalienable “moral rights”, from what I understand, were intended exactly to limit the scope of this so that the author could at least receive acknowledgement even if they chose or were forced to give up any and all material benefits or other control over their creation. ... I’m not sure I entirely understand what you wanted to say, sorry, so this reply might be missing the point.
- nuerow 5y ago> ... Generally called a monopoly, yes. No, it really is not and this assertion makes absolutely no sense at all. Keep in mind that a monopoly refers to a single company or person selling something in a market being the only supplier of said thing. As it is easy to understand, monopolies have absolutely zero to do with this. This is a fundamental author's rights issue, where the author of any intellectual work has the right to decide who and how is allowed to use his own work, whether or not there is any sort of transaction or compensation.
- cgriswald 5y agoThat's not correct. The other poster was talking about a monopoly in the more general sense: If someone has exclusive control of a thing, they have a monopoly. It's absolutely correct to say that US copyright law grants a limited-time monopoly to creators. You're talking about an entity that has a monopoly (generally in a market). Perhaps confusingly, monopoly is also the word we use to describe such an entity.
- geewee 5y agoWhy? In what world does using software to marginalize people or mislead the public create a better world?
- chasd00 5y agobecause some people should be marginalized less than others.
- rrss 5y agopresumably the same one where freedom of speech is valued because the people empowered to make decisions for others about what is right or wrong can be wrong.
- Kye 5y agoCopyright already empowers the creator of the software to do this. Licenses are a loosening of the built-in restriction.
- macspoofing 5y ago>In what world does using software to marginalize people or mislead the public create a better world? The road to hell ... something something ... good intentions. Who defines what 'marginalization of people' means (a strange term if you really think about it), and why would you think they would get that definition right?
- hn_throwaway_99 5y ago> Who defines what 'marginalization of people' means The software creators, which seems very reasonable to me. This isn't some arbitrary judge deeming what is marginalizing or not. This is the creators of the software saying "We don't want to build something that complete dickweeds can use for evil." Don't like their definition of "dickweeds" or "evil"? Fine, build your own shit then.
- SaintGhurka 5y ago
- jlangenauer 5y agoWhy? The creators created the software, they can put any conditions they please on how others might use it. They're under no moral or legal obligation to allow people to use the fruits of their labors, except as they permit.
- diegoperini 5y ago> they can put any conditions they please on how others might use it Isn't it "how they sell it" instead of "how they use it"? Edit: Also, "how" doesn't necessarily mean "what for".
- margalabargala 5y agoIt is not. The license in questions says "if you use this software in a way we don't like, we can revoke your license". Nothing to do with selling it.
- ekianjo 5y ago> they can put any conditions they please on how others might use it. Yeah, and that's not called free software, Free Software is about empowering end users, not the creator.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- eterevsky 5y agoThey can, which doesn't mean they should. Also, I think a person has a mortal obligation to allow that their political position is at least partially flawed.
- madaxe_again 5y agoWould you say that you should have to work with every potential client who ever approaches you, whether or not they intend to pay, and whether or not they set fire to your dog last fall?
- veltas 5y agoNot just Stallman, it's incompatible with the OSI definition of open source.
- chrisseaton 5y ago> incompatible with the OSI definition of open source So what? Why does it matter what they think?
- zelon88 5y agoIt doesn't. The OSI is basically a fancy landing page that tricks people into thinking open source has a front man. Everything about the OSI comes from a pedestrian perspective. Really nothing more than an informative blog.
- teddyh 5y agoBecause they created the term itself. The term became popular because of the meaning they gave it.
- ToddWBurgess 5y agoDepends where you live. In Canada and a lot of other parts of the world intellectual property also has something called moral rights. What is being done here is well within the copyright holder's moral rights in many parts of the world. If your name is associated with a project you have the right to assert how your project is used because it could reflect on the copyright holder's name and reputation. Like all things intellectual property rights, the copyright's moral rights would have to be determined by a court of law in the copyright holder's legal jurisdiction.
- Semaphor 5y agoI think you replied to the wrong comment? This is about OSI: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_Source_Initiative https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_Source_Initiative
- s7r 5y ago> Restricting software use to only people approved by the creators is a terrible idea. Everyone is free to use the software. If a project is found to be in violation of the Code of Conduct (e.g. discriminating against marginalized communities, manipulating public opinion, automating weapons) than the community developing the software takes steps to remedy the problem with the reported violator, or the project falls out of compliance with the license. I agree with your hesitance and apprehension of how it could could go wrong. There is significant responsibility in interpretation and governance, presumably (though in some cases, it could be pretty clear — like with weapons.). And in cases with consequences related to violence and weapons and oppression, it also seems like a step in the right direction. In the context of some software, this may not fit or be useful. In other libraries, it could also be incredibly important and impactful. It also requires stepping out of our innocence. It requires accepting responsibility for interpretation, decision-making, and governance — and that sometimes, some of our decisions may not be right. Sometimes, we have to make decisions even when the answers aren't clear. This is part of our personal lives, being in families, being in communities, being in companies. It's just decision-making at the end of the day — call it what you want (e.g. governance, licensing, restricting). Why shouldn't that kind of decisionmaking and responsibility be part of software and the communities building software — especially given its growing impact on the world around us? > Society has to operate with some level of trust that even people we disagree with This is well said. I would just note that ml5.js's approach leaves room for disagreement, and a pathway to hear and understand and reconcile disagreement, before any action is taken. The devil is in implementation — though it does seem wise, and the community has likely thought through and accounted for more of the problems than we have. They probably had discussions just like this, actually, with perspectives just like ours.
- moritonal 5y agoIf I interpret all this correctly. What if the project was bought out by the kind of people who run patent-troll companies? Suddenly your retroactive license that can at any point be invalid based on someone's opinion of wrong is a giant liability. I'd struggle to recommend such a risk.
- 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mdp2021 5y agoYour point about the «terrible idea», including the statement «Otherwise the situation will get worse», requires more defence. There is an issue with undesirable use of technology, so many are fearing future regret (Alfred Nobel in front of the title 'Le marchand de la mort est mort') - this has to be assessed, and is not solved by an appeal to trust (which is exactly what is lacking). The fear is about the opposite to «improv[ing] the world».
- Ardren 5y ago> If all software was licensed that way, 5-15 years would pass then suddenly there'd be a whole bunch of "Wow, Stallman was right again! We should have been using free software licenses!" style articles. Why do you think that would be the case? If the license doesn't achieve what the creator wanted, then they can just change it. It's not up to the greater community to decide what the best license is for other peoples projects. It sounds like you have your own idea of what will "improve the world" and want other people to license their work to match with it.
- delroth 5y ago> If the license doesn't achieve what the creator wanted, then they can just change it. No, you can't "just change it" if you have external contributors and you allow them to keep ownership of their contributions (the default). Many people object to CLAs on philosophical reasons and will refuse to sign them. Now your "just change it" is a 6-12 months effort trying to chase down every single contributor and nitpicking your license change until everyone is happy, or rewriting a bunch of code due to licensing issues.
- kkjjkgjjgg 5y agoI don't think you can change the license in hindsight, though? At most you could change it for newer versions of your software?
- Dumblydorr 5y agoIs it really a terrible idea to restrict your software from being used to control weaponry? To spread lies about science, like climate change denial or vaccine lies? To host child pornography sharing? These above scenarios amount to handing criminals and bad actors powerful technological tools which allow them to increase harms done to society. This is a software company's choice, there is no law that states a company must provide its software to whomever, even if they have evil intent.
- mlyle 5y ago> Is it really a terrible idea to restrict your software from being used to control weaponry? To spread lies about science, like climate change denial or vaccine lies? No, but there's a terrible slippery slope to have the creator able to make value judgments about uses of the software after the software is adopted and exert power over the users this way. > To host child pornography sharing? I think it's a bit of hyperbole once we're extending this value judgment to conduct that is already otherwise illegal. Is someone breaking the law to host child pornography and facing criminal charges going to be deterred by the possibility of civil damages from license noncompliance?
- andreilys 5y agoTo spread lies about science, like climate change denial or vaccine lies? Of course it’s only a lie when your in-group defines it as such. I recall at the beginning of the pandemic the CDC and surgeon general saying “masks weren’t necessary” and that “the lab leak theory is a conspiracy”. Of course both proved to be Noble Lies put out by the institutions. I know it’s comforting to think of the world in terms of good/evil and truth/lies, but unfortunately it’s a messy complicated world and things are not as clear cut as we’d like.
- kumarsw 5y agoThe issue with a "weird" license like this is that anyone other than individuals will be afraid to touch it. This includes corporations, universities and governments. Existing licenses like MIT or BSD are well-understood and don't need to go through legal. Strange clauses turn into lots of hours and lead time with legal making sure they won't be an issue.
- krageon 5y ago> Society has to operate with some level of trust that even people we disagree with, using methods we don't approve of, have the potential to improve the world. This is emphatically wrong. For at least two to three generations society has operated with a large part of it understanding that another large part of it is unethical and wrong (i.e. conscientious objectors and folks that sympathise but cannot bring up the courage to do so). If being so understanding is what made the world better, then 1930 would truly have been a golden age.
- cblconfederate 5y agoStallman was always right
- archagon 5y agoPersonally, I can’t abide my software being used to harm others. My definition of “harm” will certainly differ from that of others, but for important software, I’d be happy to append a “not for military use” clause to the OSS license, which would beat keeping the software closed source and entirely proprietary.
- lorabe 5y agoNot really, it goes withing the framework of freedom to define what actions are to be allowed or not under certain licenses. There is nothing wrong with making, let's say, a licence that prohibits the use of its adhered product for activities such as the development of nuclear weapons.