3 ms·
Housing is an investment only if you own more than one. Also you have to find a way to derive some monetary value from owning it. Also buying anything can be o
by DeathArrow 5y ago
Housing is an investment only if you own more than one. Also you have to find a way to derive some monetary value from owning it.
Also buying anything can be or not an investment. If you buy some bananas expecting to sell them for profit, then it is an investment.
Should countries also stop buying and selling bananas for profit? After all, eating is a basic need, more so than housing.
- kayamon 5y agoWhen you reach the point at which the buying/selling of bananas becomes more important than eating bananas, that may be the time at which to consider that something's gone wrong in the economy.
- graeme 5y agoThis is incorrect. In a lot of countries people rent or have historically rented. Including America in the past. America subsidizes homeownership specifically so now everyone does that, but people’s first and only house is definitely an investment. Housing is a basic need, homeownership isn’t one, any more than running a farm is a basic human need.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- loeg 5y agoI think this is a non sequitur. The cost of renting is a direct proxy for the cost of homes. It doesn't matter who the owner is -- if home prices rise exponentially, rents rise exponentially.
- satellite2 5y agoI think you got the point. Bananas are a depreciating asset but you can still make a profit around it. House prices should be the same, depreciating. That doesn't mean real estate should not be a profitable business though. But it should probably not be profitable for the end user.
- chii 5y agoprofit and depreciation are different, orthogonal things. A banana can be profitable because people who buy that banana can buy it at a higher-than-production-cost price, because their jobs produce more value per hour than growing banana (and agriculture has become so efficient). The fact that bananas spoils after a while doesn't make a difference here.
- yobbo 5y agoHousing is more "consumption" or "speculation" than "investment", since a house generates a negative cash flow. What defines an investment is generally expected future positive cash flow. What makes most house buying decisions speculative is how the market price is justified. And today the "residual value" (value of the asset when you sell it) dominates buying decisions. This is defined as speculation (in future market price). Without residual value, the market for old houses would be like the market for old cars or bicycles. Imagine if government legislation enabled lenders to lend random amounts with old cars as security: it would put a price floor on second hand cars. Since second hand cars are of limited supply, and ownership of such a car enables you to borrow at minimal rate, therefore the market price of an old car becomes the value of the getting that loan.
- staticman2 5y agoHousing doesn't generage a negetive cash flow like you are describing, it pays "imputed rent". You have to live somewhere, so when you live in a house the money you save on rental costs is like a dividend.
- xenihn 5y ago>Housing is an investment only if you own more than one. Every California rental I've lived in for the past five years had the owner residing in it as their primary residence, renting out the spare rooms, while doing one of two things: not declaring any of the rental income while still getting primary residence tax breaks, or declaring it as a full rental (and using another address as their primary address, despite not living there), and writing off the exorbitant Bay Area HOA fees.