5 ms·
A residential voltage electric shock has a low probability of killing you, but each one has that probability, and some day you may be unlucky. Knowing how to m
by marcosdumay 5y ago
A residential voltage electric shock has a low probability of killing you, but each one has that probability, and some day you may be unlucky.
Knowing how to move around the wire will further reduce the probability, so you can indeed learn to improve your odds. But still, each shock carries that probability (and it's much higher than the things we consider common, like driving a car in a high-speed road). How many times are you ok with putting your life at risk?
One should better avoid working on live wires. If you can't avoid, there are gear and safety procedures that may save your life, uncomfortable as they are. There is no reason for getting shocked all the time.
- Dylan16807 5y ago> How many times are you ok with putting your life at risk? That's not the right question to ask. If it was that black and white then you'd never get in a car.
- marcosdumay 5y agoOk, if you really want a cost-benefit analysis, please state what is the benefit, because out of not bothering to turn the electricity off or not buying some cheap protection gear, I'm out of ideas.
- Dylan16807 5y agoSaving a chunk of time and effort. The same benefit you get from unimportant car trips. Most people go on unimportant car trips just to save a few minutes or for a minor convenience, despite the risk. It's not a huge benefit each time, but it's also not a huge risk each time. So don't round just one side to zero. Also who said they aren't using protective gear like insulated tools? That sentence was talking about electricians after all.
- marcosdumay 5y agoGetting a shock is much more dangerous than doing a random car trip. Orders of magnitude more. Switching the power off takes a minute or two (how large is the building?). Looks to me the OP's friend is just rounding the risk on his life to zero due to normalization of deviance alone and you are keen on defending it because "well, if a professional does it, there may be some good reason". Rest assured that plenty of professionals die because of the that kind of thing. (Normalization of deviance is the large cause of death on every dangerous profession, and mostly done by professionals.) By the way, the safety gear for working on life wires is more than insulated tools. Insulating yourself from the wire and the ground are just as important.
- Dylan16807 5y ago> Getting a shock is much more dangerous than doing a random car trip. ...similarly, a car crash is much more dangerous than doing a random electrical adjustment. You don't get to assume one of them fails but not the other. > Looks to me the OP's friend is just rounding the risk on his life to zero due to normalization of deviance alone He's rounding it to zero because it's a very low risk, just like people do with car trips. > that kind of thing Do I get to lump drunk driving into normal driving? It's still "that kind of thing". I think we need to look at the risk of the specific type of dangerous activity, instead of lumping it into a generic "danger" bin and ignoring car danger because you personally don't feel it qualifies as "normalization of deviance".