6 ms·
The Patriot Act Has Threatened Freedom for 20 Years
- 1cvmask 5y agoWould we decry such measure in other countries that are not our allies? Would we call it autocratic/authoritarian/fascist etc.?? If so then why are so compliant here.
- dgb23 5y agoI suspect the name has something to do with it.
- 1ncorrect 5y agoAl-Qaeda and Bin Laden became superfluous vestiges on 2001-09-12 when the world’s governments took a hard right and created the world they prophesied.
- headphoneswater 5y agoIt's hard to argue with results we haven't experianced any terrorist attacks on that scale since it was put into law. Maybe my freedom is being infinged somehow but I haven't noticed it
- voldacar 5y agoI have some astrological services to sell you
- rembicilious 5y agoThe USA didn’t have any terror attacks on that scale before 9/11 either.
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoImagine you were an Iraqi minding your own business and 100x more of your friends and family were killed by bombs from a foreign attack.
- greenyoda 5y agoIf the first World Trade Center attack in 1993 would have been more successful, it could have killed thousands of people - the bomb was intended to topple Tower 1 into Tower 2, bringing both down.[1] Luckily, it only ended up killing 6 and injuring 1000. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1993_World_Trade_Center_bombing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1993_World_Trade_Center_bombin...
- gremlinsinc 5y agoWas gonna reply w/ something like this but we did have a few... Germans invaded near the statue of liberty and blew shit up (ww1).... and Pearl Harbor...those were technically acts of war, but amounts to the same, and the sinking of the Luscitania... But, for the most part America has been safe before and after the one isolated event of 9/11 and there's no proof that anything we've done since has made us safer (likely it's had the opposite effect by stirring up animosity).
- nsonha 5y agono proof but I thought increased airport security must have caught some stuff.
- s5300 5y agoPretty sure it's been admitted that many programs viable because of the Patriot Act have stopped absolutely zero terrorist attacks and have indeed completely infringed upon your freedoms. https://tutanota.com/blog/posts/nsa-phone-surveillance-illegal-expensive/ https://tutanota.com/blog/posts/nsa-phone-surveillance-illeg...
- headphoneswater 5y agoThat's hard to believe, we essentialy won the war on terror here's a real report not a political charged blog: https://www.justice.gov/archive/olp/pdf/patriot_report_from_the_field0704.pdf https://www.justice.gov/archive/olp/pdf/patriot_report_from_...
- vmception 5y agoYou should read literally anything from the last 15 years, especially from rights groups. EFF, ACLU, watchdogs, thinktanks. If you only respect government sources then the GAO has plenty of gems on this topic. I’ll make a separate comment for my other thoughts
- busymom0 5y agoACLU has gone to crap in the last few years unfortunately. It's been fully co-opted by the democrats for many years. Just like the SPLC, ADL etc. Look at where vast majority of their donations come from. 1. ACLU actively gives their data to Facebook: https://www.axios.com/aclu-data-shares-facebook-4f1d21f4-d432-4998-8c67-364500015c28.html https://www.axios.com/aclu-data-shares-facebook-4f1d21f4-d43... https://fortune.com/2021/04/02/aclu-shares-data-facebook-third-parties-digital-privacy/ https://fortune.com/2021/04/02/aclu-shares-data-facebook-thi... 2. ACLU claims Second Amendment is Racist > "Racism is foundational to the Second Amendment and its inclusion in the Bill of Rights." https://twitter.com/ACLU/status/1419294620417155074 https://twitter.com/ACLU/status/1419294620417155074 Fun fact: Vermont ratified the individual right to gun ownership and the abolishing of slavery in their State Constitution at the same time in 1777. The second amendment actually helped defeat racism and the only thing racist about it is the disproportionate infringement against minorities. > Vermont’s Declaration of Rights of 1777 set forth the following fundamental rights and abolished slavery: That all men are born equally free and independent, and have certain natural, inherent, and unalienable rights, amongst which are the enjoying and defending life and liberty; acquiring, possessing, and protecting property, and pursuing and obtaining happiness and safety. Therefore, no male person, born in this country, or brought from over sea, ought to be holden by law, to serve any person, as a servant, slave, or apprentice, after he arrives to the age of twenty-one years; nor female, in like manner, after she arrives to the age of eighteen years. > Vt. Constitution, Art. I, § 1 (1777). See Zilversmit at 116. The Vermont Declaration also provided: “That the people have a right to bear arms for the defence of themselves and the State . . . .” Id., § 15. 3. ACLU used to defend free speech of even neo-nazis but have since then abandoned their principles: https://greenwald.substack.com/p/aclu-again-cowardly-abstains-from https://greenwald.substack.com/p/aclu-again-cowardly-abstain... 4. ACLU's most famous lawyer calls JK Rowling and Abigail Shrier "white supremacists" without any proof whatsoever: https://twitter.com/abigailshrier/status/1358246098364583936?lang=en https://twitter.com/abigailshrier/status/1358246098364583936... The same lawyer has also called for banning of Abigail Shrier's book. 5. Last year, they warned against using COVID-19 passport systems as they endanger privacy rights by creating a new surveillance infrastructure to collect health data which has the potential of mission creep to expand into other areas such as conditioning travel or access to housing. Such status may be stored with other personal details, such as travel, employment, or housing information, heightening the intrusiveness of an immunity passport system. They recommended focussing on the implementation of widespread, free, and quick testing, without creating a new privacy-invasive infrastructure that threatens everyone’s rights. https://archive.is/5KrP8 https://archive.is/5KrP8 But now, ACLU claims ‘Vaccine mandates actually further civil liberties’: https://www.marketwatch.com/story/vaccine-mandates-actually-further-civil-liberties-the-aclu-writes-in-an-op-ed-11630609117 https://www.marketwatch.com/story/vaccine-mandates-actually-... The ACLU, Prior to COVID, Denounced Mandates and Coercive Measures to Fight Pandemics. Now, they have completely reversed its views, arguing vaccine mandates help civil liberties and bodily autonomy "is not absolute." https://greenwald.substack.com/p/the-aclu-prior-to-covid-denounced https://greenwald.substack.com/p/the-aclu-prior-to-covid-den...
- nsonha 5y agoDidn’t someone in CIA claim they had all the data that could uncover the attack plan, just didn’t have enough analysts for that to have happened? If that is true then increasing surveillance would not change a thing, at the end data collected will just sit there untouched, or waiting to be abused.
- aaronbrethorst 5y agoBush was warned over a month before the attack. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bin_Ladin_Determined_To_Strike_in_US https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bin_Ladin_Determined_To_Strike...
- craftinator 5y agoMy favorite part was when he knee-jerk reacted to the towers being bombed by invading 2 countries that we knew had nothing to do with it.
- kuraudo 5y agoStill waiting on Saudi Arabia invasion (not that I believe that would be the proper answer either, but still).
- catlikesshrimp 5y agoSaudi Arabia is an ally, an a bussiness partner
- lamontcg 5y agoYou misspelled Iran. Trump gave it a shot by assassinating Soleimani, the Iranians just didn't retaliate enough to provide justification.
- raxxorrax 5y agoNever let a crisis go to waste for strategical ambitions I guess.
- 5y ago
- aaronbrethorst 5y agoHomer : Well, there's not a bear in sight. The Bear Patrol is sure doing its job. Lisa : That's specious reasoning, Dad. Homer : Thank you, sweetie. Lisa : Dad, what if I were to tell you that this rock keeps away tigers. Homer : Uh-huh, and how does it work? Lisa : It doesn't work. It's just a stupid rock. Homer : I see. Lisa : But you don't see any tigers around, do you? Homer : Lisa, I'd like to buy your rock. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xSVqLHghLpw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xSVqLHghLpw
- craftinator 5y agoTo the parent commenter: do you shear yourself, or does somebody just come by with clippers every now and then?
- aaronbrethorst 5y agoFrankly I’m disappointed you didn’t call me a “sheeple,” but I’ll let it go because I’m excited to meet the one person in the United States who still must like Dick Cheney. Hi! (Or are you referring to the person I replied to…?)
- craftinator 5y ago> (Or are you referring to the person I replied to…?) Well, this is awkward... Yes.
- craftinator 5y agoAnd it's a bit late to edit, but I really did want to use sheeple... Just felt too obtuse, I wanted to be just a little more circumspect.
- cm2187 5y agoTo the OP’s defence, there has been numerous, large scale murderous terrorist attacks in Europe over the same period, so it’s not like if there was no bear in sight. Now you can debate whether it is the result of good policing or of a much smaller muslim immigration or some other factor.
- CalChris 5y agoBoston Marathon bombing. San Bernadino shootings.
- KennyBlanken 5y agoThe Boston Marathon bombing is another example of the US intelligence community knowing about the danger. The Russians rang us up and said "hey these two traveled to and from a known terrorist training camp", and everyone just shrugged. Day-of, the bomb sniffing dogs left the finish line area when the VIPs did. Not long after, the bombers set up their bombs...
- nsonha 5y agospeaking of shooting, not a single thing changed because no evident the sugested changes would help
- gitgud 5y agoCorrelation does not imply causation...
- mardifoufs 5y agoBut wasn't the patriot act pretty much neutered when it's most important sections (section 215 being the most controversial one) expired under the Trump administration back in 2020? But it seems like the sunsetting of those sections received very very little coverage, all things considered and the discourse around the patriot act reads as if no one is acknowledging or giving any importance to those sections expiring. I don't understand and I know I'm missing something about how american lawmaking works. What's the catch?
- HideousKojima 5y ago>But it seems like the sunsetting of those sections received very very little coverage Because the left didn't want to bring attention to something good that Trump did, and neither did the neocons on the right. Only the libertarian wing of the right and the privacy advocate wing of the left cared to talk about it.
- tw04 5y agoYa... No. The Patriot act didn't make it out of Congress. It had literally nothing to do with Trump, the Democrats shot it down long before it got anywhere near him. https://archive.md/tBIHY https://archive.md/tBIHY
- mardifoufs 5y agoI'm not sure that's accurate at all. I agree that Trump isn't really to credit since he also pushed for another (earlier) surveillance bill but in this case it's very clear that his veto was crucial to block an extension of the sections. Your article is from march 2020 and while it does mention the house dems/senate GOP agreeing on a new bill, the Trump's veto threat came in 2 months later. >House Democrats scrapped a vote to reauthorize national security surveillance authorities that have been expired since March after Republicans revolted from the measure following tweets from President Donald Trump urging them to oppose it. [...] >Pelosi charged at a news conference Thursday that Republican support for the bill "disappeared by a tweet -- the twinkle of a tweet." [...] >Trump issued a veto threat over Twitter Wednesday after telling Republicans to vote against it, and he celebrated the bill's failure in the House on Thursday. source: https://cnn.com/cnn/2020/05/27/politics/house-vote-fisa/index.html https://cnn.com/cnn/2020/05/27/politics/house-vote-fisa/inde...
- canjobear 5y agoI'm confused because as far as I can tell the Patriot Act is not currently in force, having expired in 2020[0]. But it seems that everyone is proceeding as if it is still in force, as if waiting on Congress to actually renew it is just a formality? Is this really how things work? [0] https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2020/12/section-215-expired-year-review-2020 https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2020/12/section-215-expired-ye...
- dragonwriter 5y ago>I'm confused because as far as I can tell the Patriot Act is not currently in force, having expired in 2020 Nope, most of it remains in force, only a small (but important) minority of it is covered by sunset provisions. [0] [0] https://www.aclu.org/other/patriot-act-sunsets https://www.aclu.org/other/patriot-act-sunsets
- southerntofu 5y agoIf you believe in rule of law, you're gonna have a bad time! At least in France and USA (the examples i know best), written law has mostly never been applied: - NSA gathered tons of info before 9/11 and before dragnet surveillance was legal - CIA imported tons of cocaine to feed popular neighborhoods with crack (destroy solidarity) and finance their counter-revolutionary wars which Congress knew nothing about (like financing and arming the fascist Contras in Nicaragua) - let's not even talk about FBI's CoIntelPro program of surveillance, manipulation, and assassination of militants (see also: Cointelpro 101 documentary) - likewise in France, la Sûreté de l'État (CIA equivalent in the 19th century) persecuted anarchists long before the "lois scélérates" (scoundrel laws) outlawed anarchist propaganda - french police at the border deports people before they can apply for asylum, which is illegal in french law and according to international convention; just like french police deports romanian citizens back to Romania while it's illegal under Schengen accords - french criminal police (supposedly "anti-criminal", la BAC) is every year involved in scandals of drug trafficking, corruption, fake testimonies, assassinations, and many other mafia-like activities; the chief of anti-drugs police was arrested for being the top importer of drugs in the entire country, which everyone knew for many years - let's not even get into the even bigger corruption scandals at the heart of State (Cahuzac and so many other ministries found evading taxes, Macron enabling his personal bodyguard Benalla to dress up as a cop and beat random people on the streets, Sarkozy assassinating Kadhafi who illegally financed his political campaign...) These are just examples. The rule of law is just a myth we tell children so they're happy to be exploited by a boss and live miserably because they had a "fair chance" in life. The truth is laws and cops are the tools of the oppressors and have never served the people. The psychopaths in power will do all they want and can get away with, no matter what the law says. So yes, sorry to break your dreams, but that's how things work.
- gorwell 5y agoThe Patriot Act was when I realized you can't judge a bill by its name.
- sieabahlpark 5y agoYet HR1 is still seen as the godsend of voting rights under the same assumption. Bills imo shouldn't be able to be named something akin to propaganda for smear campaigns
- ssss11 5y agoIt’s proper doublespeak isn’t it!!
- KennyBlanken 5y agoYou can. When a word like "Patriot" is in the name of a bill about security and intelligence, it screams "fascism inside!" It was fascism wrapped in a big ol' American flag so any critics could be attacked as shitting on the graves of heroes and victims, with a side dish of "endangering America" and "not giving us the tools we need so you're to blame if it happens again." The hijackers weren't caught was because Bush ignored six briefings about Bin Laden, Al Qaeda, and suspicious activity. Not because of lacking intelligence. Bush was outright told that terrorists were in-country, planning to use airplanes for an attack along with explosives. Bin Laden's aides told a reporter they were planning an attack. The CIA knew there was group in the country. Bin Laden was under pressure; he was largely seen as a failure militarily and was trying to remain relevant as attention shifted to Chechnya. The intelligence community was so concerned they titled one of the last of the briefings "Bin Laden Determined To Strike in US" hoping that would get his attention. It didn't. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bin_Ladin_Determined_To_Strike_in_US https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bin_Ladin_Determined_To_Strike... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/September_11_intelligence_before_the_attacks https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/September_11_intelligence_befo... People think his "oh shit" face the morning of 9/11 was because of some horror at the scale of the attack or something. Nah. He realized he was in deep, deep shit because he'd been warned, repeatedly, about Bin Laden planning an attack. Reportedly Bin Laden was shocked at the scale of American response, but I think he didn't realize that Bush was willing to do anything to stay in for a second term (and how many dollar signs Cheney saw.) https://www.nytimes.com/2004/04/10/us/august-01-brief-is-said-to-warn-of-attack-plans.html https://www.nytimes.com/2004/04/10/us/august-01-brief-is-sai... https://www.nytimes.com/2012/09/11/opinion/the-bush-white-house-was-deaf-to-9-11-warnings.html https://www.nytimes.com/2012/09/11/opinion/the-bush-white-ho... https://www.businessinsider.com/new-report-shows-how-many-warnings-about-bin-laden-were-ignored-by-the-bush-white-house-2012-9 https://www.businessinsider.com/new-report-shows-how-many-wa... https://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2015/11/cia-directors-documentary-911-bush-213353/ https://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2015/11/cia-director... https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2004/04/while-bush-vacationed-9-11-warnings-went-unheard.html https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2004/04/while-bush-vacat... The fallout of the Patriot Act cannot be understated. One of many effects: dramatically reduced access to the US banking system for people who lack the right sort of identification, for whatever reason. Real ID bullshit is doing similar, making it much more difficult to secure government-issued ID, solving a problem that by and large doesn't exist.
- hikerclimber1 5y agoI agree.
- richardatlarge 5y agoI see a lot of freedom in the US, don’t see much responsibility though.
- easytiger 5y agocare to elaborate?
- richardatlarge 5y agoWell I keep hearing all kinds of people ranting about their freedom, often in relation to COVID restrictions. Or taxes, or... As if living off of the back of a highly complex society incurred no responsibilities. That’s a parasitic not a symbiotic relationship
- easytiger 5y agoWell i'm at least somewhat glad there are some people pushing back against micro control of one's life. You of course might enjoy the odd tolaitarian diktat, but each to his own.
- mdp2021 5y agoThe idea of "freedom" mixes "freedom from" and "freedom to" ("freedom to shoot" is a thing, "freedom from being shot" is another etc.). If you demanded freedom from dumb, irrational positions from the public, you will want to demand the same freedom from dumb, irrational positions from the administration. Such freedom includes freedom from unreasonable restrictions - freedom to do what is reasonable. I am not sure about the USA, but I grant you there has been extreme abuse of good sense around the world in the past two years (if literal, non generalized rules for Los Angeles had been made valid for the Mojave, for example).
- inopinatus 5y agoThe legal construction of American rights was unique for its day (and remains unusual), being essentially a big list of freedoms & protections you have, with the assumption that government otherwise has unlimited authority. Governments across the US then presuppose that if it's not on this list, then they can stop you doing it pretty much arbitrarily, and then write baroque laws to nibble away at what you did have. This is in contrast to the constitutional fundamentals of many older nations that start with the assumption that individuals can do anything, and then make laws saying what's illegal and/or compelled, and it's the rights of government that are limited by default. Which is more free? I've always taken the view that the axioms of the US style are deceptively less free at an individual level, although this is an opinion often wildly unpopular with many Americans, who are powerfully indoctrinated from birth to assume they're the one true "land of the free". I guess "land of the most overtly protected from government abuses" is a bit of a mouthful. The saving grace being, it's also the system best aligned with democracy, that famed system of selection whose principal value-add is enabling removal of the most egregious governments every few years without needing an army. In any case, the consequences of the alternative construction of freedom are felt throughout American society and jurisprudence.
- rob_c 5y agoYes, this was the new normal when freedoms were offered up on a plate because of some underdeveloped people in another continent decrying the west as a bad place... Now it's the alter of covid that freedoms are offered up on. It's a shame nothing changed much in 20 years
- gambiting 5y agoI don't think that's a fair comparison. If we look at this rationally, an incredibly small percentage of the population was and is at any risk of terrorist attacks. Any further attacks could have been prevented without the widespread erosion of privacy and giving incredible powers to the government and law enforcement. Covid on the other hand put everyone at risk. Even if your individual chance of getting seriously sick is relatively low, (nearly)everyone is at risk of catching it and playing Russian roulette with the outcome. That alone warrants certain steps that limit personal freedom temporarily. I support those measures, as long as they are actually removed soon. Maybe I'm being naive, I don't know, but I certainly don't think comparing the terrorist threat to covid is correct or even appropriate.
- hnarn 5y ago> because of some underdeveloped people in another continent decrying the west I’m not taking sides here but that’s a pretty heavy euphemism for 9/11
- aww_dang 5y agoYes, but why stop there? Let's increase the powers of the state. Give them authority to mandate experimental vaccinations. Movement is a privilege, not a freedom. After all, this is an emergency! Grant them authority to centrally dictate energy consumption and print permission to consume energy via carbon credits. If the climate apocalypse isn't an emergency, I don't know what is! Better yet, let's move on from that and synthesize both concepts. We need to mandate a cashless society, UBI, proof of vaccination, CBDC, social credit scores, digital IDs and carbon credits. I'm always surprised how many people openly condemn the previous manufactured crisis and usurpation, while proudly walking into the next. The flippant dismissals of concerns and demands for conformity fit the same pattern. Yet somehow, the fearful appeals always manage to convince members of the public that, "This time is different, it is an emergency!"
- mdp2021 5y agoDear Aww, // surely you do not believe that the current world can do without the use of tags, /S without having some readers agree to the literal idea in expressions intended as ironic. // And think of the people that reading your words may have fainted in a moment of doubt. // Best Regards,
- smitty1e 5y agoWe The People should hate on, not only the Patriot Act, but every other "we have to pass it to see what's in it" piece of vast legislation that is: - rammed through substantially unread; - despite its prolix nature, is hardly more than a requirements outline to be filled in by un-elected, faceless Executive Branch bureaucrats as "regulations"; - continues to place financial burdens on unborn generations with gusto--"Taxation without representation" turned up to eleventy. Rather than offer a standard spleen dump, the broader point for this audience that's being made is that the government isn't scalable. The 1787 Constitution (while brilliant) is as a script that ran more-or-less well on a single instance, but has not forklifted into the cloud gracefully. And people are not software, but the readers of this site can make some important recommendations about how to capture the liberty we hold dear and avoid the various tyranny traps.
- Something1234 5y ago> - continues to place financial burdens on unborn generations with gusto--"Taxation without representation" turned up to eleventy. Can you expand on this?
- smitty1e 5y agoThere was this hilarious John Boehner riff when he was speaker after 2010: “History has shown that future spending cuts rarely materialize,” said Andrew Roth, vice president of government affairs for the Club for Growth, which is best known for financing campaigns against Republicans deemed not conservative enough. "Nothing binds a future Congress from erasing them.” https://www.csmonitor.com/USA/Politics/2011/0728/Why-John-Boehner-is-determined-to-pass-his-doomed-debt-ceiling-bill https://www.csmonitor.com/USA/Politics/2011/0728/Why-John-Bo... However theoretically true Boehner's statement, the entitlement spending IS treated as binding, for all the unmet obligations of the government are something like an order of magnitude higher that the already ludicrous debt. No one can credibly accuse Congress of fiscal sobriety. Thanks, Johnny B.